[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference moira::naturism

Title:Naturism
Notice:Site report index is in topic 7
Moderator:GENRAL::KILGORE
Created:Tue Jan 26 1988
Last Modified:Thu May 08 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:457
Total number of notes:3687

115.0. "naturism and religion" by CXCAD::MCCOY () Thu Sep 29 1988 13:49

       I feel the need to start this off with a disclaimer, or at least
       a clear explanation of my motives so as to not elicit the wrong
       responses. I've read through this conference with some interest
       for a while now and have a specific question I would like to pose
       to the group. The question involves religious beliefs and
       naturism but I want it understood that I'm not out point fingers,
       condemn or convert. I basically have honest questions in my mind
       and would like to know others opinions. Also, as much as I'll try
       not to, I'm afraid that I may have to use 'labels' in phrasing my
       question. I hate doing that because different people associate
       different meanings to a given label and that always leads to
       misunderstandings. Anyway, please accept this in the innocent,
       non-threatening way that it is meant.

       Is there anyone (or does anyone know of anyone) who considers
       themselves to be a 'born-again' or 'Bible-believing' Christian
       (see what I mean about labels) and a naturist? And if so, how do
       you (or they) validate naturist activities against the
       Judeo-Christian traditional teaching that nude is bad?

       dean

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
115.1Some people have no trouble combining themMOIRA::FAIMANA goblet, a goblet, yea, even a hoopThu Sep 29 1988 15:0627
    Not being a Christian, I don't have a personal answer to this
    question, and I don't want to preempt anyone who does. 
    
    I would like to mention that the compatibility of naturism and
    Biblical teachings is a subject that has gotten some discussion in
    naturist circles.  In fact, I think a good chunk of one issue of CwS
    was devoted to naturism and religion, and there have been a number
    of other articles devoted to the sort of "proof by quoting chapter
    and verse" (both ways, of course) that some people love to engage
    in.
    
    Jim Cunningham has consistently made a strong argument for nudity
    from a Catholic standpoint, including having published Divine
    Reflections, a Christian/Nudist magazine. (See my review of his
    magazine Clothing-Optional Life in note 40.) 
    
    Also, Cedar Waters, a nudist camp that we frequent, is owned and run
    by a family with very strong fundamentalist Christian principles.
    (See the latest issue of CwS for a photo of their billboard with a
    "Robertson for President" banner attached to it from last spring's
    primary campaign.)
    
    So, there are certainly some people for whom naturism is not
    inconsistent with, and may even be mandated by, a more-or-less
    traditional, "fundamentalist" Christianity.
    
    	-Neil
115.2thanks for understandingCXCAD::MCCOYThu Sep 29 1988 15:4210
    Neil, thanks for the response. I was hesitant to bring up the question
    for the fear of being misunderstood but I see I got my meaning across.
    It was do to your title (Some people have no trouble combining them)
    that I posed the question.
    
    I'm at CXO and if anyone here has a copy of the CwS that Neil referred
    to in .1 could I borrow it? Thanks.
    
    dean
    
115.3CwS request filledGENRAL::KILGOREThe Desert RatThu Sep 29 1988 17:2310
Dean,  I'm also at CXO and subscribe to CwS.  If I can remember, I'll bring it
in tomorrow (unless Bob isn't done reading it!).  I'm a "space cadet" right 
now, getting ready to take vacation for a week, so I may not remember.  You 
may have to wait until I return on the 10th of Oct.  I work in Eng Repro, down-
stairs from you (unless you've moved to CXN!), so it would not be difficult to 
get it to you.

I'll give you a call when I bring it in.

Judy
115.4A few random thoughtsBSS::RJONESWed Oct 05 1988 14:5611
	Interesting to note that according to the book of Genesis, Adam
and Eve didn't feel any shame in their nakedness until after they had
eaten of the fruit they had been warned against.  It was them trying
to conceal their bodies that tipped God off that they had done the deed.

	Another semi-related thought is that St. Francis of Assisi was
known to have shed every last article of clothing on numerous occassions,
once to symbolize his spiritual birth, and most frequently to give away
his clothing to someone more in need of it than he.

Richard
115.5In the beginning....BSS::RJONESFri Oct 14 1988 15:095
    I've heard it said that the first bookkeepers were Adam and
    Eve; that they invented the "loose-leaf" system!
    
    ;-)
    Richard
115.6Roots of objections to nudismMOIRA::FAIMANlight upon the figured leafThu Oct 20 1988 16:1138
    It is obvious that nudism is highly offensive to many people holding
    what would be categorized as "fundamentalist Christian" beliefs.  I
    suspect that there are two completely independent factors here. 

    There are some theological arguments, pro and con, about nudity:

        There is one traditional view that everything having to do with the
        world and the flesh is tainted, and that only the spirit is pure.
	This view leads to suspicion, suppression, and concealment of the
	body.

