[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ssag::ask_ssag

Title:Ask the Storage Architecture Group
Notice:Check out our web page at http://www-starch.shr.dec.com
Moderator:SSAG::TERZAN
Created:Wed Oct 15 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:6756
Total number of notes:25276

6465.0. "No of CIPCA required?" by HGOVC::PATRICKNG () Tue Mar 11 1997 07:22

    Hi all,
    
    What is the number of CIPCA required for a 2-node CI cluster? The
    system configuration includes 2x Alphaserver 4100, 3x HSJ50 and a
    SC008-AC. The alpha configuration tool always recommend 4 CIpCA. I
    believe 2 CIPCA adapters should be enough for 2-node cluster.
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
6465.1CI is ten years old...XDELTA::HOFFMANSteve, OpenVMS EngineeringTue Mar 11 1997 14:578
   For a new VMScluster, I'd take a serious look at memory channel (MC),
   I'd definitely configure Ethernet or (better) FDDI, and I'd definitely
   look to configure a dual-host SCSI (possibly with the HSZ40/RZ29 or
   HSZ40/RZ40 storage) in preference to a CI/HSJ solution.

   But to answer your question, yes, the minimum number of CI controllers
   required for a two-node VMScluster is two.
6465.2old isn't necessarily bad...TROOA::MSCHNEIDERmartin.schneider@tro.mts.dec.comWed Mar 12 1997 01:3615
    RE: .-1
    
    Interesting you recommend going SCSI over CI .... yes the technology is
    over 10 years old, but when I asked some of the Storage Engineers which
    technology they would recommend for bet your business solutions (which
    clusters usually are), they recommended CI over SCSI.  The HSJ50
    performance is much improved and basically on par with the HSZ50.  Then
    you get all the distance advantages of CI over SCSI, plus redundant
    paths in the cable.
    
    Yes it costs way more than a SCSI solution, but proven reliability is
    worth something.
    
    Of course once Fiberchannel/UltraSCSI stuff arrives then we really will
    see a significant performance difference over CI.
6465.3Thanks.HGOVC::PATRICKNGWed Mar 12 1997 10:004
    Thanks for your reply.
    
    
    Patrick
6465.4AMCFAC::RABAHYdtn 471-5160, outside 1-810-347-5160Wed Mar 12 1997 10:171
CI is hot pluggable ...