[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference moira::naturism

Title:Naturism
Notice:Site report index is in topic 7
Moderator:GENRAL::KILGORE
Created:Tue Jan 26 1988
Last Modified:Thu May 08 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:457
Total number of notes:3687

188.0. "NPR report on Eastern Gathering" by MOIRA::FAIMAN (light upon the figured leaf) Sun Jul 09 1989 19:43

    The following was contributed by a conference reader who wishes to
    remain anonymous.
    
    	-Neil Faiman, moderator
    
    -----------------------------------------------------------------------

Last night _All_Things_Considered_ included a story on naturism.  (I caught it
this morning as WBUR re-broadcasted it.)  Because the beginning of the
half-hour contained a teaser on the story I started my tape recorder so that I
could catch it and transcribe it.  Below is the story:

(Anchor)
Today, thousands of Americans will take off to celebrate the 13th annual
national nude weekend.  One of the groups sponsoring these activities in the
Naturist Society, the Naturist are an international organization of 16000 card
carrying nudists, who believe in what they call a clothing-optional lifestyle.
A couple of weeks back NPR's Ann Goodwin and a friend joined 700 naturists at
the groups' annual eastern gathering.

     The event is being held in the heart of Pennsylvania's Poconno Mountains,
     at a Girl Scout camp.  Down the road is one of those Las Vegas style
     honeymoon resorts with a red, heart shaped bathtub and red satin sheets. 
     On the ride up I read through a quarterly magazine called
     _Clothed_With_The_Sun_, which explains the importance of supporting
     nudists' rights at national parks and seashores across the country; and
     it contains reports on recent events like a nudist clothing drive for
     Armenian earthquake victims.  There's also a list of weekend events;
     group massage workshops taught by the stroking community; a media clinic
     on how to present a wholesome public image; volleyball and tennis
     tournaments; lifestyles classes for single, families, gays, and marrieds
     without naturist partners; and canoeing, or canuding as they prefer to
     call it.  I'm not sure what to expect.

     When we pull into the camp's parking lot we watch the new-comers hurl
     their clothes into their cars and stride through the mud to the
     registration office wearing only beach thongs and carrying bottles of
     sunscreen lotion.  They're naked.  They're really naked.  Nudists I
     realize come in all ages, sizes and shapes, including smooth, wrinkled,
     lumpy, scarred and tattooed.  But weeding through the sea of mostly nude
     bodies, I'm puzzled at why hundreds of people would want to get together
     to be nude. A nudist official, Arny Erikson, denies that there is
     anything titillating or sexual about that many people being nude together,
     and looking around I can believe him, but I noticed that there are far
     fewer women than men.

     	(man's voice) "It is hard to get a woman to go alone into a bar, even
     	into a restaurant alone, and how can we expect a woman to knock a
     	nudist's door alone?  So, we gotta explain to them that, you know this
     	is a nice lifestyle; and we have also learned statistically that women
     	are reluctant to become nudists to begin with, but having first become
     	a nudist, you can't get her out of there."

     That may be, but I don't see any women by themselves, and I don't think
     that I would have attended this event alone.  Neither my boyfriend or I
     take off our clothes until the temperature climbs up into the 90s and
     skinny-dipping begins to sound inviting.  But at the pool there's no
     place to change, just chairs lined up along a fence.  The pool is packed
     and I'm thinking "How fast can I get in the water?"  Once I'm in it's OK,
     but getting out of the pool I feel dozens of eyes watching me.  I ask
     Claire Gesselman, who's a member of a Virginia naturists group, how she
     feels about being outnumbered by men, and about people checking her out.

     	Personally I don't find if there are a few more men than women I don't
     	find it uncomfortable because the men who are participating in this
     	activity are (pause) not here to look at women's bodies.

     Maybe the pool is just more conducive to gawking, but if, in general
     there's little staring at a naturist gathering, it may be because these
     are not the kind of sclupted young bodies you find in Calvin Klien
     commercials.  By and large the naturist are a prosperous looking bunch,
     Claire agrees.

     	I think that there may be a heavier proportion or a larger proportion
     	of people who are not in top physical condition, you know working out
     	and all that sort of thing, because some of the people who do that are
     	very rigorous working out are very body conscious and they do compare
     	themselves to other people every day when they go to the gym, and so
     	they're much less comfortable in this kind of a situation, than
     	someone who's maybe a little overweight and has accepted the fact that
     	they are.

