[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference napalm::guitar

Title:GUITARnotes - Where Every Note has Emotion
Notice:Discussion of the finer stringed instruments
Moderator:KDX200::COOPER
Created:Thu Aug 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3280
Total number of notes:61432

1557.0. "Painfull Practice" by MENACE::ROLLA () Mon Nov 20 1989 17:24

    Pain in the NECK!
    Anybody out there ever get a stiff neck from playing guitar.
    I've been playing guitar for 15 years and never had this problem
    'till recently.  I switched to bass and am playing a Hofner 
    Beatle bass which is very light but tends to be somewhat off
    balance (a little top heavy).  It's definately a muscle, I've
    tried various straps, no difference.  Went to the doctor and
    he prescribed some muscle relaxers but theres got to be a simple
    stretching/excersise sollution!  Anybody else ever run into
    this problem?  Any suggestions?
    
    Myk
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1557.1TCC::COOPERCaptain KRUNCH !Mon Nov 20 1989 18:478
    Sometimes my shoulder bothers me... I just figure it's because I'm a
    little out of shape from practicing in the sitting position a lot...
    
    Now, on the other hand, I sure have gotten several sore necks/shoulders
    from bangin' heads while playing Metallica and Priest...But now I do
    "nice music" so it's no longer a problem.
    
    ;^)
1557.2adapt....RAVEN1::DANDREAFractured Fairy TalesMon Nov 20 1989 18:478
    Yep,
    
    It happened to me when I got my first Les Paul after playing much
    lighter SG's.  The cramp finally disappeared after a few MONTHS.
    I just plain got used to the heavier guitar. Sorry, but I don't know of
    any exercises to relieve it, although a wider strap should help some.
    
    Steve
1557.3CRUMMY::LANGEMon Nov 20 1989 18:521
    Take the Pain!
1557.4No thanksMENACE::ROLLAMon Nov 20 1989 19:398
    Re:-1 I'd rather not!
    
    It's strange 'cause my Strat is much heavier than the Hofner.  I've
    tried different straps...didn't help!  And this is pushing 6 months,
    I thought it was 'cause I was outa 'playing' shape too.
    
    Oh well
    
1557.5seek help from a physician specializing in musicians' problems or sports medicineCOOKIE::WITHERSFixed in a Prior ReleaseMon Nov 20 1989 23:0232
1557.6drugs and therapyMENACE::ROLLATue Nov 21 1989 11:336
    That's interesting 'cause the GP I went to yesterday prescribed
    a bunch of muscle relaxers etc. and said that I should contact
    a Physical Therapy group.  I was expecting him to just give me
    some exercises to do.  He did mention posture and sleeping habits.
    myk
1557.7Bad Balance===Lots of PainOTOO01::ELLACOTTFreddie's RevengeTue Nov 21 1989 13:1911
    Get a different bass, one that's BALANCED!!!. The only time I have
    ever had problems like that, was when I owned (as a second bass)
    a neck heavy Vantage bass. Nice tone with the preamp, but not worth 
    the pain. I also learned that once you get to the state of pain
    just moving your arm or head you just have to stop for a couple
    of days and take your muscle relaxants until thet stretch or pull
    mends otherwise the cramping just causes more problems. I have found
    that ROBAXISOL (sp) C1/8 with codine helps if you absolutely have
    to continue but it's not good for long term use (a few days only).
    In Canada it's not prescription but you have to ask for it...oh
    DON'T OPERATE HEAVY MACHINERY while using it...no heavy metal either
1557.8check postureTOOK::SUDAMALiving is easy with eyes closed...Tue Nov 21 1989 15:3316
    Two suggestions: the first one is, have you changed anything else about
    your posture when you changed instruments? I have noticed that I have
    much less muscle strain when I stand erect during rehearsals than when
    I sit on a stool. I think it's because when I sit down I tend to hunch
    over the instrument, and this puts more stress on my neck and
    shoulders, even though some of the weight of the guitar is resting on
    my leg. I'm talking about when using the same position for several
    hours.
    
