[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::womannotes-v3

Title:Topics of Interest to Women
Notice:V3 is closed. TURRIS::WOMANNOTES-V5 is open.
Moderator:REGENT::BROOMHEAD
Created:Thu Jan 30 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 30 1995
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1078
Total number of notes:52352

182.0. "independence -> too much of a good thing?" by NOATAK::BLAZEK (a new moon, a warm sun) Wed Jun 06 1990 20:09

There is dialog in the movie Barfly which goes something like this:

Wanda:  "I hate people.  Do you hate people?"
Henry:  "No, but I seem to feel better when they're not around."

We are conditioned, and pressured, to form one lifelong committed love 
relationship, to remain with the same company and forge ahead with _a_
career that oftentimes means doing the same type of work years on end,
to accept injustices and forgive betrayals in the name of preserverance
of relationships, to establish longterm business contacts, to live in 
one home for lengthy periods of time, and to be as stable as possible.
We have been taught that to crave self-exploration and alone-time on an
expansive basis, unless it's religious stuff, is abnormal.  We've been 
taught to surround ourselves with people who are supposed to be in our 
lives to stay.  We've been taught that being fickle is bad.  We've been
taught that choosing a solitary life-path is eccentric, at best.

As someone who thrives on change and new challenges, who prefers to be 
alone, who has not yet understood why others are content to remain in 
relationships riddled with problems, who loves moving to new homes each
year or two, who prefers the challenge of new jobs, and who very gladly
would live alone for many years to come (perhaps the rest of my life!),
I've faced many shocked people who ask things like, "What?  You're not
married yet?  Why not?  Don't you want children?  Didn't you just move
a year ago?  What happened to <insert name>?  Why do you spend so much
time ALONE?"

I'm eternally changing, growing, and evolving.  And I cannot help but 
feel that, as a woman, I'm somehow weird for not desiring stability and
continuity, and, in fact, shunning it in nearly all facets of my life.
Which is OK.  I accept myself and am not battling this, but I do still
feel curiously bugged by how radically independent and fickle I can be.
Does it continue to escalate as you get older?  (Egads!)

Carla

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
182.1You must hear a different drummerAKOFIN::MACMILLANWed Jun 06 1990 20:577
    I'm not sure what the question is but you sound great to me Carla. Your
    path isn't one I'd choose but thats why you're on it and I'm on mine.
    
    Do you hear a different drummer? That's great..sounds like you're
    having a great life.
    
    -D-
182.2Just say no to stability!TLE::D_CARROLLThe more you know the better it getsWed Jun 06 1990 21:0520
Carla,

I understand how your feel.  I like constant change...new living spaces, new
friends, new work to do, etc.  (I *loevd* school because it changed 
constantly.)  I also found that recently my dependence on the presence of
others has almost vanished.  The thought of spending the rest of my life
"alone" (ie: unmarried) doesn't scare me like it used to, and, in fact,
sounds more and more appealing.

I could never and would never want to give up on people altogether.  By
lately I haven't been buying into the "long term stability" myth presented
by society.  Stability?  Why?

People tell me, though, that I am feeling this way just because of my young
age.

D!

[I'm considering a new apartment, even though I have only been in mine for 
about 5 months]
182.3but I like my chair in this cornerTINCUP::KOLBEThe dilettante debutanteWed Jun 06 1990 22:3718
    Oh I don't know Carla, I miss you and you've hardly gone. Maybe it's
    just us old folks that like stability. ;*)

    When I was younger I moved around, changed jobs, was alone, was with
    someone, and alternated these patterns numerous times. I rarely stayed
    in one place for a year. I lived that way for several years and crossed
    several states in my restlessness.

    I still feel the desire for periodic change but also find comfort in a
    certain stability. I like my current house and the state I live in.
    Right now I'm not thinking about moving but it's always possible. I've
    been known to make radical changes at a moments notice in the past.

    As for relationships, I'm beginning to believe that lifelong
    attachments are the exception and not the rule. I'd like another
    relationship in my life but I don't think I'd ever get married again.
    It seems too binding and scary anymore. Perhaps it's just that I
    realised that the stabilty of marriage was only an image. liesl
182.4meSNOC02::WRIGHTPINK FROGSThu Jun 07 1990 00:3214
    Carla,
    
    	Quite simply I just think that "you are you".  *I* don't like been
    alone, I prefer people around me.  Not to depend on just to be there. 
    I don't even need to have to talk to them.  A presence is fine.
    I also like stability in my homelife.  Somewhere cosy and welcoming to
    live that I can settle into.  Work is a little different, yes I like
    variety, don't we all.  I also like sticking to things and seeing them
    out and watching things change.  It gives me satisfaction.
    This is just the way I am.  I don't htink Ill change when I get older. 
    I like me now.
    	C'est la vie.
    
    			Holly
182.5LEZAH::BOBBITTfantasiaThu Jun 07 1990 12:096
    Well, when it comes to change, it makes me nervous, if not downright
    scared sometimes.  Stability seems so much *safer*, because it's a
    *known* commodity.
    
