[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::sf

Title:Arcana Caelestia
Notice:Directory listings are in topic 2
Moderator:NETRIX::thomas
Created:Thu Dec 08 1983
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1300
Total number of notes:18728

815.0. "Man-Kzin Wars!" by MEMIT::SCOLARO (Fusion in a Glass!) Wed Aug 02 1989 15:57

    Well, has anyone else read the Man-Kzin War's shared "history" of that
    period of Larry Niven's Known Space?
    
    I have the first two volumes and I think they are great, especially
    Dean Ing's stories!  I am now reading Pournelle's story in II and it is
    pretty good also.
    
    Tony
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
815.1meeeoow!GUESS::STOLOSThu Aug 03 1989 11:014
    yes! i read the first vol. a few months back and pick up the second
    this weekend...great adventure from "those rattail tabbies from
    hell" ;')
    pete
815.2Good stuffSA1794::CHARBONNDI'm the NRAFri Aug 04 1989 10:282
    Warning - 'The Childrens' Hour' steals heavily from a
    famous movie. But it is quite good. And nasty.
815.3Re.2MEMIT::SCOLAROFusion in a Glass!Fri Aug 04 1989 13:098
    >          <<< Note 815.2 by SA1794::CHARBONND "I'm the NRA" >>>
    
    >Warning - 'The Childrens' Hour' steals heavily from a
    >famous movie. But it is quite good. And nasty.
    
    Which one?  Set it behind hiddens, but I really cannot identify it.
    
    Tony
815.4A hintTLE::DMURPHYDennis MurphyFri Aug 04 1989 14:196

    Let's just say that the owner of the bar in 'The Children's Hour' is
    NOT named Rick.

    Dennis Murphy

815.5YepMEMIT::SCOLAROFusion in a Glass!Fri Aug 04 1989 14:436
    GRONK!  Ok, I get it.  Very different direction than what I was
    thinking.  But, now that you mention it, a very interesting rip-off. 
    Some technological related differences, but close enough for horse-
    shoes.
    
    Tony
815.6ELRIC::MARSHALLhunting the snarkMon Aug 07 1989 17:5811
    "The Children's Hour" is also the title of a play and a movie dealing
    with something completely different.
    
    Any relation?
    
                                                   
                  /
                 (  ___
                  ) ///
                 /
    
815.7Forget the title...SNDCSL::SMITHLet's go trigger Warf!Mon Aug 14 1989 19:316
    Just saw the third volume in the Man-Kzin Wars shareduniverseseries,
    I think it was at Lauriats in the Burlington Mall.  Now I'm awaiting
    my copy anxiously... (It's a Baen book and my SO gets all the new
    Baen SF via permanent mail-order every month).
    
    Willie
815.8basic info?ALASKA::QUIRICIMon Aug 14 1989 19:439
    i assume the Man-Kzin wars series is a spin-off of Larry Niven's
    Ringworld series and some short stories?
    
    could someone fill me in on the apparent 3 volumes of this series,
    since i really enjoyed the afore-mentioned stuff?
    
    also, re: .7, is Baen a SF publisher? are they new? good?
    
    ken
815.9AnswersSNDCSL::SMITHLet's go trigger Warf!Mon Aug 14 1989 20:0014
    Yup, though one might more clearly say it's more books in the series of
    his Known Space, except now he's thrown it open to others, in the
    shared-universe style.
    
    I really enjoyed the first two volumes, and expect the third to
    be good as well.  It's not till one of these things gets into 5
    to 10 books that they print anything that comes along....
    
    Baen is a publisher.  I dunno how new they are, though they have
    been around for (guess) at least 5 years that I know about.  We
    get all their new SF/Fantasy every month, and while I'm not wild
    about _everything_ we get in, most of it's quite good.
    
    Willie 
815.10Tangent...RUBY::BOYAJIANHe's baaaaccckkk!!!!Tue Aug 15 1989 08:0910
    Jim Baen started out as an editor for the magazine GALAXY, bringing
    it out of the slump it'd been through for about five years. In the
    mid-70's, he got the position as sf editor at Ace Books, and helped
    make that one of the premiere sf houses of the time. Eventually,
    he moved over to Pinnacle Books, where he co-created the Tor Books
    line. After a few years, he decided to strike out on his own, and
    created a "packaging" firm, Baen Books, which was contracted by
    Pocket Books to be their sf line.
    
