[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference quark::human_relations-v1

Title:What's all this fuss about 'sax and violins'?
Notice:Archived V1 - Current conference is QUARK::HUMAN_RELATIONS
Moderator:ELESYS::JASNIEWSKI
Created:Fri May 09 1986
Last Modified:Wed Jun 26 1996
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1327
Total number of notes:28298

116.0. "How to end a relationship?" by ATFAB::REDDEN (Hardening of the Catagories) Mon Oct 27 1986 09:54

    Several topics have developed questions around how to establish
    and enhance relationships.  Similarly, several topics have dealt
    with the pain of ending relationships.  It seems odd to me that
    we don't seem to have a body of knowledge on how to end relationships
    without trauma.  This is particularly apparent in SO-type situations,
    but I grimace at the number of times I have pretended I would keep
    in touch with a departing friend, knowing in my heart that what
    I really meant was goodbye but didn't know how to say it.  Is this
    something else that was taught while I was cutting class, or does
    it seem to you that our culture is lacking in this area?  If you
    have any guidelines that work for you, would you be willing to share
    them?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
116.1Sometimes being honest really hurts......MTV::FOLEYBoom shacka-lackaMon Oct 27 1986 10:5420

	I think I cut the same class.. :-)

	Breaking up a relationship has to be one of the hardest things
	to do. I mean, how do you say to someone you really care about and
	perhaps love dearly that you don't want to be with them anymore?
	It's a terrible feeling of rejection and loneliness to have to
	deal with. You don't want to hurt them but you also don't want to
	hurt yourself anymore. You see ahead of what is happening and know
	in your heart and soul that it won't work. 

	I don't envy anyone in that situation. I hate being in it myself.
	I have lots of trouble dealing with it but when push comes to
	shove I just say what I *really* feel and hope that someday the
	other person will understand. Sometimes it works and sometimes it
	doesn't. That's the risk you have to take in order to be human.
			

							mike
116.2Solution UnknownAIMHI::HEBERTMon Oct 27 1986 11:2512
    Well I think it's better to be honest with someone than be a "cold"
    hearted fool that will play emotional "head games" with you!  There
    is no real solution for this problem other than to stop beating
    around the bush and making each other miserable.
    
    Sure it's not easy (for anyone) but you'll eventually learn to deal
    with what is best for you and continue with your life.  Just because
    you say "good-bye" to someone doesn't mean you can't remain friends.
    Although, I realize in some cases that may be impossible but you
    just have to make the best of it.
    
    If life was a bowl of peaches, boy it would be so boring!!!
116.3"honesty is the BEST policy"PULSAR::CFIELDMon Oct 27 1986 12:059
    Ending a relationship can be a very hurting, sometimes traumatic
    experience, depending on the degree of the relationship.  I feel
    that honesty is the only way to deal with a situation such as this.
    Time has a way of healing all things and "pretending that you would
    keep in touch, knowing in your heart that what you really meant
    was goodby" is only creating expectations that will never come to
    pass.  Isn't it better either to end it once and for all or maybe
    even depart as friends?
    
116.4Cultural Basis, I thinkMINAR::BISHOPMon Oct 27 1986 12:4219
    This may be (note "MAY") an American problem: two experiences I
    had while in high school seem to imply this.
    
    I went to Austria with the Experiment in International Living (you
    live with a local family, then travel around a bit with the other
    ten or so Americans in the program).  At the end of the summer,
    people exchanged addresses.  I wrote one letter to one of the other
    Americans.  I got none back.  Typical, no?
    
    I also, at another time, went to Germany with an English program
    which was almost identical.  At the end, everyone said "good-bye".
    No exchange of addresses.
    
    Maybe most Americans can't be happy with the idea that a good time
    is over?  Maybe they don't distinguish between close friendships
    which will last and companionships due to proximity which will not,
    and try to turn the many companionships one has into close friendships?

    				-John Bishop
116.6Gone, but not forgottenHOMBRE::CONLIFFEBoston in 89!!Mon Oct 27 1986 13:3417
Story 1:
When a cat first meets you (and wants to be friends), it makes a tremendous
fuss of you.. it purrs and rubs against you, and offers itself for stroking
and generally occupies all your attention.
When a cat leaves you, it walks away. No fuss, just an exit. 

Story 2:
If you've ever taken off a large Band-aid (American for Elastoplast), you
know that you can either yank it off in one mighty "OUCH!" or tug away
slowly in a series of little "ouches". 

Opinion:
As you might gather, I prefer just walking away (or being walked away from)
when a relationship is over. I've experienced both possibilities from both
sides, and my experience is that it hurts less in the long run just to leave.

