[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

843.0. "SQL Access Group" by BROKE::THOMAS () Fri Jan 18 1991 23:58

    The SQL Access Group is a consortium of interested database and
    tools vendors which are working to define a standard Remote Data 
    Access service and protocol to submit to the ANSI and ISO 
    standards committees.  SQL Access will provide a method for 
    application programs or databases to access databases from 
    multiple DBMS vendors through one programming interface.
    
    Specifications for the SQL Access Application Program Interface 
    and the SQL Access File Access Protocol are complete.  Members
    of the consortium are now developing prototypes which will be 
    demonstrated at an Interoperability Trade Show scheduled for 
    June 1991.
    
    Members of the SQL Access Consortium include the following:
    
    American Research Corp		Ashton-Tate
    Borland International		British Telecom
    Bull				Cincom
    Cooperative Systems			Digital Equipment Corp
    Fujitsu				Hewlett Packard
    Information Builders		InfoCentre Corp
    Informix				Ingres
    Lotus				Metaphor
    Microsoft				NCR
    Oracle				OSF
    Retix 				Sun Microsystems
    Sybase				Tandem Computers
    Teradata				X/OPEN
    
    
    DEC's representative on the committee is Jeff Balboni, and we have 
    2-3 other engineers that produce papers/make presentations to the 
    consortium.
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
843.1Can you spell IBM?BROKE::HIGGSSQL is a camel in disguiseSun Jan 20 1991 21:141
Conspicuously absent, you will note, is Big Blue...
843.2Online specs?TRCO01::BROWNRPC - Really Practical ComputingTue Jan 22 1991 08:2411
    
>>    Specifications for the SQL Access Application Program Interface 
>>    and the SQL Access File Access Protocol are complete.  Members
>>    of the consortium are now developing prototypes which will be 
>>    demonstrated at an Interoperability Trade Show scheduled for 
>>    June 1991.
  
  	Any online copy of the specifications? and/or what our demo will
  show/consist of?
  
-ian
843.3Sybase submits standard?POBOX::LACEYACMS/Rdb, the transaction AutobahnWed Jan 23 1991 00:235
    Sybase says there "tabular interchange protocol" has been accepted by
    the OSF as the standard. How this this fit in with SQL Access &
    SQL-Services?
    
    _Paul
843.4Sorry -- no online specBROKE::THOMASThu Jan 24 1991 00:158
    X/Open will be publishing the SQL Access technical spec in the 
    X/Open Portability Guide Version 4 (XPG4), expected in 3/91.
    
    The Prototype Press Demonstration has just been rescheduled for 
    July, 1991.  At this demo, all Producing members will demonstrate
    the SQL Access Client and/or Server that they have developed.
    There will be many types of hardware and software systems, 
    connected through OSI, all speaking to one another.
843.5Update on SQL Access MembershipBROKE::THOMASThu Jan 24 1991 01:0834
    SQL Access membership is growing quickly -- approximately 2-3 new
    member join every month.  As of January's meeting, here's the most
    current list of SQL Access members:
    
    Producers  (15)                    Reviewers  (18)
    ---------                          ---------
    Cincom Systems, Inc                Apple Computer, Inc
    Digital Equipment Corp             Ashton-Tate
    Fujitsu                            Bull, H.N.
    Hewlett Packard                    DB/Access
    Informix                           Dupont Information Systems
    Lotus                              Fulcrum Technologies
    Metaphor                           Gupta Technologies
    Microsoft Corp                     Infocenter
    NCR                                Ingres Corp
    Oracle Corp                        Locus Computing Corp
    Sun Microsystems                   MCC Technology Corp
    Sybase                             Micro Decisionware, Inc
    Tandem Computers                   Microrim
    Teradata                           Novell, Inc
    Unify Corporation                  Progress Software
                                       Retrix
                                       Software Technologies
                                       Sterling Software
    
    (notable omissions are IBM and Computer Associates)
    
    SQL Access also has formal relationships with the associated standards
    bodies, including:
    
    ANSI SQL2 Committee (X3H2)
    ANSI RDA (X3H2.1)
    Open Systems Foundation (OSF)
    X/Open
843.6Is Sybase really going to be a standard?VAOU02::NJOHNSONWestcoast WizMon Jan 28 1991 06:285
    Could someone address the claim that Sybase has had their standards
    accepted by the OSF committee?
    
