[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference napalm::guitar

Title:GUITARnotes - Where Every Note has Emotion
Notice:Discussion of the finer stringed instruments
Moderator:KDX200::COOPER
Created:Thu Aug 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3280
Total number of notes:61432

3177.0. "Tuning Acoustic Duets/Trios Guitars" by DEBUG::GALLO (Fast/Good/Cheap... Pick 2!) Tue Feb 20 1996 22:37

    Any recommendations for tuning a duet's (or a trio's) acoustic
    guitars?  This is for the guitarists at our church.  I always
    see them tuning to the exact pitch, string for string.
    
    I thought there were some techniques for tuning duets or trios
    guitars differently, such that the result was a fuller, more
    unique sound.
    
    (then again, maybe I'm just dreaming ;^)
    
    Thanks for any suggestions.   Paul
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
3177.1SMURF::PBECKRob Peter and pay *me*...Wed Feb 21 1996 10:155
>    I thought there were some techniques for tuning duets or trios
>    guitars differently, such that the result was a fuller, more
>    unique sound.
    
    I think that technique is called "playing out of tune"...
3177.2"Standard" plus "High-string"STRATA::PHILLIPSMusic of the spheres.Wed Feb 21 1996 10:1823
    Not really sure what would work here, but here goes....
    
    In a situation with two acoustic six string guitars, one thing you
    might try is to have one guitar tune to regular concert pitch, and the
    other one tune to a "Nashville high-string" tuning:
    
    Guitar #1 =>	E	A	D	G	B	E
    
    Guitar #2 =		E	A	D	G	B	E
    	              |--these four tuned an octave--|
    		      |  higher than guitar #1       |
    
    Naturally, you have to use very light strings on guitar #2; some people
    just use the light half of a twelve string set!
    
    As I understand, this tuning is sometimes used to "un-clutter" the low
    frequencies and give a nice rhythm sound.  Don't know if that's what
    you're looking for, but you might want to try it....
    
    Hope that helps, anyway.  Good luck!
    
    					--Eric--
  
3177.3GANTRY::ALLBERYJimWed Feb 21 1996 10:284
    Re:
    >>some people just use the light half of a twelve string set!
    
    I've never heard of anyone doing it any other way.
3177.4NEWVAX::LAURENTHal Laurent @ COPWed Feb 21 1996 10:3911
re: .3

>    Re:
>    >>some people just use the light half of a twelve string set!
>    
>    I've never heard of anyone doing it any other way.

I buy individual strings of the proper guage from Musician's Fiend and
make my own high-strung sets.

-Hal
3177.5*Kiss*MILKWY::JACQUESVintage taste, reissue budgetWed Feb 21 1996 11:3412
    I think the author is referring to using differant tempered scales 
    for each instrument to get subtle phase differances. 
    
    Anything is possible but in live playing situations, I prefer to use
    the *KISS* principle (keep it simple, stupid). I would suggest that
    everyone tune to the same scale (using an electronic tuner). By the
    time people warm up, the instruments will vary slightly resulting in
    the same affect anyways. When you take into account intonation of the
    individual instruments, you are going to hear slight variations
    anyways.
    
    Mark
3177.6SMURF::wolf95.zk3.dec.com::PBECKPaul Beck, WASTED::PBECKWed Feb 21 1996 12:453
Another variation is to have one of the guitars be a 12-string. No 12-string in 
the history of the breed has ever been in tune, so you get some of the effect 
automatically...
3177.7POWDML::MAY_BWed Feb 21 1996 14:014
    My Martin 12 string stays in tune.
    
    
    Bruce
3177.8... once I *get* it in tune ...SMURF::wolf95.zk3.dec.com::PBECKPaul Beck, WASTED::PBECKWed Feb 21 1996 15:401
So does mine, actually...
3177.9It's the strings, not the guitarMILKWY::JACQUESVintage taste, reissue budgetWed Feb 21 1996 16:5311
    I have a Guild D25-12 strung with light gauge strings. The Octave G
    is a .008 gauge string. This string tends to stretch and become flat.
    The rest of the strings stay in tune very well.  I blame this more
    on the string set than the instrument. I suppose I should try a 
    heavier set. I should add that I tune this guitar to standard pitch
    (not dropped).
    
    One of these days, I'm going to restring one of my guitars to the
    Nashville tuning. 
    
    Mark 
3177.10SMURF::wolf95.zk3.dec.com::PBECKPaul Beck, WASTED::PBECKWed Feb 21 1996 17:4510
Lest we go any deeper into this ... .6 was a joke. The full version of the joke 
goes

... a 12-string can never be in tune, because if it were, the sympathetic 
vibrations would tear the instrument apart ...


A useful story that I've used on stage a few times when it was time to stop 
tuning and start playing... I stole the joke from someone who was using it with 
respect to a hammered dulcimer.
3177.11CHEFS::BRIGGS_Rthey use computers don't theyThu Feb 22 1996 05:2910
    Re 12 strings. See the topic raised years ago in this conference. Unless
    you have 12 individual saddles (i.e. one for each string) where each
    has been specifically positioned for a certain gauge string (or where
    they are adjustable like on a standard Strat) then a 12 string is, by
    definition, always out of tune.
    
    And this is what makes a 12 string sound great. That 'ever so slightly'
    out of tune sound.
    
    Richard
3177.12E::EVANSThu Feb 22 1996 10:287
Almost every guitar can be put in perfect tuning with open strings.  The 
problems comes with fretted notes.  Then even 6 string guitars have some 
notes that are slightly off pitch.  

Jim

3177.13what about a capo(sp?)??AIMTEC::JOHNSON_RThu Feb 22 1996 15:183
    how about have one guitar use a capo(sp?) and play in a different key??
    
    rj/31334
3177.14ASABET::pelkey.ogo.dec.com::pelkeyprofessional hombreThu Feb 22 1996 16:0316
re: base note..  tunings...

as .13 indicated...

capo the second guitar at first position A..


This shortens the scale of the capoed guitar so that
now the first position E is up at the E/B position.

This helps to clean up the low strings and
puts a little separation between the guitars..

re: 12's yea, almost like a built in chorus!