[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference turris::cooks

Title:How to Make them Goodies
Notice:Please Don't Start New Notes for Old Topics! Check 5.*
Moderator:FUTURE::DDESMAISONSec.com::winalski
Created:Wed Feb 19 1986
Last Modified:Thu Jun 05 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:4127
Total number of notes:31160

2141.0. "Cookie Chemistry Info Needed" by ALLVAX::JEFFERSON () Thu Dec 07 1989 13:46

    
    What is the reason for mixing a 'batter' type cookie recipe and
    refridgerating overnite before use??   
    
    Is there some necessary chemcial reaction that takes place??
    The obvious reasons would be if the recipe contained yeast or a
    large percentage of butter.... but it doesn't.
    
    Now that I think about it, don't most pancake and waffle recipes
    suggest waiting a bit beforecooking?
    
    The recipe-in-question is for pizzelles (sp?)... and consists mostly
    of eggs, oil, sugar and flour plus assorted flavorings.
    Other than increasing the chances for salmonella, what is the purpose
    of mixing one day, and baking the next??  Will they be crisper,
    lighter, fluffier, brown-more-evenly, ....  get the picture?
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2141.1EVERTHING you ever wanted to know...FORTSC::WILDEAsk yourself..am I a happy cow?Thu Dec 07 1989 18:0122
Thin batters containing oil, eggs, flour, etc. generally are mixed with
vigorous action which beats in a LOT of air.  If you want a thin, consistent
product, you want the air to settle out of the mix, and you want the flour
absorbtion to come up a little...hence, the suggestion that you let your
batter sit at least 30 minutes (at room temperature - warm up the batter
and make sure it cooks in the expected time) up to overnight(8 hours or so)
WELL CHILLED in order to avoid salmonella - warm up 30 minutes at room
temp before making your crepes or pizzelles.

Of course, the one flaw in the whole "scientific" plan is that flour
may absorb more or less liquid depending on the grind, the temperature
of the flour, liquids, and the way you look at it  8^}....the solution
to controlling that somewhat is to warm your flour in the oven before
using it (10 minutes at 150 degrees F) if you want it to absorb more
liquid and gain more elasticity and chill it for 30 minutes if you 
need the reverse effect....like in the summer when making pancakes
or crepes on a really hot day.

Now, a batter that is "ripening" to grow natural yeast (sourdough, etc)
is left at room temp to promote growth of the desirable beasties...but
it is NOT recommended to add eggs or fats until just before using the
batter - in order to avoid the problems of salmonella, rancidity, etc.
2141.2Pizzelles Don't Need RefrigerationGOLETA::GOHN_LIFri Dec 08 1989 13:307
    We make pizzelles at least twice a year and we've never refrigerated
    the batter.  The only failure we had was one year when my dad forgot
    to take out the butter.  He melted it.  Yuck!!!!
    
    It wouldn't be Christmas at our house without these cookies.
    
    Linda
2141.4I second that second reply!ERWIN::FARINAFri Dec 15 1989 22:078
    RE: .2:  Ditto!  I've never refrigerated pizzelle batter, nor has my
    father, or his mother before him, nor any other relative.  We've never
    had a problem getting a thin, crisp cookie, even though we don't let
    the batter sit for 30 minutes as .1 suggests.  --Susan
    
    PS:  I've never let pancake batter sit for long, either.  I'd guess it
    depends on the type of pancake you're looking for.  I like them high,
    and "fluffy."       
2141.5another reason...CSG001::SCHOFIELDWed Jan 10 1990 16:506
    I know with Sugar Cookie dough, you couldn't roll out the freshly
    mixed dough, because it would be too soft. But after refrid-ing
    it for a while, its stiff enough to cut with cutters... maybe thats
    what of one of the reasons.
    
    b
2141.6why are my cookies so thick?CALS::HEALEYM&ES, MRO4, 297-2426Mon Sep 27 1993 16:4920
	There was some discussion in here a while back about how
	to get those Original Toll House Chocolate Chip cookies
	to come out flat.  I made a batch over the weekend and
	they tasted pretty good but they didn't spread!  They just
	remained round lumps (ok, they spread a little).  When I
	was a kid, they used to come up really thin compared to 
	what I turned out this weekend.

	Unfortunately, I cannot find the note on this but I think
	it had something to do with either the temperature they
	are baked at or the shortening/butter used.  I used 2 sticks
	of Land of Lakes Morning Blend I think (margarine... reduced
	calorie maybe but I'm not sure).  

	So, anybody care to point that note out to me or tell me
	the answer here?  I searched under "cookie", "butter",
	"shorten" and couldn't find it!

	Karen
2141.7fattening agentKAOFS::M_BARNEYDance with a Moonlit KnightMon Sep 27 1993 18:066
    I suspect its the margarine - I get very different results
    for the same cookie depending on whether I use margarine, 
    butter, "diet" versions of both, or shortening. 
    Do some experimenting with this.
    
    Monica
2141.8check out Consumer ReportsGOLLY::CARROLLa work in progressMon Sep 27 1993 18:1913
    Anyone interested in cookies should check out this months Consumer
    Reports.
    
    In addition to rating commercially available chocolate chip cookies,
    they also talked about some of the results of variations on the
    traditional Toll House cookies.  (like using butter vs marg vs
    shortening, halving the fat, halving the eggs etc.)
    
    I didn't read it carefully, not being a cookie person, but I vaguely
    remember that margarine made cookies thinner, crispier and greasier
    than butter.  Don't quote me on that.
    
    D!
2141.9CX3PST::PWAKET::CBUTTERWORTHGive Me Wings...Wed Sep 29 1993 21:305
    I tend to use more flour than "mom" when making toll house cookies
    and mine don't flatten out as much as hers do.  I like mine thicker,
    she likes the really thin ones.  
    
    \C