[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference thebay::joyoflex

Title:The Joy of Lex
Notice:A Notes File even your grammar could love
Moderator:THEBAY::SYSTEM
Created:Fri Feb 28 1986
Last Modified:Mon Jun 02 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1192
Total number of notes:42769

292.0. "Former Deceased" by SWSNOD::RPGDOC (Dennis the Menace) Fri Dec 12 1986 12:33

    
    A Boston Globe columnist recently related an anecdote about Abraham
    Lincoln writing a check and giving it to someone who approached
    him on the street in Washington asking for some money.
    
    In the column, and in the anecdote, he was referred to as "former"
    President.  Now, in the anecdote, this is not possible because he
    was serving in office as President at the time.  John Wilkes Booth
    made it impossible for Lincoln to end his days in retirement as
    a "former President", but what about history.  Is it correct to
    refer to Lincoln or John F. Kennedy as "former Presidents"?
    
    I believe that Presidents who died while in office can be referred
    to as "past Presidents", but not as "former Presidents".
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
292.1I think they keep the title.APTECH::RSTONEFri Dec 12 1986 14:289
    It is my impression that the title of "President" [of the United
    States] is akin to military rank and degrees of education.  Once earned,
    they are not normally taken away.  I believe we still have a President
    Ford and a President Carter just as we have retired Generals, Colonels,
    and Doctors.  (Nixon may have given up his title by resignation,
    but that may be debatable.)
    
    I will stand corrected if someone claims better knowledge of political
    protocol.
292.2Then-President LincolnSUPER::KENAHO frabjous day! Callooh! Callay!!Fri Dec 12 1986 18:2110
    They do keep the title, but based on the context of the article,
    Lincoln was President -- at the time of the incident. (And as mentioned
    in the base note, Lincoln never made it to former; he went directly
    from "Mr. President" to "the late Mr. Lincoln.") 
    
    I personally think the article should have read "...then-President
    Lincoln," meaning "President at that time."
    
					andrew
    
292.3INK::KALLISSupport Hallowe'enFri Dec 12 1986 18:3518
    Well, someone who once was a governor of a state (in the United
    States) or was a (U.S.) ambassador retains the title _as a form
    of address_.  Thus, private-citizen Nelson Rockefeller or Avirell
    Harriman were routinely addressed as "Governor, and Mr. Ambassador,
    respectively [though both had been both]," when past office.
    Occasionally, Henry Kissinger in an interview is addressed either
    as "ambassador" or "Mr. Secretary." 
    
    By usage, I suppose when referring to, say, James Earl Carter, one
    ought say "Former President Carter," unless you're speaking of actions
    he did when _in_ office (when "President Carter" would be appropriate);
    when meeting and addressing him, "Mr. President" would be correct.
    Neither Lincoln nor Kennedy is currently President, so the form
    would be incorrect (unless you were contacting them through a seance).
    
    Steve kallis, Jr.
    
    
292.4Not too lateSSDEVO::GOLDSTEINFri Dec 12 1986 22:085
    In recent rebroadcast of a Boston Pops concert, the announcer said
    "The orchestra is conducted by the late Author Fiedler."  Must have
    been a special for Halloween.
    
    Bernie
292.5He didn't write muchSSDEVO::GOLDSTEINFri Dec 12 1986 22:206
    re: .4
    
    Make that the late Arthur Fielder.
    
    Bernie
    
292.6Nit, nit, nit..LYMPH::LAMBERTI've got everything I need (almost)Mon Dec 15 1986 14:275
re: .5

Make that Arthur Fiedler.  (He didn't do much ball playing, either :-)

-- Sam
292.7"I can call the spirits from the vasty deep. ..."INK::KALLISSupport Hallowe'enMon Dec 15 1986 15:0712
    Re .4:
    
    On things musical, there was a live concert some years ago, being
    broadcast, where the announcer said,"This is [composer's work],
    _opus posthumous_."   He added, "`_Opus posthumous_' means he composed
    it after he was dead."
    
    Actually, it meanms it was first published after he was dead, but
    the announcer's explanation has a lot more charm.
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
    
292.8three B composers: Beethoven,Brahms, and BlochRAYNAL::OSMANand silos to fill before I feep, and silos to fill before I feepMon Dec 15 1986 17:2810
You know what Arthur Fiedler is doing now ?  No, what.  Decomposing!
(adding to the stupidity is the fact that he wasn't a composer)

You know what Arthur Fiedler'd (how's that for a contraction) be doing
if he were alive right now ?  No, what.  Clawing at the walls of his
coffin.

Sorry.  My conduct is abominable.

/Eric
292.9A # noteTOPDOC::SLOANETue Dec 16 1986 12:295
    That's enough fieldling around - some of these comments are in right
    field. But some of you have field for this sort of thing.
    
    -bs
    
292.10GETTING BACK To the subject...DRAGON::MCVAYPete McVay, VRO (Telecomm)Sat Jan 03 1987 00:207
    In "Strictly Speaking", Edwin Neumann deplored the use of the word
    "former" in referring to past members of an administration.  He
    said it sounded as though they had been nominated to that post.
    
    "Mr. Smith, I now appoint you a former ambassador to Sweden."
    
    "Thank you, Mr. President."
292.11Once a veteran, always ...HEADS::OSBORNSally's VAXNotes Vanity PlateTue Jan 06 1987 14:115
Sam Hall, recently and allegedly detained against his will -- you 
certainly more than enough about that incident.

However, he was identified as an EX MARINE VETERAN in a broadcast 
from National Public Radio.
292.12connotationsREGENT::MERRILLIf you've got it, font it.Tue Jan 06 1987 17:0110
    It is derogatory to call someone an "ex-marine" as this implies
    that they received a dishonorable discharge.  
    
    It is complimentary to call someone a "former marine" as that denotes
    an honorable discharge.  This is a convention that is used within
    all of the military and foreign service (diplomatic corps).
    
    	Rick
    	Merrill
    
292.13depends...31778::LAMBERTI've got everything I need (almost)Tue Jan 06 1987 17:405
.12>    It is complimentary to call someone a "former marine" ...

Probably depends on who you ask... :-) :-) :-)

-- Sam
292.14Once and Future ...INK::KALLISSupport Hallowe'enTue Jan 06 1987 17:499
    Re .11:
    
    Not necessarily.  Maybe he reenlisted. :-)  [that would make him
    a "former veteran"].  
    
    Re ,13:  whom.
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.