[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference hips::uk_audioo

Title:You get surface noise in real life too
Notice:Let's be conformist
Moderator:GOVT02::BARKER
Created:Thu Jul 28 1988
Last Modified:Mon Jun 02 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:550
Total number of notes:3847

242.0. "Nad3020 ghost in my machine" by SIOG::T_OCONNELL () Mon Dec 17 1990 19:50

    I have Nad3020 amp which is about 5 years old. It has been giving me
    trouble for most of that time. I returned it to the dealer who sold
    it to me who supposedly fixed it but the problem is still there. I 
    have been too lazy to do anything about it but my interest in hi-fi
    has been aroused again and I would like to get to the bottom of the
    problem. Judging by the wealth of knowledge out there someone might
    recognise the problem. The said problem manifests itself in a couple
    of ways and there are a few ways of temporarily getting rid of it 
    which explains why I have suffered on for so long.
    
    Manifestation no 1 :
    
    Phono input selected on amp but record not playing. System left
    on for about 5 to 10 minutes. Result : Bass hum in speakers.
    Temporary solution: Turn off amp and turn on again or remove earth
    strap from terminal on amp and touch off case of amp. Problem usually
    returns within a couple of minutes.
    
    Manifestation no 2 :
    
    Phono input selected and record deck playing. After 5 to 10 minutes
    hum starts to drown music. Temporary solution : As above or turn off
    record deck. Problem returns as above.
    
    A few additional points to note :
    Problem never occurs when tape deck is selected on amp.
    Turntable is Dual CS505-1.
    Somebody mentioned to me that they had heard that Nad did produce
    some bad batches off the 3020. Something to do with the power
    transistors.
    
    I really would appreciate it anyone could throw some light on this
    problem. 
    
    Tom
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
242.1Might be Acoustic FeedbackHAND::LARSENRob Larsen @BSTMon Dec 17 1990 20:2126
    I Have had this before with other systems.
    
    Questions:  1. Does this happen with Headphones ?
                2. Is everything ok with all other inputs ?
    
    
    Try this:   Put LP on turntable leave the turntable plugged into the 
    		Amp but disconect from the mains. Place arm on the record
    		And then turn the volume up SLOWLY. Do you get feedback
    		like you would from a microphone ? 
    
    		If so the turntable needs to be isolated. Try moving it
    		away from the speakers. Get a proper Turntable Table. 
    		(IE Target). Put you Speakers on Proper Stands.
    
    		If that doesnt do the trick, Its probably a mains problem.
    
    		PS What Cartridge & Speakers are you using.
    
    		PPS If you get the propers stands etc. Your system will
   		sound better too. :-)
    
    		Have fun.
    
    		Rob.
    
242.2WIKKIT::WARWICKTrevor WarwickMon Dec 17 1990 21:287
    
    Is the Turntable grounded on its mains plug as well as through the
    connection on the amp ? If so, I think it could be a ground loop, but I
    was under the impression that ground loops caused hum problems that are
    either ON or OFF - I didn't think that they slowly got worse.
    
    Trevor
242.3My hi-fi is not well!SIOG::T_OCONNELLTue Dec 18 1990 12:5419
    Thanks for your replies,
    
    Re .1 :  Yes the problem does occur with headphones and yes everything
             seems to be ok on the other inputs.
    
             I tried your suggestion about selecting phono and not plugging
             in the record deck and the problem recurred. However I dont
             think it is acoustic feedback. The sound I get from the
             speakers is not the high pitched whine usually associated with
             microphones. It is more of a bass hum, and sounds rather like
             a truck passing by the house. 
             The cartridge I am using is an Ortofon TKS 49S and the speakers
             are AR 18EJs. The speakers are not mounted on proper stands
             and neither is the Dual.
    
    Re .2 :  I am not sure if the Dual is grounded through the mains plug.
             I will check this tonight. If it is not what should I do?
    
    Regards,Tom
242.4Leave the NAD alone!HAND::LARSENRob Larsen @BSTTue Dec 18 1990 13:4015
    Ok we have proved what it isnt :-)
     
    If all other inputs are ok I would think that Its the deck or cartridge
    that is at fault. Or the suggestions in .2. Can you borrow another deck
    from anywhere (frendly dealer maybe). Also a new cartridge may help.
    
    FWIW Acoustic feedback in hifi systems is low frequency. Its is caused
    by the sound from the speakers going back into the Cartridge. Hence my
    question about headphones.
    
    
    Have fun.
    
    Rob.
    
