[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference napalm::commusic_v1

Title:* * Computer Music, MIDI, and Related Topics * *
Notice:Conference has been write-locked. Use new version.
Moderator:DYPSS1::SCHAFER
Created:Thu Feb 20 1986
Last Modified:Mon Aug 29 1994
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2852
Total number of notes:33157

957.0. "Fender Rhodes Owners Speak Up" by SUBSYS::ORIN () Wed Sep 23 1987 16:10

    This is a note from an avid keyboard fan (see note 929) to enquire
    if there are any people still actually using the old Rhodes keyboards
    anymore. I traded mine in years ago in favor of lighter electronic
    keyboards that have "Rhodes like" piano presets. With my Roland
    rack mount MKS-20 and S50 sampler, I even sold my upright acoustic
    piano. The Kurzweil K250 as MIDI controller in the studio with its
    piano action does the job. Is the acoustic piano dead for all except
    the hardcore purists? I do sometimes miss the presence of a fine
    acoustic instrument but sure don't mind the lack of required tuning and
    the hassle of hauling heavy instruments to gigs. Please no flames
    from the acoustic instrument fanatics. This is an honest inquiry
    to see what people are using out there.
    
    Dave
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
957.1I can wet it????JAWS::COTESet you on dumplings...Wed Sep 23 1987 16:3433
    
    Glad to see you finally got this "reply" vs "write" thing down...;^)
    
    Anyhow, I use my Rhodes 73 ALL THE TIME!!! It's probably the most
    used piece of gear in my studio. Let's see...
    
                       1. Stack another keyboard on top of it 
    
                       2. There's a little flat area on either
                          side of the keyboard; just right for
                          putting a beer on.
    
                       3. The distance from the front of the white
                          keys to the front of the black is just the
                          width of my ashtray, so I leave it there.
    
                       4. There's a nice pen/pencil holder behind the
                          keys...
    
                       5. The arched top makes a nice percussive sound
                          when given a decided whack...
    
                       6. Mine is micro-tuned so that opens up some
                          interesting avenues to explore...
    
                       7. The cat likes to sit on it.
    
                       8. Nice sustain pedal, but it's sys-ex so I
                          don't get a chance to use it much.
    
                  
    Edd
    
957.2where are we ? didn't I just post this ?SALSA::MOELLERWed Sep 23 1987 20:179
    Several noters still own Rhodes, and are using them primarily as
    equipment stands, I believe. I sold my cherry '73 73 for $250 and
    was happy to get it. I also own an MKS-20 and a sampler.. so for
    studio/live performance, unless there is a well-tuned grand there,
    acoustic piano is a thing of the past.
    
    However, I have a beautiful Haddorf spinet in my living room.
    
    karl moeller
957.3They've gone about as far as they can goDREGS::BLICKSTEINDaveWed Sep 23 1987 21:0020
    My Roland RD-300 with builtin MKS-20 "plays" and sounds just like a Rhodes
    in my opinion.  That is not only does it sound like a Rhodes, but
    it seems to respond to the way I play it just like a Rhodes.  The
    feel of the keyboard is slightly different but that doesn't bother
    me.
    
    And in fact, this is what 'sold' the RD-300 to me.
    
    I remember seeing it in a store, sitting down, turning it on, striking 
    an Eb13 b5 and being able to hear every note in the chord clearly
    and going "ahhh".  Then I turned the chorus on,... "ouuuuuuu".
    
    Then they told me the price,.... "damn".  But I got it anyway.
    
    I think its this 'chordal acuity' (the ability to pick out all the
    notes in a complex chord) that makes the Rhodes so popular.  I can
    think of no other instrument that even compares to the Rhodes in
    that respect.

    	db
957.4Electric pianos are definitely dead.MAY20::BAILEYSteph BaileyWed Sep 23 1987 22:5828
    The rhodes (and wurlies) are especially dead, since they are resonably
    easy to mimic accurately with a variety of synths, and the action
    ain't so hard to emulate either.
    
