[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

1078.0. "Woman returns to ex for fourth time" by QUARK::HR_MODERATOR () Fri Sep 28 1990 12:34

    The following topic has been contributed by a member of our community
    who wishes to remain anonymous.  If you wish to contact the author by
    mail, please send your message to QUARK::HR_MODERATOR, specifying the
    conference name and note number. Your message will be forwarded with
    your name attached  unless you request otherwise.

				Steve






	I would like to share a relationship experience with the members of 
the noting community to get some feedback. Maybe something like this has 
happened to you or a friend and you have some first hand experience. My 
purpose is also to let off some steam and frustration of having gone thru this
experience.

	I have known this lady for about two years. Off and on have had 
occasion to be with her. About a month and a half ago we went out as friends 
to dance with each other. Things just seemed to click for us. We became close 
very quickly. We enjoyed each others company and wanted to be with each other 
all the time. We spent every minute we could with each other. As soon as Pattie 
came home from work she would call and we would get together as soon as I could 
get to her. We talked about how we missed each other and how our lives had been
affected since we met each other. We told each other how much in love we were 
with each other. We both have the same religious philosophy. My own personal
belief about sex is that it is something only to be shared with a person that 
has shown a total commitment to the relationship. Marriage would be that 
commitment. It was my understanding that she shared the same in thought and 
action. We did sleep together though, and we shared all the affection that went 
along with being together, in bed clothed. With no sexual touching. And in case
you are wondering, YES it was extremely difficult to handle the emotions. 
Having the agreement between the two of us made it easier.
	We talked about marriage. Pattie expressed her fear about the 
relationship because I will be moving in about four months to another state. 
That was scary for her. Other than that I could see nothing to prevent a 
mutually committed relationship. Our lives seemed to be going in the same 
direction and in ways that complimented the relationship.

	So much for the relationship. We slept with each other on a Friday, 
spent the entire day and most of the night together on Saturday. Pattie 
remarried her X husband for the fourth time on Monday. Without notice to me
and apparently little thought on her part. There was no way she was seeing 
him behind my back because we spent all our free time together, including a 
auto roundtrip of 1060 miles. Yes I knew of her relationship with her X. We 
talked about it several times. I believed her when she told me that it was over 
between them, that she had learned her lesson. About being physically abusied, 
going thru the time of him having an affair with another woman, etc. 
I thought, who in there right mind would ever go back for a forth time? And it 
crossed my mind about the sanity of even going back for the 2nd or 3rd time. 
Obviously, she lied to me and most all she lied to herself about what was 
still between them. Or at least what she thinks is between them. 

	So after all this, I`m feeling some pertty heavy emotions. Most of 
all I feel used, abusied, sh*t on, abandoned, and I am very angry at myself 
for allowing it to happen. I`m embarrased to let people know that I was 
so taken in. Even though I don`t know what I could have done to prevent it, 
other than stay away from her to begin with. It`s just that everything felt so 
comfortable when I was with her. I knew her background and was willing to 
accept her for who she was. If there was anyplace that I failed, that was it.
My acceptanc was too total. I didn`t take the time to determine if she was 
being true to herself. I will approach my next relationship with more 
caution. 
	
	Intellectually, I know I am better off with this woman out of my life.
I just don`t feel that way yet. I want her back yet I don`t. I feel like she 
will return and talk it over with me and realize that she made a mistake, yet 
I know that won`t happen. I feel that I am still in love, yet I know I am not. 
It`s kinda like the country western song about the jukebox in my mind. "I don`t
need any quarters, I don`t need any dimes. You filled the jukebox up forever 
when you said goodbye."
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1078.1mean move...DUGGAN::MAHONEYFri Sep 28 1990 13:0010
    That is the result of a total lack of morality.  You knew her past, yet
    you were ready to trust a person devoid of morals... why?
    I am very sorry for you because what she did is a "blow below the belt"
    and you don't deserve that.  Put HER out of your mind and please,
    follow your instints and... be selective, there are lots of people like
    her around, but there are many, many decent folks around...don't loose
    faith in humankind, only on those who are not up to your own
    standards... follow your integrity and go on with your life... wish you
    the best.
    