    --- jerry
815.11$GUESS::STOLOSFri Aug 25 1989 18:1233
   
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    spoiler following
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
     i just finished vol2 and loved it, did any one notice that in the
    children's hour when the spys finally broke into the computer they
    got the $ prompt. 
    that was great!!
    pete
815.12Not just me...LENO::GRIERmjg's holistic computing agencyMon Sep 11 1989 23:045
   I was afraid that was just me (and my "corporate ego" :-) that noticed that
when I read it this past weekend...

					-mjg (who's glad it didn't say
					      "C>"...)
815.13RAINBO::TARBETSama budu polevat'Fri Sep 22 1989 20:134
    it was probably a Cyber 74 running Kronos  :-)
    
    						=maggie-who-thinks-
    						60-bit-words-are-still-okay
815.14@TLE::AMARTINAlan H. MartinSat Dec 30 1989 02:513
Nah, if it was a dollar sign *without* a trailing space, it was a Tops-20
account with wheel turned on.
				/AHM
815.15Kzin IV is a good readPENUTS::HNELSONHoyt 275-3407 C/RDB/SQL/X/MotifThu Nov 07 1991 20:2235
    I polished off Volume IV of the Kzin Wars series last weekend. It was
    excellent, IMO. It has two stories, one novel length, the other quite
    short. Being really bad at remembering things, I'm blanking on the
    author of the longer piece, but I think Stirling and Bear collaborated
    on the shorter. I'm probably wrong. Anyway, it's a real good read, both
    stories replete with the sfysics and logic problems one expects from
    Niven. Both stories evoked the alien nature of Kzin well. The longer
    story introduced a novel new life-form: independent newly-born "digits"
    combine in groups of five to form land-roving adults, each of the five
    retaining their own brains and independently-operated eyes, making for
    lots of internal conversation and differential talents among the
    "fingers." Nice.
    
    I thought Niven's introduction was interesting. He discussed his
    response to an amateur who wanted to use Kzin in a Star Trek setting, and
    was asking Larry's permission. Larry refused, allegedly on esthetic
    grounds, mentioning that Larry has commissioned Kzin work and later
    rejected it because it failed to meet his standards. He also made a
    point of pointedly mentioning the term "lawsuit" and explicitly
    discouraged writers using computer networks (USENET?) to publish Kzin 
    writings.
    
    This could be interpreted, I think, as Niven's way of protecting his
    right to the Kzin series. He's undoubtedly collecting some serious
    bucks for making all the effort of writing a two-page intro (I'm sure
    there's actually more work entailed, but how much could there be?). And
    Larry _did_ say something along the lines "If you want any more Known Space
    stories, you'll have to write them yourself" -- this was published in
    the back of one of his Known Space books. I think that paragraph might
    have put Known Space in the public domain, sort of, and that Niven's
    comments in Kzin IV are an attempt to forestall challenges by bringing
    up the L-work (lawsuit).
    
    Speculative fiction, and not written as well as Larry's :) - Hoyt
                                             
815.16RUBY::BOYAJIANHistory is made at nightFri Nov 08 1991 02:2530
    re:.15
    
    This was discussed ad nauseum on Usenet in rec.arts.sf-lovers.
    
    The specific situation that Larry was referring to and was trying
    to avoid mentioning in detail was apparently a series of soft-core
    (or possibly hard-core) pornographic stories that someone on the
    net was writing and posting to alt.sex or rec.arts.erotica or
    whatever. Larry's trying to keep from making the same mistake that
    Paramount made. In the early years of STAR TREK fandom, Paramount
    never tried to squelch all of the fan fiction that was being written
    and published, even the pornographic stuff. Maybe it was because
    the show was off the air and they considered Trek to be an all-but-
    dead property, I dunno. Anyway, by the time they *did* get concerned
    about it, they didn't have a legal leg to stand on. There wasn't
    any way they could stop the fan fiction because in the law's view,
    they implicitly gave permission by allowing it to go on for years.
    Larry *has* to go after even the little guys if he wants to protect
    his right to control his property later.
    