    							Thanks,
    								Neil
843.7look elsewhereNOVA::NEEDLEMANno good deed goes unpunishedTue Jan 29 1991 18:174
    try in the OSF conference ?
	SSGBPM::OSF   
    
    
843.8Sybase are digging themselves a credibility holeBROKE::ASHELL::WATSONpatience is a virtueThu Jan 31 1991 21:0015
    I know that Sybase are claiming that SQL/Access have adopted their API.
    This is not true. Here are the facts:
    o	Digital, Microsoft and Sybase worked together on an API called SQL
    	Connectivity. (Lotus were also in this group at one point.)
    o	Each of the three vendors contributed to SQL Connectivity. 
    o	SQL Access voted to make the SQL Connectivity API the basis for the
    	SQL Access API. (Overwhelming victory over the Oracle candidate.)
    o	So, by the time SQL Access publish an API, it will look like the
    	SQL Connectivity API - but it is very unlikely to be identical to
    	it.
    o	Hence the Sybase API is really just one of several grandparents of
    	the yet-to-be-born SQL Access API.
    
    		Andrew.
    
843.9and we helped..DATABS::JOEDAD::NEEDLEMANno good deed goes unpunishedFri Feb 01 1991 17:427
    
    The Feb. edition of DBMS magazine has an interview with Micro
    Decisionware's Richard Hackathorn. He releases a lot of data around the
    client API issues.
    
    Barry
    
843.10Reply .5 is not completely accurateCOOKIE::MELTONThe zen of character setsMon Feb 04 1991 22:5431
Sorry, 'tain't so!
    
    SQL Access also has formal relationships with the associated standards
    bodies, including:
    
    ANSI SQL2 Committee (X3H2)
    ANSI RDA (X3H2.1)
    Open Systems Foundation (OSF)
    X/Open

There exists *no* possible mechanism for SQL Access to have a "formal
relationship" with either ANSI X3H2 or X3H2.1.  There are, in fact, a
number of companies that are members of SAG that also have representatives
on the X3H2 and/or X3H2.1 committees, but ANSI rules do not permit a
*formal* relationship between an ANSI Technical Committee (e.g., X3H2) or
Task Group (e.g., X3H2.1) and a consortium (e.g., SAG).

However, the overlap in membership is significant and quite important.
That implies that X3H2 and X3H2.1 get input that effectively originates in
SAG and that SAG pays close attention to the formal standards process.

The relationship between SAG and X/Open has been long-standing but is
still (to my knowledge, at least) not formalized.  The apparent reason is
that Roger Sippl, chairman/president/? of SAG and also chairman/etc. of
Informix, has failed to sign the contract between X/Open and SAG, although
X/Open signed the contract over a year ago.  No information has surface
that explains to my satisfaction why Roger hasn't signed the contract, but
he apparently claims that the "board" hasn't approved it.  Strange...

Thanks,
   Jim
843.11Unisys (Burroughs) membership?IJSAPL::OLTHOFHenny Olthof @UTO 838-2021Wed Mar 13 1991 17:277
    SQL Access plays a key role in making the Information Network happen.
    My customer who uses UNISYS machines (Burroughs) wants to know if
    they are present in SQL Access. I did not find their name in note .0
    and .5.
    
    Thanks,
    Henny Olthof, TP-DB Netherlands
843.12I want to watch!!!OFFPLS::HODGESThu Mar 14 1991 02:254
    re:  a few back. . . .
    
    What is the 'trade show' in July where all of this can be demonstrated
    and can 'mere mortals' attend?
843.13Lastest membership listBROKE::THOMASThu Mar 28 1991 23:5523
    As of 3/91:         <P> = Producer
    
    Apple               	Gupta                 	Novell
    Ashton-Tate			HP	<P>		Oracle     <P>
    ASK (Ingres)  <P>		Infocentre		Progress
    Boeing			Informix    <P>		Retix
    Borland			Locus			Software AG
    Bull			Lotus	    <P>		Sterling Software
    Cincom	<P>		MCC	    <P>		Sun Microsystems <P>
    DB Access			Metaphor		Sybase     <P>
    DEC		<P>		Micro Decisionware	Tandem     <P>
    du Pont			Microrim		Teradata   <P>
    Fujitsu	<P>		Microsoft   <P>		Unify
    Fulcrum			NCR	    <P>		Unisys     <P>
    
    Others who are interested, but have not yet committed:
    
    Bell Northern Research	Micro Focus		Racal-Milgo
    British Telecom Research	Mimer Software AB	RAIMA
    COGNOS			MIPS Computer		Santa Cruz Operation
    Coromandel Industries	Nucleus International	Software Products Intl
    Honeywell			OEI		
    
843.14it is realDATABS::DATABS::NEEDLEMANtoday nas/is, tomorrow...Wed May 08 1991 20:246
    re .12
    
    As of today, the event is currently planned in the summer and it is a
    press event, not a public gathering -sorry
    
    Barry
843.15SQL Access AnnouncementCIMNET::BOURDEAURich Bourdeau CIM Product MarketingThu May 23 1991 22:02179
 -----       SQL Access first to demonstrate         
|C I S|      multivendor and               
 -----  
             Source : Business Wire              Date : 21-MAY-91



     + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + 
     |  Please be advised that the information contained within this | 
     +  report is copyrighted material.  The following policies must + 
     |  be adhered to:                                               | 
     +                                                               + 
     |     -  No reformatting of the data segments                   | 
     +     -  No external distribution                               + 
     |     -  Internal use only in accordance with vendor agreements | 
     + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + - + 


SANTA CLARA, Calif.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The SQL Access Group, a 
consortium of leading database software and hardware companies, will 
demonstrate multi-vendor database interoperability for the first time 
in the industry this July.

