[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::mennotes-v1

Title:Topics Pertaining to Men
Notice:Archived V1 - Current file is QUARK::MENNOTES
Moderator:QUARK::LIONEL
Created:Fri Nov 07 1986
Last Modified:Tue Jan 26 1993
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:867
Total number of notes:32923

624.0. "Expession of anger/sex under bad influence" by SRATGA::SCARBERRY_CI () Mon Jul 22 1991 17:55

    I posted a similar question to the one that follows in Wommennotes.
     But that question led me to this one.
    
    Women and sex vs. Men and sex; in respect to how each relate to
    the experience:  (First, beware! these are generalizations and do
    not pertain to all persons in similar circumstances or situations).
    (Second, as I am a heterosexual, I can not relate to homosexuals
    and I do not know how the following would represent homosexual
    relations).  (But, it would be interesting to hear any thoughts
    from the entire notes community)!!
    
    It seems, that when a woman has a poor self-image or upon bad
    experiences with men, being her father or past boyfriends in respect
    to how she was treated by them, prostitution becomes a way of life.
     Most prostitutes, remember this is a generalization, do come from
    fatherless or bad father homes.  And for men, bad experiences with
    mom leads to criminal life, i.e. killing.
    
    I wonder why for men, prostitution isn't the most popular way under
    similar circumstances. 
    Does sex for women imply so much more or is there more to sex for
    women than for men?    
                                             
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
624.1QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centMon Jul 22 1991 18:0615
You're asking why men don't turn to prostitution out of anger against
women?  I would have thought the answer obvious - the market for male
prostitutes is infinitesimal compared to that for females.  In a society
where almost any woman who wants sex can get it for free, or even have
a man "pay" her for it, how many women would seek out the services of
a gigolo?

These men who want to channel their anger in this fashion will sometimes
turn to violence, especially rape, as it is the easiest and "most socially 
acceptable" channel available to them.  

Now I understand that in the gay world, male prostitution is more common, but
I don't know if the motivation is often anything other than money.

				Steve
624.2SRATGA::SCARBERRY_CIMon Jul 22 1991 21:4326
    re.1
    
    This is true what you say.  The market is better for women prostitutes.
     What do you mean by "socially acceptable"?  I also comment on the
    motivation factor as it pertains to male prostitutes.  The motivation
    for the  woman prostitute is also money.  One has to really keep
    2 minds when selling sex and giving love.  They're entirely different.
     To be able to do this, I think at some point that person has become
    depressed.  Or if not, but to continue in the selling of sex, one
    may become dissillusioned or confused between dissassoiated sex
    and loving sex.  
    
    But anyway, as a theory: the woman has sex with a paying man.  Maybe
    she feels like she's getting even.  If a woman rapes a man, does
    he feel violated or lucky?  Whereas, if a man rapes, that woman
    would definitely feel violated, not lucky at all.!  So, she couldn't
    get back at men by raping them, but by making him pay very dearly
    instead.  She gets rich, easily, since sex has become so robotic
    and non-emotional.  But, if a man were to behave in this way, is
    it the same.  Or must he act his anger agressively?
                                                       
    These are all a collage of thoughts that welcome discussion.  It
    was while watching a documentary about serial killers;  they were
    all men, and for the most part, hated their mothers or did not have
    healthy relationships with women, that these questions came to my
    mind.
624.3Drop Psych. 101 and take Principles of EconomicsPENUTS::HNELSONHoyt 275-3407 C/RDB/SQL/X/MotifTue Jul 23 1991 10:525
    I think that female prostitution is typically just another instance of
    abuse by men. Maybe Dad sexually abused her, so she runs away from
    home. Getting off the bus, she's met by a pimp who gets her addicted to
    heroin and puts her on the street to earn her fix. No deep psychology
    required here: it's pure exploitation.
624.5QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centTue Jul 23 1991 14:2627
Re: .2

What I said was "more socially acceptable", in quotes.  By this I meant that
a large part of our society believes, deep inside, that sexual and physical
violence against women is acceptable, and that the women "deserve" it.  This
is fostered by the glamorous treatment given such behavior in art and
literature, as well as the "look the other way" tolerance in real life.
Though the "official" stance is that it is reprehensible, in reality many
men - and women - tend to excuse or explain it away.  It's all part of the
pattern of male power over women which has been with us for thousands of years.
And all you have to do is look at a newspaper, read a book or watch a movie
to see that it's still there.

Though I in no way claim to be an expert on this, I don't think most women
who turn to prostitution do it directly as an act of revenge against men.
Most likely, they were (and many still are) abused by men in their life,
and they have come to feel that their only value in life is as an object
of sexual fulfilment for men.  I think that the number who do so purely
for the money (little of which they get to keep), or because they enjoy
it, is very small indeed.

As for women raping men - physiology makes this near impossible.  It does
happen, and from what I have read, the men involved have felt just as
violated as women who are rsped.  But rape of men is so rare as to be of
no real consequence.

				Steve
624.6and the converse of course...ROYAL::NICHOLSit ain't easy being greenTue Jul 23 1991 14:466
    one might wonder
    
    "What happens to self-abusive women"
    
    One answer ...
    They seek out and find abusive men.
624.7SRATGA::SCARBERRY_CITue Jul 23 1991 14:461
    All of your comments are quite good.
624.8p.s.ROYAL::NICHOLSit ain't easy being greenTue Jul 23 1991 14:549
    one might wonder
    
    "What happens to self-abusive women"
    
    One answer ...
    They seek out and find abusive men.

