[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference moira::parenting

Title:Parenting
Notice:Previous PARENTING version at MOIRA::PARENTING_V3
Moderator:GEMEVN::FAIMANY
Created:Thu Apr 09 1992
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1292
Total number of notes:34837

1241.0. "PUNISHED BY REWARDS" by EVER::LALIBERTE (PSG/IAE - OGO) Mon Jan 27 1997 14:35

    Can someone summarize for me the concepts in Alfie Kohn's 
    book PUNISHED BY REWARDS.  If this has been discussed in
    another note, pls point me to it. Thanks.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1241.1virtue is its own reward?RUMOR::CONSIDINETue Jan 28 1997 14:119
From the blurb I read -

The basic concept is that giving physical rewards for good behavior
reinforces the child to ask "what is in it for me?"  as opposed to
internalizing why it is in their interest to eat their vegetables,
be honest, trustworthy, etc.


Maura
1241.2WRKSYS::MACKAY_ETue Jan 28 1997 14:4913
    
    The concept in .1 is pretty much how we've raised our daughter.
    We have never used any physical rewards since we EXPECT her to
    be capable of accomplishments (such as toilet training, brushing
    her teeth, be honest, be compassionate, etc) just because she is
    human. Since all humans (unless challenged) can use a toilet or
    toothbrush or tell the truth or be nice, we don't see the point 
    of rewarding such natural progressions. Yes, we do have celebrations 
    for extraordinary achievements, like being on the honors roll or
    winning a competition. It works for us.
     
    
    Eva  
1241.3CSLALL::JACQUES_CACrazy ways are evidentTue Jan 28 1997 15:1419
    I tell you, I get a good poop out of my Angeline and I'm ready
    to throw a parade as a reward!  ;-)
    
    So far, though, I generally do not give much in the way of 
    physical reward for an immediate action.  Well I mean, encouragement
    and hugs and expressions of pride flow easily.  But an actual treat
    as a reward comes at more unexpected times.
    
    Like Saturday...I've been trying to teach Angeline to ask for 
    things "nicely".  Ongoing process.   However, we both got up in
    great moods Saturday.  She asked for things well without prompting.
    We played together nice all day, and had fun outside, and she didn't
    protest much of anything...we just had a great day.  Sometime during
    the afternoon, I slipped her a couple Hershey's kisses just "for being
    so good today" and "making Mama have SO much fun!".  :-)
    
    Works for now, but I'm sure things will change and change with time.
    
    						cj *->