[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference thebay::joyoflex

Title:The Joy of Lex
Notice:A Notes File even your grammar could love
Moderator:THEBAY::SYSTEM
Created:Fri Feb 28 1986
Last Modified:Mon Jun 02 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1192
Total number of notes:42769

372.0. "Can You Say, 'Water'?" by CHARON::MCGLINCHEY (Nolite id cogere) Wed Jun 24 1987 22:17

    I have noticed that the pronunciation of certain words can be
    an indicator of a person's geographic origins. Pygmalion did, too,
    and was able to discern an accent to a resolution of a few city
    blocks within London. 
    
    One word that gives it away is:
    
    			WATER
    
    This word has a different pronunciation in many major East Coast
    cities:
    		Boston:		WAWH-duh
    		Philadelphia (my home town): WOOD-duh
    		Baltimore:	WAAH-der
    		Burlington, VT:	Wah-deh (hardly any syllable accent)
    
    Are you noters aware of any other geographical giveaway words,
    or other identifiable pronunciations of 'water'?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
372.1wawa is for washing cahsSPMFG1::CHARBONNDThu Jun 25 1987 10:381
    Real men pronounce it "budweiser"   :-)
372.2people study this for a livingDEBIT::RANDALLI'm no ladyThu Jun 25 1987 12:0510
    If you're particularly fascinated by these gory details, you can go
    back to school and get a PhD and lots (:)) of grant money to study the
    way people say wawa and why people from the western part of the country
    pronounce the "h" in "which" while people from the east say "witch" (so
    they can't tell which witch you're talking about....)
    
    I've always thought one of the nicer things about notes is that
    my VT131 doesn't type with a Western accent!
    
    --bonnie 
372.3TH101PSTJTT::TABERReliefe is just a NEXT UNSEEN awayThu Jun 25 1987 13:0527
>    					...Pygmalion did, too,
>    and was able to discern an accent to a resolution of a few city
>    blocks within London. 
    
I believe that when Pygmalion was around, there WASN'T a London.  You 
must mean Prof. Henry Higgins. (Since both characters are fictional, I 
suppose you could argue it either way...)

Pygmalion (as best I can recall it) was a sculptor in classical Rome who
made a statue of a woman so beautiful he fell in love with it.  Venus
felt the love was so strong, she granted the statue life.  (We can count 
ourselves fortunate that this doesn't really happen...imagine what 
Picasso would have had strolling around on his arm.)

Anyway, now comes our dispeptic playwright G.B.Shaw and writes a play
based on a linguistics professor "creating" someone beautiful, and uses 
the title to link it bacck to the classical story.  But Shaw stoutly 
maintains for the rest of his life that Henry NEVER loved Eliza, and the 
public was a bunch of sodden-eyed happy-ending seekers for wanting them 
to get together in the end.  Well, he chose the title...   I think it 
was just more of the devilment that he loved, and he chose it because he 
knew people would draw the conclusions they did and he could pretend it 
was never in his mind that they would.

Theatre history lesson over.
					Ta,
					>>>==>PStJTT
372.4New York Coffee.APTECH::RSTONERoyThu Jun 25 1987 13:366
    CAW-fee is a dead giveaway for someone from the New York City/Northern
    New Jersey area.
    
    _Out_ and _about_ give away most Canadians.  My best phonetic spelling
    would put them as:   OWoot and a-BOWoot, with the OWoot sounded
    as a single quick syllable.
372.5Of course, I don't have an accentPSTJTT::TABERReliefe is just a NEXT UNSEEN awayThu Jun 25 1987 14:039
Re: .4

A friend of mine gets infinite enjoyment out of having me say "There's a 
mouse in the house, get out, get out." because I picked up a Maritime accent
from my mother, and the "ou" dipthong comes out "aoot." (Sort of.  
There's no really good way to spell out the sound.)  The interesting 
thing to me is that people from the coastal area of Virginia have the 
same sound.
					>>>==>PStJTT
372.6WELSWS::MANNIONThu Jun 25 1987 14:344
    If only there were ASCII values for the characters of the IPA.
    
    Phillip
    
372.7many versionsDEBIT::RANDALLI'm no ladyThu Jun 25 1987 14:376
    re: the account of the Pygmalion story -- 
    
    Not all classical versions of this story end happily; in many tellings,
    the unfortunate sculptor is punished for his lust. 
    