The demonstration, to be held in New York, will show a prototype of 
the recently completed Phase I technical specification.  The 
association also outlined its technical direction beyond the upcoming 
demonstration.

``We're please with the progress made towards our goal of enabling 
front-end clients and database servers to work together,'' said Roger 
Sippl, chairman of the SQL Access Group.  ``The SQL Access Group will 
continue to address technology that meets the evolving needs of the 
user in the area of database interoperability.''

In other news, the Phase I technical specification will be published 
by X/Open Consortium Ltd. to provide a preliminary look at the 
technology.  Also, seven new companies have joined the association 
bringing the membership to 40.


Phase I demonstration

The interoperability demonstration will show tools from different 
vendors talking to a number of other vendors' databases in a simulated 
real-world environment where multiple clients and servers will exchange 
information.

``For the vision of interoperability to be fulfilled, users must be 
able to access any database on the network with equal ease.  The 
demonstration of our prototype is the first step toward offering users 
a solution for true database interoperability,'' said Jeff Balboni, 
chairman of the joint technical committee.


                                                  

                                      ( 1 )



 -----       SQL Access first to demonstrate                | 21-MAY-91
|C I S|      multivendor and                                | Business Wire
 -----       

For 18 months, the SQL Access Group has focused on development of 
technical specifications, based on standards, that will enable multiple 
front-end clients and back-end database servers to work together.

The Phase I work includes an embedded Structured Query Language 
(SQL) specification for application portability and OSI Remote Database 
Access for database interoperability.


Phase II work


Now that Phase I specifications have been set, the group is 
addressing other technologies pertaining to interoperability including 
user requirements in the areas of the Call Level Interface and TCP/IP 
support.

Phase II work will include a Call Level Interface subroutine 
library and TCP/IP networking support for databases and tools.

According to Balboni, addressing the Call Level Interface is 
important because some programmers prefer a subroutine style of 
programming to an embedded SQL interface when developing relational 
database management system applications.  TCP/IP support is significant 
because it is the most widely used networking protocol.

Meanwhile, the new members are Boeing Computer Services, Borland 
International, British Telecom, MCC, Mimer Software AB, Uniface and 
Unisys Corp.

The SQL Access Group, founded in 1989, is a non-profit corporation 
proliferating technical specifications that will enable multiple 
SQL-based relational databases and tools to work together. 

The group is not a standards organization, but a consortium of 40 
leading companies intent on accelerating research underway by such 
standards groups as the American National Standards Institute (ANSI) 
and the International Standards Organization (ISO).  The association is 
open to both vendors and users.  The members are:
-0-
*T

o  Apple Computer Corp.             o  Metaphor

o  Ashton-Tate                      o  Micro Decisionware

o  ASK Inc.                         o  Microrim

o  Boeing Computer Services         o  Microsoft Corp.

                                                  

                                      ( 2 )



 -----       SQL Access first to demonstrate                | 21-MAY-91
|C I S|      multivendor and                                | Business Wire
 -----       


o  Borland International            o  Mimer Software AB

o  British Telecom Research         o  NCR Corp.

o  Bull HN Information Systems Inc. o  Novell Inc.

o  Cincom Systems                   o  Oracle Corp.

o  DB Access                        o  Progress Software Corp.

o  Digital Equipment Corp.          o  Retix

o  Du Pont Information Systems      o  Software AG

o  Fujitsu America Inc.             o  Sterling Software

o  Fulcrum Technologies Inc.        o  Sun Microsystems

o  GUPTA Technologies               o  Sybase Inc.

o  Hewlett-Packard Co.              o  Tandem Computers Inc.

o  Infocentre Corp.                 o  Teradata Corp.

o  Informix Software Inc.           o  Uniface

o  Locus Computing Corp.            o  Unify Corp.

o  Lotus Development Corp.          o  Unisys Corp.

o  MCC                              o  X/Open Consortium Ltd.
*T

The SQL Access Group is a registered association mark of the SQL 
Access Group.  All other companies and products mentioned in this 
document are protected by appropriate trademarks.













