[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference thebay::joyoflex

Title:The Joy of Lex
Notice:A Notes File even your grammar could love
Moderator:THEBAY::SYSTEM
Created:Fri Feb 28 1986
Last Modified:Mon Jun 02 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1192
Total number of notes:42769

395.0. "Not what you say, but how you say it!" by CHUCKM::MURRAY (Chuck Murray) Wed Aug 12 1987 22:39

    From the July 1987 "Translation News" (DEC-internal publication):
    
    "It's not only languages different from our own that can baffle
    us. The way in which our familiar, native tongue is spoken in
    different countries can also cause difficulties. I read in an
    Australian newspaper that a U.K. national visiting that country
    thought that she had been sent home 'to die' when the nurse at
    a Melbourne hospital told her she could go home 'today'. 
    
    "The newspaper quotes a health authority spokesman as saying that
    the misunderstanding underlined the need for improved interpreting
    services in Queensland hospitals... "

    ----------------------------------------------------
    Any other examples (actual or hypothetical) of national pronunciation
    differences causing comic misunderstandings?   [This poor patient
    no doubt thought she was going literally down under Down Under.]
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
395.1A man could come to a sticky end!!!IOSG::DUTTNigel DuttThu Aug 13 1987 11:295
    Not quite what you were after, but......
    
    The name of the best selling brand of condoms in Britain is the
    same as that of the best selling sticky tape in Australia. The
    possibilities for confusion are endless. 
395.2Snip snip, and Bob's your auntie!IOSG::ROBERTSRThu Aug 13 1987 17:2017
    
    Up in Yorkshire we have an expression, "Seen to" (as in "...being
    seen to", "get seen to...") which has unfortunate conotations for
    folks at the bottom of Britain....
    
    In Yorkshire it means; a) being beaten up    
    
                       or, b) having your manhood cut off and put in
                              a plastic bag by a vet....
    
    But,.... down south, people have said that they're going to the
    doctor to get "seen to".  Now this may just be a fetish peculiar
    to southern GPs, or a new form of cure-all alternative medicine,
    but I'm going to steer clear of it, if ya don't mind.....
    
    Richard...
    	
395.3PASTIS::MONAHANI am not a free number, I am a telephone boxFri Aug 14 1987 04:2516
    	When they first introduced unattended railway crossings in England,
    they had flashing lights to indicate that a train was approaching,
    and a sign that said "WAIT WHILE LIGHTS FLASH".
    
    	Unfortunately, in Notinghamshire dialect, "while" means what
    "until" means in most other places. So drivers would approach the
    crossing, notice that the lights were not flashing, and settle down
    to wait. Then, when the lights started to flash ......
    
    	The wording on the signs was changed.
    
    	Ah!  .1 brings back memories of the Ealing office, and Big Anne,
    the Australian secretary, who would shout across the office "Can
    you throw us the Durex". About the same sort of effect as asking
    for a rubber, or offering to knock someone up (give them a morning
    call) in the U.S..
395.4...COMICS::KEYCalling International Rescue...Tue Sep 01 1987 12:516
    I just spent a weekend in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, where one of the
    better-known beers is one from McEwan's, called "Scotch". An
    acquaintance there, when he first moved up from the South, asked for 
    "a scotch and soda" and got a pint of bitter topped up with water...
    
    Andy
395.5Slow boat to ChinaTHE780::MEARNSTue Sep 29 1987 19:287
    
    There was a story last year about a man who was on his way to Oakland
    (Ca.).  His plane stopped in Los Angeles.  He stayed aboard.  The
    plane departed.  After several hours of what should have been an
    hour's flight, the man asked why it was taking so long to get to
    Oakland.  He was informed that Auckland was still many hours ahead.
    
395.6don't leave us in such pains !VIDEO::OSMANtype video::user$7:[osman]eric.sixWed Sep 30 1987 16:024
So then what happened ?  How did he react ?  What did he do when he
got there ?

/Eric
395.7You have to be thereGLIVET::RECKARDWed Sep 30 1987 16:121
    Re .5  Did the airline serve beef Wellington?  Or kiwi fruit?
395.8You want what????ODIHAM::HILLNick Hill - UK Corp. ActtsTue May 10 1988 18:2720
    Re .3 with its references to rubbers and getting knocked up...
    