     In the evenings people gather at the rec hall, a giant old Quonset hut
     festooned with colored streamers and covered hand painted signs bearing
     funny slogans that once hung outside the Girl Scout's cabins; it looks
     like a summer camp movie set from the 1950s.  Each night there are dance
     parties held here, with music to please everyone.  Thursday was big-band
     and swing music, Friday a live blue-grass group showed up, and tonight
     there's a dance contest with a nude disk-jockey who plays rock and roll
     into the wee hours of the morning.  Some people bring their children
     along to the dance, but most kids are tucked in bed by the time things
     really get going.  A male cross-dresser, in a slinky black satin dress,
     joins the disk-jockey on stage and brings down the house with a strip
     tease.  By this time the atmosphere is charged with sexuality, the room
     is dense with hot, sweaty, enthusiastic dancers.  We sit down on the
     metal folding chairs line up along the edges of the scuffed wooden dance
     floor and watch, but I feel the kind of nervous you get peaking at
     Playboy magazines as a kid; except these people are three-dimensional and
     not more than a few feet away.  They're scantily dressed if they're
     dressed at all.  Many women wear tight stretchy numbers unzipped far
     enough to reveal a generous amount of cleavage, it clearly excites the
     men.  I don't feel like dancing and I have to step out for air.

     For the naturists the world is divided up into two groups: nudists and
     the rest.  Even after three days of nothing but nude bodies I think that
     I'm forever doomed to be part of the second camp.  I put my clothes back
     on as soon as I got out of the pool, and I've kept them on ever since. 
     I'm Ann Goodwin.

The story ended with the music and chorus from TOTALLY NUDE from
The_Talking_Heads' "NAKED" album.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
188.1my $0.02AWAKE::WESTERVELTSun Jul 09 1989 21:2114

	I wonder what people's reaction to this report is.  Personally,
	it seemed to me that Ann Goodwin did not have a particularly
	open mind (for what that's worth) and chose to broadcast from
	the "these folks are not to be trusted" viewpoint.  The report 
	consisted primarily of her own subjective feelings projected onto the
	crowds she was with.  In particular, she seemed rather obsessed
	with the so-called sexual angle and almost managed to make everyone
	sound like a sexual pervert of some kind.  Well maybe I'm overstating
	it but she certainly sounded like she considered the whole thing
	an unnecessary exercise in bad taste.  It was more negative than
	most broadcasts of this type I've heard.  (She should have interviewed
	Lee Baxandall, wasn't he there?)  What do other people think?
188.2COVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertTue Jul 11 1989 00:4814
>In particular, she seemed rather obsessed with the so-called sexual angle and
>almost managed to make everyone sound like a sexual pervert of some kind.
>Well maybe I'm overstating it but she certainly sounded like she considered the
>whole thing an unnecessary exercise in bad taste.

It seems her report turned negative when the cross-dresser did the strip tease.

A strip tease at a naturist convention, as well as people wearing seductive
clothing, seems pretty out of line to me.

If there weren't dopes like that hanging around amongst the naturists and
creating a sexually charged atmosphere, there might be a lot less skepticism.

/john
188.3I agree with JohnGENRAL::KILGOREWe are the People, Earth & StarsTue Jul 11 1989 14:0722
I wonder if others present at the gathering knew Ann Goodwin was doing a story 
about the naturist, then took the opportunity to put themselves in the "light" 
and ending up making a mockery of the nudist scene?  

I still believe there is nothing sexual about getting together with a bunch of 
nude people UNLESS your motive is to be sexual.  And I agree with John that 
Ann's tune changed with the cross-dresser's actions.  I wouldn't be comfortable
in a strange environment, where I was new to the activity of nudism, and then
have a striptease performed when it was not the time or place for it.  I've
watched a few in my time, and every one of them had sexual connotations.  If
you are in to that sort of thing, fine.  Just don't perform it at Naturist 
gatherings because someone will always take it and "run" with it, reporting
it to the world that nudist are sex crazed maniacs.  It just isn't true!  This
is a excellent example [very sick and in poor taste, in my opinion] of how the 
actions of a few get blow out of proportion.