    The other suggestion is, try Yoga classes. There are many exercises
    that stretch and relax the muscles in your neck, shoulders and upper
    back. Most modern physical therapy routines were copped from classic
    Yoga exercises. They just give them fancy names like "extreme
    nuero-muscular extension", etc.
    
    - Ram
1557.9JAWS::PELKEYLoco Boy Makes goodTue Nov 21 1989 15:4517
    Well, here's a thought..
    
    Different guitars will fall on your body in different
    ways.  A Strat for instance tends to lay back on your
    abdomen where a paul will lay flatter on your body.
    
    Could the hoffner be sitting on your stomach in a way which,
    when you look at the neck, you have to twist *your* neck
    to see the fret board ?
    
    The only reason I thought of this is when switching from my
    Ibanez to my Strat.... 
    
    Of course it could be the 'top-heavyness' that you referred to.

    Good luck what ever you find out.
    
1557.10are you a low rider ???LUDWIG::BOUCHARDTue Nov 21 1989 17:1520
    How low do you wear your bass ???  I used to have pain after playing
    for a couple hours, at the time i was playing an Ibanez Musician
    neck through body design, sounded great but was one heavy mutha.
    What i ended up doing is wearing it higher on my chest.  i found
    that when i was wearing it low, either playing with a pick or not,
    I rested much more weight on the guitar body with my forearm and
    hand than when i wore it higher.  Also when you wear it higher it
    tends to distribute the weight more evenly across your back as 
    opposed to if you wear it low all the weight tends to hang on that
    shoulder.  Give it a try and see if it helps,  ;^)   If you ar used
    to wearing it low it may take a little time getting used to the
    new feel, but once you get used to it i think you'll find that your
    capable of greater reach and speed.  Plus think of the good company
    you'll be with,    look how high,  Stanley Clark, Al Dimeola, Tuck
    Andress and Steve Howe wear they're guitars.   
    
                                                     Smokin'  Bass
    
    
                                                         Dan . . .
1557.11ZYDECO::MCABEEles haricotsTue Nov 21 1989 23:0417
>    That's interesting 'cause the GP I went to yesterday prescribed
>    a bunch of muscle relaxers etc. and said that I should contact
>    a Physical Therapy group.  I was expecting him to just give me
>    some exercises to do.  He did mention posture and sleeping habits.
>    myk

GP's tend to not be qualified for treating this kind of ailment.  It's still
fairly new as a subspecialty.  

I've preached my sermon before, so I'll just summarize it.  If you develop any 
kind of persistent pain from playing your instrument, you should see an 
orthopedist or rheumatologist who understands injuries resulting from overuse.
If you have pain in your fingers, wrist, elbow or shoulder immediately after
playing, an immediate ice pack might save you from months of misery.

Bob
1557.12VLNVAX::ALECLAIREFri Nov 24 1989 14:283
    My RichBich is top-heavy, but that dosen't bother me at all cuz
    I play sitting down. Try it, I play alot better on my tail. Don't
    use any strength at all to hold the thing.  
1557.13right arm problemsCOPCLU::SANDGRENKeep it simpleMon May 02 1994 11:3824
	After I got my new Fender Strat I've started to get problems
	with my right arm. It feels like the curved body of the Strat
	fits so nicely to my right arm that it prevents the blood from
	flowing freely - I don't know if this is right, but that's how
	it feels. This happens after intensive scale practicing for 2-3
	hours, sitting on a chair. A couple of days after, I feel like
	having a 'cold' arm, not really a pain, but something that
	feels like it could develop to something worse. Now since I
	share my practicing between the Strat and the classic guitar,
	it has not developed yet, but I'm a bit worried about it - I'd
	hate to be forced to less practicing...