    Whilst working for another company here in the UK, a colleague decided
    to relocate to the US, so we undertook a crash course on what not to
    say after crossing the 'pond'.
    
    The most memorable phrases he had to abandon were:
    
    "May I bum a ...?" meaning "Will you give me a ...?"

    Hence:
    
    "May I bum a fag?" meaning "Will you give me a cigarette"

    "Lend me a rubber" meaning "Lend me an eraser"

    It highlighted the 'Two nations separated by a single language'    
    
Nick    
    
395.9"bum" is in use in the USPSTJTT::TABERReach out and whack someoneTue May 10 1988 22:2114
    
>    "May I bum a ...?" meaning "Will you give me a ...?"

This is common use in the US as well.  Usually the phrase introduces a 
request for a cigarette or a ride.  Although for proper blending, he 
should ask "Can I...?"  "May" is correct, but hardly used.

>    "May I bum a fag?" 

Even though "bum" as in "borrow" is in use here, it might still be 
trouble to use that particular phrase, unless you were in San Francisco, 
and someone had lent you a rubber. :-)

					>>>==>PStJTT
395.10AKOV11::BOYAJIANMonsters from the IdWed May 11 1988 12:3217
    PStJTT beat me to it, but I'll elaborate pedantically.
    
    I just checked, and "bum" (as a transitive verb) is in the
    American Heritage Dictionary, defined as "To acquire by begging
    or sponging." It is, not surprisingly, derived from the noun
    "bum" (tramp, hobo).
    
    The etymology: "From earlier *bummer*, a loafer, probably from
    German *bummler*, from *bummeln*, to loaf."
    
    So, the word has a reasonably respectable history.
    
    --- jerry
    
    (I also agree with PStJTT -- how *do* you pronounce that,
    Patrick? :-) -- that it should be "Can I bum..." rather than
    "May I bum..." "May" is just too polite. :-))
395.11of coursePSTJTT::TABERReach out and whack someoneWed May 11 1988 19:467
    
>    (I also agree with PStJTT -- how *do* you pronounce that,
>    Patrick? :-) 

It's pronounced just the way it's spelt.  ;-)

					>>>==>PStJTT
395.12just try thisVIA::RANDALLI feel a novel coming onWed May 11 1988 20:304
    Probably just about like the sound I made when I read JP's
    joke about hominy you get when you order grits.
    
    --bonnie
395.13NEARLY::GOODENOUGHJeff Goodenough, IPG Reading UKWed May 11 1988 22:234
    It's OK for you people making these clever puns; I just had to
    look up hominy in *my* dictionary.
    
    Jeff.  :-) :-) :-) :-)
395.14How grainy are grits?GRNDAD::STONERoyThu May 12 1988 01:521
    Personally, I think these hominy lines are getting pretty corny!  :^ }
395.15just a suggestionVIA::RANDALLI feel a novel coming onThu May 12 1988 02:304
    Maybe the hominy would be better if we had more sopranos and fewer
    basses?
    
    --bonnie
395.16AKOV11::BOYAJIANMonsters from the IdThu May 12 1988 13:533
    And just what is the basses for that suggestion, Bonnie?
    
    --- jerry
395.17Just to be contralto!DSSDEV::STONERoyThu May 12 1988 19:101
    I'm not sure I like the tenor of that last question!
395.18aauuggghhh!TWEED::B_REINKEwhere the sidewalk endsThu May 12 1988 19:121
    
395.19sounds like somebody stepped on the soprano's toe!VIA::RANDALLI feel a novel coming onThu May 12 1988 19:201
    
395.20ME::TRUMPLERI juggle tectonic platesFri May 13 1988 00:432
    How sharp of you to take note of that, Bonnie.  Hopefully her
    toe isn't too flat...
395.21GNUVAX::BOBBITTshowtime, Synergy...Fri May 13 1988 02:421
    C here now!  You're all more treble than you're worth....
395.22not quite dead yetDECSIM::HEILMANIs that a Sears poncho?Fri May 13 1988 03:201
    My philosophy is "Just B natural"
395.23AKOV11::BOYAJIANMonsters from the IdFri May 13 1988 13:264
    That certainly sounds like the key to happiness. It strikes a
    familiar chord, anyways.
    
