[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::cooks

Title:How to Make them Goodies
Notice:Please Don't Start New Notes for Old Topics! Check 5.*
Moderator:FUTURE::DDESMAISONSec.com::winalski
Created:Wed Feb 19 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:4127
Total number of notes:31160

3631.0. "SHELF-LIFE OF BUTTERMILK?" by POWDML::LAMONT () Wed Sep 16 1992 17:55

    I have a recipe that calls for Buttermilk.  Now I bought some recently
    (or so I thought) and used 1/2 to make the recipe.  Now I'd like to
    make this recipe again.  The questions is....how long is buttermilk
    good for?  The date on the carton says it's expired but I smelled it, it
    smells like buttermilk, and seems fine.  I know the date on the carton
    is usually the "sell date" and not the spoil date, but I'm worried.
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
3631.1what I would do.NOVA::FISHERRdb/VMS DinosaurWed Sep 16 1992 18:498
    I think "3-4 weeks" makes it a "must go" if your refrigerator's temp is
    40F or below.
    
    if it's less than a week beyond the sell date it's ok, 2 weeks is
    probably ok and 3 weeks is hold it one more so you know it's bad and
    must be tossed.  :-)
    
    ed
3631.2Dry ButtermilkRANGER::PESENTIOnly messages can be draggedThu Sep 17 1992 10:333
Next time, try getting the instant powdered buttermilk.  It's usually near the 
instant milk in the market.  It's the greatest.  I can't tell the difference,
even in biscuits.  And it keeps forever in the cupboard. 
3631.3keep it in the fridge?UHUH::EIKENBERRYCamry owners exit through trunkThu Sep 17 1992 12:569
>even in biscuits.  And it keeps forever in the cupboard. 
    
    I was keeping my powdered buttermilk in the cupboard, too, until
    someone in this notesfile pointed out that it says "Keep refrigerated
    after opening" on it.  I never noticed any degradation from being in
    the cabinet, but now I keep it in the fridge.
    
    --Sharon
    
3631.4PATE::MACNEALruck `n' rollThu Sep 17 1992 15:393
3631.5Rules for tossing stuff out.GUCCI::DENORMANDIECan you see the beach yet?Thu Sep 17 1992 15:5414
    re: When to throw away stuff.
    
    I used to never know how to judge when to toss things out.  My ex
    taught me that to first give it the sniff test and then follow rule #1:
    
    Rule #1: When in doubt, throw it out.  
    
    When that fails go to Rule #2. 
    
    Rule #2: Always follow rule #1
    
    Bruce
    
    
3631.6ADD WATER THEN BAKE?POWDML::LAMONTFri Sep 18 1992 18:368
    Thanks.  Never heard of dried buttermilk before.  My mom used to make
    that instant milk when we were kids, I hated it.  But if I'm cooking
    with it, I suppose I'd never know the difference.  Do you add water to
    the powdered buttermilk BEFORE you use it in a recipe?  Silly question
    probably, but I'm not sure since I really never baked with any kind of
    powdered milk product.
    
    
3631.7It was easy to use, I'll admit...FLUKES::SUTTONHe roams the seas in freedom...Fri Sep 18 1992 19:1811
    
    The directions on the powdered buttermilk that I've used said to add
    the appropriate amount of the powder (I don't recall the numbers, it
    may have been two or three tablespoons per cup of fresh buttermilk) to
    your dry ingredients; when the recipe called for adding buttermilk, I'd
    just add the equivalent amount of water and proceed from there.
    
    It was easy to work with, but I still like to buy fresh buttermilk for
    my biscuits, scones and breads.
    
    	/Harry
3631.8Consistency of buttermilkSNOC02::MASCALL"Tiddley quid?" dixit Porcellus.Fri Sep 25 1992 05:3310
I bought some buttermilk for a recipe for the first time recently, and 
was surprised at the consistency. It was more like yoghurt than milk. 
Was this OK buttermilk or did I buy old buttermilk by accident?

Doesn't taste too nice on its own, does it?

Sheridan
:^)


3631.9I thought this was obvious.....COMET::HAYESJDuck and cover!Mon Sep 28 1992 05:098
    What's wrong with freezing the leftover buttermilk?  Use half of the
    buttermilk in a recipie, put the other half in an appropriate sized
    Tupperware (or similar) container and freeze it.  Am I missing some-
    thing here?
    
    
    Steve
    
3631.10Question on buttermilkCCAD30::ARCHEYI have not lost my mind! It is backed up on a floppy somewhere.Thu Jan 13 1994 01:1115
HI

Can someone tell me what the difference is between buttermilk and ordinary milk??

I've seen quite a few recipes lately that uses buttermilk which I would like to 
try.  However, I have never seen it in the shops (I'm from New Zealand, BTW). 

Can I substitue milk instead??


Regards
Dianne



3631.11Use YogurtSUPER::MARSHChocolate - 3 of the 4 necessary food groupsThu Jan 13 1994 02:387
Hi

        Yogurt is a substitute for buttermilk.

          1 cup yogurt = 1 cup buttermilk


3631.12make your ownGOLLY::CARROLLa work in progressThu Jan 13 1994 12:1917
    There are a number of alternatives...
    
    powdered buttermilk (have a friend mail it from the States :-)
    yogurt
    1 c milk + 1 tsp white vinegar or lemon juice (I believe that's
        the ratio - to "sour" the milk)
    
    You can't substitute milk *directly* because buttermilk has a higher
    acid quantity which affects things like baking soda.  It most
    conversions I've seen, if you replace buttermilk with regular milk you
    must reduce the baking soda (and sometimes increase the baking powder.)
    Also the taste is different.
    
    As for shelf life - it lasts a long time (3+ weeks) in the frig, but if
    you were thinking of shipping it - don't.
    
    D!
3631.13CCAD30::ARCHEYI have not lost my mind! It is backed up on a floppy somewhere.Thu Jan 13 1994 21:436
Hi

Thanks for your replies.  I can now make the waffle recipe, note 564.23 amongst
others.

Di
3631.14GOLLY::CARROLLa work in progressFri Jan 14 1994 11:573
    Also note that 564.23 has explicit directions at the end for using
    regular milk.  I would suspect that you could replace the baking
    soda/cream of tartar combination with baking powder.
3631.15Less powder, more soda ?MSE1::SUTTONHe roams the seas in freedom...Mon Jan 17 1994 11:3113
    Actually, I'm pretty sure it's just the opposite: reduce baking powder
    and increase baking soda.
    
    In the buttermilk biscuits I made over the weekend, for instance, the
    original recipe which used milk called for a tablespoon of baking
    powder and no baking soda. When I substituted buttermilk, I had to
    reduce the baking powder to 2 teaspoons and add 1/4 teaspoon of baking
    soda.
    
    If I remember it, I'll check my copy of Kitchen Science tonight to get
    the reasons and post them here tomorrow.
    
    	/Harry
3631.16rightGOLLY::CARROLLa work in progressMon Jan 17 1994 12:1917
    >    Actually, I'm pretty sure it's just the opposite: reduce baking
    powder
    >    and increase baking soda.
    [...]
    > When I substituted buttermilk, I had to
        reduce the baking powder to 2 teaspoons and add 1/4 teaspoon of
    >baking
        soda.
    
    Exactly.  I was giving the instructions for replacing buttermilk with
    milk, not the other way around.
    
    More buttermilk = more acid = more soda/less powder
    less buttermilk = less acid = less soda/more powder
    
    
    D!