[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference cookie::notes$archive:cd_v1

Title:Welcome to the CD Notes Conference
Notice:Welcome to COOKIE
Moderator:COOKIE::ROLLOW
Created:Mon Feb 17 1986
Last Modified:Fri Mar 03 1989
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1517
Total number of notes:13349

1019.0. "Best sounding CDs?" by DSSDEV::MOR () Fri Dec 18 1987 12:49

    List your "best sounding" CDs here.  At times, I don't know if a
    CD I'm interested in buying is all that better sounding than a
    tape at half the price.  Knowing that a CD sounds really great
    would be of great help in making my decision.
    
    I might as well start it off.  I just started collecting, but
    from what I own so far, my best sounding CDs are:
    
    Sting - Nothing Like the Sun
    Pink Floyd - The Wall
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1019.1Can't rave enough about the sound of this discDSSDEV::HALLGRIMSSONThe piano has been thinking...Fri Dec 18 1987 14:505
    "Ancient Dreams" by Patrick Ahearn on Private Music
    
    Amazing soundstage and percussion timbres.  This is almost all
    Fairlight CMI (synthesizer) but I forget that every time.
    
1019.2Transcribed from the 78 rpm discsCOVERT::COVERTJohn R. CovertFri Dec 18 1987 16:479
"The Mikado" performed by D'Oyly Carte, recorded in 1936.


Just kidding... it's not really my best sounding CD.

The real answer I still think is one of the first ones I bought, the Slatkin
Mahler's Second.

/john
1019.3Lot of different tastes, butHPSCAD::WALLI see the middle kingdom...Fri Dec 18 1987 17:2514
    
    Well, for studio rock, I'd say Rush's album "Power Windows" although
    the remaster of the Alan Parsons Project's "Tales of Mystery and
    Imagination" runs an extremely close second.
    
    For live rock, Rush's "Exit... Stage Left"
    
    For classical stuff, I'd say "Rossini: Overtures" by Sir Neville
    Marriner and the Academy of Saint-Martin-In-The-Field.
    
    For live classical, "Horowitz in Moscow"
    
    DFW
    
1019.4new age choicesSOFBAS::LACAIREFri Dec 18 1987 17:267
    "Lovely Thunder" by Harold Budd
    "Between Two Worlds" by Patrick O'Hearn
    
    Both have great dynamic range and low frequency info.
    Both create nice soundstage on my system.
    -Steve.
    
1019.5Best and WorstCURIUM::SHAHFri Dec 18 1987 18:276
    
    I'd say the best sounding CD I've heard is 
       "By Request" by John Williams of Boston Pops...
    
    The worst sounding I've heard was the Top Gun soundtrack...
    
1019.6Such a hard question...COOKIE::ROLLOWReturn of the Killer Mutant MondayFri Dec 18 1987 19:1820
    Rock:
    
    	Peter Gabriel - "Security"
    	Pink Floyd - "Dark Side of the Moon"  (on Harvest)
    	The Alan Parson's Project - "Tales of Mystery and Imagination,
    		Edgar Allan Poe"
    
    Classical:
    
    	Antonin Dvorak - Overtures - Chandos CHAN 8453
    	Carl Nielsen - Orchestral Music - BIS CD-247
    	Johannes Brahms - 1st Piano Concerto - RCA 5668-2
    		(1954 Stereo Recording)
    	Giuseppe Verdi - Messa de Requiem - Telarc CD-80152
    	(There are a host of others but these stand out.)

    				* * *
    
    I'll have to think about which of my soundtrack sounds the
    best.  It's bound to be one or more of the Varese Sarabande's.
1019.7My "Top 4" (so far)GENRAL::SEAGLE44% of statistics are meaninglessFri Dec 18 1987 20:4312
    I don't have that many (yet) either, but so far my votes go to:
    
    Grusin,       "Mountain Dance"                        (GRP/Arista)
    Muti,         "Pines/Fountains/Festivals of Rome"     (Angel/EMI)
    Previn,       "The Planets"                           (Telarc)
    Vollenweider, "White Winds"                           (CBS)
    
    Again, this is based on my limited collection and I'm just going
    for overall sound/performance quality.
    
