[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::golf

Title:Welcome to the Golf Notes Conference!
Notice:FOR SALE notes in Note 69 please! Intros in note 863 or 61.
Moderator:FUNYET::ANDERSON
Created:Tue Feb 15 1994
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2129
Total number of notes:21499

1342.0. "Here's a Few Evaluations..." by SAGE::VARLEY () Thu Aug 15 1991 18:32

     Most of us play course that run the gamut as far as course
    conditioning goes. I thought it might be interesting to enter some
    comments on "Condition," and to find out what different folks enjoy.
    
     In my experience, the best conditioned courses I have played
    collectively were in Chicago. The fairways were absolutely perfect,
    with no "Wild card" kinds of grass, very uniform. Second would probably
    be Ohio, and Scioto might be the best overall I've ever seen. People
    rave about Muirfield Village, but it ain't as good as Scioto. There's a
    VERY private Jewish club outside of NYC called Century that is about as
    close to Scioto as you can get, in terms of overall condition, but I
    have to give Scioto the nod. There were a couple of bumpy spots on two
    or three tees at Century.
    
     One of the places I've enjoyed in New England is Vesper. The plush,
    Vesper bentgrass greens are really unique. Smooth and beautiful - it's
    like hitting into a "Twinkie." As far as courses with the toughest
    greens to read and putt, I'd say (In no particular order) Kittansett
    (Charcoal seaside bent), Mount Pleasant, Waterbury, Ct. (Some of the
    fastest I've ever seen) and Rockaway Hunt. In the "If you can read it
    you can make everything you see" category, I'd say Ekwanok, in
    Manchester, Vt. Courses around Washington D.C., from the simplest
    publinx to the most high rent place all have unbelievable bentgrass
    greens. 
    
     As far as tees go, there is only one place that stands out in my
    mind - Burning Tree. The tees are cut so short, and are so firm and
    uniform that when you set the soleplate of your driver down you can
    almost "Feel" the writing on the soleplate. It's almost impossible not
    to drive it well there.
    
     I'm not much of a sand player, but I think the firm sand in the traps
    at Oak Hill in Fitchburg is pretty hard to beat. You should see good
    players spin it out of that stuff.
    
     Here's my evaluation of the places I've seen this year, so far:
    
    Crumpin-Fox - Good. Several tees need to be resurfaced and trees cut
    down to give them more light. Fairways are very good. Several green
    collars are awful, but most are o.k. Putting surfaces are good and
    true, but very young. Give the front side greens 5 more years to
    mature.
    
    Sky Meadow - Good all around, although a few tees could use some work.
    They do a nice job at Sky Meadow.
    
    Misquamicut (R.I.) - Seaside course. Nice firm fairways and greens.
    Greens aren't too firm, though. Tees are small, so they take a bit of a
    beating.
    
    Piping Rock (L.I.) - Good. Typical MacDonald course with grass faced
    bunkers. Lots of wheat-type rough (Stay out of it, or else...) and
    elevated greens. Unbelievable range. Used to be a polo field.
    
    The Creek (L.I.) - Pretty good. Better course (Especially the ocean
    holes), but some ratty tees and uneven areas in the fairways. They have
    been working on this ever since Joe Dey chaired all the committees.
    From what I saw, he didn't do much of a job as Greens committee
    chairman.
    
    The National Golf Links - Good. Closer to the water, with pretty pure
    greens and firm fairways. A few unreasonable holes, including a
    "Reverse Redan" type par 3 (# 4), but all MacDonald courses have a few
    quirks.
    
    Rockaway Hunting Club - Fair, except for the greens which are perfect.
    As I've said - strong holes, weak holes, o.k. holes. Tillinghast must
    have been on drugs at times when he redesigned it.
    
    Garden City Golf Club - Good condition (Again, some SERIOUS wheat off
    the fairway. You just flat have to SW it back to the fairway), great
    design. I could play it every day. I love Garden City, even if women
    can't be in the vicinity of the golf course. Some tough pot bunkers,
    but good sand.
    
    Olympic Club (Lakeside Course) - Very good. Extremely lush fairways,
    lined with enormous trees. Absolutely NO roll. Greens were a bit soft
    and a touch shaggy, and very hard to read. They were true, however.
    Another great range - I probably should have used it. One of the most
    beautiful courses I have ever seen, and strong !!
    
     Other than "The Fox," I'll probably only play 3 or 4 other courses
    this year - tops. I'll enter some info after I play 'em. So far this
    has been a pretty good, but not great year for courses. Sometimes work
    and home pressures determine that.
    
    --Jack 
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1342.1My much shorter listWMOIS::REEVE_CThu Aug 15 1991 18:5421
    The best conditioned courses I've ever played are:
    
    -The Country Club two weeks after the 88 Open. Everything was
    essentially perfect. I've played it twice since and it hasn't been
    nearly as good.
    
    -A course called MoreFar in NY. Owned by an insurance company (can't
    remember which). Not a particularly great layout, but it was in
    immaculate condition. We were the only foursome on the course in
    mid-June and I'm told only two or three groups play it per day.
    
    -Royal Quebec outside Quebec city. This was the first really nice
    course I ever played (in 71) and it was awesome, but then again my
    sights were set pretty low in those days. My first time with a caddie,
    who was 3 times my age and I had to fight the inclination to call him
    "sir", I shoulda been carrying his clubs.
    
