[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference lgp30::christian-perspective

Title:Discussions from a Christian Perspective
Notice:Prostitutes and tax collectors welcome!
Moderator:CSC32::J_CHRISTIE
Created:Mon Sep 17 1990
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1362
Total number of notes:61362

1194.0. "Why shouldn't we all believe the same?" by CSC32::J_CHRISTIE (Ps. 85.10) Mon Dec 18 1995 21:18

What's wrong with thinking everyone should share identical beliefs?

Shalom,
Richard

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1194.1CSC32::M_EVANScuddly as a cactusTue Dec 19 1995 02:027
    Richard,
    
    nothing, as long as you all follow mine.
    
    ;-)/2
    
    meg
1194.2MKOTS3::JMARTINI press on toward the goalTue Dec 19 1995 17:298
    We are all called to likemindedness, but at the same time, faith is not
    like bipartisan politics where you should compromise...in other words,
    if we're in a room and I love vanilla ice cream..and you love chocolate
    ice cream, it seems illogical to try and come to a compromise on this. 
    You either love it, or you don't love it.  You either believe it, or
    you don't believe it.
    
    -Jack
1194.3APACHE::MYERSHe literally meant it figurativelyTue Dec 19 1995 17:547
    
    > What's wrong with thinking everyone should share identical beliefs?

    It depends on the beliefs. Jim Dornan and Phil Gramm hold beliefs that
    I'm glad are not shared by everyone.

    Eric
1194.4MKOTS3::JMARTINI press on toward the goalTue Dec 19 1995 19:234
    I can understand Dornan but not Gramm.  What specifically is his
    beliefs that are happily not shared?
    
    -Jack
1194.5CSC32::J_CHRISTIEPs. 85.10Tue Dec 19 1995 23:068
    .4
    
    Mind if we stay with the topic for awhile before getting into yet
    another political exchange?
    
    Shalom,
    Richard
    
1194.6MKOTS3::JMARTINI press on toward the goalWed Dec 20 1995 12:511
    Ooohhhhhh Alllright!  (kicking a stone)
1194.7APACHE::MYERSHe literally meant it figurativelyWed Dec 20 1995 13:233
    Sorry. It was my fault for using politicians in my example.
    
    Eric
1194.8APACHE::MYERSHe literally meant it figurativelyWed Dec 20 1995 13:297
    
    There is a difference between all coming to believe the same thing and
    all being coerced into believing the same thing. I guess I don't have a
    problem with everyone believing the same thing, as long as beliefs are
    not dictated.

    Eric
1194.10MKOTS3::JMARTINI press on toward the goalThu Dec 28 1995 17:2420
Z    I question the notion that all share identical beliefs is even
Z    desirable.
    
Z    Uniformity does exert power, admittedly.  But at what expense?
    
    
    If I may briefly digress into politics mode, neutral if possible.  
    I have recently seen in the media alot of accusations of whining
    between the two parties in D.C.  I couldn't disagree more.  I believe
    the core of the system down there is set up for debate and I believe
    the current stalemate on the budget impasse is a great testimony of
    democracy.  So in your question above, I believe uniformity can have a
    great price to it!
    
    In regards to faith, if there is likemindedness on that which is
    right, then it is very desireable...why wouldn't it be?  However, I see
    differences to be good as well since it promotes study and challenge.
    
    -Jack
    
1194.11truthNETRIX::"dowis_c@stympy.alf.dec.com"charles dowisThu Dec 28 1995 19:1733
For everyone to have the same belief....hmmm.

This would imply:

1. There is a true religion.
2. There is a way to test and prove that it is true.
3. Everyone wants to know the truth.

1. The Bible teaches us "one Lord, one faith, one baptism".  Many Christian churches 
teach that there is only one true doctrine -- that Christ was th Son of God and
he died on the cross for our sins, and we must accept him for our Savior to be
saved.  All other doctrines are unnecessary.  Some churches  believe they
hold the complete truth include: the Catholic Church, the Jehovah Witnesses, and 
the LDS Church.

2.  Some churches teach that you receive the truth by studying the Bible, and
having faith in it.  Others teach that a person can have a personal witness/
revelation through the Holy Ghost.  Others believe that God reveals himself thru the 
intellect of man as he/she studies and interprets the Bible (usually with the
"proper education" in a seminary)

3. Like the rich man who refused to give his wealth to the poor in order to
receive eternal life, many refuse to consider sacrificing the things of this life in order
to receive the riches of eternity.  They express a desire to find the truth, 
but, in reality, are unwilling to make the effort.  They relationalize 
that truth is relative to individual circumstances, OR that it is
impossible to find it,  "so why bother?"  They worship idols of their own making:
money, intellectual sophistry, etc.  

Somehow truth must "pleasing to the eyes and the intellect", it should be had for
little cost, and not be inconvenient.  Little or no sacrifices should be
involved == "once saved, always saved" would be a possible example. 
[Posted by WWW Notes gateway]
1194.9Edited and re-enteredCSC32::J_CHRISTIEPs. 85.10Thu Dec 28 1995 19:2512
.0

Former C-P member and friend Jerry Beeler used to say that when everyone
is thinking the same, no one is thinking.

I question the notion that having all share identical beliefs is even desirable.

Uniformity does exert power, admittedly.  But at what expense?

Shalom,
Richard

1194.12God leads his servants in the ways of truthRDGENG::YERKESSbring me sunshine in your smileTue Jan 02 1996 12:2217
re .11

Charles,

As a Jehovah's Witness I would like to correct something you wrote.
That is Jehovah's Witnesses do not believe they hold what you term
the complete truth, however they believe God's Word is truth 
(John 17:17). That is it's contents are truth, letting us know what 
is God's will and purpose. As time progresses we believe that God 
will shed more light or understanding to his servants on His Word 
(compare Proverbs  4:18). The fruit one bears will prove whether or 
not one is serving God or not. (Matthew 7:17-21). Those that have
God's Word and yet ignore His will are like ones groping around in
darkness, they will never come to an accurate knowledge of truth.

Phil.