1078.2Rings a BellOAKISL::JUDICEWishful thinking...Fri Sep 28 1990 13:1917
    
    Boy, does this sound familiar... Your freind is in serious need of
    counseling, and from my experience with a very similar situation, 
    she won't get help until SHE decides to. No amount of suggestion, 
    coaxing, begging, etc. will help. 
    
    This is a lot more common than you may think. Unfortunately, when
    very nice, overly trusting people get involved with this type of person
    the result is a great deal of torment for people like you. And, I 
    would predict that when Pattie finds herself depressed and in trouble
    again, you'll be the first person she'll call. 
    
    Do something you enjoy to take your mind off of this! And take care,
    as I said, others have been through the same exact situation.
    
    /Lou
    
1078.3SA1794::LIVEFri Sep 28 1990 13:344
    She'll get what she deserves - a fourth divorce. Write her off
    and do it quickly. 
    
    been there
1078.4Keeps Going Back For More!TOLKIN::JEWETTFri Sep 28 1990 14:189
    I didn't read every reply, and I am not taking sides.  I don't judge
    other people.  However, I was an abused wife and I went back about
    20 times in 5 years.  Many ask why?  I guess it really doesn't matter
    why accept at the time I was very insecure and kept trying to "fix"
    the marriage.  I am sure that she is a very insecure person, and may
    not be stable.  However I agree with the first reply that you don't 
    need to be hurt (no one does).  I try to look at it as an experience
    which is more easily said then done, and we all know that sick feeling
    of emptiness.  Take care and Sincere Regards,
1078.5Ouch!!!HENRYY::HASLAM_BACreativity UnlimitedFri Sep 28 1990 14:5347
    In spite of the pain, lucky you!  You avoided (thanks to Patti)
    what may well have been an overwhelming co-dependent relationship.
    As painful and humiliating as it is right now, you will survive
    and be far better off without her.  Yes, I know that sounds cruel
    and that the emotions are still strong, but accept the grief and
    get through it.  A brief period of counseling might be very beneficial
    for you to get those feelings out and perhaps to discover why the
    two of you were attracted in the first place.
    
    Look back on the realtionship.  If these were the mind games she
    played with you now, what kind of mind games would she have played
    with you AFTER you were married?  Is this *really* the kind of
    relationship you would want to return to?  How long could the illusion
    of happiness remain under such circumstances?  These questions will,
    no doubt, collide with your emotions, but they deserve to asked
    and answered by your inner self.  One of the problems with
    co-dependency is that unless the person with the problem WANTS to
    change, nothing anyone can do or say will make a difference for
    long.  Patti's choices must come from within herself.  You cannot, no
    matter how much you want to "fix it" for her, do so.  She must be
    the person to say "enough!" and get the counseling she needs to
    overcome this need to be a victim.  Speaking as a former battered
    and abused woman, I *know* what it takes to effect such changes.
     It takes hard work, constant vigilance to catch yourself falling
    into old patterns, and some heavy duty counseling to discover the
    why you feel you need so much pain in your life and why you don't
    deserve happiness.  Unless Patti is ready to make such a committment,
    you are far better off avoiding her altogether.  Yes, it hurts!
    Just keep looking for the lessons you've learned out of this
    experience.  It will help you to at least find some value to the
    time you spent.  Perhaps you discovered a closeness you didn't know
    you had the ability to feel.  Perhaps you have learned that just
    because someone "clicks" in the beginning, it's far more prudent
    to really get to know the person you are in love with.  It may be
    that the long courtships of past days actually had more value than
    we give them credit for.  What have you discovered about yourself
    that you may not have been aware of before this time?  If you can
    find just one thing of value, your relationship was not a total
    waste.
    
    I hope you heal soon, friend.  You have my empathy and support at
    this painful time in your life.  If you need to talk, please write
    me.
    
