[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

855.0. "Can anyone Help?" by BOBBY::RANKIN () Thu Oct 05 1989 10:10

    For many weeks I've thought about putting this into the H_R file, but
had not done it because I keep hearing this inner voice say "keep your
family business private".  Well, keeping it private has NOT provided any
answers to the problem, Soooo.

    The story is long and hopefully you'll see it to the end.  

    Nearly four years ago I married a wonderful man who has 3 sons.  I too
had been previously married and have 3 daughters.  Amazingly, the ages of
the children are very close, which lead David and I to: 1. have hopes the kids
would blend without to much trouble and 2. that the 'boys' could at long
last experience a family unity thay had NEVER had in the past. I suppose,
we hoped to be able to say "and thay all lived happily ever after". 
Well, this for the most part is happening except for David Jr, the 'middle' son, 
who is now 16 years old and no longer lives at home.  

    Events that lead up to that cold, rainy night back in January of this 
    year when
he walked out are to numerous to detail so I'll just say that we 
labelled 'puberty' as a major contributing factor.  AND hoped time would help
to heal the gap between father and son.

    The months are now ticking by, David Jr. has not spoken with his father 
since he walked out of the house.  At least once a week we see the boy
at his grandmothers house, where he avoids both his father and I like the 
plague.  Not even speaking to us when spoken to.  The kids at
home have been subjected to phyical threats of violence from Jr.  
We've had bricks thrown through our kitchen window.  

    It's now quite obvious to David and myself that David Jr. has some very
deep seeded hate within him that perhaps has been growing ever since his mom
and dad divorced. (FYI, that happened when he was 2 and his
mother has not communicated with any of the boys in over 6 years)

   (Phew, I'm getting weary from trying to get this down correctly and
    will apologise now if what seems clear to me is totally confusing to 
    you)

   Although, I'm deeply concerned for the welfare of this young adult, my
first and formost concern is for my husband and the 'family' we are working
to hold together.  

   David replays the fatefull night over and over in his mind and always
comes to the same conclusion that the split was un-avoidable. But finds it
harder and harder to live with the thought that his son harbors 
such a hate within him that he may NEVER let the past, be the past.

    I'm sure this story repeats itself in many a home. How do you cope?
    Are there any ways I can ease the pain for my husband?  What can we
    do to help Jr.? 

Thanks for listening, Vivian

  
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
855.1WAHOO::LEVESQUEYou've crossed over the river...Thu Oct 05 1989 13:2530
    I don't think that there is any way to force Jr. to deal with his
    anger. He will eventually have to deal with or it will consume him, BUT
    he is probably to young to realize that. Not knowing what the cause of
    the resentment in Jr is, it is difficult to tell you exactly which way
    to turn. I guess the first order question is "Do you know exactly what
    the cause of the problem is?" A side question is whether Jr himself
    knows what the root cause is.
    
     If you aren't sure or think there may be more to the situation than
    meets the eye, you'll have to use other methods to fight the problem. I
    would think that it may be possible to get some information (if not
    downright communication) via the oldest son or perhaps other family
    member that Jr is comfortable with. Oftentimes the same words expressed
    by a person perceived to be a peer has a better impact than one coming
    from an authority figure. Anothe possible avenue if getting information
    from the grandparents.
    
     One thing to keep in mind is that despite the fact that Jr is a child,
    as a parent you (and your husband) only have limited control over them.
    As a teenager, Jr is finding out that your ability to control is
    limited by his ability to withstand the consequences of his
    disobediance. There was only so much you and he could have done-
    suffice it to say that if you did what you could, your ability to
    control the outcome met its limit there. In short, there was probably
    nothing else you could do. And while your husband may feel the guilt
    for the situation, he must make peace with himself and allow his son to
    heal his own wounds- or at least accept help in healing their mutual
    wounds.
    
     the Doctah
855.2Get prof. help.SALEM::MELANSONnut at workThu Oct 05 1989 18:0211
    Have you or your husband thought about professional help here?
    It could be if you were involved in couseling the counselor could
    get him to come.  It sound like there is some very deep rooted
    problems with anger that if not dealt with now could be a lot
    mor serious later.
    
    Contact a family counselor, it cant hurt..
    
    god bless and good luck.
    
    jim
855.3I'd be *very* carefulSKYLRK::OLSONPartner in the Almaden Train WreckThu Oct 05 1989 20:1519
    Jr isn't responding when spoken to, at grandmother's house? 
    Observation: rude.  Were I granny, I'd throw him out if he exhibited
    such rudeness in my house.
    
    Jr is threatening the other minor children of your family?
    Observation: unacceptable.
    
    Jr is harboring deep-seated hate, to the point where you suspect he is
    throwing bricks through your windows?
    
    Observations:  your family is under assault.  Whatever the cause,
    whatever the guilt, a 16-yr old hateful young man is capable of doing
    you real, permanent, lasting damage.  You may not be able to salvage
    a relationship with Jr, but you owe yourselves defense; don't let him
    hurt the rest of you.  Physically, mentally, emotionally, however: I
    think you should take care of your family first.  His needs are second
    to yours.
             
    DougO
855.4SNOC01::MYNOTTI'll have what she's havingThu Oct 05 1989 21:5241
    My oldest daughter has given me similar problems to jr.  Up until
    last weekend, I hadn't seen or spoken to her in two years.  She
    will be 21 in December.
    