        There is another view that God made man in His own image, so that
        it is blasphemous to assert that man's body is indecent and should
        be concealed, since it is tantamount to asserting the indecency of
        God's own image.

        Being neither a Christian nor a theologian myself, I won't presume
        to try and get any deeper into these issues.  

        There is also an argument that the naked body isn't indecent in
        itself, but that nakedness should be hidden because it will tempt
        people to lust and to sexual thoughts and actions.  (I would assert
        that this particular argument is clearly false.  It must be based
        on the imaginings of someone who hasn't experienced how basically
        asexual familiar social nudity really is.) 

    But much more important, I think, is the common feeling that nudity is
    *intrinsically* nasty. This really isn't a religious view at all.  It's
    a personal and cultural prejudice.  I believe that it arises from a
    fundamental misunderstanding of what nudism is about.  It is easy to
    understand how someone who hasn't experienced a nude beach or nudist
    club could have misconceptions that would lead him or her to classify
    nudism as a vice along with free sex, drugs, and violent rock music.  I
    cannot believe that anyone with an open mind could hold that view after
    such an experience. 

	-Neil
                                         
115.7Conditioned responsesRETORT::GOODRICHTaking a long vacationTue Oct 25 1988 13:2912
    re .-1
    
    I agree - the major problem is that few folks have an open
    mind and most react based upon conditioned responses.
    
    Conditioned responses are key to survival of all species,
    it is difficult to override these responses with "reason".
    
    Such changes do occur but they seem to require either a dramatic
    force or lots of time.
    
    - Gerry
115.8HAMPS::PHILPOTT_ICol. Philpott is back in action...Wed Apr 12 1989 10:5030
    Yes I'm a Bible-believing Christian - a Lutheran to be exact.
    
    I believe that an analogy may help: many people miss-quote the Bible
    to indicate that money is evil. The actual quote of course is that
    *love* of money is evil.
    
    In the case of nudity, the only reference I can think of is to the
    expulsion of Adam & Eve from the Garden of Eden: The Lord made them
    aware that they were naked as a punishment for their sin, and they
    clothed themselves with fig leaves.
    
    The problem isn't nudity: it is an awareness of nudity. Nor is nudity
    a sin - the *awareness* of our nudity is a reminder of our Original Sin.
    
    In practicing naturism/nudism we may be aware of our nudity - certainly
    initially many of us are not only aware, but embarassed by it. That
    is in accord with the teaching of the Bible. However the Bible does
    not say we will remain aware of it, nor does it say nudity is sinful.
                                   
    We were all cast out of Eden, and we are all aware of our nudity.
    We need clothes for protection from the cold in northern or southern
    latitudes, and for protection from the sun in tropical climes. We
    need clothes for protection from being burned when cooking, or to
    protect our skin when doing dangerous things such as climbing. More
    to the point we need clothing to protect us from the censure of
    a textile world that reminds us daily that we no longer inhabit
    an Eden where we can joyously, and freely, go about our pursuits
    at leisure.
    
    /. Ian .\
115.9WiccaNEXUS::MORGANAll Hail Informatia!Tue Apr 18 1989 22:0111
    In peaceful deference to Ian, I am a Witch, Initiate and Pagan Priest
    of the Goddess. Yes 'tis true. B^)
    
    Nudity is part and parcel of our religious view because it symbolizes
    truth. We are what our bodies are and that's ok.
                       
    We don't subscribe to an origial sin theology. Sin is not a
    consideration for us at all. 
    
    There isn't much to say because it such an integral part of what
    most of us do.
115.10HAMPS::PHILPOTT_ICol. Philpott is back in action...Wed Apr 19 1989 08:5922
115.11Tell us more?IOENG::JWILLIAMSWelcome to the Bush LeagueTue Jul 18 1989 18:4013
    Whoa . . .
    
    I believe I've heard some of this mentioned by Joseph Campbell
    ( author of "The Power of Myth" ). The Earth Goddess predates most of
    the other religions by quite alot. I wasn't aware some of it existed
    still. Most of the earliest religious artifacts have female form.
    I wasn't aware that nudity was an important part in it. Does it entail
    some form of nude ritual?
    
    I only ask because different religions interest me.
    
    						Thanks,
    							John.
115.12BORN AGAIN CHRISTIONDNEAST::WAYE_MICHAELThu Nov 11 1993 06:076
    TO 115.1
    I am a born again Cristian and do practice solitary naturism.
    All things flesh or foul are permitid unless it causes a brother to
    fall. If you can go natural and be perfictly at ease no matter who
    you should meet, than you will not stumble. Only the spirit needs to be
    clothed by ritchousness (excuse the spelling) the body is only flesh.