    FWIW,
    David.
1019.8Billy Joel Greatest Hits Volumes I & IITOOK::MICHAUDJeff MichaudFri Dec 18 1987 23:394
    Billy Joel, Greatest Hits, Volume I & II
    
    I may have some clearer that I don't know about.  This is the only
    one I have turned up the amp to the max without getting any distortion.
1019.9How could I forget?COOKIE::ROLLOWReturn of the Killer Mutant MondaySat Dec 19 1987 02:131
    J.S. Bach - The Art of Fugue - Hungaroton HCD 12810-11-2
1019.10LESLIE::LESLIEAndy, CSSE DECnet/OSI Program, WG5.Sat Dec 19 1987 07:1812
1019.11COOKIE::CHAVEZDale C. - CXO3 Colo SpgsSat Dec 19 1987 21:021
Elton John Live In Austrailia - Outstanding!
1019.12WIDGIT::WESTOn a clear disk you can seek foreverSun Dec 20 1987 19:121
    I'm partial to Manheim Steamroller...
1019.13Great Beethoven sound on PROARTESALEM::MGINGRASHappy Birthday, Ludwig!!!Sun Dec 20 1987 21:485
    I really enjoy both the beautiful sound and performance of Russell
    Sherman's versions of the 5 Beethoven piano concertos on PROARTE.
    The piano has great tone and clarity and the Czech Philharmonic
    sounds majestic accompanying Sherman.
    
1019.14Star TracksPARITY::GOSSELINMon Dec 21 1987 09:147
    I like most anything by Erich Kunzel and the Cincinnati Pops. The
    "Star Tracks" CD, in particular, is especially clean sounding......
    
    
    
                                     Ken
    
1019.15I'm still not convinced by CDsDUB01::OSULLIVAN_DI'm sending out an ...---...Mon Dec 21 1987 10:205
    Classical:	Schubert's 8th (DG)
    Pop:	Michael Jackson's Bad; Springsteen's Tunnel of Love
    
    
    However...
1019.16what about the obvious?PNEUMA::WOODBURNMon Dec 21 1987 11:2910
    
    What about Dire Straights "Brothers in Arms"?
    and Don Fagen's "Night Fly"?
    and "GRP Live in Concert"?
    
    Some other good ones: Dianne Schurr "Timeless"
                          Orchestra Manhattan's "Digital Broadway"
                          Steve Earle "Guitar Town"
    
    
1019.17and I don't like pie either.CYBORG::MORRELLMon Dec 21 1987 12:026
    
    
       Re: .15  Thats Discusting. (both of those on the same line, or
    in the same reply, it's discusting,and repulsive)
    
    
1019.18two moreRDGENG::KEDMUNDSI haven't got an fm2r...Mon Dec 21 1987 13:442
    Hotel California - The Eagles
    Ammonia Avenue - Alan Parsons Project
1019.19Two biscuitsFSHQOA::SBEAUPREout the nextMon Dec 21 1987 17:374
    reply
    Van Morrison- St. Dominics Preview
    Frank Zappa- Hot Rats
    
1019.20Beauty is in the Ear ...USHS01::PARRACOMe ? I'm just a lawnmower ...Mon Dec 21 1987 17:5617
    
    re: .11  EJ - Live in Australia
    
    I grant you the recording is excellent, but after having to listen
    to poor Elton's voice after the surgery is painful, and depressing...
    
    My choices (out of over 175+ discs now):
    
    Telarc - Kunzel/Cincinnati 	TIME WARP
    Peter Gabriel		SECURITY
    Steely Dan			A DECADE of DAN
    Pat Metheny Group		STILL LIFE:TALKING
    Wynton Marsalis		HOT HOUSE FLOWERS
    The Police			GHOST in the MACHINE
    
    Enjoy !
    