    The acoustic piano, on the other hand, has an action which is still
    resonably hard to imitate (but there are those of us who don't give
    a hoot about the precise nuances of a piano action), and the sound
    is also quite complicated.
    
    For technical wizzes, it is good to grow close to a particular action,
    and there are lots of piano wizzes. The Rhodes players, on the other
    hand, were the type of people who just by merit of the fact that they
    were playing it in the first place, were willing to change actions, and
    would do so again for a step up in portability and versatility.
    
    All except Tom Scholtz and Chuck Mangione (and the latter may have
    moved away from it while I wasn't looking). 
    
    So the Rhodes is dead, but I don't think the piano will ever be.
    It will probably become like the harpsichord.
    
    
    Steph
    
    
    
    
    
957.5Rhodies unite! forever! JON::ROSSMicro-11: The VAX RISCThu Sep 24 1987 22:0817
    
    Me gotum cute little *Steinway* (gloat gloat) in the livin-room,
    which is nice to diddle occasionally (I do). The mks20 seems 
    so much easier to get onto tape, however....
    
    Dave, I cant believe you have an RD-300 that feels like a rhodes.
    Sure sounds like one....agreed. If I had an RD (or mkb1000) that
    had action like a rhodes, it would be another keyboard stand like
    mine or Edds. More expensive perhaps...
        
    I always likened playing the proverbial rhodes to a baseball player
    who's next up: you swings about 4 bats instead of one. Each rhodes
    key is like 4 little baseball bats...
    
    good synth stand. Good muscle toner...
        
        
957.6A Rhodes is (not) a Rhodes, be it called by any other nameDREGS::BLICKSTEINDaveFri Sep 25 1987 15:3911
>    Dave, I cant believe you have an RD-300 that feels like a rhodes.

    By coincidence, I stopped in at Daddy's in Nashua.  They have TWO
    Rhodes.  The action on one is completely different from the other.
    One is very stiff, one is very light (like my RD).
    
    The conclusion is that what you may think of as a Rhodes action
    depends on what you've played because there is a wide difference
    between different Rhodes.
    
    	db
957.7When is a Rhodes not a Rhodes?DYO780::SCHAFERDragons is *so* stupid ...Fri Sep 25 1987 16:3811
RE: .5, .6

   You may not be comparing apples with apples ... pre-CBS Rhodes' tend
   to be quite arthritic, while post CBS Rhodes' (ike mine) tend to have
   a lighter touch. 

   Speaking of Rhodes, I'm selling my Stage 73.  It's never been on the
   road (i.e., used at home for a few years), and looks like I bought it
   yesterday.  Any suggestions as to what I oughta ask for it? 

brad
957.8Paid <$200 for mine...JAWS::COTEHollywood! I know your middle name!Fri Sep 25 1987 16:534
    Don't mean to sound like a smart-@$$, but you'll be doing good if
    you get $250....
    
    Edd
957.10What is a Rhodes worth these days ?HPSCAD::GATULISWed Sep 30 1987 19:455
    Can't exactly say what you should ask for your Stage-73 but Union
    Music in Worcester has a brand new one for $400.
    
    Frank
    
957.11Oh, yeah...I remember those.FROST::HARRIMANbzzzzzzzzztTHWACK!hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmThu Oct 01 1987 02:1518
    
    Re: .0
    
      I never really liked the Rhodes; I was a Wurly kind of guy. However
    I gave it to my mother (really I did) a couple of years ago when
    I picked up my JX-3P (which wasn't even good at doing pianos). Now
    between an ESQ-1 and a DX-100 I can do tiney sounds like crazy,
    mellow piano/electric piano combinations, and all sorts of sensitive
    Mr. Roger's Neighborhood sounds. I also let go of my old Hammond
    because a Polysix is soooooo much lighter. 
      To play out with large keyboards which only do one or two things
    is really being purist or maybe even a bit reactionary. Unless your're
    very large and strong or have lots of friends for roadies, of course.
    