We all have to be aware of how our actions might affect other people.  Then 
those people rally against us (who prefer to be without body covering some of 
the time).  It is not a true `free' country yet, so let's do our part to make 
it more free for everyone (and not make a**es of ourselves in the meantime!).

Judy
188.4It's Hard to Believe it!HPSTEK::SHERMANTue Jul 11 1989 15:4947
    T'warnt Like Attika in 1988!
    
    If this was this year's Eastern Naturist Gathering (ENG) and that was an
    accurate description of what was going on and how things looked, I am
    glad I didn't go.  
    
    However, for some reason, I think that description was not accurate ...
    possibly it was unfair.  Professional (and I use the term with tongue
    in cheek) media persons seem to dwell on the negative or just don't
    cover events at all.  If they Pre-attitude a negative, they could
    attend a church social and come out with something nasty in their
    print demeanor.
    
    I was absolutely enthralled at the way everyone behaved at the 1988
    ENG.  I am sure I would have been at the 1989 event, also.  I am sure
    that there were many other things going on there:
    
    o Art Exhibits
    o Sports: Tennis, baseball, (Even Bocci, because I brought my set!)
    o Entertainment: We had a gong show.  The Audience was a bit rowdyish,
    but it was in the spirit of good fun.  The winners were illustrated in
    CWTS, but even I (The WASP, Remember?) laughed at the winners.  Funny,
    but nice funny if you know what I mean.
    
    o Dancing:  In 1988 the Gentleman half of one couple was a great
    dancer.  He could do any dance from way back when to tomorrow!  His
    wife, sweet thing, was crippled.  She could hardly walk (But she did,
    by golly ... and we all loved her).  She didn't dance, but HE did! 
    Almost every lady in the place danced with him.  She was happy to see
    him make the place happy.  Yes, I blinked a little when I saw him dance
    with someone else the first time.  But when you watched the dancing and
    watched his dear wife, you know you were experiencing one of the nice
    and wholesome parts of Naturism.  Words don't do it justice, so I'll
    stop.
    
    I suppose THAT would have made some real horrendous copy in a textile
    magazine.
    
    Taint what you see, It's the Taint that you bring with you! (Hey, I
    didn't know where that sentence was going when I started!  I'm glad I
    said that!)
    
    A PFFT to those who say Naturism is dirty.  Was that a four-letter
    word? Well so be it.
    
    Stan/
    
188.5What did the heart-shaped tubs have to do with it?MOIRA::FAIMANlight upon the figured leafTue Jul 11 1989 16:4540
On reading this story, I concluded that either

    the Gathering wasn't anything like the nudist experiences that I've had, or

    the reporter was fitting her experiences into a bunch of preconceptions

    -- or maybe both, of course.

Let's face it, there are lots of people in this world who are never going to be
naturists; and forcing one of these people into a naturist experience with the
expectation that they'll love it, once they know what it's really like, isn't
going to do anyone any good.  It sounds like the reporter might have been one 
of these people.

I suppose it's a common feeling that all eyes are on you, the first time you
take your clothes off, but I've never seen a beach or pool where it was
actually true.  But this report simply asserts, "Getting out of the pool I 
feel dozens of eyes watching me."  I can't tell whether that's an acknowledg-
ment of her own insecurity, or whether she really thought that everyone was
watching her.

I can imagine a female-impersonator-striptease at a nudist event as a parody,
a joke about people who get up tight about other people taking their clothes
off; but I can also imagine that the final effect might not be that simple.

As Jay reminds us from time to time, nudists are human, too, with all the
normal human sexual instincts hidden away somewhere.  I've never been to a 
nudist dance, so I can't begin to guess whether "the atmosphere was charged 
with sexuality" and the men were clearly excited by the cleavage the women
were revealing, or whether the reporter was just incredibly uptight.  I have 
a suspicion that the people at the dance couldn't give us a definitive answer, 
either.  (But any naturist knows that "tight stretchy numbers unzipped far 
enough to reveal a generous amount of cleavage" are more arousing than simple 
nudity... it makes one wonder.)

By the way, did anyone notice the veiled hints of perversity, with some people
bringing their children along to watch these hot, sweaty bodies dancing in an
atmosphere charged with sexuality?