    --- jerry
395.24Perhaps a change of staff?CURIUS::CIUFFINIIf my Personal Name were a song, it Fri May 13 1988 18:123
    
    Certainly nothing to fret about. 
    jc
395.25Just stringing you alongAYOV27::ISMITHSee those shores! What shores?Fri May 13 1988 18:364
    This play on words is causing some heated exchanges. Soon there
    may be violins...
    
    Ian.
395.26DOOZER::SOBOTFri May 13 1988 19:437
    re .25
    
    ...what, a fret of violins ?!
    
    You ought to watch it, otherwise you'll get some beats in the bar !
    
    Cheers,								Steve
395.27... Note Bene ...CURIUS::CIUFFINIIf my Personal Name were a song, it Fri May 13 1988 20:525
    
    I suppose that we should expect this kind of word play in a
    
    notes file. :-)
    jc
395.28X-ratedDECSIM::HEILMANIs that a Sears poncho?Sat May 14 1988 03:054
    RE: .25
    
    Yes its disgusting, these notes files today, filled with sax and
    violins...
395.29the buck stops here?ZFC::DERAMOI am, therefore I'll think.Sat May 14 1988 03:245
     Each of the last few replies seems to have a pun in it.
     Generous of me to call some of them puns, ne c'est pas?,
     but otherwise you might think that I had missed the really
     dumb ones.  I couldn't allow that to happen.  But now, I
     fear, this string of silly musical references must end.
395.30AKOV11::BOYAJIANMonsters from the IdSat May 14 1988 11:557
    re:.29
    
    Now, there's no need to take such an extreme measure. Just
    be patient, since this flow of puns stanza good chance of
    running out of steam on its own.
    
    --- jerry
395.31changing the key of your argumentVIA::RANDALLI feel a novel coming onMon May 16 1988 18:559
    re: .29
    
    I regret to inform you that the Buck is a stringed instrument
    popular in late medieval and early Renaissance England.  Some
    of the songs in Shakespeare's plays, particularly Ariel's song
    in _A Midsummer Night's Dream_ are believed to have been composed
    for the buck.
    
    --bonnie 
395.32Don't bar meMDVAX3::BROCKUSAnti-acronymical--They call me AAMon May 16 1988 19:435
    re:.29, .30
    
	I quaver (and semi-quaver) at the thought of disobeying this
	double-stop, but I believe we must make a concerted effort to
	continue punning.
395.33Nota Bene GoodmanAYOV27::ISMITHSee those shores! What shores?Mon May 16 1988 20:355
    Although this note may be lowering the tone of the conference, I
    feel I must join in the chorus of support. The key is not to be
    too bass, or you may well treble your chances of being excluded.
    
    Ian.
395.34 :-) DOOZER::SOBOTMon May 16 1988 21:286
    
    The authors of these appaling puns have my symphony.
    
    Personally, I feel it's all a load of Bolero's !
    
    Cheers,								Steve
395.35he said EroicallyWELSWS::MANNIONA' for the girdin' o' it!Thu May 19 1988 17:363
    I don't want to b flat about this, but it's all very cornet.
    
    E7
395.36Back to the 'Can'ODIHAM::HILLNick Hill - UK Corp. ActtsThu May 19 1988 17:4422
    Re .9 and .10
    
    Sorry to spoil the flow of puns but...
    
    $SET CONTEXT
    In the UK:
    
    "Can I...?" asks of an ability, whereas "May I...?" asks for
    permission or agreement, hence the exchanges between parents and
    children like:
    
    Child - "Dad, can I write on my bedroom wall?"
    Father - "Yes."
    Child starts writing,
    Father - "What the h**l are you doing that for, I didn't say you
    _may_ write on the wall."
    
    So in the UK there is a difference in meaning between "Can I" and
    "May I", rather than a difference in politeness.
    
