[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

1133.0. "Contemplating a divorce" by QUARK::HR_MODERATOR () Wed Jan 23 1991 16:38

    The following topic has been contributed by a member of our community
    who wishes to remain anonymous.  If you wish to contact the author by
    mail, please send your message to QUARK::HR_MODERATOR, specifying the
    conference name and note number. Your message will be forwarded with
    your name attached  unless you request otherwise.

				Steve






    I guess I'm just looking for some answers or at least some suggestions
    and would like to keep this anonymous when going into the Human
    Relations Conference.......So here goes.......
    
    
    I have been contemplating a divorce for sometime now, perhaps a year or
    so. We have recently purchased a house in Sept have been married for 9
    1/2 yrs and have a beautiful daughter 5 1/2 years old. I moved out of
    Boston due to schools for my daughter So therefore the house was
    purchased. It's a house I'm putting a lot of work in too. Just a little
    background there
    
    Everytime I try and discuss this my wife its either tears, hysterics
    and she "ALWAYS" brings up our daughter, which is of course my  number
    one concern. We have nothing in common anymore do nothing together and
    continually fight. I want it to be as amicable as possible. I would
    never take the house from my daughter nor not pay support or see her as
    often as possible. 
    
    My question is how to stop feeling guilty, how to get her to talk about
    it calmly and come to a decision.And also how to explain things to my
    daughter and make her realize I still love her and it has nothing
    whatsoever to with her ...the breaking up !!!
    
    If this sounds confusing Im sorry as i too am in a twilight zone
    
    thanks for listening and feel free to respond
    
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1133.1Do *something*ELESYS::JASNIEWSKIThis time forever!Wed Jan 23 1991 19:0127
    
    	I think that doing *something* is important, especially if you
    trully care about your daughter's well being. Whether it's divorce
    or not, I cant say. What I can say is that there's nothing worse
    (from your daughter's perspective) than having to live with two
    people who basically cant stand each other and are miserable and
    fight all the time.
    
    	The three reasons you gave dont seem completely insurmountable 
    - to me. Re-develop some common interests. Set aside a night to
    to something together and make an effort at doing it. Invest in
    some couples counseling to discover why you're continually fighting
    and what you each can do to stop that.
    
    	My parent's "continually fought" although they'd swear up and
    down that they loved each other ("to the bitter end" kind). They were 
    the classic 50's / 60's parents and stuck it out for *my* sake and I
    was told that if it wasnt for me... Which of course translated into
    if it wasnt for me, they'd be apart, away from each other and...happy.
    Speaking of guilt, that's a lot to load onto the mind of a child.
    
    	I suspect a child's inate feeling of "if it wasnt for me", when 
    parents get divorced is no less heavy.
    
    	Hope this helps you somehow. Good Luck.
    
    	Joe
1133.2Good insights...MISERY::WARD_FRGoing HOME---as an Adventurer!Wed Jan 23 1991 20:075
    re: .1 (Joe)
    
    
    Frederick
    
1133.3Try a bit harder...ROSSO::MAHONEYThu Jan 24 1991 12:5136
    I woudn't do it... but of course that is my opinion, and since you want
    feedback...
    A marriage is a long, and FIRM commitment, it is not easy, but it is
    not impossible either, I believe we just "throw the towel" way too soon
    and don't let marriage mend its weak points... we should put much more
    energy in trying to mend, to adjust, to our own families, to learn
    their moods (everybody has a temper...) and if we do, and people
    arround put up with me, why shouldn't "I" put up with theirs? You love
    your daughter, isn't she worth the effort to try to keep her with her
    mom and her dad? Would she be any happier with only one of you? would
    it be easy to keep on having contact with your "ex", as she no doubt,
    will keep seeing and loving her daughter? Would she like it if you fall
    in love and bring in a "new" mom who is not her mom?  Would she like it
    to see her mom with a "new" daddy who is not her daddy?... I don't have
    an answer to these questions... no doubt that she will grow up and will
    understand lots of things that a child wouldn't, but I would try my
    hardest to keep a home with a mother and father and would concentrate
    in finding the root of those fights or dissagreements and changing and
    adapting and learning AGAIN to do things together, as I assume that you
    DID love her and enjoyed each other's company before... 
    Please give it a try... a long try! talk and share your thoughts with
    your wife, ask her to help you achieve a better life for ALL of you,
    tell her you want to have a happy marriage (wasn't that your purpose
    when you married?) for the marriage to succeed it needs her help and
    your help, you BOTH can make it work.  And if, after trying hard it
    does not work... at least you have the peace of mind that you did all
    you could, and who knows, maybe the effort of BOTH did improve the
    daily situation as to make it worth going on...
    
