[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::cooks

Title:How to Make them Goodies
Notice:Please Don't Start New Notes for Old Topics! Check 5.*
Moderator:FUTURE::DDESMAISONSec.com::winalski
Created:Wed Feb 19 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:4127
Total number of notes:31160

2908.0. "Fish Suggestions" by TYGON::WILDE (why am I not yet a dragon?) Wed Feb 13 1991 20:39

okay, I don't know if we have covered this anywhere...but what I want to know
is what types of fish are white fleshed when cooked, lean, flakey, and NOT
FISHY tasting?  I am not big on seafood and I should eat more of it.  I like
salmon, scallops, and trout (well, its a fish).  Occasionally, I like the
fish I eat, but don't know what it is....but it is always lean, white, flakey
fish.  I know I don't like tuna and shark, and red snapper isn't all that
great.

Any suggestions?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2908.1the old standbysPENUTS::DDESMAISONSWed Feb 13 1991 20:458
    
    Well, there's always sole, halibut, schrod or cod (let's not get
    into it - okay? 8-) ) and the ever-popular haddock.  Is that the
    kind of answer you had in mind?  I mean these are really standard
    and I'm not sure if you're looking for more unusual types of fish
    or what.
    
    
2908.2Mahi Mahi will tempt you!FORTSC::CHERETONEither beg me or slap my face!Wed Feb 13 1991 21:178
    
    Dian --> promise me you will try MAHI MAHI!  It is totally lean,
    flakey, white-fleshed and definitely {{NOT}} fishy tasting.  It is
    flown in from Hawaii.  Why don't we go to the Fish Market on El 
    Camino for lunch and I'll introduce the two of you to each other?
    Perhaps as soon as this Friday? (<*:
    
    --dc
2908.3ALOSWS::LEVINEOne Step at a Time...Thu Feb 14 1991 02:2714
    
    Of those mentioned in .1, the least fishy tasting (IMHO) is sole.  I've
    always thought that haddock, halibut and cod were fishy tasting, but
    the times I had them they may have been frozen (good way to make any
    fish taste strong - the fresher it is, the less fishy-tasting it is). 
    I've always liked schrod much more, but then again I order it in places
    where it's almost always very fresh.
    
    My mother always used to soak scallops in milk before cooking them, and
    claimed that this cut down on the fish taste.  That might help
    matters...
    
    Sarah
    
2908.4WAHOO::LEVESQUENo easy way to be free...Thu Feb 14 1991 12:2440
 In the northeast, there are a number of fish with "flaky, white flesh" when
cooked that are not fishy tasting when properly prepared.

 The first rule about buying fish is that you should never buy frozen fish.
Properly cleaned and chilled fish will not taste or smell fishy (with a
few notable exceptions).

 If you catch the fish yourself (truly the best way to obtain the freshest
of fish, especially since you have complete control over the treatment of the
fish) there are a few things that you can do to make your fish the height
of epicurean delight. :-) The first thing is to immediately bleed your fish,
especially if you are busy catching and don't want to stop and clean the fish 
immediately. On most fish, this can be accomplished by cutting through the
bottom attachment of the gills to the body of the fish. Then put the fish in a 
cool, damp spot (fish box, under some seawater soaked burlap, etc). Clean the 
fish ASAP! We often clean the fish caught in one spot as the capt. moves the 
boat. Then put the fish on ice. It is definitely preferable that you do not
allow the fish flesh to lie directly on the ice; it is better to put it in
a plastic bag. As the ice melts, the flesh will absorb the fresh water (this
is a bad thing). Certain types of fish should _never_ touch fresh water 
(bluefish is one of these). If you are not going to eat the fish on the same 
day, leave the fish on ice (but in the fridge). It will keep this way for
several days.

 The most common "white" fish that can be found in the northeast are as follows:
cod, pollock, haddock, flatfish (sole, flounder, plaice, fluke), hake, and cusk.
Mahi Mahi is also very good; it is a common fish found in tropical waters. 
Halibut is also more or less white, but is a "meatier" fish than the 
aforementioned. Wolffish is an exceptionally ugly creature, which has 
delightfully tasty flesh. Tilefish is another tasty creature that is less than
handsome.

 Having just noticed that the node of the basenote author is located in Santa
Clara, I realize that much of this will be less than helpful. %^} I'd try 
lingcod, or mahi mahi (west coast). I'm not sure what other kinds of fish are
common on the west coast.

 Good luck, and remember that fresh is the way to go.

 The Doctah
2908.5CALVA::WOLINSKIuCoder sans FrontieresThu Feb 14 1991 13:007
 
 Rep .0

  Try catfish, even my teenage daughter likes and says it doesn't taste
 "fishy". Shaw's supermarkets here in New England carries it.