1019.21Police CDsDSSDEV::MORMon Dec 21 1987 18:228
    re: .20
    
    How are the rest of the Police Cds?
    
    In particular, Regetta De Blanc and Synchronicity??
    Am I better off just getting the "Singles" album?  Or are they
    all worth getting?
    
1019.22The Mac Attack is Back!!!XCUSME::MAKARAWICZMon Dec 21 1987 18:5113
    
    
    FLEETWOOD MAC......."Tango In The Night"
    TALKING HEADS......."Little Creatures"
    PAUL SIMON.........."Graceland"
    STEVE WINWOOD......."Back In The High Life"
    PETER GABRIEL......."So"
    
    
    
    
    **WARNING: Don't buy "The Big Chill Soundtrack" on CD.  Save your
    money.
1019.23Norman...COOKIE::ROLLOWReturn of the Killer Mutant MondayMon Dec 21 1987 20:363
    Synchronicity is a very clean sounding disc.  I also like the
    music and even tolerate the "Mother" track.  I don't have the
    other one, so I can't comment.
1019.24giant steps are what you take....CYBORG::MORRELLTue Dec 22 1987 08:3012
    
     
     In reply to the sound of Regatta De-Blanc,   Well I don't have
    the cd (is it out?) any way the record is great so is Zenatta Mon-datta
    and Outlandos De-Amour great music , and theres nothing wrong with
    Mother (on sync.) you got to like humour in music. Check out the
    track "On Any Other Day" from Regatta.... It's wild
    
                                          Great stuff
    
                                                 Charlie
    
1019.25AKOV11::BOYAJIANThe Dread Pirate RobertsTue Dec 22 1987 09:075
    re:.24
    
    All of the Police albums have been out on CD for quite some time.
    
    --- jerry
1019.26my favesWORDS::ILYADISWe are the dust of the universeTue Dec 22 1987 11:2811
	Pink Floyd  -  Dark  Side  of the Moon (Harvest) Which is selling as
		collectors item for - get this - $150.  This may be a little
		steep for most of us (unless you bought it 2 to 3 years ago!)

	Andreas Wollenweider (sp?) - Down to the Moon
	
	Pink Floyd - Momentary Lapse of Reason
	
	Micheal  Hedges  - Aerial  Boundaries  -  if  you  like  progressive
		acoustic guitar.
1019.27Breath, breath in the AIR...CYBORG::MORRELLTue Dec 22 1987 11:419
    
    
      Re: .26  The harvest cd is worth/selling for THAT much $$$$$???????
    
          I just bought it USED must have been 6-months ago atleast
    but still thats alot. are you sure????
    
                                                Surprised
    
1019.28DSSDEV::CHANTue Dec 22 1987 11:5720
RE.26
    
>	Pink Floyd  -  Dark  Side  of the Moon (Harvest) Which is selling as
>		collectors item for - get this - $150.  This may be a little
>		steep for most of us (unless you bought it 2 to 3 years ago!)

    You've got to be kidding, aren't you?  Where's the smiley face?
    
    The Harvest version isn't
    the best sounding DSOtM CD out there.  I've had the Capital, Harvest,
    and EMI.  The EMI is far superior to either the Capital or Harvest.
    The dealer I purchased the EMI version said that there is a Music
    Fidelity version that supposidly sounds better than the EMI but
    he has never been able to get his hands on it (hasn't even seen
    it for that matter, it may not exist.)  But hey, don't take my word
    or anyone elses of which one sounds best.  If you spent $150 for
    your copy and it sounds good to you be happy.  What you don't know
    won't kill you :^) .
    
