[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations

Title:What's all this fuss about "sax and violins"?
Notice:Please read all replies to note 1
Moderator:QUARK::LIONEL
Created:Thu Jan 21 1993
Last Modified:Fri May 09 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:133
Total number of notes:1901

80.0. "Relationship help" by QUARK::MODERATOR () Thu Oct 27 1994 14:39

    The following entry has been contributed by a member of our community
    who wishes to remain anonymous.  If you wish to contact the author by
    mail, please send your message to QUARK::MODERATOR, specifying the
    conference name and note number. Your message will be forwarded with
    your name attached  unless you request otherwise.

				Steve






    		Please give me your ideas about the following
    	relationship.  I've been dating someone for a couple of years
    	and I thought the relationship was growing slowly and steadily.
    	But for several months now there has been less and less 
    	relating.  
    
    		My friend and her ex divorced several years ago,  
    	a couple of years after his confession that he had been 
    	pursuing extracuricular activities and had probably been 
    	exposed to Aids.  Sadly this proved to be true.  He tested 
    	positive and she tested negative.  (She has continued to 
    	test negative now for 10 years.)
    
    		This spring,  he started to have serious problems and 
    	was really sick by the end of the summer.  He died several 
    	weeks ago.  The night he died,  she got a call from the hospital.
    	She drove to the hospital while I stayed with her kids who
    	were asleep.  She told them in the morning.  Then she asked
    	me to pick up one of her friends who needed a ride to be with
    	her.  After this,  she asked me to be certain to leave 
    	before her ex brother-in-law showed up.  She could see that
    	I was kind of hurt by this and explained that she didn't want
    	to have to explain who I was.  
    
    		She was devastated.  They had continued to 
    	share the caretaking of their two children and she
    	was overwhelmed by having to continue alone.  For years,  she 
    	had dreaded that people would find out about his disease and 
    	this became public shortly before his death.
    
    		But she also felt a great loss because she felt that
    	they had remained close friends,  that he needed and loved
    	her right up 'til the end.  And she was amazed by how much
    	grief she felt.  In explaining this to me,  she told me about
    	some of the kindnesses he did for her near the end inspite of 
    	his condition.  (While I think he did continue to give her 
    	cards and gifts for all the years after their divorce,  I
    	was troubled by some of what she told me.)  She told me about
    	his coming over to the house to bring her a birthday card
    	this summer and that it was the only card that she received
    	on her birthday.  This is kind of tragic picture full of 
    	pathos.
    		
    		But it is at least part fiction.  I tried to remind her 
    	that she had been out of state with me on her birthday.  I 
    	expected her to remember and say that he must have come to her
    	on a different day.  But, instead,  she responded with an angry
    	look, saying that I must have sent her a card ahead of her 
    	birthday. This discussion was in the context of her coming to
    	me to say that she needed to be apart from me and suggesting 
    	that we set the date for our next date in January.
    
    		I thought about this for a couple of days and phoned 
    	her.  I told her that this separation was no good for me, that
    	I needed to be with her.  She replied that she couldn't be
    	in a relationship with me right now.  I think she meant to 
    	be kind by telling me how much she had enjoyed the physical
    	part of our relationship.  But this just made me feel really
    	bad.  
    
    		I feel like I should just walk away,  do my crying,
    	and get on with my life because I think I only played a 
    	small role in hers.  But I'd rather believe that it ain't 
    	that bad and that things will work out in the future.  Sigh.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
80.1CRISTA::MAYNARDThe Front Row KidThu Oct 27 1994 15:232
    If you love something set it free...
    If it's meant to belong to you, it will come back...
80.2WRKSYS::MACKAY_EThu Oct 27 1994 15:3224
    
    re .0
    
    It sounds to me that:
    
    1. She needs some time to sort things out.
       She is confused about her own feelings
       and the entire situation.
    
    2. She does not seem to be mature, ie. not
       understanding human needs and relationships.
    
    3. You are really not part of her life, yet.
       You cannot be a part of her processing.
    
    4. But then, if you really care about her 
       what is a couple of months? Leaving her
       while she is in turmoil?!
    
    Eva
                                
    
     
       
80.3she needs to be by herselfMROA::MAHONEYThu Oct 27 1994 15:4017
    Obviously there were deep feelings in both of them, we are humans and
    tend to do lots of mistakes... I think he did a big "boobo" by getting
    stray and the sensible thing after that was to cut loose but that
    doesn't mean that feelings are not there... You filled a void she had,
    and when her ex was dying and called her, she went... now she needs
    time to mourn and time to heal...
    
    She needs time, that's all, and she should have it.  All you can do now
    is wait, time will tell if there is "real" love or just a need for
    companionship, a need to fill a void...  time will tell. Do you find
    yourself willing to wait?  maybe yes... maybe not... and in that case,
    she did the right thing and each one of you could go on with life.
    
    I "know" that after a close relative's death there must be a time to
    heal and accept the loss and it takes TIME to mend......
    