    She not only threatened, but attacked her sister when I was away
    on business, and has attacked me on occasion.  After two suicide
    attempts, she still will not seek help, nor talk to anybody.  She
    has been like this since she was fourteen. 
                                              
    At first over the weekend, she avoided me, didn't talk to me, and
    not until the last day, would actually be in the same room as me.
    It hasn't worried me at all.  That may sound cold, but she has to
    make peace with herself.  I have.  She too, is living with my parents.
    As much as we would like to, we can't live their lives for them.
    Nor should we feel guilt.  
    
    My ex husband made no moves to see either of his daughters for seven
    years, then suddenly was back in their lives.  He hasn't made any
    contact with the youngest for the past eight years.  She has grown
    up reasonably normal for a teenager (now 19), is very well adjusted,
    intelligent, etc.  
    
    Again, this may sound cold, but just cut jr out of your lives for
    a while and get on with your own.  Unless he seeks help himself,
    there really isn't anything you can do.  I look at my problem as
    the oldest just hasn't learnt the lessons we all learn as we're
    growing, it may take her another five years before she sees the
    light.  There has been progress, but boy, its slow.  

    The youngest doesn't want to know about, or see her sister, she
    finds it real hard to forgive her.  
    
    As for your husband, the only way I grew, was to get on with my life,
    you don't forget, but you stop dwelling.  The longer you relive
    those feelings, the worse it gets.  You have a life too.
    
    I hope this helps.
    
    ...dale
     
855.5Tough LoveSSDEVO::CHAMPIONLetting Go: The Ultimate AdventureThu Oct 05 1989 23:4810
    I'll add my support to all the other replies.
    
    You might look into a group/philosophy called "Tough Love".
    
    Drastic action calls for drastic measures.
    
    Hang in there!
    
    Carol
    
855.6XANADU::DOUCETTEFri Oct 06 1989 13:1833
    Just a few thoughts...
    
    	I agree that David seems deeply upset about things.  And without
        talking to him, I guess it could be about anything.  But one
        possibility is that he is having difficulty in coping with the
        absence of his mother.  From other children that I have seen in
        similar situations, it doesn't matter how great a homelife is
        being provided, that loss still can hurt (even when the absent
        parent has absolutely nothing to offer), and some kids can
        cope while others cannot.
    
        Do you suppose, perhaps without even knowing it, David is trying
        to get the attention of his mother?  If this is a possibility,
        maybe he should have a chance to get together with her, even live
        with her.  He may find out that he's not missing what he thinks,
        and appreciate the family he has.  He may actually get along with
        her.  I've seen this happen to a friend of mine's son (also at 16).
    
        As far as his behavior, I feel very strongly that he has no right
        acting rude in his grandparent's home either.  I found with my son
        (also 16) that while he thought that his grandparent's and uncle would 
        harbor him from all the "injustices" of my discipline, he gave me a 
        hard time.  But, I soon let my parents and brother know that, under no
        circumstances would they undermine my attempts to discipline my
        son.  As soon as he knew that we all (parents, grandparents, and
        uncle) were united and had the same rules, he cut it out, but fast.  
        They all have been a help in supporting him, but now make it perfectly 
        clear to him that they also do not intend to condone poor behavior.
    
    Take care,
    Beth
        (interpretted - he must behave and treat the rest of the family
        with respect).
855.7Sounds familiar? Thanks!!BOBBY::RANKINFri Oct 06 1989 13:2331
    Thanks to ALL for your thoughts/comments.
    
    I thought I'd better clarify an assumption.
    
    Jr. does NOT live with his grandparents. David would not allow it.
    Probably more for his mom's sake then anyone elses.  Shes as soft as
    melted butter and easily manipulated by most people, so would
    have been putty in the hands of this 'street-wise' young man. David's
    father is not longer living and his mom would NOT be able to cope with
    the hassle of a live-in grandson.  Jr. visits her regularly and it's
    at these times we 'bump' into him.
    
    In reply to:
    
    .1  Involvement of #1 son would gain us no insight what-so-ever as 
    he is a non-communicator.  Jr. DOES put him up on a pedestal but #1
    has his own set of problems and for the most part does NOT involve us.
    
    .4  Cutting Jr. out of our lives is vertually what weve done. YES the
    remainder of the family have benefited from it.  The remaining boy
    (15 years old) no longer has to put up with the bully-boy tactics as
    before and has come out of HIS shell.  He accepts and occassionally
    rejects my love as do MOST teenagers with there 'mom'.  David and I 
    often think that Jr. may have desperately been looking for a mother's 
    love when I came upon the scene, but was unable to cope with my 'style' 
    of mothering.  I'm definately NOT a soft-touch.  (I can see the girls
    noding there heads now).  
    
    Once again, thanks for your input.  Any other thoughts will be welcome.
    
    Vivian 
855.8Just to add to the confusion!BOBBY::RANKINFri Oct 06 1989 13:4211
    
    In reply to:
    
    .6  Jr's mother lives in the same neighborhood as granny.  She has made
    it perfectly clear to the boys she wants NOTHING to do with them.  
    
    As I said in the base note, it REALLY is a long complicated story.  
    The boys have vertually had NO mother since the youngest was a year
    old! That is until I came along.
    
    Vivian
855.9DittoHENRYY::HASLAM_BACreativity UnlimitedMon Oct 09 1989 20:569
    I must agree with two previous noters who suggested counseling and
    Tough Love.  I've had to use both in the past with various children.
    In my case, one of the children turned out beautifully, and the
    others are living elsewhere.  Those of us who are left, have a happy,
    healthy life.  If you want to write me at SLOVAX::HASLAM, I'd be
    happy to talk with you further about this.
    
    Best Wishes for you and your family,
    Barb