[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference 7.286::dcu

Title:DCU
Notice:1996 BoD Election results in 1004
Moderator:CPEEDY::BRADLEY
Created:Sat Feb 07 1987
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1041
Total number of notes:18759

215.0. "CRT Payed in Full/Closed Out / Reapp. Refused?" by USCTR2::ZAPPIA (noting is hard with eyes closed) Fri May 25 1990 12:51

	Three years ago I applied for a DCU CRT loan and I got approved 
	for a $3,000 credit amount.  As time went by I got tired of paying 
	$80/month to a balance which never seemed to get down.

	I then decided to pay off the balance in full and close out the 
	account.  I guess that was my mistake.

	I just applied to open another CRT for $5,000 and I was declined 
	due to insufficient income and excessive obligations.  

	What gets me is my credit history is very good and I would think
	if DCU wouldn't approve the $5,000 credit that I would still at 
	least be eligible for $3,000 limit again.

	Is it worth trying to ask them to reconsider a lessor amount even
	though I did say I would accept one on the application?

	- Jim
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
215.1If at first...ULTRA::KINDELBill Kindel @ BXB1Fri May 25 1990 14:0220
    Re .0:
    
>	I just applied to open another CRT for $5,000 and I was declined 
>	due to insufficient income and excessive obligations.  

    If the turndown is based in part on a bad credit report, you have
    specific rights to challenge any bogus information.  The DCU should be
    able to give you and idea (though they may choose not to be specific)
    of the ratio of debts to income that they're comfortable with for CRT
    lines of credit.  Keep in mind that lenders treat credit cards as if
    each is at its maximum when computing "obligations".
    
>	Is it worth trying to ask them to reconsider a lessor amount even
>	though I did say I would accept one on the application?
    
    It's worth asking.  It would have been reasonable for DCU to say, "we
    can't approve a $5000 CRT but we COULD approve $X," but that's not how
    lenders' loan committees work.  They're presented with a package on
    which to make a "yes" or "no" decision.  There's no bargaining done
    with routine applications.
215.2Application only - no credit dataUSCTR2::ZAPPIAnoting is hard with eyes closedFri May 25 1990 14:248
    
    	I was told that the decision was based only on information that I
    	entered on my application, no credit report, even though I know
    	my current credit report is accurate and clean!
    
    	Thanks for your response.
    
    	- Jim
215.3Go somewhere where they appreciate your businessCVMS::DOTENRight theory, wrong universe.Fri May 25 1990 15:196
I would ask them for the lower amount (if that is truely all you need/want). If
they still deny, I'd simply take my business elsewhere (which in fact I have -
the DCU has never approved me for a CRT loan, yet other banks given them to me
in the same afternoon!).

-Glenn-