	Nigel
116.7if ya gotta do it, do it with some honesty!REGENT::KIMBROUGHgailann, maynard, ma...Mon Oct 27 1986 14:2122
    
    Like .6 I think the most humane way to handle the break-up of a
    relationship is to walk away and get it over with..  but I also
    think there is a certain amount of tact called for in which you
    display a fair amount of honesty and express the finality of it
    all so as not to leave the other party hanging...
    
    Even when we know it is for the best it is not easy...  I think
    it fair to tell it like it is though and not drag out a person's
    hopes for a reconcile.  The most devastating ill, I think, is to
    be lied to... don't tell a person that you are leaving them because
    you need your space, don't have a formula for your life, have the
    need to have some personal time, etc etc... when the truth is you
    plan on running right into someone else's arms.. if that is the
    truth than tell it that way.. after the initial shock is over the
    truth is much easier to deal with then a lie..  a lie grows and
    festers and gets uglier when the truth does not.  
    
    later, gailann
    
    
                                                      
116.8a few thoughtsSTUBBI::B_REINKEMon Oct 27 1986 15:0919
    Before I met my husband I experienced a couple of love affairs where
    my (ex) partner just walked out and didn't let me know things were
    over. (I figured it out when expected calls and letters didn't come.)
    I don't know if I could have taken things any better if I had been
    *told* in so many words that it was over, but I *think* I would
    have. 
    
    When my oldest son had his first romance last year I did tell him
    that I felt that endings were an important part of a relationship,
    and that when and if it got to that point he should be sure to tell
    the girl what he was thinking. As a result he did tell her that
    he wanted to stop dating and "just be friends". Unfortunately she
    took this to mean it wasn't really over. 
    
    I can understand a little better now why people find it easier to
    just walk. But I still think it is kinder to at least try and let
    the other party know that things are over.

    Bonnie
116.10When Friendship Ends!!!EUCLID::LEVASSEURWhat Goes Around Comes AroundMon Oct 27 1986 15:3528
         This topic has always bothered me. I don't know how many times
    that I have had very dear friends say they'de keep in touch, only
    to never hear from them again. When I moved out of Boston in January
    I had what I thought were a handfull of close friends. Now that
    I'm up in New Hampshire, they never keep in touch (I make all the
    calls) and always seem to be busy, which was not the case while
    living in Boston.
         The only friendship that broke up that was very painful was
    with a married couple that I've been very close with for 34 years.
    We grew up toghether and have always been there for each other.
    he was the best man at my wedding and I was their son's godfather.
    When I moved to Boston they became quite remote and always had an
    excuse not to visit. I visited them on new year's day after moving
    and they were shocked that I dropped in, beforehand it was always
    an open door. This Summer I learned that my all time closest
    friend has taken it upon himself to tell the world I have AIDS.
    I DO NOT IN ANY WAY HAVE AIDS! I have tried getting in touch
    with them and the son screens all calls. Why did my ex-friend make
    his hypothesis? Well when I dropped in new years day, I had just
    finished unloading a moving truck as well as nursing an excedrin
    hangover, basicly I looked like hell and he assumes that I have
    this dreaded disease rather than just asking if I'm feeling ok.
        I've come to a point where, deep friendships are not worth
    nurturing, at least not for me. There is a lot of good material
    in Al Tofflers' "Future Shock" which deals with friendships ending.
    
    
    Ray
116.11Dealing with .......AIMHI::HEBERTMon Oct 27 1986 16:0544
    Re: .5
    
    Steve, I'll try to answer your question.
    
    By remain friends, I mean that you act civilized towards each other,
    like say hi when you see each other (rather than run the other
    direction).  Things in that line.  I hate to hurt anyone or see
    anyone else hurt so I try not to force the issues if they choose
    to blame me for the insecurities they felt.  Its much better for
    me to walk away and accept the failure rather than to try to prove
    to them that it was just as much their fault as mine.
    
    All I can say about stress is that if you don't learn to deal with
    it, then you have a problem.  I can't ease that stress, your friends
    can't ease that stress.  It's high time that you or whomever is
    feeling such stress examine the space you live in.  If it feels too
    cramp, make room.  YOU and only you can control this space.
    
    Insecurity/jealousy are just as burdensome as stress.  I can't change
    the way you or the other "SO" feels.  I learned the hard way (believe
    me) that you can't change anyone.  Just give them the space to grow
    if that is what they need.  If, for some reason,  the "SO" feels
    the need to lay a guilt trip on the other, that is not a friend.
    