	-Neil
188.7KAOFS::D_BIGELOWHedonism - ahhhhhh!Fri Jul 14 1989 12:1020
    
      Well....., I'd definitely agree that Ann's article is one-sided,
    and is trying to persuade the reader that EVERYTHING she saw was
    inappropriate.  But, if that's the case, then why was she there
    in the first place ?  Was she forced to go and do a story ?
    
      As jay pointed out, her style catches your attention immediately,
    perhaps that's why she wrote it that way, to grab a person's 
    attention.  I think she'd do well, if she wrote stories for Penthouse.
    
      In my own personal opinion, I believe that Ann secretly enjoyed
    herself while she was there.  I assume that she was naked also,
    as one part of her article metioned about all eyes being on her
    when she got out of the pool.  Did someone force her to take her
    clothes off?  Ann's style demands immediate negative reaction from
    the reader, but I think underneath all the words, she enjoyed herself
    very much.  Hmmm, maybe she'll become a regular.
    
    Darrell
    
188.8If she said she didn't like it, maybe we should believe herMOIRA::FAIMANlight upon the figured leafFri Jul 14 1989 13:1324
It is easy (for me, anyways) to get in the habit of thinking that people 
who claim to dislike of the idea of nudism would be  converted if they could 
just experience it -- if their misconceptions were dispelled, if they knew 
what it was really like, etc.

This is probably true for many people, but I think that this report was a 
valuable reminder that there are many people who *won't* like social nudity, 
even if they try it -- maybe even if they try it a lot.  It doesn't matter if
we think their reasons are simple personal preference or deep subconscious
repressions.  

The important thing is to respect everyone's right to their own personal 
choices.  (Obviously, we hope that they will respect ours as well.)  I should
no more expect everyone to share my taste for naturism than I should expect
them to share my tastes in music, literature, or anything else.

I don't think it does anyone a service to assume that someone who claims *not*
to have enjoyed a nudist experience must be deceiving us or herself.

	-Neil

(By the way, in response to a particular comment in .7, the reporter says that
she put her clothes back on when she got out of the pool, and kept them on for
the rest of the weekend.)
188.9KAOFS::D_BIGELOWHedonism - ahhhhhh!Fri Jul 14 1989 16:4211
    Woops !  I missed the last part about her putting her clothes back
    on after she got out of the pool.
    
    Neil, please try not to be so critical.  Whether or not she enjoyed
    herself makes no difference to me, I was just giving my own personal
    opinion (interpretation), of how her story came across to me.  It
    doesn't mean that I don't respect her attitudes or morals, if they
    are in fact her real feelings towards naturism.
    
    Darrell
    
188.11Anything to do with the throat?MISERY::WARD_FRGoing HOME--as an AdventurerTue Aug 01 1989 15:586
    re: .10
    
        What's a "pubic tonsure"?
    
    Frederick
    
188.12possible definition (if not a typo)FSTVAX::LEWISDisplaced Desert RatTue Aug 01 1989 16:5723
    RE: .11
    
    >>What's a "pubic tonsure"?
    
    Assuming that this was not a typo in Baxandall's letter and was
    meant as written then from the Scribner-Bantam English Dictionary
    the following definitions are offered:
    
    		Pubic [from LATIN, pubes, groin, pubic hair] situated
    adjacent to the genitals
    
    		Tonsure [again from LATIN, shearing] the act of cutting
    the hair or of shaving the head, the part of the head left bare
    by such shaving, to subject to tonsure.                
    
    
    
    	I'll let you decide if Baxandall means what is implied by the
    two word used together, or if it was a typo!!!!!
    
    
    			Dave....
    
188.13Not Entirely Astonishing, EH?IOENG::JWILLIAMSWelcome to the Bush LeagueWed Aug 02 1989 17:1813
    I just read .0, and I think this Ann Goodwin passes more gas than sound
    judgement. I am trying to imagine her reaction if no one had looked
    at her. Silly fuss.
    
    Reminds me of a line from Satanic Verses: When the camera approaches
    you want to get further away, until it turns direction and you need to
    chase after it. ( or words to that effect )
    
    The only thing worse than having people look at you is not having
    people looking at you. ( Sounds like something Oscar Wilde might have
    said )
    
    							John.