[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::sf

Title:Arcana Caelestia
Notice:Directory listings are in topic 2
Moderator:NETRIX::thomas
Created:Thu Dec 08 1983
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:1300
Total number of notes:18728

310.0. "R. A. MacAvoy" by PROSE::WAJENBERG () Thu Mar 06 1986 18:21

Roberta A. MacAvoy has written five fantasy novels that I know of:

		Tea with the Black Dragon

		A Trio for Lute
			Damiano
			Damiano's Lute
			Raphael

		The Book of Kells

I have read all but "The Book of Kells."  The other four as certainly quite 
good.  MacAvoy's heros are gentle, civilized people with strong senses of duty 
and immense quantities of grit.  I like them very much.

"Tea with the Black Dragon" is set in modern-day California.  The fantasy 
element is very subdued, but it is there and all the more intriguing for being 
subdued.  Our heroine is a semi-impoverished musician summoned to Silicon 
Valley by her daughter, a programmer, who has got herself in some mysterious 
trouble.  She arrives to find the daughter missing and a hotel room waiting 
for her.  While staying in the hotel and wondering about her daughter, she 
meets a Eurasian gentleman named Mayland Long.  He appears to be about her 
age, is urbane, cultured, courteous, and very gently enamoured of her.  He 
offers to help her find her daughter, and the book is about their subsequent 
adventures.  Notice any fantasy elements in there?  Right, there aren't any.  
Except for the odd things that Mr. Long says from time to time, and his just 
faintly superhuman abilities.

The "Trio for Lute" is very solidly fantasy.  It starts with Damiano taking a 
music lesson from his lute teacher.  Only Damiano is a warlock in Italy during 
the Avignon papacy, and his lute teacher is the archangel Raphael. In the 
first book, Damiano sets out to save his home town from being destroyed in the 
wars between city-states that wracked Italy at that time.  

The second book is about Damiano figuring out what to do with his life -- more
exciting than it might sound when his two options are magic and music, papal
intrigues brew all around him, Satan himself is out to get him, he is falling 
in love with a Finnish witch three times his age, and the Black Death stalks 
the land.

Through both these books, Raphael is Damiano's guide and advisor.  The third 
book is mostly about Raphael's adventures brought on him by his fallen brother 
Lucifer.

Damiano, the Finnish witch Saara, Damiano's talking dog Machiata, and Raphael
are all interesting characters, and all very different from each other.  
Damiano is dreamy and idealistic; Saara is just the reverse; Machiata says 
what you always knew dogs would say if they could.  Raphael is in some ways 
the most interesting.  He is gentle, even sweet, and throws no lighting bolts. 
But he is quite simply an astonishing flash of beauty and goodness.  He LOOKS 
exactly like a Renaissance picture of an angel, but he communicates none of 
the mawkish sentimentality and sugariness we have come to associate with that 
image.

Earl Wajenberg
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
310.1"Twisting the Rope"PROSE::WAJENBERGMon Sep 15 1986 15:2524
    MacAvoy has produced a sequel to "Tea with the Black Dragon," entitled
    "Twisting the Rope."  It takes place a few years after the first
    novel, in 1986 in fact.  Mayland Long and Martha Macnamara are still
    a couple, though Martha has so far not accepted Mayland's proposals.
    They are running a concert tour of a traditional Irish music band.
    One of the band members turns up dead and everyone is suspect.
    
    Just as in "Tea with the Black Dragon," the fantasy elements in
    this book are very subdued.  More subdued, in a way, than in the
    first book.  It is a pretty good read, but I found it less engrossing
    that TwtBD, perhaps because the fantasy element, when revealed,
    wasn't nearly as remarkable as the element revealed in TwtBD.
    
    At least it shows a realistic version (barring the immediate problems
    they are solving) of what the "happily ever after" of the first novel
    would be like.  Also, you get to meet Martha and Mayland again,
    which I find pleasant in itself.  Perhaps this is the middle book
    of a trilogy and just suffering from mid-trilogy slump, a common
    ailment.
    
    If you really liked "Tea with the Black Dragon," you may kinda like
    this one.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
310.2The Grey HorsePROSE::WAJENBERGTue Jun 02 1987 13:446
    I have recently read "The Grey Horse," a new fantasy by MacAvoy,
    set in Victorian Ireland.  I recommend it highly.  The hero is a
    puka, a shapeshifting fairy.  He is an interesting character, earthy,
    innocent, and likeable, but still not entirely human.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
310.3Some others ?RDGE00::ALFORDDragon Riders do it in between ....Fri Jun 05 1987 09:027
	I might be wrong, but aren't the books Beauty, The Blue Sword
	and it's sequel (I cann't remember it's name), also by MacAvoy ?

	If they are, and anyone wants to know more I will dig them out
	of my library and post summaries.

	CJA
310.4Not those othersPROSE::WAJENBERGFri Jun 05 1987 12:245
    If "Beauty" is the recent re-telling of the Beauty-and-the-Beast
    story, then no, it isn't by MacAvoy, though I can't remember the
    author's name.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
310.5Robin McKinley, not R. A. MacAvoyTALLIS::SIGELFri Jun 05 1987 20:2612
    
    The books you're thinking of are by Robin McKinley, not Roberta
    MacAvoy.  McKinley writes excellent children's fantasy (YA, too)
    and has won the Newbery Award and had a Newbery Honor Book. Her
    books include:
       BEAUTY
       THE BLUE SWORD (Newbery Honor)
       THE HERO AND THE CROWN (Newbery Award)
       THE DOOR IN THE HEDGE (novelettes)
    
    Andrew Sigel
    
310.6RDGE00::ALFORDDragon Riders do it in between ....Mon Jun 08 1987 16:108
	Re: .-1

	Yup, your'e right, I looked them up over the weekend.