    (and rear another generation of abusers/abusees)
624.9From a book I'm reading ....RDGENG::SJONESCommunication? Tell me about it!Wed Jul 24 1991 09:14121

	This is taken from "Woman Who Love Too Much" by Robin Norwood.

	Although not directly answering the base note, it covers some of
	the replies and may give an insight into the downward spiral.

	I hope it doesn't loose any emphasis by cutting bits and pieces out.
	If you want further details or expansion, I suggest you read the
	book as I'm all typed out ...... Perhaps that a new acronym ATO

	Steve
    
    
    
	From the Preface.

	Addiction is a frightening word. It conjures up images of heroin
	users jabbing needles into their arms and leading obviously self-
	destructive lives. We don't like the word and we don't want to 
	apply the concept to the way we relate to men. But many, many of
	us have been "man junkies" and, like any other addict, we need to 
	admit severity of our problem before we can begin to recover from
	it.

	If you have ever found yourself obsesed with a man, you may have
	suspected that the root of that obsession was not love but fear.
	We who love obsessively are full of fear - fear of being alone,
	fear of being unlovable and unworthy, fear of being ignored or
	abandoned or destroyed. We give our love in the deperate hope
	that the man with whom we're obsessed will take care of our fears. 
	Instead, the fears - and our obsessions - deepen until giving love
	to get it back becomes a driving force in our lives. And because our
	strategy doesn't work we try, we love even harder. We love too much.

	I first recognised the phenomenon of "loving too much" as a specific
	syndrome of thoughts, feelings and behaviours after several years of
	counselling alchohol and drug abusers. Having conducted hundreds of
	interviews with addicts and their families, I made a suprising 
	discovery. Sometimes the patients I interviewed grew up in troubled
	families, sometimes they did not; but their partners nearly always
	came from severely troubled families in which they had experienced
	greater than normal stress and pain. By struggling to cope with
	theiraddictive mates, the partners (known in the alcoholism treatment
	field as "co-alcoholics) were unconsciously recreating and reliving
	significant aspects of their childhood.

	It was nearly always from the wives and girlfiends of addictive men
	that I began to understand the nature of loving too much. Their
	personal histories revealed their need for both the superiorty and
	the suffering they experienced in their "saviour" role and helped
	me make sense of the depth of their addiction to a substance. It was
	clear that both partners in these couples were equally in need of
	help, indeed that both were literally dying of their addictions, he 
	from the effects of chemical abuse, she the effects of extreme stress.

	These co-alcoholic woman clarified for me the incredible power and 
	influence their childhood experiences had on their adult patterns
	of relating to men.


	From Chapter 1

	No one becomes such a woman, a woman who loves too much, by accident.
	To grow up a female in this society and in such a family can generate
	some predictable patterns. The following characteritics are typical of
	woman who love too much.

	1. Typically, you come from a dysfunctional home in which your 
	emotional needs were not met.

	2. Having received little real nurturing yourself, you try to fill 
	this unmet need vicariously by becoming a care-giver, espeecially
	to men who appear, in some way, needy.

	3. Because you were never able to change your parent(s) into the
	warm, loving cartakers(s) you longed for, you respond deeply to the
	familiar type of emotionlly unavailable man whom you can try to change,
	through your love.

	4. Terrified of abandonment, you will do anything to keep a relationship
	from dissoving.

	5. Almost nothing is too much trouble, takes too much time, or is too
	expensive if it will "help" the man you are involved with.

	6. Accustomed to lack of love in personal relationships, you are
	willing to wait, hope, and try harder to please.

	7. You are willing to take more than 50 percent of the responsibility,
	guilt, and blame in any relationship.

	8. Your self-esteem is critically low, and deep inside you do not
	believe you deserve to be happy. Rather, you believe you must earn the
	right to enjoy life.

	9. You have a desperate need to control your men and your relationships,
	having experienced little security in childhood. You mask your efforts
	to control people and situations as "being helpful".

	10. In a reltionship, you are much more in touch with your dream of how
	it could be than with the reality of your situation.

	11. You are addicted to men and emotional pain.

	12. You may be predisposed emotionally and often biochemically to 
	becoming addicted to drugs, alcohol, and/or certain foods, particularly
	sugary ones.

	13. By being drawn to people with problems that need fixing, or by
	being enmeshed in situations that are chaotic, uncertain, and 
	emotionally painful, you avoid focusing on your responsibilites to 
	yourself.

	14. You may have a tendancy towards episodes of depression, which you
	try to forestall through the excitement provided by an unstabble 
	relationship.

	15. You are not attracted to men who are kind, stable, reliable, and
	interested in you. You find such "nice" men boring.
    
624.10SOLVIT::KEITHReal men double clutchWed Jul 24 1991 11:277
    RE .9
    
    That is pretty close to what I have observed. I do think it starts with
    adolescence though. Girls find the 'rebel/hood/troublemaker' etc 
    'exciting'
    
    Steve
624.11Absotively PosilutelySONATA::SFESSLERTechnical EcstasyTue Aug 06 1991 17:505
    re:.10 (Steve)
    
    Yep.
    
    Shawn
624.12LONG LIVE SELF-ABUSE !HSOMAI::BUSTAMANTETue Aug 20 1991 19:092
    I would guess that self-abuse girls don't need men.
    Unless they are afraid of growing hair in the palm of their hands!