  -mike
2908.6orange roughy...DELREY::PEDERSON_PAHey man, dig this groovy scene!Thu Feb 14 1991 13:149
    Only liking certain white-flesh fishes myself, I
    used to do haddock and flounder and scallops ONLY when
    I was in N.E., now the closest I can get is orange roughy
    out here in the west. Orange Roughy tastes pretty close
    to flounder, IMHO, but I understand it's a *very* ugly
    looking fish, from what I've read here in notes.
    
    pat
    
2908.7religion comes to foodBRUMMY::IRWINFri Feb 15 1991 08:509
    it may already have been mentioned as this too is an ugly beast, but in
    the UK its known as monk fish, the fish has only one central bone and
    the flesh is abundant and meaty, some say its similar to lobster.
    Because of its meaty nature you can cook this fish in many ways
    including roasting.
    
     I too am not a fish fan but like you i like salmon, trout and funnily
    enough sardines (very fishy) when cooked over open log fires. However
    monk fish is something that i will always be tempted by.
2908.8monk fish is good!CASDEV::COLELLADoes Uranus have an aurora?Fri Feb 15 1991 11:364
    Yes, monk fish is meaty and not fishy at all.  Dian, you might like it!
    
    Cara
    
2908.9adventures aheadTYGON::WILDEwhy am I not yet a dragon?Fri Feb 15 1991 19:5113
well, thanks all, I now have plans to try:

		mahi mahi 	- Next Friday for you David....sounds great!
		monk fish	- I never would have been brave enough
				  to try this w/o your suggestion
		ling cod	- never even thought of cod, but it
				  sounds like what I like
		orange roughy	- again, I was too chicken to leap in by
				  myself.    

now, to the fish cookbooks.....

			D-the-desert-rat
2908.10Orange RoughyATLEAD::PSS_MGRDoes Fred Flintstone do his own stunts?Mon Feb 18 1991 11:0213
    Orange Roughy is a very very mild fish.  I serve it with a
    sour cream, mozzorella, and scallop sauce that puts calories
    on your hips just by making it.
    
    I agree, haddock can be a strong fish at times.  Orange
    Roughy should not have any scent at all when you purchase it.
    I usually have a hard time with grocery stores saying that their
    fresh fish just came in today....I always ask for the frozen
    and have never had a problem with 'fishy' taste since.
    
    BTW - Mahi Mahi is dolphin....8*)
    
    Kristen
2908.11Dolphin Aug?????POCUS::FCOLLINSMon Feb 18 1991 12:264
    Re .10 - Gees I was going to try Mahi Mahi too.  Oh well, I don't
    really like fish anyway.
    
    Flo
2908.12No...not "Flipper" !!!!...(I'm pretty sure...)BOOVX2::MANDILEMon Feb 18 1991 15:425
    Re .10 - I think you mean "dolphin" as in fish,
    and not the "dolphin" mammal.  There is a dolphin fish.
    
    
    Lynne
2908.13Name confusion only!CADSYS::HECTOR::RICHARDSONMon Feb 18 1991 15:425
    Don't panic: there are two creatures called "dolphin"!  One of them is
    the familiar warm-blooded mammal ("Flipper"), and the other one is a
    fish.  Mahi-mahi is fish, NOT "Flipper".   And it's good, too.
    
    /Charlotte
2908.14MR4DEC::MMARINERMon Feb 18 1991 15:464
    Well, I'm glad you cleared that up!
    
    Goodness.
    
2908.15Mahi Mahi is a fish; its name is the result of a marketing decisionSSGBPM::KENAHThe heart of the matter...Mon Feb 18 1991 18:584
    Mahi Mahi is called Mahi Mahi precisely to avoid the confusion that
    might be caused if they called it dolphin.
    
    					andrew
2908.16TLE::SASAKIMarty Sasaki ZK02-3N30 381-0151Mon Feb 18 1991 20:156
    Yes, this is a rathole, but...
    
    It is called Mahi Mahi because that's what the Hawaiians call it. In
    Mexico the fish is called a Dorado.
    
    	Marty Sasaki
2908.17WAHOO::LEVESQUENo easy way to be free...Tue Feb 19 1991 12:156
 The dolphin/dorado/mahi mahi is coryphaenea hippurus, and is completely
unrelated to the mammal of the same name. It's yellow, with greens and blues
and sometimes other colors (though these colors quickly disappear when the
fish is removed from water.)

 The Doctah
2908.18CorrectACETEK::TIMPSONPursuing an untamed OrnithoidTue Feb 19 1991 13:404
RE .17  Yes that is right.  Mahi Mahi is NOT a dolphin at all.  it doesn't 
even look like a dolphin.

Steve
2908.19beating a dead fishPENUTS::DDESMAISONSTue Feb 19 1991 15:1510
    
    Re: .18   "... it doesn't even look like a dolphin."
    
    True, although some Mahi Mahi have been known to disguise themselves
    as dolphins just to confuse the heck out of people.  This is a 
    little-known fact, I might add.
    