    --bonnie
372.8oops.CHARON::MCGLINCHEYNolite id cogereThu Jun 25 1987 15:305
    
    You're right. It should be Prof. Higgins.
    
    jim
    
372.9Statue darling?IOSG::DUTTThu Jun 25 1987 17:143
    ....then there was the guy who brought the Venus de Milo to life
    - but they just had an 'armless relationship!
     
372.10Calling G. B. ShawERASER::KALLISHallowe'en should be legal holidayThu Jun 25 1987 19:076
    Re last few:
    
    I can see the mistake with Pygmalion.  That was the story used as
    a model for _My Fair Lady_, which contained Professor Harry Higgins.
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
372.11This also holds waddaSSDEVO::GOLDSTEINThu Jun 25 1987 22:4611
    The way one pronounces the three words "Mary," "marry," and "merry"
    is also significant.  If you (Americans only) pronounce them the
    same, you are from west of the Alleghenies.  If you pronounce each
    word differently, you're from east of the Alleghenies.  I've put
    this to the test many times over the years and it never fails. 
    It's interesting to see that sometimes westerners have a difficult
    time distinguishing the eastern pronounciations when they hear them.
    Once they do detect the differences, they often find them more amusing
    than interesting.
    
    Bernie
372.12ERIS::CALLASCO in the war between the sexesFri Jun 26 1987 17:2412
    Please define "from." 
    
    For example, my parents are from Kentucky, for some suitable value of
    "from" (my mother's people came to Kentucky with Boone, and her lineage
    contains both the Hatfields and the McCoys). I was born in San Luis
    Obispo, CA; moved to Syracuse, NY when I was 2; to the Gulf Coast of
    Mississippi at 5; to Daytona Beach FL at 8; to Huntsville AL at 11; to
    Greenville, SC at 14; to Columbia MD at 15; made several moves in
    Maryland; and moved to New Hampshire at 24. Where am I "from,"
    linguistically? 
    
    	Jon
372.13Where are you not from?SSDEVO::GOLDSTEINFri Jun 26 1987 22:453
    You are the linguistic equivalent of a medical curiosity.
    
    Bernie
372.14;-)ARMORY::CHARBONNDMon Jun 29 1987 15:111
    re .12Washington D.C. of course
372.15He sure has been around...APTECH::RSTONERoyMon Jun 29 1987 15:122
    Sounds like you are from the genus "Militarus brattus".  :^)
    
372.16More on water and what you do with itREGENT::EPSTEINBruce EpsteinTue Jun 30 1987 15:318
    "Wash" is another good test: which areas of the country
    (I know at least the Midwest [west of the original 13
    states :-)]) say "warsh"?
       
    Also in Ohio (pronounced ahia), the word for H2O was
    "warder".

    Bruce (I've lived in 4 states, all different)
372.17ERIS::CALLASCO in the war between the sexesWed Jul 01 1987 19:5514
    re .13:
    
    Thanks! You made me laugh.
    
    re .14:
    
    Actually, I *do* consider Washington to be "home."
    
    re .15:
    
    I'm really of the subgenus "Nasae brattus." This is in reality a
    misnomer, as we interbreed with both M. brattus and H. sapiens sapiens. 
    
    	Jon
372.18Wuhdrree cawfeeDELNI::GOLDSTEINAll Hail Marx and Lennon (Bros. & Sisters)Wed Jul 01 1987 21:058
    In the part of enjay that I come from, it's "WUHdrrr".  There's
    an arc tracing about 10 miles west of the GW Bridge that separates
    out the New Yawk speakers from the Jrrzeyans.  The R's flow west.
    
    This can be noted in MAWRistown, but not in Joyzee City, since the
    latter is in the R-less circle.  Oh yes, we drank a lot of CAWfee
    too.
        fred_from_Passaic
372.19In RIMAGOO::PFCWhat a concept!Thu Jul 02 1987 12:395
    Down in Southern Ro-Di-Land (Rhode Island) we always pronounced
    water as "war-ter".
    