    I don't know, all I can say is that to keep a marriage going you need
    to work hard at it, but honest to God, it is worth every bit of the
    effort! (take it from a person who's been there over 26 years... I know
    what I'm talking about).  Please don't give up too soon
    Best luck,
    Ana
    
1133.4If you decide to "wait", do so impeccably.MISERY::WARD_FRGoing HOME---as an Adventurer!Thu Jan 24 1991 13:58198
re: .0
    
         I think that it is important that you make decisions that are
    *your* decisions, i.e., not doing things FOR someone else, whether
    that's your child, your spouse, parents, etc.  Do not stay in 
    the relationship "for your daughter's sake" unless it is something
    you really want to do (the guilts, resentments, etc. arising from
    doing things out of negative ambition [any ambition that isn't
    your own] are potentially far more devastating than a separation
    might be.)
         The following was sent to me last summer...I don't know if it
    has already been entered in here or not, but I do think that lots of
    what it says is very valuable.
    
    * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
	From "Stage II Recovery - Love After Addiction" by E. Larsen.  

An individual can occupy only three places in a relationship: In, Out or 
Wait.

*In* means that both individuals want to be in the relationship and are 
working in a constructive way to build the trust and hospitality necessary.

*Out* means that one or the other or both - it takes only one - has decided 
to get out.  For whatever reason or set of reasons, one partner has "fallen 
out of love" and does not want to be or is not willing to try to be in the 
relationship.  No matter how much you may love someone who chooses Out, if 
that is the choice, you do not have a choice about being In.  If your 
partner is Out, then so are you; and your choice here is not about the 
relationship but about your reaction to your partner's decision.  You can 
choose to continue to chase them, trying to force your partner to choose 
In, you can choose to remain depressed and bitter, you can choose to 
withdraw into isolation and separation for the rest of your life.  Or you 
can choose something else.  You can choose the opposite.  No matter how 
unfair you think it is, no matter how justified you are in being bitter or 
withdrawn, no matter how hard it is to let go and move on, you CAN choose 
to do just that.

*Wait*, the third option, is a valid choice.  Wait means I know I am not 
happy now, I recognize that my needs are not being met, and I am not 
willing to live this way forever, but neither am I willing or ready to walk 
away.  So I choose to gamble.  I choose to stay right here doing what I can 
to create and environment most conducive to my partner's growth and change.

This is a valid choice, but many people subsconsciously choose willed 
confusion instead.  They seem to stumble around, not knowing why things are 
the way they are or what to do about it.  Confusion, of course, is a 
marvelous way to avoid decisions.  If we are confused enough, how can 
anyone, including ourselves, expect us to make a decision?  But confusion 
hurts, and when we choose it, we sacrifice all power to influence our loved 
one.

Choosing Wait in a conscious, up-front, straight-thinking way is infinitely 
superior to choosing willed confusion.  When we choose Wait, however, we 
own that it is temporary, since it cannot go on forever; and we own that by 
choosing it we retain our own power - it is our decision to be here, so we 
should stop complaining about all that is wrong in our relationship.  If it 
gets bad enough and we are no longer willing to put up with it, we can 
always choose Out.  It's up to us.