    Larry's previously stated comment, "If you want more Known Space
    stories, you'll have to write them yourself" does *not*, either
    explicitly or implicitly put anything in the Public Domain. There
    are no laws against writing stories using other people's characters
    and settings; the law is only concerned with the sale or distribution
    of those stories. I can write all the Known Space stories I want,
    but as soon as I try to sell it, or even post it to the net, I'm
    violating Larry's rights to his characters.
    
    --- jerry
815.17Kzinti verses the UFPMTWAIN::KLAESAll the Universe, or nothing!Fri Nov 08 1991 14:3710
    	Niven's Kzinti have already appeared in the STAR TREK universe,
    in the animated television episode "Slaver Weapon", based on his short 
    story, "Soft Weapon".  Niven wrote the screen version himself. 
                                                                  
	FYI - NBC had an animated version of STAR TREK on Saturday mornings
    in 1973-1974.  While a number of the episodes left something to be
    desired, "Slaver Weapon" was certainly one of the better ones.
    
    	Larry
    
815.18Kzinti rolled into the role-playing game.ATSE::WAJENBERGThis area zoned for twilight.Fri Nov 08 1991 15:177
    Star Trek role-playing game shows a map of the Federation (a big
    circular bite out of the galactic plane) flanked by the empires of
    Klingons, Romulans, and Kzinti, as well as lesser neighbors like
    Tholians.  I don't know if the rule set provides for playing Kzinti
    characters.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
815.19It seems like Gibson's cyberpunk stuff is ripped regularlyPENUTS::HNELSONHoyt 275-3407 C/RDB/SQL/X/MotifThu Nov 21 1991 10:4415
    This is interesting. If I ever write the story I've been percolating
    for years now (!), it will be extremely derivative of Niven's Known
    Space stuff. Transfer booths and stasis fields are key, for example.
    Can I use these expressions without violating Niven's rights? Or do I
    have to resort to "transmission boxes" and "no-time fields" (yuck)?
    
    How about the berserker series? Did Saberhagen invent this? Does he
    retain the right to "license" the idea of berserkers? I think Niven
    wrote a berserker story. Did they do "cross-licensing"? :)
    
    I wonder what Larry would do if I sent him a wonderful Beowulf Shaefer
    (sp?) story. In his intro the Kzin IV he specifically deplored the
    quality of the items he rejected.
    
    Thanks for the info, all - Hoyt                                    
815.20additional readingSA1794::CHARBONNDAauugghh! Stupid tree!Mon Nov 25 1991 10:363
    In addition to the four volumes in the series, you might want to
    read Poul Anderson's full-length novel, "Incoonstant Star" which
    takes place in the Man-Kzin Wars era.
815.21I'm gonna call mine "Inconstant Planetoid"PENUTS::HNELSONHoyt 275-3407 C/RDB/SQL/X/MotifFri Dec 13 1991 11:191
    "Inconstant Star"???!!! And Niven wrote "Inconstant Moon"! 
815.22RingWorld??FROSTY::PENNEY_WBaffled by BureaucracyWed Aug 19 1992 20:1011
    I just  read  M-KW  [II] and Niven's RingWorld-two novels, I think?
    
    Where has this guy been? Great SF.
    
    The kzinti started  in  RingWorld.  Suprised I can't find anything here 
    on the series.
    
    What's the story on  Niven?    He  seems  to write lots of SF in teams.  
    Does that make for better SF?  Or more $?
    
    
815.23NivenOASS::MDILLSONGeneric Personal NameWed Aug 19 1992 22:179
    Niven is a great writer.  But he tends to be very technical and in the
    fictional world, technical=boring to some readers.  By teaming him with
    other writers, they can use his worlds and scientific ideas and add
    some spice/zip to the story.
    
    As far as money is concerned, Niven doesn't care.  He isn't in this for
    the bucks.  He was a millionaire before he started writing (Ah, family
    money) and only writes for his own enjoyment.  Fortunately, he writes
    well!
815.24TECRUS::REDFORDThu Aug 20 1992 02:4712
    Niven doesn't seem to have written much recently.  I think his
    most recent was "Achille's Choice" by him and Steve Barnes, where
    people are chosen for public office by individual athletic
    contests.  An odd idea, and seemingly contrary to everything one
    knows about what makes a good leader, but that's what SF is for.

