[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference rusure::math

Title:Mathematics at DEC
Moderator:RUSURE::EDP
Created:Mon Feb 03 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:2083
Total number of notes:14613

196.0. "HUXTABLE BRAINTEASE" by USMRW1::TOURIGNY () Fri Dec 28 1984 17:35

THREE MEN GO AWAY FOR A WEEKEND HUNTING TRIP. AS THEY ARE TRAVELING TO
THEIR DESTINATION, THEY STOPPED AT A HOTEL FOR THE NIGHT. THEY ASKED
FOR ONE ROOM. THE FRONT DESK CLERK SAID THAT THE ROOM COST $30 FOR
THE NIGHT. EACH OF THE MEN GAVE THE CLERK A TEN DOLLAR BILL.

WITH THE ROOM PAID FOR, THE FRONT DESK CLERK CALLED FOR THE BELLBOY.
THE CLERK SAID TO THE BELLBOY, "TAKE THESE THREE GENTLEMEN AND THEIR BAGS
UPSTAIRS TO THEIR ROOM".

THE FRONT DESK CLERK SUDDENLY REALIZED THAT HE OVERCHARGED THE THREE MEN
$5.00 FOR THE ROOM. HE CALLED THE BELLBOY OVER AND GAVE HIM FIVE ONE
DOLLAR BILLS AND TOLD HIM TO DELIVER THE MONEY TO THE THREE GENTLEMEN.

WHEN THE BELLBOY WAS IN THE ELEVATOR, HE REALIZED THAT THE THREE GENTLEMEN
NEGLECTED TO TIP HIM. WITH THIS THOUGHT, HE POCKETED $2.00 OF THE FIVE
ONE DOLLAR BILLS. WHEN HE ARRIVED AT THE GENTLEMEN'S ROOM, HE RETURNED
A ONE DOLLAR BILL TO EACH GENTLEMAN, EXPLAINING THAT THEY HAD BEEN
OVERCHARGED FOR THEIR ROOM.

EXPLAIN THIS:
   IF EACH GENTLEMAN PAID $9.00 EACH FOR THE ROOM (AFTER REIMBURSEMENT),
   AND THE BELLBOY POCKETED $2.00, WHAT HAPPENED TO THE EXTRA DOLLAR?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
196.1PIPA::JANZENFri Dec 28 1984 19:286
The burden of proof is on you to show that there is, indeed, an extra dollar.

The men paid the hotel $27, and the manager paid the bellhop (unwittingly)
$2.

Tom
196.2TURTLE::GILBERTSat Dec 29 1984 20:018
What extra dollar?  By the conservation of money (possible, as no governments
are involved in the problem), losses should equal gains:

	losses	   gains
	3 x $9	=  $25 + $2

The error was in adding the $2 to the $27; it should've been subtracted, to
give the inn keeper's gain.
196.3USMRW1::TOURIGNYWed Jan 02 1985 11:051
YOU HAVE THE EXACT THOUGHT PROCESS, WHICH IS THE ANSWER TO THIS PROBLEM.