    I care,
    
    Barb
1078.6WMOIS::B_REINKEWe won't play your silly gameFri Sep 28 1990 18:199
    inre .0
    
    I had a different thought, what if she paniced because she'd gotten
    too close to you and she couldn't handle it...
    
    so in running back to the old familiar situation she delt with
    her fear of something new.
    
    Bonnie
1078.7AIMHI::RAUHHome of The Cruel SpaFri Sep 28 1990 18:209
    Stranger than fiction! I knew a woman who went back to a married man,
    she broke off her engagement with me. Boogied back to his hot loynes
    and I said enough of this crap. Yes, she needs serious help, just as my
    future Ex does. But that life, can't help them who don't wanna be
    helped. Remember if she calls you and she has been bounced around the
    house, agian, she doesn't want help from athorities, you don't want 
    involvement. Besides who wants someone with sexual hangups like that
    she was displaying to you. Some folks are born with sharp heals to walk
    over you with. Stay out of harms way.  
1078.8yupPARITY::ELWELLDirty old men need love, too.Fri Sep 28 1990 18:4810
    re .6
    
    I agree. To some (me included at times) it's better to have something
    you are familiar with than something unknown, even if it seems like it
    should definitely be better.
    
    I have a feeling that's why quite a few people return to abusive
    situations.
    
    ....Bob
1078.10Try a meeting.ELESYS::JASNIEWSKIThis time forever!Fri Sep 28 1990 19:0216
    
    	Well, you could go to a "CODA" meeting and tell this story there.
    You'll find many people there who'll identify with and (therefore)
    validate all the feelings you have, from the embarrassment of letting
    people know to the anger you feel at yourself for allowing this
    to happen. Empty the jukebox by talking about it.
    
    	You'll be able to draw from the collective experience there
    and learn what has helped others when they were in a like situation
    and learn what is helping them now. You may even learn what it is 
    about you - this part you're currently angry with - that, as you said, 
    "allowed this to happen".
    
    	Hope you're feeling better soon.
    	
    	Joe
1078.11Just my thoughtsYUPPY::DAVIESAArtemis'n'me...Mon Oct 01 1990 14:2924
    
>So after all this, I`m feeling some pertty heavy emotions...... I am 
>    very angry at myself for allowing it to happen. I`m embarrased to let 
>    people know that I was so taken in.
    
Hey fella - go easy on yourself....
    You've had enough pain thrown at you from the outside without beating
    yourself up too :-}
    
    You did OK - as OK as any loving person can confronted with someone who
    is that unstable (IMO). Don't keep kicking yourself - you weren't to
    know. As for feeling embarassed - well, if anyone trys to make you feel
    a fool for honestly loving someone else then I reckon they have a sad
    attitude and are probably missing out on some of life's good stuff
    themselves. I don't think you were foolish.
    
    I'm sure your situation must hurt like hell right now, but when you've
    healed (and you *will* - you know it) don't let this experience stop
    you from loving again....
    
    'gail
    
    
    
1078.12yWORDY::C_MILLERMon Oct 01 1990 14:4023
    I can sympathize with you 100%.  I ended a 4 year realtionship, and
    then went through 3 subsequent ones that I thought "could be the one,"
    each time getting dumped.  I felt humiliated and worthless, wondering
    each day what *I* did wrong.  My self-esteem went right down the
    toilet, along with my trust for people of the opposite sex.  I still
    cared for these people long after they let me know they weren't
    interested anymore.  The only way I got over it was to talk to very
    close friends about the each experience, someone who would listen,
    offer some insight, but not tell me "you asked for it."
    
    I started a journal to record all my feelings and emotions.  That
    helped A LOT, after a month or two I no longer needed to jot down my
    every emotion.  I also sent each person a letter, explaining how I felt
    and getting it out in the open.  This also helped.  
    
    This is a form of therapy that has worked for me, perhaps you can try
    it.  What probably hurts the most is that you trusted this person with
    all your inner thoughts and emotions and then they turned around and
    betrayed you.  Try not to build a wall around yourself (although I know
    it will be hard), and learn from this experience so it doesn't happen
    again. 
    
