[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference rusure::math

Title:Mathematics at DEC
Moderator:RUSURE::EDP
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2083
Total number of notes:14613

215.0. "Another solid" by METOO::YARBROUGH () Fri Jan 25 1985 18:13

That was fun. Try this one: a 3-d solid has 6 faces, 12 edges, 8 corners
and two of the faces are hexagons. Describe the solid.

Lynn Yarbrough
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
215.1HARE::STANSat Jan 26 1985 00:177
Since two planes meet in a line, the two hexagons
can't have more than 2 vertices in common.  This would
give your solid at least 2 X 6 - 2 = 10 vertices,
which is more than the 8 you specify.

Thus the solid does not exist unless it has unusual attributes,
like coplanar faces.
215.2TURTLE::GILBERTSat Jan 26 1985 06:492
Topologically, there's no problem with the two hexagons having more
than two vertices in common.
215.3LATOUR::AMARTINSat Jan 26 1985 12:4510
But geometrically there is a big problem.  How can two distinct plane
hexagons share more than two points without becoming coplanar?

I assume that the two hexagons are supposed to be plane figures, because
if the faces don't have to be planar polygons, and the edges don't have
to become straight lines, the problem changes from discrete to continuous.
(Does anyone want to write a program which enumerates all of the possible
solids which fit these descriptions, looking for matches?  Looks like we
might see some Lisp or Prolog programs, instead of Teco and DCL).
				/AHM
215.4METOO::YARBROUGHFri Feb 08 1985 17:1122
Here it is. Nobody said it had to be convex... it's a trianglular pyramid
wth a notch cut in one edge. - Lynn Yarbrough
                   ^
                  /|\
                 / | \
                /  |  \
               /   |   \
              /    |    \
             /    / \    \
            /    /   \    \
           /    /_____\    \
          /.....\...../.....\
          \      \   /      /
           \      \ /      /
            \      |      /
             \     |     /
              \    |    /
               \   |   /
                \  |  /
                 \ | /
                  \|/
                   v