[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference terri::cars_uk

Title:Cars in the UK
Notice:Please read new conference charter 1.70
Moderator:COMICS::SHELLEYELD
Created:Sun Mar 06 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2584
Total number of notes:63384

1874.0. "Recovering car hire cost from third party insurers" by MAJORS::HANSON () Thu Aug 27 1992 15:28

Hi,

I need to put my car in for repair after being shunted from behind by a club 
footed, dithering old person who doesn't know the difference between the brake
and the accelerator !!

Whilst my car is in for repair I wish to hire a car and then claim the cost back
from the third party insurers. The only problem with this is that I will be out 
of pocket until I can get them to pay and of course ther is no guarantee that they
will.

Therefore, does anybody know of a car hire company in the Reading/Newbury area
that will rent me a car and recover the uninsured loss on my behalf. I know 
there are hire companies that do this, what I need is one in this area.

	Any help would be welcomed,


		Mark.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1874.13 ArrowsWOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsThu Aug 27 1992 16:224
    Ring 3 Arrows Car Hire - 061 655 3537, they have branches all over and
    should be able to help.  They will loan you a car and recover their
    costs (+ any uninsured loses).  They take the risk is a prang turns out
    to be your fault
1874.2Go for a small car.FIZGIG::BIGGINMThu Aug 27 1992 17:2826
    I'm doing exactly the same thing at the moment, as my solicitor advises
    me, I can hire a car for as long as the repair takes, as long as that
    car is about the smallest one you can possibly get.  If you get
    something equivalent to your own car then the third party insurers may
    not cough up for the hire car.

    I quote a letter I was sent by my solicitors:---

    "If you have to hire an alternative vehicle, hire the cheapest
    possible, since the law will not always enable you to recover the cost
    of a similar vehicle to yours"

    Doesn't matter much to me though, even the smallest of hire cars have
    probably got more power than my Mini!

    I have had a Bodywork Repair place in Caversham offer to hire me a Fiat
    Tipo for the time it takes them to repair the car at 8 pounds a day! 
    Which is damn cheap for a hire car.  It's better than almost all other
    hire car companies who just laugh at me when I try and hire a car.  All
    they do is ask whether I'm 23+, and I say "nah, I'm 21", and they
    refuse to hire me anything!!!!  :^(

    Have fun,

    	MattB
1874.3Take the easy way outWOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsThu Aug 27 1992 17:598
>    "If you have to hire an alternative vehicle, hire the cheapest
>    possible, since the law will not always enable you to recover the cost
>    of a similar vehicle to yours"

    Use 3 Arrows as stated in .1, IF you convince them you are not to
    blame, they take the risk and recover the costs.  That's the lst you
    hear of it.
    
1874.4Not the best type of car at this priceESBS01::RUTTERRut The NutThu Aug 27 1992 18:243
1874.5Don't believe it!UNTADH::TOWERSThu Aug 27 1992 18:4815
    Having been through the same loop a couple of years ago when a silly
    woman wiped me out on the M4, I don't believe any hire company is going
    to be so silly as to let you have a hire car and try and recover ALL
    the costs themselves.
    
    Why?
    
    Well, the guilty party's insurance company WILL NOT pay the full cost.
    My experience and that of other people I know who have had similar
    experiences, is that the insurance company will, at the very least,
    deduct from the hire charges something like 5p per mile that you drive
    in the hire car. They claim that this is because your car would have
    been depreciating by at least this much if you hadn't had the accident.
    
    Brian
1874.6Someone who CAN clout the insurance companiesWOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsThu Aug 27 1992 19:1011
>    woman wiped me out on the M4, I don't believe any hire company is going
>    to be so silly as to let you have a hire car and try and recover ALL
>    the costs themselves.
    
    I beg to differ, these guys have solicitors who do nothing but persue
    these cases.  I know several people who've used them, they're
    excellant.  They are specialist debt collection agencies, that happen
    to hire cars out.
    
    Joe Public has no chance of getting so much money out of insurance
    companies.  
1874.7One more...WOTVAX::MEAKINSClive MeakinsThu Aug 27 1992 19:112
    forgot to add, you may even be able to get money for the depreciation
    of your car due to it's accident.
1874.8No deductionsVOGON::KAPPLERDover, Rising more slowly, GoodThu Aug 27 1992 21:095
    I've rented a hire car and had the full cost reimbursed by the other
    parties insurance company (after some discussion with me and an AA
    provided solicitor!!).
    