    Take care.
1078.13Response from anonymous author of base noteQUARK::HR_MODERATORTue Oct 02 1990 14:5286
	I would like to thank those who have responded to the base note. My 
overall feeling from what has been written is that you care and I appreciate
the support that has been offered. I would like to give some feedback about 
what some of you wrote.

.1

I`m not sure I agree that Pattie is a person devoid of morals. I would need 
more info from you to understand the reasoning. Why, did I trust her? 
Some of that, I am in the process of learning at the present time. I ignored
her track record and her actions and believed her words. That was a mistake.
I`m sure there are a lot of decent women around. I just seem to be drawn in 
to those who have problems. That has been my pattern. I tend to be a caretaker  
and for some reason feel that I can fix things that are wrong with others. Some 
of the whys of all this are locked inside me and I am working to release the 
experiences that have created the patterns.

.2,.3,.4

I agree, Pattie is in serious need of counseling and she is less than stable.
I`m not sure about her getting what she deserves. I do feel that she will have 
to hit rock bottom before she goes for help. From being with this woman and 
based on what has happened, I firmly believe that she is a victim of childhood
sexual abuise. She is not aware of it and has no memory of it. My mother was 
sexually abusied and as a result I have a pattern of getting involved with 
sexually abusied women. There are also some other things in her past that she 
will not face. Pattie is very much out of touch with who she is. So what is it
that she deserves? I don`t like how she treated me anymore now than when it 
happened. Because she was a victim, she deserves to be victimized? I believe 
the day will come for Pattie, when she will realize how much pain she is in and
will begin to do something about it on her own. Life has a way of teaching us 
the lessons that we need. 

.5 

	I do know intellectually about all the things you mentioned. I`m sure
it would have been a total disaster if we would have gotten married, just like
it has been in all her relationships so far. I really do know what I want in a 
relationship. What I want to learn is why am I continually getting into 
relationships that I don`t want. This woman came into my life for the purpose 
of teaching me that lesson.
	For some reason, I become totally enmeshed with the women I love. Or 
maybe it isn`t love but there are certain types of women, usually the ones 
who have been sexually abuised, that I fall in love with. I am unable to see 
things from a proper perspective and even when I do see things properly, I am 
unable to speak up. It is difficult for me to function when I become so 
enmeshed in these relationships.
	I have been told in my last therapy session that somewhere very early 
in my life or even possibly in the womb, I lost my voice. Somewhere along the 
way, I made a decision that it was better not to speak or make any noise. I was 
able to get more of my needs met by remaining silent, and it was also less 
painful. I feel that this area is worth exploring. Since a lot of my life was 
spent in silence, for fear of upsetting those who were my caretakers.

.6

I agree that the closeness she was beginning to feel was too much for her to
handle. She once told me that after knowing her for three weeks, I knew more 
about her than her X knew, in the two or three years that they had been 
together. Isn`t it ironic that something that is most treasured by some, is 
most feared by others.
 
.11

I think what bothers me the most is how much I accepted this woman and put my
trust in her. I loved her in the only way I know how. By unconditionally 
accepting her and believing that she was loving and capable of rising above 
anything that may have been in her past. I thought she was truthful with me 
only to find that she wasn`t. And so out of touch with herself that she can`t
even recognize her own truth. It just seems like such a waste of human 
potential 

.12

Journal`s have always helped. And writing a letter to the person has also 
helped. Even though some of the letters have never been mailed. I also started 
a dialouge with my inner child. It seems like, if I would have been more 
connected with my inner child much of the pain that I put the child thru could 
have been avoided. Anyway that is what I am trying to do. Connect deeply with 
the child so that I can be more sensitive with what I`m feeling. 

Again thanks for the support. I needed it at this time in my life even though
I was fearful that some responses might be judgemental. A couple hinted at 
judgement but overall the feedback was supportive. I appreciate the time you 
spent to reply.