    Nick - UK pedant
    
395.37BONG!!NEARLY::GOODENOUGHJeff Goodenough, IPG Reading UKThu May 19 1988 18:4011
    Re: .31: Bonnie, I'm amazed no-one picked you up on this, especially
    in such an erudite notes file as this one.  Ariel, apart from being
    a detergent powder, is a character in "The Tempest", not "A Midsummer
    Night's Dream".  Maybe you were thinking of Puck?  Puck's buck ...
    Hmmm.  :-)
    
    Re: .36 Although I also live in the UK, if my son said "Can I write
    on the bedroom wall?" I think I would say "No."  My son is not
    particularly pedantic.
    
    Jeff.
395.38all-inclusive responseMARKER::KALLISDon't confuse `want' and `need.'Thu May 19 1988 20:0610
    Re .36 (Nick), .37 (Jeff):
    
    >... Although I also live in the UK, if my son said "Can I write
    >on the bedroom wall?" I think I would say "No."
     
    Although I don't live in the U.K., if a child of mine asked that
    question, I believbe I'd say, "Don't even think of doing it!"
    That covers both contingencies.
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
395.39take the first letter of each line ...SETF::DERAMOI am, therefore I'll think.Thu May 19 1988 22:344
     We finally seem to be out of musical pun mode.  Good.
     Now I can admit that I did sneak one into .29 myself!
     
     Dan
395.40ME::TRUMPLERI juggle tectonic platesThu May 19 1988 22:405
    Re .39:
    Actually, the musical noters were resting.  They will soon return with
    a chorus of punishment.
    
    >M
395.41Play onRAVEN1::MKENNEDYThu May 19 1988 23:194
OK, you guys, pull out all the stops.  I'm getting the twang of this.

Moffatt
Greenville, SC
395.42It's the same here only differentPSTJTT::TABERTouch-sensitive software engineeringThu May 19 1988 23:389
re: .36

We have precisely the same distinction between "may I" and "can I" in 
the US, it's just honored more in the breech than in the observance. If 
you ask "Can I" you blend.  If you ask "May I" large people will 
probably beat you up and take your money.  Occasonally, someone WILL 
haul out the old "You can, but you may not." in which case you just beat 
him up and take his wallet.
					>>>==>PStJTT
395.43pedant or parentODIHAM::HILLNick Hill - UK Corp. ActtsFri May 20 1988 15:386
    Re .37
    
    I didn't aim to have pedantic children - they just came out that
    way!!!
    
    Nick
395.441. Clever! 2. Gotcha!NEARLY::GOODENOUGHJeff Goodenough, IPG Reading UKFri May 20 1988 16:3012
    Re: .39  Dunno how you can FACE admitting that.
    
    Re: .42
    
    > We have precisely the same distinction between "may I" and "can I" in 
    > the US, it's just honored more in the breech than in the observance.
    
    You mean, like, if he asks "Can I write on the wall?", you point
    a gun at him?
    
    Jeff. :-)

395.45I can't remember if I shot five graffitists or six...feel lucky?PSTJTT::TABERTouch-sensitive software engineeringFri May 20 1988 22:286
>    You mean, like, if he asks "Can I write on the wall?", you point
>    a gun at him?

It cuts past the grammar and gives an unambiguous answer...

					>>>==>PStJTT
395.46solutionMARKER::KALLISDon't confuse `want' and `need.'Sat May 21 1988 00:115
    Re .45 (PStJTT):
    
    And the kid, in a panic, yells, "Grammar!"
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
395.47but I guess they are allowed to be pedanticZFC::DERAMOI am, therefore I'll think.Sat May 21 1988 03:3810
     Most of the teachers who tried to teach us the difference
     between "Can I ...?" and "May I ...?" answered
     
                       Can I ... ?
     
     with
     
                       I don't know, can you?
     
     Dan
395.48How do you spell seppuku?TLE::RANDALLI feel a novel coming onWed May 25 1988 19:185
    Ariel changed plays while I wasn't watching?  My God, how
    embarassing. That should teach me not to be pedantic when I'm
    working late preparing a call interface manual for production.
    
    --bonnie, blushing