    (Actually doesn't that violate the theory of conservation of R's.
     By the theory we should say "war-ta".)
372.20How do linguists stand it?TSG::KELLEHERNot me, but an incredible simulationWed Jul 08 1987 13:4668
    My friend, Sandra, is from Toronto, and we've had a heap of
    fun getting her to recite "I'm a Little Teapot" with that
    strange pronunciation of the "out" sound.  (It IS hard to
    describe in writing what a Canadian "ou" sounds like!  Try
    saying "out" a few times, each time with your mouth open a
    bit less than the last.  Sometime before you're just mumbling
    you'll have made the sound.)
    
    But ALL of our friends knew about that little linguistic fluke,
    so the fun we could get out of it was limited.  Came the day,
    however, just before Sandra and I were about to leave for a long
    weekend in Canada when she said the word "shone" (as in "the
    sun shone yesterday.")  I rhymed the word with "bone" and "cone"
    and "stone."  She rhymed it with "dawn" and "lawn" and "Sean Connery."
    
    "'Shone'," I said.
    
    "No, 'shawn'," sez she.
    
    "Say it again."
    
    "'Shawn.'"
    
    "No, it's 'shone.'"
    
    "It's 'shawn.'"
    
    Well, I just assumed she was in a bit of mental verb-lock,
    and that if we dropped it and came back to it an hour later, 
    her brain would have sounded it out again and we would both 
    be saying "shone."  This was at college in upstate NY, and 
    our friends had all left for the long weekend, so we had
    no one around the dorm to verify either pronunciation.  So
    we left for Canada.  We figured we'd ask some of her brother's
    friends when we got to his place.
    
    Her brother, Dave, was also in college, and that night he
    and his four crazed roommates were having a truly olympic
    beer bash in their house.  People everywhere.  Bottles 
    everywhere.  Cigarettes smoldering in pools of liquor.
    Loud music and lots of general ruckus.  Sandra and I step in,
    meet Dave and I'm quickly introduced to those of his friends
    still vertical.
    
    I'm thinking, "No, no, now is _not_ the time..." but before I
    can say anything, Sandra turns to one of the wilder roommates
    and says "How do YOU pronounce shawn, as in 'The sun shawn
    yesterday'?"  He looks bewildered, but says, "...yeah, shawn..."
    
    Sandra looks at me, a lovely kind of vindication in her eyes.
    
    Well, if it's not obvious, a beer bash is _not_ the best place
    to begin an eclectic discussion of linguistics.  Mainly because
    most of the participants will be having such fun laughing 
    at you for grouping "shone" with words like "bone" and "cone"
    and "stone."  And they did.  I had to keep deflecting the conversation 
    to other topics the rest of the evening as strangers stumbled 
    up and said things like, "HOW do you pronounce shawn???"  When
    it came time to leave Dave's place and head on to Toronto 
    I shook Dave's hand.  "Had a great time," I said.
    
    It was a long weekend.  We quizzed Sandra's mother and a few of
    her friends, and everyone was certain I had misplaced a brain
    lobe or two.  But eventually we got back to the States.  Then 
    I had my revenge...
    
    
    			Tom Kelleher
372.21You let it wash over youWELSWS::MANNIONThu Jul 09 1987 11:317
    Surely "shone" should rhyme with "on" and "gone", as in "The sun's
    gone and shone on me." 
    
    This doesn't happen often in Britain, but it does produce a multiple
    (oh, Jeez, no) rhyme.
    
    Phillip
372.22Shine on, Shine on, Hahvust Mooon...ASD::DIGRAZIAThu Jul 09 1987 14:2517
	Re .20:


	"But eventually we got back to the States.  Then 
	 I had my revenge..."
    
    
	No you didn't.  It's "shawn".


	Regards, Robert  (Stateside, or at least Mass/NH)


	PS  It's "war-tur", "war-tuh" if you're in a hurry.  I don't know
	    where these people come from who say "wadda".  Foreigners, no
	    doubt.
372.23Shone does rhyme with stone!APTECH::RSTONERoyThu Jul 09 1987 14:4923
    Re: .20, .21, .22
    
    I'll stick up for the pronunciation of "shone" as ryming with
    "stone" [that's me :^)].  All of my dictionaries show it as
    having a long "o" vowel sound.  I find no reference to it having
    a short "o" as in _Don Juan_.
    
    However....there are some arguments that are not really worth
    winning.  Sometimes it's better to consider, "When in Rome do as
    the Romans do."  Unless, of course, you know damn well your right
    and don't care what impression you give to others. 
    