    -Jody
    
182.6Hey, *you're* the one with "Changes fill my time" :-)TLE::D_CARROLLThe more you know the better it getsThu Jun 07 1990 13:0816
>    scared sometimes.  Stability seems so much *safer*, because it's a
>    *known* commodity.
 
Aha!  Maybe that explains something.  Stability is *not* a known commodity for
me.  I have almost never experienced it.  When I was growing up, I moved
from town to town and state to state at least every two years.  The longest
time I ever spent in one place was at RPI for four years.  And that doesn't
really count, below school provides it's *own* changes.  A quarter of the
population changes every year, classes change, I moved every 6 months while
I was there, etc.
   
Maybe I am just *scared* of things staying the same?

I get bored easily.  My life has to be chaos...

D!
182.7DZIGN::STHILAIREanother day in paradiseThu Jun 07 1990 13:1221
    Even if I had the money to move constantly, two conflicts for me
    would always be that I'm a collector and I have pets.  And, if I
    had more money I would collect *more* things.  If a person likes
    to nice things around, and collect things, such as a lot of oil
    paintings, glass things, etc., it can be more difficult to move
    often.  Also, it would be hard to move often or long distances with
    a lot of pets, and would never give up my cats just to move someplace
    else.  Still, a third thing, if someone owns a home and has worked
    hard to plant trees and shrubs and create a nice flower garden,
    it can be sad to leave it all.  I still miss my rose bush from the
    house my ex-husband and I owned.  I planted it.  I drove by the
    other day and it was starting to bloom and I wanted to stop the
    car and dig it up -"Give me my rose bush!"  I can understand the
    appeal of travel and change but my conflict is that when I find
    something I like, I get attached to it.
    
    I also prefer to have people around me most of the time, as long
    as I have some privacy.  
    
    Lorna
    
182.8Carla...you're making me thinkAKOFIN::MACMILLANThu Jun 07 1990 14:0014
	Carla raises some interesting issues here. I'm sure that all of
us at one time or another has wished to break free somehow. No more spouses,
children, jobs comittments and things which tie us down to one situation or
another.

	I've asked myself (more and more as I get older) what did I buy into
here? Is this where I want to be in my life? This responsible family man thing
is it real does it offer meaningfulness? 

	Do I remain in the situation because of a sense of reponsibility or
is it that I lack Carla's courage and because of it I avoid a greater growth?

	-D-

182.9"and freedom, oh! freedom..."ULTRA::THIGPENT.A.N.J.Thu Jun 07 1990 14:4033
    Hmmm.  Being a grownup is awful -- you have to take responsibility for
    your choices.  And then commit to the choice, and accept both the
    rewards and regrets.  Two examples.
    
    My older brother chose (in some sense) the path of "freedom".  He has
    never married.  He has studied lots of stuff in and out of school --
    anthropology, engineering, ecology.  He has lived in various parts of
    the country.  He has pursued various interests, inclucing his latest
    craze, boats, without being restricted by the needs of others.  A good
    characterization would be that he doesn't make compromises, and will
    not give up his freedom.  He likes all that part.  But he has regrets,
    like he would like (probably his fantasy/ideal of) much of what I have:
    home, family, stability, etc.
    
    I have also chosen (in some sense) a path.  I spent time early on
    travelling and working in various minimum-wage jobs.  I went back to
    college and got a degree, luckily in something practical.  Got married
    at 25, and got a job in a corporation -- the start of compromises, or
    tradeoffs, if you will.  After being married for 5 years, I had a
    child, and 2 years later another.  I love my family, and usually have
    fun with them.  I often have fun at work too :').   I enjoy my home and
    garden, they give me a lot of satisfaction.  But my freedom is
    constrained, in that I would like to do things that at least for now I
    cannot do -- things my brother can if he chooses -- like spend more time
    in a canoe for example, or go woods-walking alone, or read till all
    hours.
    
    So, my take on it goes like this.  There are many paths, and many for
    each of us.  I have chosen, and committed to my choice, knowing that it
    will bring me both satisfactions and frustrations, contentment and
    regret, at different times.  If it becomes unbearable or sufficiently
    unrewarding, I will change it.  While I am happy on it, I will stay on
    the path.  But I may look at the scenery...
182.10RAVEN1::AAGESENbeing happy shouldn't be illegalThu Jun 07 1990 15:4113
    
    re. D!
    
    i think i understand what you are saying...
    
    for you, stability would be a change
    
    so you are more comfortable with *change* which you try and keep a
    stable occurance of...
    
    (-:
    
    ~r
182.11The only constant...DELNI::POETIC::PEGGYJustice and LicenseWed Jun 13 1990 21:4320
    
    stability - thats what comes with old age or something???

	I can not move from place to place so I change the place
	I stay at - Ask my kids - I move the rooms around all
	the time.

	The trouble with change is that it is so constant.

	I perfer to be by myself more often than not but I do
	enjoy watching people interact.

	But then who ever said I as a mature, responsible person.

	_peggy
		(-)
		 |
			She changes everything she touches
			and everything she touches changes.