If you are stuck in Wait, you can still keep busy.  Doing what?  You can 
(1) understand (2) decide (3) work your own program (4)refuse to enable or 
seek revenge (5) create a crisis, or (6) if it is over, walk away and never 
look back.

*Understand*

It has been said that no one *wants* to be a jerk.  If you are in a 
relationship with someone who does not play fair and in so doing causes you 
much pain, understand that there are reasons.  Not that there aren't also 
choices, but there are reasons.  The more effort you exert to understand 
those reasons - family of origin reasons, life experience reasons - the 
more beneficial it will be.

This is not to say, of course, that the more you understand the more you 
should be willing to accept intolerable behaviour.  No.  But the more 
understanding you possess, the better equipped you are to act in a way 
that might help.

Also, the more understanding you gain, the less angry you may become.  As 
irritating and frustrating as your partner's behaviour may be, at least you 
see a reason for its existence.  From your new perspective, you may be 
better able to say something in a different tone of voice, with a look in 
your eye that encourages rather than rejects.

*Decide*

Again, it's important not to allow yourself to be a victim who has no power 
and no ability to make decisions.  You can decide In, Out or Wait.  You can 
decide how long you are willing to Wait.  You can decided what it really is 
you want for your life, you can decide what it is costing you and will cost 
you if you refuse to decide.  You have many, many choices.  All of them - 
when you make them - can empower you.

*Work Your Program*			[This the way it is written - aj]

More will be said about working your own program in the next chapter.  
Basically, it means to take care of yourself. There is no greater gift you 
can give your partner and no more powerful thing you can do for your 
relationship than to be as healthy as your possibly can be.  How effective 
you are in encouraging good in your relationship is directly proportional to 
the degree of serenity and balance you possess.

When we are in pain our first impulse is to withdraw and retreat, to stop 
doing everything that gave us pleasure before.  We discontinue hobbies, 
overlook friends, and neglect having fun.  But the more depleted we become, 
the less we have to give.

To take care of yourself you need to be willing to ask the tough  
questions.  Self-delusion is not gift to yourself.  If you have chosen 
Wait, regularly as yourself these questions:  Is this where I want to be?  
Is all this uncertainty worth it?  Is this where my partner wants to be?  
How long am I willing to Wait?

*Refuse to Enable or to Seek Revenge*

While you're in Wait, it is difficult not to choose one of these paths.  
More common is to switch back and forth between the two, creating more 
confusion and conflict as you do so.

To "enable" means to be overly willing to do anything to keep your partner 
happy.  Often in response to the panic you may feel that your relationship 
may end and you may end up alone.  Enablers will make excuses for and 
accept excuses from their partners.  They will accept intolerable behavior, 
smile when they wan to cry, and refuse to look honestly at the direction 
the relationship is going.  Whenever Enablers enable they send out the 
message that whatever their partner choose to do is okay; there will be no 
consequence.  By continuing the behavior that got them in Wait in the first 
place, Enablers create all the more pressure and confusion.

Another option during Wait involves the opposite behavior; to quit trying, 
but not to choose Out.  And what do people do who stay stuck in Wait when 
the relationship has ended?  They get revenge.  The ways of getting 
revenge, of course are endless.  Sly putdowns, cynicism, deliberately 
choosing anything that's contrary to what the partner says or does.  
Revenge is a game, like all the other; and game responds to game.

*Create a Crisis*

Getting out of Wait and into In or Out often requires a crises, or 
confrontation.  Someone must say "It's over" or "I am not willing to live 
this way any longer.  Here is what must happen or it is over".

Creating a crisis is a last ditch effort.  Don't do it unless you are 
certain you can live with the consequences.  here are the four phases you 
much act out to successfully create a crisis:

	1. State your demands clearly and specifically
	2. State the consequences clearly
	3. Put a monitoring system in place (talk!)
	4. Make sure you consistently apply the consequences.