    Niven's glory period was the early seventies, when he wrote the first
    Ringworld novel, "Protector" (highly recommended if you like the
    hard stuff), and his classic shorts such as "Inconstant Moon". 
    He didn't hit those peaks again, but at least he hit them once.
    
    /jlr
815.25Like the Kzin Concept...CGHUB::PENNEY_WBaffled by BureaucracyFri Aug 21 1992 13:2526
    Yup, he seems to  be  pretty  good.    There's a couple of books that I 
    think he may have written  in  conjunction with other authors, but  I'm 
    not sure.  One was something like "Lathe  of  God";  the other "Joshua, 
    SOn of None".  It was so long ago,  I  can't  remember  anything  about 
    "Lathe of God", except that it was put on TV,  possibly  PBS  [??] MANY 
    years ago...  "Joshua, Son of None" was a good read,  about the cloning 
    of  JFK.  Forget exactly how it turned out, but I don't  think  it  was 
    happy.
    
    Then  again, maybe my memory is doing its usual, & Niven wasn't involved 
    with either...  Ah, the side effects of middle age :-)
    
    Anyhow, I  enjoyed  "RingWorld" once I got into it.  "Man-Kzin Wars" is 
    excellent,  particulalry  about  the  telepathic  human  that  projects 
    himself as a Kzin.    Neat  ending  to  that  one!  [But not written by 
    Niven.] Amazing how the SF authors are doing that now, writing in other 
    author's scenarios..
    
    I've been reading SF since about 1954.  I'm now the "older" generation, 
    'cause I remember how my parents &  others  used  to  view it as trash:  
    Asimov, Heinlein, Bradbury, VOnnegut..  Back then, I  had read every SF 
    novel in Needham Public Library.  I think their  collection then fit on 
    one or two very small shelves...  Amazing how the  genre  evolved.  I'm 
    no great SF trivia freak;  it's just my preferred way  to  escape!   My 
    wife reads trashy romantic novels; I read SF!  Good stuff cheap.
    
815.26ESGWST::RDAVISBlue devils for a brown studyFri Aug 21 1992 15:453
    "Lathe of Heaven" was by that hard sf icon, Ursula K. LeGuin.
    
    Ray
815.27M-KW IVCGHUB::PENNEY_WBaffled by BureaucracyMon Aug 24 1992 15:394
    Well, the  book  I  read  was Man_Kzin Wars IV.  Can't remember the two 
    authors, but I'd  recommend  it  highly.  Last story was neat, if a bit 
    short.  Loved the ending.
    
815.28more Niven on the waySA1794::CHARBONNDBush in '92 - Barbara!Tue Aug 25 1992 08:343
    I understand that Niven and Jerry Pournelle are working on the sequel
    to "The Mote in God's Eye" - should be interesting when they get it
    finished.
815.29VSSCAD::SIGELTue Aug 25 1992 15:268
Re .28

>    I understand that Niven and Jerry Pournelle are working on the sequel
>    to "The Mote in God's Eye" - should be interesting when they get it
>    finished.

They have finished it.  I don't recall whether it's due out late this year
or sometime in 1993.
815.30Niven has run dryVSSCAD::ALTMANBARBWed Sep 02 1992 19:255
I also read about a year ago that when asked why he hadn't published
anything lately, Niven answered that he was blocked, and could not write.
The partnerships have allowed him to do some work.  The Man/Kzin set of
books are written by other people in Niven's universe.
BTW, the Kzin go WAY back before Ringworld.
815.31SWAM1::HERKELRAT_RAIf they fire one, we'll fire one. One fired, sirFri Sep 04 1992 00:415
    The sequel to Mote in Gods Eye has two titles.  In the US it will
    be issued as The Gripping Hand, while the British title will be
    The Mote Around Murchinson's Eye.
    
    US publication is scheduled for Feb 93, I believe.
815.32KACIE::SANDERI do more in a week than most people do in a day :-)Tue Sep 08 1992 20:421
MAN KZIN V  is now out....