    Kenney
1019.29A long list...CELICA::CLEARYDo turkeys enjoy the holidays?Tue Dec 22 1987 13:1914
    o Billy Joel - The Bridge
    o Til Tuesday - Welcome Home
    o Steely Dan - Decade 
    o Fleetwood Mac _ Tango In The Night
    o Doobie Brothers - Greatest Hits Vol. I
    o Andreas Vollenweider - Down To The Moon
    o Donald Fagen - The Nightfly
    o Dire Straits - Brothers In Arms
    o David Sanborn - A Change Of Heart
    o Beatles - Rubber Soul
    
    Could go on and on...
    
    
1019.30WFOVX0::SCHRAFTPeter C. Schraft 242-2235Tue Dec 22 1987 13:349
    re.28
    
    	There is (was) a Mobile Fidelity version of the Dark Side of
    the Moon released. My brother got his about 3 years ago new. It's
    supposed to be the best sounding version of them all.  
    
    
    Peter
    
1019.31My limited opinionDECWET::HELSELTue Dec 22 1987 13:3710
    I was surprised at how good Crosby, Stills and Nash (the one with
    Neil Young looking out the back door) sounded.  I thought it would
    be bad but decided to take a chance.  I was surprised...maybe because
    I expected the worst.  Maybe my albums was just so worn out that
    anything would sound good. 
    
    I found that U2's Unforgettable Fire  was pretty good and I'm not
    a big U2 fan.
    
    Brett
1019.32My ListCSC32::J_PARSONSBruno...Is that you?Tue Dec 22 1987 13:426
    Dire Straits	- 	Brothers in Arms
    Andreas Vollenweider -	White Winds
    Dave Grusin/Lee Ritenour -	Harlequin
    Winton Marsalis	-	Hot House Flowers
    Amanda McBroom	-	Dreaming
    David Sanborn	-	A Change of Heart
1019.33Make me an offer :-)DECWET::HELSELTue Dec 22 1987 16:4819
    There seems to be some amount of debate of Dark Side of the Moon.
    
    I just came from Silver Platter in Bellevue.  They had both the
    Capitol and Harvest version of Dark Side.  When I asked about the
    EMI version, I was told that Harvest is a subsidiary of EMI and
    that there is only one version other than Capitol.
    
    It was concurred by the folks there that the Harvest version is
    *much* better and hence, the price was greater also.  The Capitol
    version was selling at 14.95 and I won't say how much more the
    Harvest version was selling for.
    
    I will start the bidding at $100.  Send me mail.
    
    As for the other Pink Floyd CD's, it was the opinion of the Silver
    Platter staff that they are all pretty good on CBS.  They sited
    Meddle, Animals and Wish You Were Here as being good.
    
    Brett.
1019.34AKOV11::BOYAJIANThe Dread Pirate RobertsTue Dec 22 1987 19:099
    re:.33
    
    That guy is giving you a line. Actually, Capitol, Harvest, and
    EMI are bedfellows. The Capitol is the US release, the Harvest
    is the UK release, and the EMI is the Japanese release. I have
    the EMI version. Every report I've seen comparing the different
    versions claims that the EMI issue is the best of the three.
    
    --- jerry
1019.35MEMORY::SLATERTue Dec 22 1987 19:415
    re -.33 .34 and others on "dark side"
    
    Are these different mixes? Or ome other difference?
    
    Les
1019.36AKOV11::BOYAJIANThe Dread Pirate RobertsWed Dec 23 1987 01:285
    re:.35
    
    Same mix, but different remasterings.
    
    --- jerry
1019.37chaseing away the moments that make up a DULL day...CYBORG::MORRELLWed Dec 23 1987 09:0114
    
    
       Re: Dark side.... I Agree that the Harvest sounds alot cleaner
    than the CBS, though I've never seen the EMI version i can't say
    it exists, and I don't see how it can get any cleaner than the Harvest
    edition. and then again I don't care if it's cleaner the Harvest
    because the Harvest is GREAT.
    