The last point is not easy, just essential.  You must be willing to follow 
through and live with the consequences you determine in advance.  Thus 
people in Wait have an enormous need for a support system and a personal 
program for growth.  It takes a great deal of strength to create a crises 
and stick with the consequences.  Even though you may know right down to 
your toes that what you're doing is both necessary and right, being right 
doesn't make it easy.

If you have created a crisis or have come to the realization that it is 
over, then the only step possible is closure.  Closure means you have 
chosen Out.  It doesn't mean maybe.  It doesn't mean the door is open a 
little.  It doesn't mean "Unless there is change I am finished".  All of 
those may be valid, but they define Wait.  When you know it's over or when 
you choose it to be over, the only fair, sane decision left is OUT.  Out 
means the relationship is dead.

Out does not mean you still don't care about the other person.  It doesn't 
mean that all the feelings are dead, though they may be.  What it does mean 
is you are no longer involved in the relationship.  Closure means that with 
all the sadness and grief that may accompany it, you are no longer willing 
to try, that the door is shut, and that you are looking forward with your 
life.

If you have remained emotionally attached to your partner and your partner 
wants out, chances are they may offer to still be friends.  In what seems 
to be a spirit of forgiveness and maturity, you may be invited to stay in 
touch, have coffee once in a while.  Beware - if you are emotionally 
attached, you cannot possibly have periodic contact with this person and 
still find freedom.  After enough time has passed maybe you will, but not 
now.  Such offers are more often than not an attempt to soothe feelings of 
guilt not an attempt to be friends.  If friendship is the issue, be a 
friend to yourself first.  Refuse to put yourself in a lose-lose situation 
where your heart can break a little more.

There  is nothing easy about Out or Wait, and certainly nothing easy about 
getting closure, but it's important not to do or believe in these things that 
will make the experience even harder than it already is.  The sooner we 
start to heal, the sooner we can get past the painful present and work for 
a better tomorrow.  I hope these suggestions will speed up the process.
     
    * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 
    
    
 Frederick
    

1133.5Sounds like me a few years agoICEE::BERGFri Jan 25 1991 13:4744
I normally do not offer advice, but this struck me as interesting since I found
myself in the same position several years ago. What I think I will do is give
some of what happened to me and you can take it for what it is worth. 

I had been married for twelve years and found my self in a relationship that 
was eighter tears, negative emotional excitement, or cold war. The bottom line
was that neighter of us were happy. The kids were always in the four front
of the situation and we were always "trying again" for them with my ex telling
me that divorce would be toughest on them. Well I was having to travel a lot
which gave me a lot of time to reflect and sort things out. I decided several
things. First I wasn't happy and it showed in the way I dealt with my ex and the
kids. Kids means three wonderful loving daughters who didn't understand why
the dad that they loved didn't seem to like them very much. Second, I was
married a long time. One one hand it would seem that that wasn't something that
should be thrown away, but at the same time if it wasn't going to work out then
it was time to make a move so that both myself and my ex might have time to 
pick up the pieces, get some help, and maybe find another lifelong mate,
something we both still want. Third, my situation was starting to affect my 
work, friends, and health. 

What did I do. After evaluating it for several years I have decided that I am 
much happier (Except for the the single life BS), I have new very close friends
and the best part. My kids are happier and we are close again, and my ex and I
are friends. Would I ever go back to her. No, why try to ruin a great friendship
again. I pay excess child support every month and I put my ex through college so
that she could provide a secure place for my daughters to grow up in. I don't 
like not being a daily part of thier lives, but it is worth it for me. Would I
do it again or would I try to work it out. That is a hard question. To resurrect
a bad relationship takes total commitment and understanding from both parties,
With help from a professional source. When you need advice on how to work on
your car you call a mechanic because eighter you can't fix it or have failed, so
relationships are not really too different. If you can't seem to fix it them 
find someone who can help you. It is important that you both go with the 
attitude that it is a joint problem and not "Her problem".

