[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference napalm::commusic_v1

Title:* * Computer Music, MIDI, and Related Topics * *
Notice:Conference has been write-locked. Use new version.
Moderator:DYPSS1::SCHAFER
Created:Thu Feb 20 1986
Last Modified:Mon Aug 29 1994
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2852
Total number of notes:33157

2826.0. "Measuring S/N ratio" by COMET::BELLMJ () Fri Jan 17 1992 04:40

    I'd like to discuss the methods for determining signal to noise ratio
    on musical equipment.  As far as I can tell (keys and dir/titles) this
    has not been discussed in detail.
    
    I sent my D4 back to fix the noise problem, and they sent it back to me
    saying it was fixed.  WRONG.  Either I've got an amazingly picky ear or
    the box is defective, or the S/N ratio is simply poor, because of
    engineering.  My little CD player as a reference, I think my ears are
    fine.  It has no background noise.  But the D4 sounds like bad tape.
    
    So, how does one go about measuring S/N and putting it into a rating
    involving dB?  
    
    I tried turning it on, hooking up a volt meter to it and measuring AC,
    but it said 0.  So what I'm hearing must be below 1 volt, or .1
    (whatever).  When I strike the preview button, the signal goes up to
    about .150-.185 V.  I guess that doesn't help me.
    
    The reason want to attempt this, is to get some data armed when I yell
    at them.  I'm going to return it and I want some sort of validity to
    what I claim, instead of them saying "we fixed it, I don't know what
    your problem is."
    
    Thanks in advance...
    Mike
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2826.1KOMRAD::FRANCKJIM - DTN 237-3436Fri Jan 17 1992 10:0215
Noise is usually measured in reference to a standard output signal, usually the
loudest music you can play.  It's probably best to use an oscilloscope to
measure it.  The equation is:

DB = 20 X LOG (noise level / signal level)

For instance, if the noise level is 0.01 volts and the signal level is 1 volt,
the signal to noise would be 

DB = 20 X LOG (0.01 / 1 ) = 20 X -2 = - 40 DB

Cassette tapes are usually around -60 DB
CD's are between -90 and -110 DB

You can easily hear noise that is between -40 and -50 DB below the signal.
2826.2KOBAL::DICKSONFri Jan 17 1992 11:2412
    You need a scope because a typical tool-box AC voltmeter can not
    measure the kind of frequencies that might be present.  The noise is
    essentially white noise.  Also scopes are typically much more
    sensitive.
    
    I took an LP turntable (remember them) back to the dealer because I
    heard a swishing noise that turned out to come from static electricity
    generated in the nylon bearing, radiated by the aluminum platter, and
    picked up by the cartridge.  The guy at the store got out his test
    record and S/N measuring device and we measured this noise.  It turned
    out to be entirely within spec.  In a quiet room, it is amazing how
    soft of a sound you can hear.
2826.3MIZZOU::SHERMANECADSR::Sherman DTN 223-3326Fri Jan 17 1992 13:1118
    When I went to master last week and listened to the D70 over the DAT I
    could clearly hear noise.  The meter on the DAT went down to about -70
    dB or so.  The D70 went up to a max of about -30 dB, covering a 40 dB
    span.  Even though I could hear the noise, it didn't register on the
    DAT's meter.  So, I figure that the D70 has about a 50 dB S/N ratio
    or so.  You might try a similar experiment with your box.  I don't know
    if the manual has a spec on S/N ratio for the D70.
    
    One other point, when at home I didn't notice the D70 noise so much. 
    Two reasons.  The first is that in the home I run the sound through my
    home stereo system.  The noise of the home stereo with nothing hooked
    up is louder than the noise generated by the D70.  Second, when I make 
    a tape the noise is typically much less than tape hiss.  It's only when I 
    go straight to DAT that I really notice the noise because only then do I
    have a sound system that gives me dead silence.  This is a pro-DAT recorder,
    too.  I don't know if lesser DAT recorders give you any noise.
    
    Steve
2826.4Procedure on how to measure noise on a keyboardESKIMO::FOSSETTThu Jan 23 1992 00:115
    When using a scope to measure the noise on a keyboard, how can you tell 
    what part of the signal is noise?  Would I have to setup a patch that
    just generates a sine wave so that the noise signal is obvious?

    Calvin    
2826.54GL::DICKSONThu Jan 23 1992 14:527
    It depends on whether there is any noise when you are *not*
    pressing a key.  If there is, then you measure it by itself.
    Then you sound the note and measure total amplitude of note
    and noise together.
    
    If the noise is only there during a note, then it is probably
    quantization noise in the digital synthesis process.
2826.6ThanksESKIMO::FOSSETTThu Jan 23 1992 20:563
    Thanks for the tip on measuring s/n ratio on synths.
    
    Calvin