        Is that guy trying to sell a harvest edition? I'm confused but
    I'll give him $10.00 as thats all I paid for mine, used. (it's
    imaculate)
    
                                                   Satisfied
    
1019.38"Lorelei, let's live together..."HPSCAD::WALLI see the middle kingdom...Wed Dec 23 1987 11:2910
    
    Leaping off that Pink Floyd digression (I've got the CBS version,
    and it seems OK to me)
    
    An extremely pleasant surprise -- Styx's "Equinox."  Clean as your
    mom's kitchen floor.  And not a bad album, neither.
    
    Now, if I can just get myself to stop listening to `Lorelei...'
    
    DFW
1019.39Great mix, sound, pressing....FACT01::LAWRENCEJim/Hartford A.C.T.,DTN 383-4523Wed Dec 23 1987 11:429
    
    Amanda McBroom   - Dreaming
    
    Any of Andre Previn's Telarc CDs.
    
    Juice Newton     - Emotions
    
    Horiwitz in Moscow
    
1019.40Kenny G- DuotonesSCENIC::SMITHGO Celtics!!!!Wed Dec 23 1987 12:194
    As stated in an earlier note (597 I think), if you like sax, Kenny
    G's Duotones is a must!!!!  
    
    Donna
1019.41Especially track 2 - "Coming Up Close"BAVIKI::GOODMichael GoodWed Dec 23 1987 13:592
    For rock CD's, my best-sounding one is 'Til Tuesday's "Welcome Home."
    Can't really pick a favorite for classical CD's.
1019.42NEXUS::GORTMAKERthe GortThu Dec 24 1987 00:0811
    Classical Gas- Mason Willams & Manheim Steamroller
    Fresh Aire III- Manheim
    Jethro Tull- Songs from the wood
    Neal Young- Harvest
    
    re.10 Andy, Still unable to get the original soundtrack here in
    the US of A Cant even get it ordered. Geeeez and this is the land
    o' plenty?!?!?! 
    
    -j
    
1019.43WarningRUTLND::COTESat Dec 26 1987 22:132
*** Warning *** If you like the Eagles Greatest Hits save your money
    and get the tape or album.
1019.44COOKIE::ROLLOWI'm a sucker for good fugue.Sat Dec 26 1987 22:303
    re: .-1
    
    Could you be more precise?
1019.45re -2DSSDEV::MORMon Dec 28 1987 10:187
    re: .-2
    
    I took someones advice in this note and bought Hotel California.
    They were right!  It sounds great!  Are you saying that Best Hits
    Volume 2 doesn't sound good?  I was just about to get a copy of
    it.
    
1019.46Willy DeVille's MiracleSTKHLM::LIDENCDs look as good as they soundTue Dec 29 1987 05:1911
	When it  comes  to good-sounding CDs my vote goes to Willy DeVille's
	recent  effort,  'Miracle'.  Squeaky clean DDD recording produced by
	Mark  Knopfler, who also plays guitar on most tracks. Willy's vocals
	are  displayed in a very good way. Willy DeVille, of course, used to
	be the singer in Mink DeVille.  

	Listen to the track 'Spanish Jack' for some very deep bass sounds. 

	Anyone who likes the work of Mark Knopfler should check out this CD.

	- GL -
1019.47Been waiting for thisVAXWRK::SCHNEIDERPenguins don't come from next door!Wed Dec 30 1987 16:098
    Re: Willy DeVille.
    
    I've been asking around for this disk from the moment I heard it
    was coming out, before it was even released.  I haven't been able
    to lay my hands on it though.  Has anyone seen it?  At any sort
    of discount, or do I have to pay $16.99 for it.
    
    Dan
1019.48BIRKA::LITBY...and he built a Crooked HouseThu Dec 31 1987 08:0711

	Rock - 	    Jennifer Rush: "Movin'" (CBS)
	      	    Jennifer Warnes: "Famous Blue Raincoat" (Sonet)

	Jazz -      Spyro Gyra: "Breakout" (MCA)

	Classical - Mozart: Requiem Berlin Phil./Karajan (DG)


	-- POL