    I also have a Kawai EP-308 electric grand in my living room - I
    don't take it out to play. Just keeps me in perspective, I guess.
    
    /pjh
957.12another rhodes storyBEOWLF::BARTHFri Oct 02 1987 15:3014
    As far a Rhodes prices go, I sold mine about 2 years ago for $400
    (or $450 - can't remember).  I did the job, though;  there was no
    affordable portable synth that did anything close to a piano (i.e.,
    in feel, velocity sensitivity; not necessarily in sound), so the
    Rhodes was the best alternative.
    
    It was said that Wurlitzers has a brand new one for $350?  I didn't
    think they were made anymore.

    I do miss the action, though; mine was one of the "later" models
    that had a really good - not mushy - action.  The Dx doesn't cut
    it as far as that goes.
    
    Ron
957.13Question about the piano preamp - Model 73PKENT::KENTPeter Kent - SASE, 223-1933Wed Dec 06 1989 15:5313
    I bought a Fender Rhodes for my son to learn piano.  It was a used
    instrument and I bought it on recommendation of his piano teacher and
    his school music teacher.  I have a question.  I hooked the unit
    up to a Heathkit stereo amp. from the little preamp in the piano. 
    I'm not sure if the connection is optimum, i.e. the impedance is
    matched, etc.  I'm using the phono input, which something like 67Kohms
    for an input impedance.  What I don't know is,  what is the output 
    impedance of that little preamp in the piano.  There's a bit of noise
    on the line, I think because the cable is way too long for a phono type
    input.  I imagine that most people have their piano hooked up to a
    band-style amplifier which is properly (I guess) matched to the piano. 
    I have the service manual for the instument which explains just about
    everything except that.  
957.14no way joseSTROKR::DEHAHNWed Dec 06 1989 17:1010
    
    You not only have a level mismatch as well as an impedance mismatch,
    you are using the phono inputs RIAA eq circuit and destroying the sound
    of your Rhodes.
    
    You have to find a line level input like a tape input, or CD input. Or
    even the play half of the tape monitor loop.
    
    CdH
    
957.15Must have been a different model than mineCSC32::MOLLERNightmare on Sesame StreetThu Dec 07 1989 14:286
	What Pre-amp is this?? I've owned a 77 key and an 88 key Rhodes
	and neither had a pre-amp in them (This was in the early to mid
	1970's). I just plugged them into either the P.A. or my Fender
	Bassman Amplifier & played.

							Jens    
957.16AmpPKENT::KENTPeter Kent - SASE, 223-1933Thu Dec 07 1989 15:2510
    The only input on the amp which gives reasonable levels of volume 
    is the phono input.  I tried all the others.  I realize that the phono
    equalization is wrong for the piano.  I'm just looking for a figure for
    the output impedance of that little preamp.
    
    Re. -.1
    There's a little battery operated preamp which sits behind the
    nameboard on the piano.  I don't have any circuit info on it.
    
    Peter
957.17you can taste the differenceSWAV1::STEWARTThere is no dark side of the moon...Thu Dec 07 1989 23:0514





	Maybe it's time to change the battery in that little preamp?







957.18Battery's okayPKENT::KENTPeter Kent - SASE, 223-1933Fri Dec 08 1989 15:475
    Re. -.1
    
    Battery's okay.  I gave it the tongue test - it's a 9v battery.
    
    Peter
957.19My 2.4 cents on the RhodesCACIQE::NUNEZEdgar NunezFri Dec 08 1989 20:2610
    There were a couple of modification to the stock Rhodes which replaced
    the volume and tone controls. I installed one  many moons ago
    which was an active EQ, the other that I know of was a EQ with a 
    build_in Chorus.
    
    Both of them had very low output and I suspect that a Home
    stereo would need a lot of gain to reproduce at a decent volume
    and probably because of the gain hum will be also reproduce.
                           
    Edgar (who_is_getting_the_rhodes_out_of_the_closet)