	The Blade, which I traded away for the Strat, did not give me
	any problems like this - I think due to a more 'sharp' curve on
	the body - and perhaps also because it didn't have the same lo-
	cation of the volume pot as the Strat. I've now taken off the
	knob on the pot to see if it helps (I kept finding myself try-
	ing not to hit it with my right hand when playing).

	Any of you recognize this problem? Any advices?

	Poul

1557.14sorry.......NAVY5::SDANDREAI got yer huckleberry...Mon May 02 1994 11:503
    have you tried playing left handed?
    
    >:*)<
1557.15 let's not overdo it! EZ2GET::STEWARTFight fire with marshmallowsMon May 02 1994 12:2413
    
    That's one reason why you should never get rid of an old guitar!  Now
    you can't go back and do an A/B test...
    
    Your body will tell you what feels right.  Just find the posture that
    lets you play your scales faster & easier.  And oh, yeah, take your
    foot off of that little step thing...  *8')
    
    Besides, 2 to 3 hours in one position doing anything is too much.  You
    need to take at least a 5 minute break every hour, unless you really
    want that RSI disability check.  Put the axe down, walk around, and
    stretch.
    
1557.16GIDDAY::KNIGHTPThere's room for you insideTue May 03 1994 03:323
    DONT PLAY SCALES!!!!!
    	8^).
    P.K.
1557.17ICS::CONROYPlaces to go, people to annoyTue May 03 1994 12:3522
Poul,

I've had some problems with tendonitis in my right elbow (not from
playing guitar) and I've found that certain playing positions
seem to aggravate it. 

With the classical guitar I need to hold the neck up a bit higher
so there's less pressure on my elbow where it rests on the side of the 
guitar.

I also have a Strat. I find the Strat to be very comfortable. That's what
the curve on the body is designed for, I think.

I'd experiment with some different sitting positions. Try playing with a
strap on with the guitar held a bit higher. Don't play if it hurts. If 
your problem is tendonitis, it's hard to get rid of.

The suggestion to take breaks is a good one too. Play for short periods
with short breaks.

Hope this helps,
Bob
1557.18GOES11::HOUSEAren't you glad I asked?Tue May 03 1994 14:089
    If anything, I've had the opposite effect.  Guitars which have more of
    an edge to them tend to cut off the circulation a little on my right
    (picking) arm as the edge of the guitar pushes into the skin of my
    forearm.  I notice this with my Les Paul (very sharp edge) if I wear it
    up too high.  Doesn't seem to be as much of a problem if I wear it a
    little lower.  It's harder on my left wrist to play with it lower, but
    more comfortable for my right one.  Trade offs, trade offs.
    
    Greg
1557.19thanksCOPCLU::SANDGRENKeep it simpleWed May 04 1994 05:1016
	Thanks for the advices guys. I do try to adjust my playing posi-
	tion to minimum discomfort, and I also do stretch exercises of
	arms and fingers in between (have always done this). But this is
	bugging me; some time ago, I used to rest my underarms on my desk
	to reach the keyboard to my workstation, rather than placing the
	keyboard on the edge of the desk and let the underarms hang free
	- and this developed some of the same feeling in both my arms/
	hands - I guess I'm vulnerable to sustained pressure like this.

	Perhaps it has not been that bad the last couple of days - maybe
	it helped to remove the knob on the volume pot. That pot has a
	stupid position IMO!

	Poul

1557.20I'll go crawl back under a rock now...SPECXN::LEITZbutch leitzThu May 05 1994 15:539
Hey, I haven't checked out the notes file in a while, but seeing painful
practices made me wanna relate that this "guitar wannabe" actually bled
my fingers during practice a week or so ago trying to hork an SRV lick
(unsuccessfully). I always heard of this kind of thing happening but 
thought it was pretty crazy till i saw the blood. :-) Actually it
wasn't really all that painful until the next day when I tried to practice 
again. I didn't have wrap-around callouses on one finger & that's the
one I was leaning on too hard. Right on the corner. Ouch. So it gave
me opportunity to practice drums again for a while.