242.5Rob you're a sound manSIOG::T_OCONNELLTue Dec 18 1990 16:596
    Rob,
       I will be able to try another deck tommorow night although it will
    not be another Dual. If it turns out that this solves the problem do
    you think that I should go ahead and buy a new cartridge and if so can
    you recommend a decent cartridge which wont break the bank. Keep it up
    Rob youre playing a blinder!
242.6Carefull with that NAD Eugine.CRATE::WATSONBack to monoTue Dec 18 1990 17:4111
    If your going to replace you cartridge then me carefull. Althought the
    '3020 is a good amp the MM input stage does tend to clip when used with
    very ``dynamic'' (I hate that word) cartridges eg Rega R100, Bias, any
    thin by Linn. So be careful and take you amp along to any demos you go to.
    
    The cartridge I use to recommend for the NAD was the A&R C77 but I don't
    know if they still make it and there must be someting better these
    days.
    
    As for your amp problems it sounds like a wierd case of earth loop ...
    but I'm baffled by the time delay ???
242.7Can't trype for nitsCRATE::WATSONBack to monoTue Dec 18 1990 17:421
    After re-reading my last reply I really should learn to read / type ...
242.8Do what *YOU* want toHAND::LARSENRob Larsen @BSTTue Dec 18 1990 19:1646
242.9On the contrary, it must be the ampHLFS00::STEENWINKELThe Taming of the ScrewFri Dec 28 1990 17:5734
    Re:.4
    >Ok we have proved what it isnt :-)
    > 
    >If all other inputs are ok I would think that Its the deck or cartridge
    >that is at fault. Or the suggestions in .2. Can you borrow another deck
    
    It could still be the NAD! Phono input has a separate preamp to get the
    signal (couple of mV) up to line/aux/tape level (couple of 100mV) and
    apply RIAA frequency correction. This makes Phono inputs more sensitive
    to problems like ground loops or bad ground.
    
    When you say it still appears when the record player is disconnected
    from the amp, it's clear that it MUST be in the amp, and only in the
    phono preamp to add. (You've disconnected all cables from the player to
    the amp, including the ground wire?). 
    The sound you describe as a truck passing has to do with a phase shift
    in the amp feedback loop (which controls the gain the amp delivers)
    that causes the amp to go unstable at a low frequency. When, as in your
    case, it is absent at first but appears over time, it seems to indicate
    temperature sensitivity of one component or the other. Most likely are
    electrolytic caps, but a bad soldering joint can do it as well. If it
    appears in both channels at the same time it's a component that's
    common for both channels, like supply stabilisation. Try getting hold
    of a can of freezer spray (mind the ozone layer!), and chill the
    various components near the phono input one by one. I can't give you
    details how things look like inside the amp, but this must be easy
    enough. 
    The problem itself is rather nasty to eliminate if it's a design fault,
    but since it shouldn't be (just a matter of component aging, tolerances
    going off), it should be fixable by replacing a component or two.
    
    Good luck.
    
                                                             - Rik -
242.10NAD 3220PE hassles...HEWIE::CHRISMy plant, Eric, OD'd on Grendel and Baby BioThu Jan 16 1992 17:0222
    
    
    Another problem with a NAD amp unfortunately, maybe one of you lot
    could help me out a bit please...?!!
    
    
    I switched the amp on yesterday morning to listen to the radio and one
    of the channels was dead.  I did the obligatory checking of terminals
    round the back and the speaker cables.  After all this stuff I decided
    to switch the thing off for a while and check it later, when I switched
    it back on a few hours later, the dead channel did a bit of a
    re-incarnation job and was sort of working!  It seems to pack up when I
    turn the amp up slightly, but if I switch it off and leave it for a few
    seconds, it comes back working.  I haven't been running it heavily
    really.
    
    All that I can think of is there's a temperature related problem with
    one of the output (can't think of the component name, but think it's a
    round thing with an oval bit on the end! =;*)  )...
    
    Any help appreciated.
    Chris.
242.11A bit of elementary trouble shooting....BAHTAT::SALLITTa legend in his lunchtimeFri Jan 17 1992 12:2913
    re .10....
    
    If it happens with all sources, swap over the speaker connections, as
    a pair, between L & R. If the problem moves to the other side, the
    fault is with the amp; if it stays oon the same  side then it's the
    speaker or cable/plugs.
    
    If it happens on one source only, swap over the L & R inputs for the
    failing source. If the problem remains with the same side, the amp
    input for that source is faulty; if the problem moves, it's the source
    component or cable/plugs at fault.
    
    Dave
242.12HEWIE::CHRISMy plant, Eric, OD'd on Grendel and Baby BioMon Jan 20 1992 16:158
               
    
    The problem with the amp appears to have gone for the moment!  It was
    definitely a problem with the components in the amp itself as I'd
    swapped over the speaker cables, speakers, and the sources.
    
    Ta for the help.
    Chris.