                                                  

                                      ( 3 )

843.16So what does this mean to DEC users?SNOMAN::AARONDoing DECnet...PCSA...LanW...PATHWORKS since v1!Fri Jun 21 1991 02:558
How does the standard relate to SQL/Services?  Will this be an easy migration
path for our customers?  Is there a corporate message that we can deliver?

Sure, it looks like we've driven this technology (along with Microsoft and
Sybase), but that doesn't answer the question...

Inquiring minds want to know,
Aaron
843.17The Open AdvantageBROKE::THOMASThu Jul 11 1991 02:2818
    SQL Access establishes a standard format and protocol for remote data
    access.  It performs the same functions as both SQL/Services and our 
    RdbAccess/VIDA products.  We will certainly provide an easy migration/
    cohabitation path between SQL Access and SQL/Services.  SQL Access
    makes life easier for our customers.  They can go out and buy Lotus
    1-2-3 or Borland Paradox or Joe Blow's WonderGizmo and all these tools
    will speak the same generic language (SQL Access) and be able to access
    all the databases the customer might have (with a few exceptions).
    In addition, Rdb applications will be able to transparently access data
    from all those same databases.  Our CSOs and ISVs will be happy,
    because they only have to write their systems once using SQL Access,
    and they don't need to port to xxx different systems.
    
    The corporate message here is that Digital provides the Open Advantage
    (Have you seen this message in our recent advertising?).  Digital
    supports industry standards because it makes life easier for our
    customers.  Standards will never exist unless major forces (like DEC,
    HP, and Tandem in this case) get together to create the standard.
843.18SQL Access demo a big success!BROKE::LOMARTIREFri Jul 26 1991 00:43141
 






             SQL Access Group Debuts Database Interoperability Prototype



          Congratulations to the RdbStar:Link to SQL Access Team!

          On Tuesday, July 16, "the first step towards universal database
          access" was successfully taken. The SQL Access Group, a con-
          sortium founded in 1989 by Digital, Ask/Ingres, Tandem, Sun
          and Hewlett-Packard which now consists of 42 leading systems
          and software vendors, held a press event and demonstration of
          the Phase I Technical Specification at the Plaza Hotel in New
          York. The Phase I Specification describes a standard API for
          client/server database communication using embedded SQL and
          ISO/OSI network connectivity. It was developed in conjunction
          with industry standards from ANSI, ISO and X/OPEN and is now
          being published by X/OPEN as part of its XPG4 specification.

          The event was attended by over 70 consultants, analysts and
          press members, as well as many of the SQL Access members. The
          entire event went exceptionally well and was well received by
          the attendees. Several articles praising the event have already
          appeared in Digital Review, Information Week and UNIX Today.

          The following SQL Access Group member companies, and their prod-
          ucts, were represented in the demo. The demo highlighted exam-
          ples of various clients working with different servers, showing
          that data entered from one client application was immediately
          available to another, even though the clients and the database
          management system were from different vendors.









                                                                         1

 






          ________________________________________________________________

          Company________________Client__________________Server___________

          ASK/Ingres             Windows 4GL

          Cincom Systems         MANTIS

          Digital                DECquery                Rdb/VMS
                                 SQL/Services

          Fujitsu                                        RDB II

          Hewlett-Packard        NewWave Access          HP ALLBASE/SQL

          Informix and           Wingz                   Informix Online
          Unisys

          MCC                        Object Oriented Research Prototype

          Microsoft              EXCEL

          NCR and Sybase                                 SYBASE SQL Server

          Oracle                 SQL*Forms/Menu          ORACLE RDBMS
                                 Oracle Graphics

          Sun                    SimplifySQL

          Tandem                                         NonStop SQL

          Teradata                                       DBC/1012

          Unify                  ACCELL/SQL

          ________________________________________________________________

          2

 









          Congratulations to those from Digital who put in so much to
          make this event such a success: Scott Newman, Bill McGuire, Jeff
          Balboni, Bob Lomme, Linda Kipnes, D'Aun Bowers, Vickie Farrell,
          Barry Needleman and Bill Beauregard.

          Digital will be sponsoring the SQL Access Lab for Phase II at
          the San Francisco Systems Center. Phase II of SQL Access will
          consist of:

          o  Call Level Interface - SQL/Connectivity

          o  TCP/IP Support

          The first products from Digital based on SQL Access are planned
          for announcement in October. There will be a project announce-
          ment of the SQL Access Server for Rdb/VMS and a program an-
          nouncement of the SQL Access Server for ULTRIX/SQL at the Open
          Advantage II event.


















                                                                         3
843.19SQL_Access notes conference.BROKE::MCGUIREWed Sep 25 1991 07:143
    SQL Access now has a notes conference of its own: broke::sql_access.  Hit
    KP7 to add it.  For your convenience this note string has been transplanted
    there as note 11.