[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::sf

Title:Arcana Caelestia
Notice:Directory listings are in topic 2
Moderator:NETRIX::thomas
Created:Thu Dec 08 1983
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1300
Total number of notes:18728

595.0. "Where does "Freedom - I Won't" come from?" by EXIT26::STRATTON (I'm Noting as fast as I can) Sun Mar 13 1988 03:01

        Can anyone tell me the name/author of a particular short
        story?  About all I remember was that a military space
        vessel landed on a planet, and tried, without success,
        to contact the leaders (there weren't any) and to force
        the natives to do things (which they wouldn't).
        
        The other major thing I remember is that the natives had
        a "weapon" that was actually a slogan/philosophy - "Freedom
        - I Won't".
        
        Thanks,
        
Jim Stratton
        
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
595.1are you a gand? myob!ARCANA::CONNELLYHill of dreamsMon Mar 14 1988 01:325
Sounds familiar...i think the last line of the story was:
"And then there were none."  Maybe that was the title too?

Author was C. M. Kornbluth, i think.
595.2possible title/authorMLNTSC::CESANIMon Mar 14 1988 07:3543
    i read it a lot of years ago and seem to recall that it went by
    the title "and then there were none" indicating the fact that
    the philosophy converted everyone 
    
    the author was Eric Frank Russell
    
    possible minor spoiler
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    
    it was something about being a gand (or gandhi type non violent
    person) or an antigand
    
    there were two terms ob(ligations)
    			 myob (Mind Your Own Businness) 
    which become clear to the terrans during the story
    
    
595.3SA1794::CHARBONNDJAFOMon Mar 14 1988 11:271
    Doesn't that bring to mind the Star Trek episode "Mirror, Mirror"?
595.4BAKHOE::KENAHMy journey begins with my first stepMon Mar 14 1988 13:387
    "...And Then There Were None" can be found in the Science Fiction
    Hall of Fame collection, Volume II.
                        
    Very good story.
    
    					andrew
    
595.5top-notch authorINK::KALLISWhy is everyone getting uptight?Tue Mar 15 1988 13:217
    Re .4 (Andrew):
                  
    >Very good story.
    
    Nearly anything by Eric frank Russell can be so categorized.
    
    Steve Kallis, Jr.
595.6Here's anotherMEO78B::MCGHIElooking for a door...Sat Apr 02 1988 11:0413
    I've read a book by James P Hogan (ex-Digit) which follows the same
    basic concept as queried in .0
    
    It was called "Voyage from Yesteryear'
    
    I thought it was really good, put forward some really interesting
    ideas on the way people/society behaves etc.
    
    Mike
    
    	bye the way, I've read as many James P Hogan books as I can
    findl and Igve enjoyed them all
    
595.7Cause and effectEXIT26::STRATTONI'm Noting as fast as I canMon Apr 04 1988 02:568
        re .6 and the reference to Hogan's _Voyage From Yesteryear_...
        
        In fact, I had just re-read that book and "And Then There
        Were None" came to mind - that's why I asked .0 in the
        first place.
        
Jim Stratton
        
595.8I forgot the titleELIS::BUREMAPRUNE JUICE: The warrior's drinkFri Sep 18 1992 12:499
    I know this is a bit late...
    
    But this sounds like a story by Robert Heinlein. I think the slogan of
    the natives was "TANSTAAFL" (There Ain't No Such Thing As A Free
    Lunch).
    
    FWIW,
    
    Wildrik
595.9MYOB! -- Mind Your Own Business!WHO301::BOWERSDave Bowers @WHOFri Sep 18 1992 14:310
595.10SWAM1::HERKELRAT_RAIf they fire one, we'll fire one. One fired, sirFri Sep 18 1992 18:568
    Re: -.2
    
    You're thinking of one of the best all time sf novels, The Moon Is A
    Harsh Mistress.  Don't ya just love a computer with a sense of humor?
    Sonic booms in the authority compound, toilets running backwards and
    a televanglist that marks the spot of his demise with an "X".
    
    Herk