[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::sf

Title:Arcana Caelestia
Notice:Directory listings are in topic 2
Moderator:NETRIX::thomas
Created:Thu Dec 08 1983
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1300
Total number of notes:18728

474.0. "Jewish SF" by JLR::REDFORD () Thu May 14 1987 21:20

    The mention of Jewish SF in another note prompted me to start a
    discussion of it here.  What books fall into this category?
    I can think of a couple:
    
    "Diasporah" by W. R. Yates (I think) - Israel is reborn as a space
    colony after being destroyed by a nuclear war.
    
    "The Red Magician" by Lisa Goldstein - Black versus white magic
    in a Czech village about to be overrun by the Nazis.
    
    "The Tsaddik of the Seven Wonders" by Isadore Hablium - A comic 
    novel, but read too long ago to remember.
    
    The last two are fantasy, but we'll count them too.

    Of course, there is the Golem story from the Middle Ages, which
    probably counts as the first robot.  Any others?  

    /jlr

    PS Would the loss of the Earth in Asimov's future history count as a Jewish
    theme?  There are actually quite a few stories where Earth is destroyed
    and the remanants of humanity must make their way in the galactic empire.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
474.1oneSTUBBI::B_REINKEthe fire and the rose are oneFri May 15 1987 03:194
    The Well World Series which more or less has Nathan Brasil -
    who was/is a rabbi in different incarnations of the universe...
    
    by Jack Chalker
474.2Foundation ?LDP::HAFEZAmr A. Hafez 'On the EVE of Destruction'Tue May 19 1987 13:315
    While not explicit, I believe that Asimov's foundation series was
    inspired by the creation and growth of the state of Israel. 
    
    Amr
    
474.3RomeBANDIT::MARSHALLhunting the snarkTue May 19 1987 14:5615
    re .2:
    
    Asimov has said that the Foundation Series was inspired by the Roman
    Empire. The fall of the Galactic Empire was meant to follow the
    fall of the Roman Empire.
    
    Now, whether there are similarities between the modern nation of
    Israel and the (first?) Foundation, is another matter.
    
                                                   
                  /
                 (  ___
                  ) ///
                 /
    
474.4WANDERING STARSMXOV00::ZAJBERTWed Jun 03 1987 23:3214
	Some years ago a friend lent me a book called "Wandering Stars"
which is an anthology of SF short stories by jewish authors.

	The stories were very good and it is the only book I've read that 
has an accent (Yiddish, of course).

	I don't remember who was the editor.

	I highly recomend it if you can find it. It seems it was printed some
time ago and I don't know if it is still available.

						Mauricio

474.5WANDERING STARS by Jack DannISWSW::VILAINMIOHMIGOD, a real valley boy...Thu Jun 04 1987 04:0013
    WANDERING STARS by Jack Dann
    
    Mom got it through the SFBK and it's still in her library.  I also
    saw a copy in my temple's library!  I think it's out of print though
    so you may have to hunt through used book stores or have your local
    SF bookseller (like DANGERIOUS VISIONS or CHANGE OF HOBBIT in LA
    or THE OTHER CHANGE OF HOBBIT in Berkely).
    
    Great book.  It has I AM SEARCHING FOR KADAK by Harlan Ellison and
    other fun stories (like ON VENUS, HAVE WE GOT A RABBI! by Robert
    Silverberg).
    
    /MeV/
474.6"Cross" Reference...BMT::MENDESFree Lunches For SaleThu Jun 04 1987 04:155
    Also, see Note 442.76 (which seems to have been the precursor for
    this note). There was a WANDERING STARS sequel. (May have some of
    the stories you're looking for in .5)
    
    - Richard
474.7"A Canticle for Liebowitz"LDP::BUSCHTue Jan 19 1988 11:539
Would "A Canticle for Liebowitz" qualify?  Actually, the only Jewish characters 
in the story are the martyred scientist, Liebowitz, and the tent maker in the 
first section of the book. The rest of the action takes place during three
periods in the life of a monastary dedicated to St. Liebowitz.  The story
ends with an exodus from a doomed Earth with the hopes of re-establishing
civilization somewhere "out there".  Sorry, I don't remember all the details.

Dave

474.8Does it get better?ANGORA::MLOEWENo problemTue Jan 19 1988 18:3816
    re "A Canticle for Liebowitz"
    
    I'm currently reading this right now.  I'm a couple of chapters
    into the second section.  Frankly, I'm still having trouble picking
    up on it.  I find it moving too slow.  I think I know what
    they're trying to hit upon, but they haven't answered any of the
    questions yet; Who is the "Wanderer"?  Is Liebowitz really a Saint?
    What are the Liebowitz blueprints of?
    
    Also, does the book have to have so much Latin in it?  I have to skip
    over the material whenever they go into a Latin speaking paragraph.
    Does the book get anymore interesting?  I read somewhere in this 
    conference that it was pretty good.
    Has anyone else read it?
    
    Mike_L
474.9Good all the way through!IND::BOWERSCount Zero InterruptTue Jan 19 1988 18:5810
    re -.1;
    
    -	It continues at a fairly contemplative pace.
    
    -	Don't expect answers to your questions.
    
    -	It's high on my "best ever" list.
    
    -dave
    
474.10I liked it.LDP::BUSCHTue Jan 19 1988 20:0631
< Is Liebowitz really a Saint?

I think "Sainthood is in the eyes of the beholder". He was trying, as I recall, 
to preserve knowledge in the form of books from the book burning fanatics who 
would plunge the world back into the dark ages.

< What are the Liebowitz blueprints of?

Some electrical circuit, I believe, but this is irrelevant since the prints are 
revered simply as relics as is the cryptic shopping list found in the fallout
shelter (or whatever it was, my memory is hazy).

< Also, does the book have to have so much Latin in it?  I have to skip
< over the material whenever they go into a Latin speaking paragraph.

It's probably not mandatory but it is interesting to get the translations. There
is a phrase in Hebrew in the first section which, when translated, simply states
what was already stated in English, something to the effect that the hermit is a
tent maker.

< Does the book get anymore interesting?

I thought the ending had some parts which gave me a bit of philosophy to ponder.
BTW, did you notice that the names of the Abbots in each section started with a
letter of the alphabet indicating their relative position in the chronology?

One more point. There was a serialized radio dramatizaton of the story on PBS a
few years ago. That was what interested me in reading the book. It was OK but I 
prefered the book.

Dave
474.11RE 474.10DICKNS::KLAESI would advise youse ta keep dialin'.Tue Jan 19 1988 20:3512
    	The blueprint Francis found was of a nuclear missle, codenamed
    "Squirrel Cage".  Of course the monks who read and copied it had
    no idea what it was, and they especially didn't think the device
    depicted on the paper could catch squirrels. :^)
    
    	I find this novel to be one of the best SF novels ever written,
    and the radio play was excellent as well.  Except for the "Wandering
    Jew" and Leibowitz in the story, the book is actually oriented to
    the Roman Catholic Church.
    
    	Larry
    
474.12beyond my schematics editorJLR::REDFORDTue Jan 19 1988 21:4511
474.13It's good to see MLS's name is getting around! :-)YODA::BARANSKInot free love, love freelyWed Apr 20 1988 17:140