[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference ulysse::rdb_vms_competition

Title:DEC Rdb against the World
Moderator:HERON::GODFRIND
Created:Fri Jun 12 1987
Last Modified:Thu Feb 23 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1348
Total number of notes:5438

13.0. "Cullinet news anybody?" by TIPPLE::FARESE () Thu Jul 02 1987 23:44

I have read in DIGITAL REVIEW (the bad guys) that we might be planning
something with Cullinet.  Does anybody have any real information on our
plans or on how the Cullinet product may work in the future?  This is
of great interest to me since we are dealing with IDMS/R IBM shops who
would like to employ VAXes and need the ability to talk with IDMS/R.
VIDA has already been discussed and is a possibility, but they really
need better access (and more data transparency) than VIDA can supply.
Anybody have any info or contacts?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
13.1negotiations are sensitiveNOVA::BERENSONRdb/VMS - Number ONE on VAXTue Jul 07 1987 16:475
This is an unrestricted conference, therefore no discussion of any
negotiations we may be having with another firm should take place.
When (and if) the persons at Digital and Cullinet negotiating (assuming
Digital Review is correct) want to let the rest of us in on any
agreements, then they can be discussed here.
13.2Cullinet: A Case Study...BMT::TIMMINSFri Jul 10 1987 01:1345
        
    re .0       
    
    	(Sorry I didn't see the rag's article but...)
    
    	Other Published info... (I hope its not too old)
    
    	Cullinet acquired Esvel's Stellar Technology (in C) to be
    	ported to VAX/VMS environment.
    
    	Cullinet is re-architecting all existing Cullinet applications
    	to work with this SQL/relational technology for the VAX
    	environment.
    
        Cullinet will market product as IDMS/SQL.  Speculation is that
    	Cullinet will port this relational product to MVS in future
    	-- but its just speculation.  
    
    	(Note:  IDMS/SQL is renamed IDMS/D product)
    
        (Unverified but saw published) that Cullinet's "two DBMSs <IDMS/R
        and IDMS/SQL> talk to each other, which leads to having ADS/O
    	and the data dictionary on smaller (in terms of the departmental
    	or distributed environment) processors..."
                                         
    		previous quote from Gartner Group's SMS service
    		(E-034-303 "Case Study:  Cullinet Strategies" 12/29/87)
    
    
    	Cullinet's IDMS Architect (CASE tool from LBMS with enhancements)
    	is already available for IDMS/R, no known plans for IDMS/SQL.
    
        Dave Chapman "In 1988, the revenues from the VAX sector should
    	be about 30 percent of our total DBMS revenues."
                                                                     
    	Cullinet's focus will be on selling applications and tools.
    
    
    	Regards,
    
    	Larry T.    
        333-6771
    
    
                
13.3Final Reply, I hopeCEDSWS::BOOTHThere's madness in my methodFri Jul 10 1987 08:1511
      Let's finish this. IDMS/SQL will be available this Fall. It will
    perform at about 25-30 Debit/Credit TPS on a high end VAX. The logical
    view of IDMS/R and IDMS/SQL will be the same. Consequently, ADS/O
    will be the same on VAX as on IBM. The current IDMS/R tools will be ported
    to the VAX environment over the next 18-24 months. The name will
    be IDMS/SQL. The original name was IDMS/Distributed, then shortened
    to IDMS/D, then changed to IDMS/SQL to avoid confusion with IDMS
    and IDMS/R.
      None of this information came from the seemingly omniscent Gartner
    Group! Honest to God, there are other sources.
      --- Michael Booth
13.4BMT::TIMMINSFri Jul 10 1987 20:5511
    
    
    .3 
    
    I agree completely.  
    
    Larry T.
    
    PS (Please excuse any "seemingly" GG hype -- just trying to help.)
    LJT 8^)
    
13.5Cullinet's VAX productsMJOVAX::WEINBROMWed Jul 15 1987 07:5449
    This afternoon, we just completed a demonstration of Cullinet's
    VAX database and "application development system".  The demo was
    done in conjunction with Cullinet's DC Office, the developer of
    the interactive SQL part of IDMS/SQL (from the former ESVEL) and
    the product manager for Magic (the former AMCORE/EMCORE?) for the
    Mechanicsburg Navy Depot.  Both of these products are scheduled
    to go into beta test at the end of this month.  I don't know when
    the announcement to the public will be.
    
    Some interesting points:
    
    o	There is currently NO LINK and NO CONVERSION "tool" to go between
	IDMS/R and    IDMS/SQL.  (i.e. No tools to convert IDMS/R
    	schemas to IDMS/SQL and no communication links between ICMS
    	and IDMS/SQL.)  Cullinet told the customer that these
    	things were being developed.
    
    o	There is no conversion tools (yet) to go from ADS/O, Cullinet's
    	IBM development tool to Magic nor the other way.  (The name Magic 
    	is already taken and it will be called something else when finally
    	announced.)
    
    o	Magic is their appilication application development system.
	It includes a screen generator, a report generator, a menu system,
    	a data dictionary (that interfaces to IDMS/SQL) and a
    	4GL.

    o	Magic is quite impressive in a demo.  The output from it is very 
    	"PC like" with windows, pop-up help and ring menus.  It uses
    	a "screen painter" a la FMS/TDMS to define both screens
    	and reports.  It has a 4GL that drives them.  This 4GL
    	is then translated into COBOL or FORTRAN or BASIC.  My impression
    	is that it is quite complete.  In many ways it's similar to
    	Powerhouse, though the screens are much better than Powerhouse.

    If you need more information, the Cullinet salesforce or at 
    least their DC office, is currently speaking to customers about
    these products and doing demos.
    
        Speaking only for this demo, I know that the Cullinet name made
    the customer much more comfortable about the whole thing even though
    the products aren't related.  (They already have IDMS/R and ADS/O.)

	Steve Weinbrom DTN/348-2236
    
    Note:  Rdb was not an option and not proposed.  A decision of the
    Salesforce (DEC's) and Sales Support Consultants.  The subject was
    closed before I came into the picture.
    
13.6Whoops!MJOVAX::WEINBROMWed Jul 15 1987 08:0111
    Better make myself cleaer: 
    
    WE have a communication link to IDMS/R & ICMS.  It's called VIDA.
    CULLINET does not have a link.

    
    Magic is "multi-tasking".  It uses one process per user for the
    screen manager, and one subprocess per "task" which is pretty much
    anything that is not a menu.  There is also an ad hoc report writer
    (menu driven of course) called FASTINFO that is a part of Magic.
    to implement their screens.