    Suerte
80.4Look Honestly...43GMC::KEITHDr. DeuceFri Oct 28 1994 11:0237
    Let us examine some things:
    
    1 You have been in a relationship with this woman for ~2 years.
    
    2 She is/was legally divorced from this person.
    
    3 >After this, she asked me to be certain to leave 
      >before her ex brother-in-law showed up.  
    
    4 >She could see that I was kind of hurt by this and explained that 
      >she didn't want to have to explain who I was.  
    
    
    I do not mean to be hurtful, but #3 & 4 say it all. After ~2 years she
    can't 'explain' you to her 'ex' brother-in-law? You are an
    embarrasment? You are chopped liver? What?
    
    This is hard, but apparently you do not mean a whole lot to her. She should
    be looking to you, among others, for support during these times if you
    were someone special in her life.
     
        >I feel like I should just walk away,  do my crying,
    	>and get on with my life because I think I only played a 
    	>small role in hers.  
    
    Based upon what I have said and what you feel, take approriate actions.
    
    
        >But I'd rather believe that it ain't bad and that things 
        >will work out in the future.  Sigh.
    
    All of us would rather feel this way. You invested your time and love
    in this woman. It is always painful to come up short in the end, 2nd
    best and 2nd place. You deserve better...
    
    Peace
    Steve
80.5ELESYS::JASNIEWSKIWhy not ask why?Fri Oct 28 1994 19:2644
    
    	Re anon -
    
    	Relationships can be complicated by one's grief and mourning the
    death of a loved one - or maybe it's the other way around - that one's
    grief and mourning the death of a loved one can be complicated by a
    relationship.
    
    	It sounds to me that that's what could be happening for your
    friend. You may see your presence in her life at this time as a benefit
    to her, (you certainly see it as beneficial to yourself) - though
    instead, it may very well be an effective *distractant* to what she
    needs to process emotionally. Hence, her request for...some
    considerable space.
    
    	Now, true love taken as the extension of one's self for the
    emotional and spiritual growth of another; are you willing to set aside
    your own needs to allow her to grow through what she needs to go
    through, as far as her emotional processing around her dead exhusband?
    (Remember - emotions are emotions, thoughts are thoughts - feelings dont
    have to make any sense at all...)
    
    	Actually, considering the magnitude of what her's are by your
    description "Devastated", 1/96 is a very reasonable time for your
    next date. This stuff can take years, and it's been years, BUT, I
    presume you've been with her through a lot of it. Perhaps she realizes
    down in her soul that she needs to walk those last few steps _alone_,
    without the emotional intimacy that a one-on-one M/F relationship
    usually provides. To put the pieces of her emotional self back together, 
    so to speak. Maybe she realizes she's just not all "there"...and it's
    hard to be in a relationship with a heart so fragmented. (It's kinda
    like a disk-drive - it starts thrashing all over the place until it
    wears itself out and finally crashes...)
    
    	Rather than just leave it in disgust and defeat, why not say "okay -
    take all the time you need - I will see you in January if you still want
    to". I know - easy to *say* - but - if you really like her, give it a
    shot, take the risk and hopefully she'll be waiting for you on the other
    side. In doing that you'll have raised your importance in her life to
    something greatly significant.
    
    	Hope this helps,
    
    	Joe
80.6QUARK::LIONELFree advice is worth every centFri Oct 28 1994 20:093
I think that date was supposed to be 1/95....

		Steve
80.7Walk in her shoes for those two months!MR4DEC::JONESSat Oct 29 1994 12:4355
    The other thing to consider in this situation is that you are
    probably feeling competition. In this case competition is not
    from another male, but another person...herself.  I think
    most of us here are saying that what she has not been without
    is people in her life for at least the last 2 years.  You
    have been there in some capacity and he was there in spirit
    if not in person at times...literally or figuratively..i.e. in
    her mind...as in the B'day thing.
    
    What it sounds like her heart is saying in a way her head can't
    explain..and probably rightly so, is,"Let me live the next several
    days and hours alone to figure out and heal from things I probably
    always knew I had to deal with, but now have no choice about."
    
    A couple of facts jump out at me:
    -The fact she had not adequately dealt...to her family..how and where
    to introduce/position you, suggests that was put off 'til
    some future time...that time is now. So he has to figure
    out whether there is a place for you or not...real dilemma
    -The fact that he would eventually lose the battle with AIDS did
    not remove the follow on fact that she would have to deal with
    the loss.  Some people project to the end state and are pretty
    much ready for it when it happens.  In her case it sounds like
    she put that off until now.
    -The fact that the rest of her life will be rebuilding from one
    brick to the next is just now hitting her.  Will you be one
    of those bricks?  Who knows..sounds like the real fact is that
    she is only now dealing with what the structure will be.  Then
    she will have time to decide on the building materials.
    
