[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference bookie::movies

Title:Movie Reviews and Discussion
Notice:Please do DIR/TITLE before starting a new topic on a movie!
Moderator:VAXCPU::michaudo.dec.com::tamara::eppes
Created:Thu Jan 28 1993
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1249
Total number of notes:16012

524.0. "Sunset Boulevard" by TLE::JBISHOP () Mon Apr 18 1994 14:31

    A classic: Gloria Swanson, William Holden, Erich von Stroheim,
    Billy Wilder writing the script and directing, cameos by Cecil 
    B. DeMille, Buster Keaton and others.  My big movie book gives
    it five stars, and I'll agree (with caveats of course, or why 
    else write this?).
    
    Plot:
    =====
    
    Holden plays a down-on-his-luck scriptwriter who winds up
    being the kept man of a faded star from the silent days.
    There's a girl, and some element of mystery about the star's
    butler.
    
    Acting:
    =======
    
    The remarkable part of this is that Gloria Swanson _was_ a
    silent star, and is in some sense playing her own story, or
    rather an "almost" story of her life.  It's quite brave for
    an ex-young beauty to play an ex-young beauty who is trying
    to hold on to her image.
    
    Anyway, Gloria dives into her role with gusto, hovering just
    on the edge of sliding into parody or humor.  Her clawing
    hands are wonderful.  The others are ok, but pale in comparison.
    
    Caveats:
    ========
    
    Warning: spoilers coming!
    
    The plot background requires the star's first husband to give
    up his career as a rising director and to become her butler.
    This is something odd and unlikely, and I don't think it's
    sufficiently motivated.
    
    Norma Desmond (the star) is only 50 (line of dialog), and so
    isn't all that old, considering what other actresses have done.
    And she's a very good-looking 50.  But for plot purposes she has
    to be completely out of the running as an actress.  She should
    have been made a less-attractive 50 for this to work for me.
    
    The scriptwriter has to be a character who just drifts, and is
    passive, but this doesn't fit with his career and his voice-overs.
    The transition doesn't make sense.  For example, at one point 
    he's being hired to help edit a script Norma wrote, and he
    doesn't ask for X dollars a week, despite the clear negotiations
    on salary in the previous dialog and his own voice-over about
    how he'd dangled the bait and she'd bitten.  That's more than 
    drifting, that's actively seeking gigolohood.
    
    Bottom line:
    ============
    
    Well worth seeing and memorable.
    
    			-John Bishop
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
524.1FWIW17617::MAYNARDThe Front Row KidTue Apr 19 1994 12:074
    The Butler was played by Eric Von Stroheim, a very well known,
    avant-garde, silent film director...
    
    					Jim
524.25468::J_TOMAOTue Apr 19 1994 13:1916
    I love this movie!!!  BTW, I believe the character's name is Nora, not
    Norma.
    
    Wings recently did a spoof on the begining scene of William Holden
    floating face down in the pool - and whoever saw the Carole Burnett
    spoof can not forget her entrance as she came down the staircase with
    *those eyebrows* :^)))))))).  (mumble mumble Harvey) played the
    Stroheim character, complete with the German boots and slapping a
    riding crop......
    
    The only part of the original SB I didn't car for was the bit about the
    dead monkey.
    
    I would love to see the Broadway version of this classic movie.
    
    Jt
524.3BEDAZL::MAXFIELDTue Apr 19 1994 14:0115
    I recently read an interview with Billy Wilder, the director of
    "Sunset Boulevard" (the movie ;-)) and he hadn't seen it again
    until recently. He was pleased with it, felt it held up, and
    wouldn't change anything about it.
    
    And sorry Joyce, the character is definitely Norma Desmond.
    
    Glenn Close beat out Patty Lupone to play the role of Norma
    in the Broadway production of the musical.  Lupone had been
    playing it in London, Close in L.A.  Interestingly, Meryl Streep
    is taking over for Close in the L.A. production (Streep has
    a lovely voice, actually).
    
    
    Richard
524.4That butler part....GALVIA::HELSOMWed Apr 20 1994 12:2533
This is also one of my top 20 or so....

Re: 0, implausibilities in the plot: it's both better and worse than you think. 

The relationship between Norma Desmond and the butler mirrors that between
Gloria Swanson and Stroheim very closely: they were married, he directed her
films, they divorced and (I think) continued a close but odd relationship.
Gloria Swanson obviously knows a great part when she sees one, but it's very
difficult to see what could have induced Stroheim to play unless he really was
subservient to Swanson in some way.

On the other hand, the William Holden character and associated plot is straight
out of a million films noirs (I suppose is the way to spell it). The attractive,
opportunistic and completely stupid stranger wreaking sexual havoc and general
mayhem occurs in, for example, the Postman Always Rings Twice, and (with the
twist that he's Fred McMurray and looks respectable) in Wilder's own Double
Indemnity.

Apropos of not much, Sunset Boulevard has Wilder's most up-front talking corpse.
Wilder actually wanted Holden sitting up in the morgue, but the studio made him
make do with a voice-over and the body in the pool. (In the interests of
shortening the film rather than taste, as far as I can tell.) Wilder really
likes talking corpses, and their total inability to tell the truth even when it
doesn't make any difference. 

I didn't see anything about this in his "autobiography", which is really an
extended collection of his anecdotes. I could guess that he really liked
Rashomon, which came out in the early 1950s. Or that it was one way of
expressing the total absurdity of the Holocaust, when people he once knew well
are dead and there's no sensible story why, only a grotesque and absurd set of
memories. Does anyone out there have any ideas or information on this?

Helen
524.5Films noir54291::GARLICK_NThu Apr 21 1994 06:045
    I had always understood that the reason he kept the corpse in the mortuary
    scene *out* of the film was because preview audiences laughed it off the
    screen. Does his book tell another story?
    
    Nick
524.6Corpsing...GALVIA::HELSOMThu Apr 21 1994 08:1310
Re: -1,

That's probably right. I had the impression the studio had a hand in it. My
German's not that wonderful, so I may have missed the point. I can imagine that
if the  film got as far as previews with the talking corpse, the audience would
have laughed loud. Since all the morgue material would have been extra, it would
have made for a very long film as well. Wilder probably agreed with the studio
after the previews.

Helen
524.729052::WSA038::SATTERFIELDClose enough for jazz.Thu Apr 28 1994 22:1113

re last couple

In an interview on AMC Wilder relates that the first preview he attended with
that scene the audience laughed and generally evinced displeasure. He left
the theatre and was sitting on some steps in the lobby feeling depressed with
his head in his hands. A lady walked by and, apparently in an attempt to
commiserate with him, said "Wasn't that the biggest load of **** you've
ever seen" (or something like that). Wilder agreed with her.


Randy
524.8They cut that bit out......GALVIA::HELSOMFri Apr 29 1994 07:569
Re: -1 

Was that the Fassbinder interview (the one that went out in 3 one hour segments
on UK TV)? 

I'm sure the gist of it is true, but I think Billy Wilder is still inventing
stories. I wish somebody would let him make a film again...

Helen
524.929052::WSA038::SATTERFIELDClose enough for jazz.Mon May 02 1994 22:2512

re .8

No, it was one of the monthy AMC interviews called "Reflections on the Silver
Screen" with ? Brown. Most are half hour interviews but some, including this
one with Wilder, are an hour. Brown mostly asks the standard questions for 
whoever he's interviewing, seldom covering any new ground. Wilder is one of
the more entertaining, his wit is still sharp.


Randy