[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference napalm::commusic_v1

Title:* * Computer Music, MIDI, and Related Topics * *
Notice:Conference has been write-locked. Use new version.
Moderator:DYPSS1::SCHAFER
Created:Thu Feb 20 1986
Last Modified:Mon Aug 29 1994
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2852
Total number of notes:33157

1979.0. "Advice on purchasing Roland D20 LA Synth" by USCTR2::AMCDONALD (ALLAN) Mon May 01 1989 12:58

I'm upgrading from Casio CZ-1 to Roland D-20, and plan on sticking 
with a single component philosophy thru college.  D-20 is for
$1295 (fully warranted and inc. TAX). I'd like your advice on the
wisdom of this.  Is there anything that makes it a bad idea?  Is
$1295 the best possible price? 

Thanks, regards,
Heather 
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1979.1Look at Ensoniq and KorgDREGS::BLICKSTEINConliberativeMon May 01 1989 17:1815
    You might want to have a look at either the Ensoniq ESQ-1 or SQ-80.
    
    The user interface is considered to be more powerful and much more
    user friendly than the D-20, but lots of folks don't like the Ensoniq
    sounds as much.
    
    Roland is also legendary for poor manuals and Ensoniq is legendary
    for terrific manuals.  If you're new at this, that might be an
    important consideration.
    
    I'd also certainly take a look at the Korg M1 which has, IMO, the
    best sounds of all of them but is more expensive and (according
    to Keyboard magazine) has an inferior sequencer.
    
    	db
1979.2HAMER::COCCOLIL<>7Mon May 01 1989 20:478
    
    
    	D20 a cheesy sequencer compared to the Ensonics. If you like
    the Roland D sound, better to go with a D10 and a separate sequencer.
    These are my opinions, anyway.
    
    						Rich
    
1979.3Vote for D20WOTVAX::KENTTue May 02 1989 08:2211
    
    
    Having seen and played with a D20 and having set a friend off on
    a similar path I would wholeheartedly recommend the D20. The concept
    of having all the bits you need Diskdrive/sequencer/"excellent"
    drum machine/multi-timbral/reverb synth in one machine is, I think unique 
    except for the Yamha V50 which does not sound as good. 
                                                                 
    I wish these had been around 3 years ago when I started out.
                                     
    						Paul.
1979.4great sounds + all the drums you wantMARVIN::MACHINTue May 02 1989 08:294
    I vote for D1/20 too. Important point about the disk drive, which
    you're unlikely to afford if you go D10+sequencer.
    
    Richard.
1979.5Much to considerTYFYS::MOLLERHalloween the 13th on Elm Street #7Tue May 02 1989 15:2937
    I own an ESQ1 & you have to buy additional gear to make as many Timbres
    as available on the D10/D20/D100/MT32 (these are all sort of the same
    family). I Have an MT-32 and borrow a D110 on occasion. Ny Nephew has
    a D10 (and a Yamaha DX7). We all seem to like the Roland sounds and
    especially the drums that are built it. The ESQ1/SQ80's have a very
    nice sequencer in them, but to effectively use the Ensoniq keybooards,
    you really have to buy a drum machine or some sort of multi-timbral box
    with drum sounds in it. You'll also need some sort of multi-timbral
    box with the Ensoniq gear (you soon grow tired of running out of
    notes). I know practically nothing about the D20's sequencer. It may be
    good (I understand it only holds one song), or mediocre, that's hard to
    say. Lately manufacturers seem to be putting more things into the boxes
    (like sequencers). You might look into something like the D10 and an
    seperate sequencer, such as a Roland MC500 (has a disk drive) or an
    Alesis MMT-8 (no disk drive) or some of the more recent Yamaha
    sequencers. You might even look into a Personal Computer with
    sequencing software.

    I'll only give you one warning about Disk units. The 2.8 inch drive
    disks cost $4.00 to $6.00 each & hold very little (60K bytes). The
    3.5 inch and 5 1/4 inch are available everywhere & can be had for $1.00
    to $2.00 each and they hold quite a lot (800K is a common number).
    I have a seperate sequencer & disk drive (not to mention the seperate
    sequencer in the ESQ1) & I load everything in the MIDI network from a
    single drive. If you want to keep it simple, go withe the D20. If you
    want flexibility (such as the ability to outgrow either the keyboard
    or the sequencer with out losing an old friend) go with a seperate
    keyboard and seperate sequencer. Most of my stuff is now in a 6 high
    rack mount & I don't want anymore keyboards, one is plenty for me.
    I do enjoy, however, access to 2 sequencers at any time & use them
    both during Live performance.

						    Jens
    
    
    
    
1979.6You can go a long way with the ESQ sequencerDREGS::BLICKSTEINConliberativeTue May 02 1989 16:0816
    Jens advice is good, but to give you an idea how far you can go
    with the ESQ-1 synthesizer, the ESQ-1 was my first piece of MIDI
    gear.   I have since bought two more synths, a sampler, mixers,
    recorders, several effects units, reverbs, racks, guitar processors,
    etc. etc.
    
    What do I use for a sequencer: the same sequencer that I had on
    the ESQ-1 (only I upgraded to a SQ-80 which has essentially the
    identical sequencer as the ESQ-1).
    
    For my purposes, none of the dedicated sequencers offered nearly
    enough over the ESQ-1 to warrant their price.  The Roland MC-500 MK II
    with the S-MRC software sounds nice, but at that price I'd rather get 
    a PC-based sequencer.
    
    	db
1979.7What's done is done, but in the future...DYO780::SCHAFERBrad - back in Ohio.Tue May 02 1989 16:3211
    Please remember to either:

	DIR/TITLE=topic
	SHOW KEYWORD/FULL topic
	EXTRACT NOTE filename 2.1 and $SEARCH filename topic

    before creating a new (redundant) topic.

    Also, PLEASE read notes 1.1 and 1.2 and follow the guidelines. Thanks. 

-b
1979.8new kid on the block!!!!GIDDAY::KNIGHTPTue Dec 04 1990 00:2810
    I am going to pick up my new D20 next week.  I chose it after looking
    at the M1 K1 etc and on the advice of a friend.  Is there anything in
    particular I should be wary of or try ?  This is my first
    sequencer/midi piece of gear.  Also has anyone tried those plug in Ram
    cards they offer?  Thanks in advance
     
    Peter Knight
    Melbourne Australia