    So, consider all those challenges...yes many of them are self induced
    because of her procrastination in several areas.  That is neither
    bad or good as far as she is concerned...just another fact.
    In your case, you have none of those to deal with..only
    you desire for her to include you in her plans.  I think the
    first response of letting go of something and seeing if it
    comes back is good advice.  She needs time..lots of it.  Jan1st
    may actually be a little too fast given that she has two
    very significant holidays and the thought of a NEW YEAR without
    whatever realtionship arrangements she had at this time last
    year..to look forward to in the coming year...Ugg! what a challenge
    for anyone.
    
    Remember, you are not competing(or at least it doesn't sound like your
    are)with another guy here. You are competing with the rebuilding
    of a delicate thing...a person's life and future.  If the foundation
    isn't solid, the bricks above that will always be in jeapardy.
    
    Pray for her, love her from a distance, but undertand and accept..
    the result may not be what you want, but then she has to live
    with herself.
    
    my .02
    
    jim
80.8Thanks from basenoterQUARK::MODERATORMon Nov 07 1994 14:4277
Thanks from basenoter.


        Thanks for all your replies. You've given me much to think about
        at a time when I need help to get some perspective on this. In
        regard to your replies:

              -.1 &     I guess if time passes and she doesn't want to
              -.3       see me, then I'll have an answer. But if she's
                        been using me to fill some needs without really
                        caring for me, I feel that I owe it to myself
                        to stop that. I could be her friend but not her
                        lover.

              -.4       "She should be looking to you, among others, for
                        support..."

                        She has looked to her friends, family, God, and
                        casual acquaintances, but not to me. Seems like
                        she took a lot of support from me up until to his
                        death but then felt uncomfortable with me around
                        after that.

                        I "... do not mean a whole lot to her."

                        The day after she told me that she wanted to be
                        apart until January, she wrote me a letter. She
                        explained that she felt bad after talking with me
                        when she had expected to feel relieved. She said
                        that I'd been very nice to her and that she was
                        "praying for clarity" about what our relationship
                        is to her.

                        Before getting the letter, I called her up to
                        tell her that I was really unhappy about not
                        being able to see her, especially at Thanksgiving
                        and Christmas. She responded that apparently she
                        hadn't made her needs clear to me. I said with
                        some hurt that I'd heard a lot about her needs
                        but that I had my own.

              -.5       Your response made me think about what is going
                        on in her life.

                        "...are you willing to set aside your own needs
                        to allow her to grow through what she needs to
                        go through, as far as her emotional processing
                        around her dead exhusband?"

                        I want to feel that she will come to the other
                        side of her grief and be able to move on. But
                        early on in our relationship, she talked a lot
                        about him. She told me that she wondered if her
                        closeness to him had caused her two relationships
                        prior to ours to break up.

                        I remember her telling me with enthusiasm about a
                        counselor's suggestions about how she could set
                        up a regular schedule with her ex for childcare.
                        She seemed to think this was a great idea for
                        reducing her interactions with him. But she never
                        tried it. How can I know if she will ever go
                        through her "emotional processing around her
                        dead exhusband?" I don't know if she feels any
                        differently about that relationship than she did
                        ten years ago.

              I went and spoke with the minister of her church who knows
              her well and me somewhat. I told him of my confusion. He
              replied that she is rebuilding her life and that she's
              also very confused about everything. But he said that she
              has great faith which is a real strength. I like him but I
              think faith can either strenthen or weaken us depending on
              whether we use it to face reality or avoid it. Thanks again
              for all of your help.


80.9ELESYS::JASNIEWSKIWhy not ask why?Tue Nov 08 1994 13:5441
    
    	You're welcome.
    
    >              -.5       Your response made me think about what is going
    >                        on in her life.
    
    	In my experience I've found that matters - a lot - in
    relationships. Part of intimacy is the willingness to be accountable to
    what's happening with the other person, when it's appropriate. Whether
    you want to do that and/or whether it's appropriate is entirely a
    personal decision one makes for themselves. In the situation you
    described, you could simply decide "I dont want to do this" and move
    on. Or, having decided you want to, then ponder the appropriateness
    of your choice of action. Which then depends entirely on your feelings
    around your question:
    
    >                   How can I know if she will ever go
    >                   through her "emotional processing around her
    >                   dead exhusband?" I don't know if she feels any
    >                   differently about that relationship than she did
    >                   ten years ago.
    
    	If you're clear that someone simply isnt willing to process through
    their grief around a loss such as was described, IMHO it's "inappropriate"
    to extend yourself for their benefit. An analogy could be made to a
    drunk or addict unwilling to get help for themselves; going out of your
    way to their benefit will likely only enable them to stay in their
    problem.
    
    	However, if you know that there's some openmindedness and
    willingness around _doing something_ about her situation (you mentioned
    that she exhibited some enthusiasm about the results of a counseling
    session, also that her minister reported that she's "rebuilding her 
    life ") I'd say that the outlook is good for her to "go through it"
    and "feel differently" about it as a result of doing that. You can help
    her with this; perhaps indirectly - for now - if you so choose. It is
    a *choice*, based on how you feel about yourself, her and on what you 
    know to be true about her in this situation.
    
    	Joe