[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference moira::parenting_v3

Title:Parenting
Notice:READ 1.27 BEFORE WRITING
Moderator:CSC32::DUBOIS
Created:Wed May 30 1990
Last Modified:Tue May 27 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1364
Total number of notes:23848

734.0. "Which Cool-Mist Humidifier?" by TRACTR::MAZUR () Wed Feb 27 1991 13:41

    Hi,
    
    	Can anyone recommend a good "cool-mist" humidifier/vaporizer
    for my daughter's room?  She's got her first cold and the one
    we have is very old.  
    
    Thanks!
    Sheryl
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
734.1Consumer ReportsNEWPRT::WAHL_ROWed Feb 27 1991 14:148
    
    I'm not sure of the brand, but my husband has been looking for the top
    rated brand in Consumer Reports for a month now.  I can't even remember the
    issue, but if you send me mail, I can give him a call.....
    
    Rochelle
    
    newprt::wahl_ro
734.2I use Gold Star Ultrasonic SHRMAX::ROGUSKAWed Feb 27 1991 16:2921
    I have a couple of ultrasonic humidifiers (don't want to get into
    the debate over whether they should be used or not - I use them 
    and have no problem, just clean them weekly!) The one in my son's
    room is a Holmes I think about three years old and working fine.
    
    I just bought two (2) new ones. A couple of weeks ago I bought a 
    Gold Star humidifier at Bradlees - based on price alone it was 24.99
    the cheapest I could find!  It works fine does the job I need and
    is adequate for my needs.  Last night I bought another one at Bradlees
    because we need an additional one one ground floor of the house - 
    we just installed new hardwood floors & with forced hot air heating
    we need additional mositure.
    
    I read the Consumer reports I believe they recommend the Bonnaire (?)
    but I didn't want to spend $50+ on a humidifier - especially seeing I
    new I would end up needing two!  By the way I tried the warm air
    humidifer by Polenex and it was so noisey I cleaned it up and returned
    it to the store telling them it was to [[[[loud]]]]!
                                   
    Kathy
    
734.3Dust...Dust...DustEXIT26::SULLIVANWed Feb 27 1991 17:2916
    Hi,
    
    I bought a Polonex cold air humidifier.  It is okay....It does make a
    gurgling noise while it is on and boy....does it cause the dust to pile
    up on your furniture.  
    
    I bought it because where we live it is very dry and I need the
    humidity to make it easier to breath.  But you have to keep it running
    for a while to notice a difference.  And I work day and some evenings
    so it's hard for me to keep it going constantly.  I am expecting a baby
    in June....so I'll be able to keep it on more often.
    
    By the way...I spent 59.00 for it.
    
    Donna
    
734.4MAMTS3::MWANNEMACHERlet us pray to HimWed Feb 27 1991 17:379
    The issue as to whether to use the cool mist or not has nothing to do
    with the humidifier itself, but rather with the quality of the water.  
    The answer to this problem is to use distilled water in the cool mist
    humidifier, this water has been purified and thus there are no
    contaminents going into the air.  
    
    Peace,
    
    Mike 
734.5KAOFS::S_BROOKAsk Not for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for ME!Wed Feb 27 1991 17:536
    Not to go down this rathole again, but .4 isn't totally correct
    becasue dust and spores in the air will land in the humidifier and
    the moist environment makes a near perfect breeeding ground for
    spores and other wonderful beasties.  Therefore, it is essential
    that all humidifiers should be cleaned and disinfected on a regular
    basis no matter what kind of water you use.
734.6No Ultrasonic Humidifiers for Me!TUNER::CLEMENTWed Feb 27 1991 19:347
    I have two ultrasonic humidifiers that I no longer use.  Everytime
    I did, my son would have a sinus infection.  I would clean mine 
    very other day, so it wasn't from lack of cleaning.  I would go with
    the cool mist vaporizer.  That's what my doctor suggested I use on
    my son when needed.  
    
    
734.7Bionair is the brand nameWORDY::STEINHARTPixillatedThu Feb 28 1991 12:2422
    We have the Bionair (sp?) and are very pleased with it.  It runs about
    $75 though.  It is very highly rated because it boils the incoming
    water then cools it before spritzing.  It is quiet.  It has two tanks
    that are easy to carry.  The water enters the active unit through a
    small valve in the bottom on the tank.  We've had no white dust. 
    
    The first one we got had a defect in one of the valves.  We exchanged
    it.  They are carried at Lechmere, etc.
    
    By the way, we use it in the master bedroom only.  The baby slept in
    our room until she was 4 months old.  Now she sleeps in her room
    without benefit of a humidifier.  If she needs one next winter, I may
    get her "el cheap-o" from the drugstore - about $25.00.  Can't see
    spending $75 per bedroom, and the unit is larger than el cheap-o.
    
    A previous note mentioned central air:  You can get a humidifier that
    attaches to the main heat duct near the oil burner.  It runs whenever
    the heat blasts.  Ask your oil burner company or a contractor who does
    ducts.  It keeps our house level at about 40% and we raise it to 55% in
    our bedroom at night with the humidifier.
    
    Laura               
734.8Patten works fineBAUCIS::CROTEAUThu Feb 28 1991 16:186
    I live in New Hampshire where the water has a high mineral content.
    We had tried many brands of cool mist humidifiers.  They would work
    fine for about 2 weeks, then they would clog with minerals.  We 
    finally bought a Patten humidifier.  It has a filter and a quiet fan.
    They sell them at Lechmere's for $50 and are somethimes on sale for
    $40.  We are very pleased with it.
734.9Bionair ok for high mineral waterWORDY::STEINHARTPixillatedThu Feb 28 1991 17:514
    Bionair also works in high-mineral New Hampshire.  It has a plastic
    drawer where extracted minerals are deposited for disposal. 
    
    L
734.10BPOV02::D_PAGETFri Mar 08 1991 02:195
    We have the Bionaire 204 (?), which is the one Consumer Reports
    recommends.  We have VERY hard water, for which you can get a special
    filter for the Bionaire.  We filter the water as it runs into the tanks
    and, except for when it's turned up full blast, have never had white
    dust.