    I have special friends out there that each one has to be dealt with
    differently.  I'm not saying all friends act/live/think the same
    that is why you have to communicate you thoughts with them.  If
    they foresee you as a burden, forget them.  There are other people
    out there who will appreciate you for the wonderful person you are,
    can be.  No one says "everyone" has to like you, like what you are,
    etc.
    
    Life a bowl of peaches, no I am not saying men and women should
    be friends because stress is better than being bored!  Far from
    it!  You CAN have friends without stress.  What I meant by that
    comment is that live can be exciting, boring, ruthless, painfull;
    the list could go on an on!  The key to your success lies in
    "HOW YOU DEAL WITH IT!"
    
    Carole
    
    BTW, the above is just my feeling and hope that this is not taken
    personally amongst anyone.  
    
116.13My two cents...MEDUSA::FIGUEROAMon Oct 27 1986 20:2417
    If a relationship is enjoyable but has to end because of some reason
    not having to do with the quality of the relationship, a quick,
    clean, and honest break is best.  Why run the risk of turning a
    good experience into an bad experience by delaying the inevitable
    or by telling stories?
    
    If the relationship that is ending is not enjoyable, why would you
    want to stick around?  Concern for the other person's feelings is
    understandable, but you are not doing the other person any favors
    by dragging it out.  They have to get on with their lives just as
    you do.
    
    As far as the interaction of SO's and friends/previous SO's is
    concerned, does an SO have the right to demand/expect that you will
    give up previous associations for them?  I take the attitude of,
    "I was not her first relationship and I may not be her last, so
    why expect her lifestyle to begin and end with this relationship".
116.15Ouch, that hurts, friend!MMO01::RESENDELife and love are all a dreamTue Oct 28 1986 05:5851
    Gee, Bob you sure set off a busy topic!
    
    RE:  .* The pain of friendship
    
    I have a plaque in my office which I find sums up this topic
    for me succinctly ...
    
    
                 "Some people come into our lives and quickly
               go ... some stay for awhile and leave footprints
              on our hearts, and we are never, ever the same ..."
                                  - Anonymous
    
    Recognizing that with the joy of friendship, we have to accept
    the risk, and the reality of the pain of losing or ending that
    friendship is a large portion of the "how to deal with it" question.
    While I'd prefer to go through life "painless", I'd rather suffer
    this pain than go without the moments of joy which having that
    friendship brings.
    
    I don't think there's any "easy" way to end a friendship.  In fact,
    it just about kills me when a very close friendship ends, which is
    fortunately not a common event for me, so I guess that I'll never
    get used to it.  It's a significant loss, in many ways like a divorce
    or death in the family; in fact on reflection it is indeed very much
    like those events.
    
    As for ending "it" by leaving without a word, my (very strong) opinion
    is that it is the cruelest, inhumane way to end it.  The leaver (as
    well as the leavee) has to live the rest of his or her life with a lot
    of "loose ends" and unanswered questions.  That's an unfair and 
    unnecessary burden to lay on someone.  But who said life was fair, 
    right?  It may be hard to be honest enough to sit down and have that
    final talk, but you may regret not having it later.
    
    Re:  .9  on the apparent lack of long-term friendships ...
    
    Bob, I share your feelings.  They are there, but so very rare.  And as 
    the "Eagle" has spoken a few replies back, perhaps we just can't handle 
    "too many" SOs simultaneously.
    
    Re:  .10 >I've come to a point where, deep friendships are not worth
             >nurturing, at least not for me.
    
    Ray, that makes me so sad!  Maybe I'm a glutton for punishment, but I 
    can't imagine going through life without any, even with the 
    disappointment which often comes with them.  Makes me feel most alive. 
    I hope you don't always feel that way.  But that's my value system, 
    right ...?
    
    Steve
116.16walking is ok, but...HOMBRE::HOWERTue Oct 28 1986 12:549
	I think I'd agree with the opinion that the best way to end a 
	"close" relationship is by leaving cleanly; however, both parties
	should agree (or at least know) that the relationship is going
	to end then - one party should not just "walk out" unexpectedly.

	One of the saddest experiences is to come home expecting to find
	someone who is still special to you, only to find the house empty....	

		HH
116.17Not only submarines go under water!NFL::GIRARDTue Oct 28 1986 17:119
        RE: .16
    
        Even sadder, come home and find out that the person who you
    thought was close to you, isn't.
    
        And come home every day to that.
    
        Not all relationships are physical splits.  Some never end.
    
116.18Sadder stillCURIUM::JACKSONSat Nov 01 1986 22:047
    Re: .17
    
    Yes, that would sure be sad. What would be even sadder is continuing
    to accept and live with that situation, not realizing that you have
    the power to change it.
    --
    						Seth