For my it has worked out the best way I think it could have, but my ex really
had some problems with it for a while afterwords. She went to counseling at the
college and we had the kids attend some workshop which helped them. I feel like
if we couldn't be the best at marriage, then maybe we could be the best at
divorce. 

Good luck my friend and be careful.

Brett Berg
1133.6"Do what's right."FTMUDG::REINBOLDFri Jan 25 1991 14:5526
    I agree that a couple should use all possible resources (i.e.,
    counselling) to keep a marriage together if there's a chance that
    both partners will be happy in the marriage. Especially if there
    are children involved.
    
    However, I do NOT believe that two adults should continue to live
    unhappy lives together "for the sake of the children."  That's not
    good for anybody, including the children.  You can't give *yourself*
    to your children in a healthy, nurturing way if you are unhappy
    yourself.  I believe there has to be a balance between putting the
    best interests of the children first, and doing things You need for
    You first.
    
    BTW I think .4 was excellent.  It certainly allows me to clarify my own
    current situation in my mind.  Thank you.
    
    Paula
    
    By the way, I was married for 8 years and had 2 children, when I
    divorced their father.  Has it affected them?  I'm sure it has.
    But at least they have seen me take charge of my life to a large
    degree.  In the marriage as it was, they would have seen 2 adults
    who never learned to take charge of anything. They would have grown
    up in a bad marriage and an unhealthy (mentally) household.  Life
    hasn't been rosy for them, but I think this way they will be better
    able to cope with life than had we stayed married.
1133.7My experienceDUCK::SMITHS2Fri Feb 08 1991 14:3029
    
    Speaking as a daughter whose parents divorced when I was ten, I
    personally think .3 is wrong.  I agree with .6, if after trying to make
    it work it becomes obvious that it won't, it's best to get out.  Don't
    try to stay together "for the sake of the children".
    
    My Mum and Dad were obviously not happy married to each other.  Now,
    twelve years later, they are both remarried and extremely happy.  I
    didn't mind that my Mum introduced a new "dad" and my Dad introduced a
    new "mum".  In fact, out of the situation I have gained four
    step-brothers and two step-sisters!
    
    Neither my sister (who is two years younger than me) or I have suffered
    from my parents divorce - I would far rather see my parents apart and
    happy than together and miserable.  It helped that our parents did a
    lot of reassuring us that they both still loved us alot, and that they
    remained on good terms throughout the whole thing.  Neither one ever
    said a bad word about the other, and we were never involved in an
    emotional tug of war, for which I am very grateful.
    
    I am now married myself and although I'm very happy I know that if it
    ever came to it, I would not stay married and miserable.  Honestly, the
    best thing for your little girl is to have two loving parents ...
    whether they are together or not.
    
    Just my thoughts...
    
    Sam
    
1133.8C'est la vie!!OTOA01::PICHETTESat Apr 20 1991 16:0626
    WoW.....I am in the exact same situation, only I have been married for
    12 years. We got married really young (19) and now have a beautiful son
    (4 1/2). We have both lost the trust we once had and are definitly not
    happy together anymore. Like so many, we do not want to hurt our boy in
    any way, shape or form, however I am coming to the conclusion that life
    would probably be better for him if we were apart.
    
    I feel I still love my wife, but only when we are apart. I also feel
    that we are trying harder to have an amicable seperation than we did
    with making our marriage work, but c'est la vie!! We seperated for
    about 1 1/2 months very recently, but are now under the same roof to
    work out all the details. (i.e. finances, custody, etc...) After she
    came back she felt we should give it one more shot, but I feel her
    reasons are not the right ones and she is doing this out of guilt. I
    have never actually lived on my own, and nor has she, and feel that we
    both have to do a little growing up.
    
    This is the toughest spot I have ever found myself in, and like
    yourself, I am at a total loss as to what to do.
    
    I know this note is not much help, but I thought you would like to know
    that you are not alone!!!!
    
    Regards from the great city of Ottawa Canada
    Mike