    
    
    
2908.20bemused or confused - take your pickTYGON::WILDEwhy am I not yet a dragon?Tue Feb 19 1991 18:028
>    True, although some Mahi Mahi have been known to disguise themselves
>    as dolphins just to confuse the heck out of people.  This is a 
>    little-known fact, I might add.
    
probably don't jump thru hoops very well, however....dead give-away...

back to the subject at hand...I forget...was mahi mahi recommended as a
light flakey fish or not?
2908.21mahi's makin' eyes at mePENUTS::DDESMAISONSTue Feb 19 1991 19:4716
    
    
    
    Di,
    
    Actually, I would have guessed that it's not that light.  The
    only reason being that The Forest Cafe in Cambridge (great Mexican
    place) has, as its special catch(es) practically every night, from 
    what I can tell, tuna and mahi mahi.  What a weird sentence THAT
    was - sorry.  Anyways, I assumed they picked these because they can
    stand up well to spicey, complex sauces and are somewhat meaty.
    But previous replies seem to indicate otherwise.  Guess I'll have
    to try it one of these days.  
    
    Di
    
2908.22not without first person recommendation...TYGON::WILDEwhy am I not yet a dragon?Tue Feb 19 1991 23:315
    Di,

being an abject coward about fish....tell me how you like it, will ya?

				D     8^}
2908.23YUMMY !!!WLDWST::GRIBBENZero to 60, in 1.7 seconds !!!Wed Feb 20 1991 07:109
    
    
    I love it.    I like it broiled or on the grill, with a little lemon
    herb sauce.
    
    
    RRG
    
    
2908.24ask nicely and they will slice it up for you!ASABET::C_AQUILIAWed Feb 20 1991 12:1312
    if you live or work near maynard, massachusetts go to the quarterdeck
    restaurant and fish market.  although expensive some cuts are not and
    they have a great selection where you can familiarize yourself with
    the different types of fish mentioned earlier.  i would suggest trying
    the monkfish.  at the deck its about 5.99/lb which is cheap compared to
    the others which run about 10.00/lb.  this fish however is well worth
    the price as they catch it themselves and never sell fish over a day
    old.  anyways.. broil your monkfish with garlic butter.  poor man's
    lobster they call it.  sometimes i prefer it over lobster!
    
    cj
    
2908.25A warning about MonkfishMOSAIC::PESENTIOnly messages can be draggedWed Feb 20 1991 12:545
Always...

No!

Never look at a whole monkfish...  Gives a new meaning to UGLY.
2908.26-1 You're Right!MR4DEC::MMARINERWed Feb 20 1991 13:2411
    I just saw a whole monkfish on a Julia Child's show this past weekend. 
    Lordy, it is awful looking.  She says the only part you eat is the tail
    and proceeded to debone the tail section and filet it.  The whole fish
    just lay there on a huge bed of ice and starred at the camera.
    
    I don't know exactly who removed the tail from the fish for her, she
    probably bought it that way and just borrowed the whole fish to
    display.  She wouldn't have the strength.  She said it has another name
    in Europe but I forget what.
    
    Mary Lou
2908.27AliasesSSGBPM::KENAHThe heart of the matter...Wed Feb 20 1991 13:363
    The Monkfish is also called the Dogfish or the Goosefish.
    
    					andrew
2908.28WAHOO::LEVESQUENo easy way to be free...Wed Feb 20 1991 14:2122
 Um, not to rathole this too much, but goosefish is an acceptable alias in
the US for monkfish, but dogfish is not. Dogfish refers to a small type
of shark which infests the waters of the northeast and can be quite a nuisance.
They are usually 3-4 feet long, and have very small teeth. The two general
varieties are the spiny dogfish and the smooth dogfish, both of which inhabit
northeastern waters (among other places), the latter being identified by a lack
of bony protrusions behind the pectoral and dorsal fins.

 As far as mahi mahi being a flakey white fish, I'm not really sure. However,
my grandmother says it is "as close as you can get to a white flaky fish in
Florida, and it is delicious." It should be easily available in california.

 If you can get some haddock or cod or pollock, you will get white flaky flesh.
I believe that hake is also white and flaky, and cusk is as well. Any of
the small flatfishes will do- sole, flounder, fluke, plaice. They are all 
very delicate in taste.

 I personally also like the meatier fish as well like swordfish and *tuna*. I
had blackened yellowfin tuna a few weeks ago, and it was out of this world!
I'm getting hungry...

 The Doctah
2908.29European monkfish = LotteMOSAIC::PESENTIOnly messages can be draggedWed Feb 20 1991 14:401
Another nickname is Anglerfish, I think.
2908.30all this from a simple questionBRUMMY::IRWINWed Feb 20 1991 15:234
    this could go on for years, i do not think that angler fish is
    monkfish. Angler fish is also known as rape (pronounced rap A).This
    fish is very popular in Spain and is more like a cod in texture.
    
2908.31try ole' whiskersJETSAM::GRUBBSThu Mar 07 1991 16:1222
    
    
	I gotta jump in here and say HEY!, I vote for the catfish suggestion
    mentioned many notes back.
    
    	If your not of the New England persuasion these are good caught
    fresh out of the nearest lake.  They can also be bought at the fish market
    or Supermarket in most parts of the country, though availability can be
    spotty.  Farm fed catfish has become quite an industry, mainly because 
    the fish are fed a constant diet in a controlled environment which makes 
    for some great fryin' or grilling fish.
   
    They've always been my personal favorite..
    
    --Bert
    
    
    	BTW, don't forget the hushpuppies and slaw when you make'em!