    -Essex Country Club, I hope. I'm playing it for the first time next
    week and I hear it's in great shape.
    
    Chris
1342.2re .1CSC32::J_KLEINFri Aug 16 1991 02:2015
    
    re .1
    
    Is that Essex Country Club outside of Windsor, Ontario?
    
    I saw my first pro tournament there (the Canadian Open) sometime
    in the early 1970's. A very nice traditional course with HUGE trees
    and in very nice condition as I recall.
    
    Another well conditioned public course in that same area is Roseland.
    I haven't been there in about 15 years (I moved out of Detroit about
    12 years ago), I hope it's still there. It's the only public course
    I've ever been to that had caddies available.
    
                                 -Joe
1342.3My favoritesSONATA::FEENEYnon golfers live half a lifeFri Aug 16 1991 11:5921
Black Diamond in Florida, built by Stan Olsen, designed by Fazio is immaculate.

It is built in the highest spot in Florida around a quarry and you actually do 
go up and down in terrain like in New England. The course from tee to green is 
perrrfffectly maintained sans any blemish whatsoever including divots.

It is private and the centered fold for the development.

Shattuck Inn in Jaffery N.H. Its a jewel from tee to green with all Bent grass.
The same designer who built Shaker Hills the new course in Harvard Mass. I like
the condition of Shattuck Inn better because it is more mature (took three years 
to build) and each hole is carved out of wilderness such that you really don't 
see the other holes, whereas, Shaker Hills has the traditional side by side although 
the fairways are separated by trees. I do wish Shattuck Inn some time in the future
would clear out rocks in the soil in the rough surrounding the fairways.

Just played Oak Hill in Fitchburg Mass. which had the plushest fairways I have
had the pleasure to play.

Torrey Pines in San Diego, great course considering it gets a lot of play, It 
is so natural and beautiful that you don't mind the blemishes.
1342.4MRKTNG::VARLEYFri Aug 16 1991 13:1127
    Re: .1 - Chris, I've heard of MoreFar sometime in my distant past, and
    I believe that it was described just as you say - fabulous shape and
    absolutely no play. Sounds like you're gonna play Essex County Club
    (Unless the course you described really is in Canada) up on the North
    shore. It's supposed to be British in nature, like Myopia - only on the
    water. Our former club pro played it years ago and didn't like it
    because of its rugged, natural design. From what he was bitching about,
    it sounded just perfect to me. You gotta love those old courses.
    
     There's another old one in Dedham called Dedham Polo Club which is
    neat. Very short, some blind shots and unusual holes, but in its own
    way it is a gem. The tees and fairways are pretty good (Those old
    Yankees don't like to spend much on aesthetics), but the greens are
    great. Another course which is supposed to be in great shape now is
    Worcester C.C. I haven't played it for a while because my connections
    kind of petered out. Also, the pro is a dork of the first order. Too
    bad - I live close by, and I love the course.
    
     Glad someone else likes Oak Hill. I never remembered the fairways as
    being outstanding - good, but not outstanding. Everybody sees things
    differently, I guess. The greens were always very good.
    
     One more course in Central Mass which is always in very nice shape is
    Whitinsville. I never tire of playing there.
    
    --Jack 
    
1342.5Mass versionWMOIS::REEVE_CFri Aug 16 1991 14:138
    The Essex I was referring to is the one in Mass. where they played some
    of the early US Opens. I played Newport, R.I. CC (site of the first
    Open) many years ago, sounds like Essex is similar.
    
    re- Worcester- my brother played it earlier this summer and really
    raved on it. He's played all the best courses in Mass and rates it #1.
    
    Chris
1342.6notesMRKTNG::VARLEYFri Aug 16 1991 16:349
     I don't know if I'd go that far with Worcester. Except for the 3rd
    hole (IMO), the first 6 are pretty mundane. I'd certainly rate Salem
    and Brookline higher, and (From what I've heard - I haven't played it)
    Winchester. Kittansett, too. Longmeadow and Myopia would also have a
    shot, except they both seem to have terrific front 9's and routine back
    9's. I should mention that the par 3 9th hole at Myopia ("Pond") is my
    favorite short par 3 in golf.
    
    --Jacl
1342.7"My Feet Have Wings..."MRKTNG::VARLEYWed Aug 21 1991 13:2915
     Let me add another course to the list that really impressed me -
    Winged Foot - West. Played it yesterday. Immaculate greens with lots of
    speed and hidden rolls that hold very well. Fairways were very good, as
    were the tees. The driving range was kind of an embarrassment for a
    course like this - it had a big net at the end (Which you could clear),
    and another fairway behind it, jeopardizing players. The facility was
    fantastic - huge stone clubhouse, great grill room and locker rooms. We
    played with a young member who always plays from the "Tips" (I didn't),
    and who is a + 1 Handicap. He also has locker # 1. I think his family
    has some connections... Hopefully I'll be going back this fall to play
    Winged Foot - East, Quaker Ridge and Fenway, but there are no sure
    things in life... IMO, Olympic is even harder, except for the par 3's
    which, at Winged Foot, are fabulous - If you're into pain.
    
    --Jack