    JK
1874.9VANGA::KERRELLDave Kerrell @REO 830-2279Thu Aug 27 1992 21:424
I've also hired a car and had full costs reimbursed with help from the AA claims
assistance people.

Dave.
1874.10SIMD::BROWNLMake mine a BroadsideThu Aug 27 1992 23:114
    I have hired a car and had full costs imbursed with the help of my
    insurance company.
    
    Laurie.
1874.11AAIS Claims AssistanceBAHTAT::LECTER::SUMMERFIELDWorking for PharoahFri Aug 28 1992 14:427
    Another vote for AA Claims Assistance Service. They recovered all the
    costs of a hire car (Ford Sierra 1.8LX) whilst I was sorting out
    replacement for my car(MG Maestro EFI) which had been written-off by a
    blind lorry driver. I did 5000 miles in 7 weeks in that bloody Sierra,
    I deserved a bonus for tolerance...
    
    Clive 
1874.12Two years late, but never mindUNTADH::TOWERSFri Aug 28 1992 16:133
    Hmmm. It sounds like I ought to go out and join the AA.
    
    Brian
1874.13Non-members welcomeCMOTEC::JASPERMon Sep 07 1992 16:309
    You dont need to belong to the AA, just pay the premiums. The policies
    are not the cheapest, but you do get a discount voucher for (among
    other things) Hertz car rental, as well as what others have testified
    to as well-toothed support. Me ? I insured through the AA, I'll let you
    know how I get on with recovering my hire car costs from Horseman's
    Hit & Run Coach company after their driver failed to notice his coach
    wouldnt reverse any further.
    
    Tony.
1874.14They still do that?VANGA::KERRELLDave Kerrell @REO 830-2279Mon Sep 07 1992 19:146
> Horseman's Hit & Run Coach company

Brings back memories of Acre Rd and the lunch time bus demolishing cars parked
near the car park entrance...

Dave.
1874.15Glad to hear it can be done!WOTVAX::HATTOSI think, Therefore I'm paid lessThu Sep 10 1992 21:4219
My wife has been shunted this week, she took the car to the body shop, who said
the chassis was twisted and it would be best if she didn't drive it. (Who cares 
if they get the job!!)

She obviously stated that she would be without a car, try these people they said,
proffering a leaflet.

I was dubious, nobody does this for free! Sure enough an ORION 1.6LX Auto. turned
up and they explained to us that they make their money by getting a very switched
on solicitor to run the case. He has a vested interest in getting as much money as
possible, as he gets 25% of the claim. The hire firm get 25%, which more than 
covers their hire charges, wifey gets the rest!

They have assured us that we will not be out of pocket at any time.

I guess the moral is "Get a professional to sort it out!" We would never have 
recovered enough to pay for a hire car.

Stuart
1874.16My experiences FWIWLARVAE::IVES_JBad Karma in the UKFri Sep 11 1992 13:2520
    My wife had a similar experience a few years ago. She was side slammed
    by a guy comming out of his drive in Reading.
    
    We said he did'nt look (cars parked at the side of the road), he said
    my wife was speeding. In all honesty it was probably a bit of both. Our
    car was in the docks for several weeks being put right. We got a hire
    car on one of these schemes from a compnay in Wokingham, a right old
    nail of a 1.3 Escort (20MPG!!!).
    
    The insurrance firms haggled and haggled and eventually the thing was
    due to go to court. I got the distinct feeling that the other parties
    insurrurers dug their heels in more because of the additional cost (to
    them )  of the car hire cost. In the end it was settled out of court
    and did'nt cost us anything but it was all rather messy.
    
    I'd reccomend it but only if you are in no doubt about your being in
    the right. I guess in a rear shunt you would be as it is the driver
    behinds responsibility to leave enough room.
    
    
1874.17WOTVAX::NISBETDDougie Nisbet | Bid Support/OSSThu Nov 05 1992 18:1521
    I've just been involved in a rear-end shunt, and the AA told me that it
    was getting riskier taking out a hire car as insurance companies are
    getting less likely to pay out. 
    
    The trouble with all this Pay and Claim crap is that you have to pay
    first - and we don't all have gold plated Amexes. In my case as a Temp,
    it is hardly worth my while hiring a car as the costs of said hire are
    a not inconsiderable percentage of my wages. I'd be better off taking a
    weeks unpaid hols.
    