	I enjoyed them anyway, even if they are not by R.A.MacAvoy.
	I haven't read THE DOOR IN THE HEDGE though, any good ?

	CJA
310.7They don't give those awards for nothing...TALLIS::SIGELMon Jun 08 1987 19:302
    Haven't read anything by McKinley that isn't any good.
    	Andrew
310.8SOFTY::HEFFELFINGERThe valient Spaceman Spiff!Tue Jun 09 1987 19:1014
    	And oh by the way...
    
    	Don't be put off by a book because it's a "children's book".
    In fact, The sight of the Newberry award on any fantasy book will
    make my buy it even if I've never heard of the author in my life.
    
    	Another vote for the McKinley books.  Beauty was marvolous and
    I can't wait for another book in the Damar series.  Door in the Hedge
    is a bit less acessible than her other books, I found, but not bad.
    McKinley is one of the half dozen authors that I ALWAYS look for
    and that Gary (my husband) knows he should buy on sight.
    
tlh
        
310.9PROSE::WAJENBERGWed Jun 10 1987 13:171
    Perhaps it's time to start a topic on McKinley?
310.10Sorry, couldn't resist it ..RDGE00::ALFORDDragon Riders do it in between ....Wed Jun 10 1987 15:148


	Re: .7    -< They don't give those awards for nothing... >-



	Yeah, but they're American ..... :^}
310.11"Lens of the World"ATSE::WAJENBERGMon Jun 17 1991 12:3337
    R. A. MacAvoy has come out with a new novel, "Lens of the World," the
    first in a trilogy.  For those of you who, like me, are sick of 
    sequelitis, take heart; MacAvoy knows how to write a real trilogy
    (three separate but linked novels, as opposed to one novel published in
    three installments).  I would never have known this was a triology if
    the cover hadn't said so.  Furthermore, if the "Trio for Lute" is any
    guide, the next book need not suffer from mid-trilogy slump.
    
    "Lens of the World" is an epistolary novel, written as a series of
    letters from the narrator to his king.  The narrator is Nazhuret "the
    Goblin," aged forty, narrating the adventures he had around age 20.
    He was an ugly little shrimp of a boy, growing up at an Eton-like
    boarding school for gentry, sponsored by a remote uncle, with no known
    parentage himself.  After graduation he meets Powl, a man who becomes
    (though that word is never used) his guru, and the adventures start.
    
    This is MacAvoy's first fantasy set in a fictitious world.  (But not
    her first such fiction.  "Third Eagle" is set in an SF future.)  At
    first I thought it was the semi-standard medieval-or-something world of
    Tolkien-and-water fantasy, but no, it's a Renaissance-or-something
    world.  Watching the parallels and differences is interesting.  The
    narrator's country is sort of like England a century or so after the
    Norman conquest, but, like France, borders a country full of people
    like Moors.  So far, so medieval.  But the technical level is
    definitely renaissance, as the reference to lenses shows.
    
    But the unreality of the nations and languages is nearly the only
    fantasy touch.  The hero MAY encounter a werewolf, but he is never
    really sure.  He certainly encounters a large carnivore, but whether it
    should be called a dragon or not is very arguable.  No one does any
    obviously effective magic.  But, as with "Tea with the Black Dragon,"
    this very light tincture of fantasy works well.  For one thing, it
    keeps you guessing, since you do not know what is truly possible here.
    
    And, as always, MacAvoy's characters and narrative style are excellent.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
310.12"King of the Dead"CUPMK::WAJENBERGMon Mar 29 1993 16:3621
    After a long gap, the second book of the "Lens of the World" trilogy
    has come out.  It is called "The King of the Dead" and is the further
    adventures of Nazhuret.  (See .11.)
    
    "King of the Dead" is what Nazhuret's name means in the language of
    Rezhmia.  Rezhmia is the vaguely Arabic nation bordering on Velonya,
    the vaguely Norman-English nation where Nazhuret lives.  He has a
    foreign name because his mother was Rezhmian -- and of noble birth. 
    This geneology, combined with the yogi-like skills he acquired in the
    previous book, are the reason he is sent on an espionage/diplomatic
    mission to Rezhmia, to try to head off a war.
    
    He is accompanied by his lady-love, Arlin, whom we met in the first
    book, a sort of lady musketeer.  (She is not typical of Velonyan or 
    Rezhmian women, a fact that is not only rationalized but made an 
    integral feature of the plot.)
    
    I haven't finished the book yet, but it looks as if MacAvoy does indeed
    avoid the mid-trilogy slump as I said in .11.
    
    Earl Wajenberg
310.13NETRIX::thomasThe Code WarriorMon Mar 29 1993 16:514
I read _KotD_ before _LotW_ and found I liked _KotD_ much better.  In fact,
given the wrappers for each novel, it makes more sense that way.  Nazhuret
writing for his tutor in the second book, while in the first for the king
about his tutor (after the tutor had died).