    One good way to catch a Canadian (or particularly a Britisher) is
    to ask if they have a 4th of July in their country.  The answer
    will usually be negative.  So then you ask if their calendars jump
    from the 3rd to the 5th with nothing in between.

    Last year I was is Calgary, Alberta and made a joke about their
    cold winters...as they say about Maine, they have only two seasons;
    winter and the 4th of July.  The Canadian replied with a very
    huffy, "_We_ don't have a 4th of July in Canada!"  My reply to
    that really caught him off guard.  I'm sure he didn't appreciate
    it, but I thought he had it coming! 
372.24by the done's early lightWAGON::DONHAMBorn again! And again, and again...Thu Jul 09 1987 19:244
    
    My _Webster's Ninth_ shaws "shawn" as a legit pronunciation in Canada
    and Britain.
    
372.25A feast of unreason ...GENRAL::JHUGHESNOTE, learn, and inwardly digestThu Jul 09 1987 20:0516
    Re .23:
    
>   One good way to catch a Canadian (or particularly a Britisher) is
>   to ask if they have a 4th of July in their country.  The answer
>   will usually be negative.  
    
    ... not if the Canadian/Britisher is on the ball -- and has in all
    probability heard the question many times before. His/her response
    will be: "Oh yes -- but we call it by a different name than you do".

    At which point the innocent American falls into the trap and says: 
    "Oh really? What do you call it?"
    
    And the reply comes back:

    "Thanksgiving!" ....
372.26ASD::DIGRAZIAFri Jul 10 1987 01:336
	My Random House, 1966, shows only the long "o" pronunciation
	for "shone".  I don't recall finding any other mistakes in
	the dictionary.

	Regards, R.
372.2750 million can't be wrongWELSWS::MANNIONFri Jul 10 1987 11:264
    Short "o", definitely, throughout Britain, so Yankee dictionaries
    be damned.
    
    Phillip, Miguela, Bryan etc.
372.28I'll have to remember that.APTECH::RSTONERoyFri Jul 10 1987 15:027
    Re: .25, .27
    
    OK. I'll have to file that one in the same category as _zed_ for
    the letter 'Z', and the silent 'u' in _colour_, _labour_, etc.

    To each his own!  There's no point in making an issue over it.
    
372.29Essential issuesBAEDEV::RECKARDFri Jul 10 1987 16:2314
    Re: .28
    
>   OK. I'll have to file that one in the same category as _zed_ for
>   the letter 'Z', and the silent 'u' in _colour_, _labour_, etc.

>   To each his own!  There's no point in making an issue over it.

    I disagree, Roy.  There are many points in making issues over this
    kind of thing.  This is a distinguishing feature of this notes file.
    Some American-type person thought it enough of an issue to drop that
    first 'u'.  This person did it, I'm sure, to promote lexical discourse
    through the ages, not to make for more logical spelling or to save on
    keystrokes ... er ... penstrokes.
    Ain't it fun!
372.30In England, we pronounce it 'water' :-)IPG::GOODENOUGHJeff Goodenough, IPG Reading-UKMon Jul 27 1987 13:008
    Re: .19,.22  Interesting!  And I always thought 't' in the US was
    an orthographical anachronism, as I've only ever heard it pronounced
    'd' :-)
    
    Incidentally the London (Cockney) pronunciation would be waw'ah
    (the ' representing a glottal stop).
    
    Jeff.
372.31'O' dear!KAOFS::S_BROOKFri Jun 03 1988 21:5814
    re .28 - .29
    
    It definitely is one of those areas where we all chose to differ.
    As both Canadian and English, I too pronounce Shone with a short
    'o', like 'shawn'.  Whenever I see color, labor etc., I always want
    to pronounce the o as in "or" or "bore" rather than the softer "ur"
    sound as in "burr".
    
    Another interesting variation also on 'o's I've noticed is the actual
    pronunciation of a long 'o'.  In Canada and Britain, the long o
    is almost aspirated, whereas in some areas of the NE U.S. I've visited
    it has a much more forced and round sound.
    
    stuart
372.32COOKIE::DEVINEBob DevineFri Jun 24 1988 06:253
    Sometimes a 'R' gets inserted into "wa" words.
    
    How do you pronounce:  watch, wash, and Washington?