    The company which the AA recomended I went to for a quote have just
    told me that my car won't be fixed until Monday evening. I was
    expecting it today. 
    
    I tried to arrange to borrow an idle Pool car, but Car Fleet clearly
    don't indulge in such staggeringly practical ideas such as lending a
    car to a Temp for a few days. They're being recalled, and will be for
    some quite considerable period of time, apparantly. 
    
    Dougie
    
1874.18Try company in .1FUTURS::FIDOpersonal name intentionally left blankThu Nov 05 1992 18:191
1874.19MAJORS::QUICKIf I were your husband I'd drink it...Thu Nov 05 1992 18:2110
	Re .17 - if it wasn't your fault, the other driver's insurance
	company *have* to hire you a car if you want one. If they refuse,
	take the matter to the Ombudsman. Insurance companies are trying
	very hard not to pay out these days for obvious reasons; a lot
	of people let them get away with it which is why they do it. I've
	found that just the threat of involving the Ombudsman will usually
	pry their chequebooks open with remarkable rapidity, however.

	JJ.
1874.20WOTVAX::MCCAFFREYJIf in doubt switch it off.Mon Mar 11 1996 12:5523
    Although this is an old note I'd like some advice, comments please.
    
    My friend had a collision with an on coming car. The other driver
    admitted fault and in teh police traffic accident report it clearly
    states this.
    
    The car has been written off and so she is now left with no car.  Her
    insurance company in it's policy states she is entitled to a hire car
    while her's is being repaired.  However, the other driver, now says it
    is 50/50 even though the police report has her down as saying she is
    100% responsible.  Consequently the insurance company will not give out
    a hire car as the claim is being disputed by the other driver.
    
    What happens if your car is written off?  are you normally entitled to
    a hire car until the company pays up?  Friend now has no car, no money,
    whiplash and is out of pocket while having to take taxis everywhere.
    
    Unfortunately not a member of the AA so can't use their legal services
    as I have done successfully in the past......
    
    I would be interested in any comments...
    
    josie
1874.21WOTVAX::STONEGTemperature Drop in Downtime Winterland....Mon Mar 11 1996 13:2914
    
    If the accident was the other persons fault, then your friend's
    insurance Co wouldn't be paying for the hire car anyway, the other
    party would. If it says in the policy that you get a hire car then
    they should provide one and where necessary recover the cost from the
    other persons insurance afterwards. I've had this on a couple of
    occasions - there is sometimes a limit of 2 weeks on the initial hire -
    and I kept the hire car until mine was repaired (12 weeks in one
    case!).
    
    I'd contact my broker in the first instance - it's what they get
    commission for after all - the Insurance company second.
    
    Graham
1874.22KERNEL::IMBIERSKITGood frames, Bad frames...Mon Mar 11 1996 17:3337
1874.23KERNEL::IMBIERSKITGood frames, Bad frames...Mon Mar 11 1996 17:3917
1874.24injuries, get it recordedWOTVAX::HATTONMWaiting for JS to offer me a drive...Mon Mar 11 1996 17:5211
    
    ditto -1  record all your injuries IN FULL and get as much info written
    down by the "quack" as you can.  Whiplash can/does last for years. 
    
    My wife still suffers (+5 yrs) neck/back pains alot and occasionally my 
    sister (+10 yrs).  Both of their accidents were 100% NOT there fault.
    
    Regards,
    
    - MARK -
    
1874.25WOTVAX::MCCAFFREYJIf in doubt switch it off.Tue Mar 12 1996 12:3223
    Thanks for the replies...
    
    she did go to hospital straight after the accident and did have a neck
    collar on for a day.  I guess there is a report from there which should
    go to her doctors anyway.
    
    I think they were going through the broker who seems next to useless. 
    I am keen to get her going in the right direction as she is my nanny
    and so needs the car for work etc.  The inconvenience from a work point
    of view is ridiculous - ie getting taxis to work, being late, etc etc. 
    Meanwhile the other driver gets their car repaired and is happily
    driving around.
    
    Getting your car written off is no joke.  Apparently the insurance
    assessor has officially written it off so I guess it's just a case of
    waiting for the money.  Meanwhile she has to find money she hasn't got
    to get around.  
    
    I'll bear in mind the comments about the whiplash....
    
    thanks
    
    josie