[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

2410.0. "Decisions, decisions..." by RANGER::GORCZYCA () Thu Sep 10 1992 13:54

Problem: My wife and I both have ~20 year old Raleigh "Grand Prix" 10-speed
         bicycles that definitely need work.  We've been riding more during
         the last couple of years (to/from work 1-2 times/week, 25 miles 
         round-trip...also geared up for and completed the MS150), but still
         can't be classified as "enthusiasts"...we do this more for exercise
         than for fun.

Possible Solutions:

	1) Stop biking
	2) Bike with cycle in current condition an apply fixes "as required"
	   (Bike shops really hate working on these bikes, however, since they
	    no longer have replacement parts)
	3) Completely overhaul each bike replacing:
		- wheels
		- crank sets & pedals
		- deraillers & brakes
	4) Buy new bikes

Preferences:

	1) Not really an option at this time
	2) Easiest option BUT I hate my current derailler system and the various
	   noises that this never-been-overhauled cycle makes.
	3) This is the option that, intellectually, make the most sense.
	   On the plus side:
		- I'm not into racing, so I don't need the lightest frame made
		  (also, I'd rather lose the weight in my body...)
		- I can pick and choose the parts I want
		- It "seems" like it should be a cost effective solution
	   On the minus side:
		- I don't know if new parts will fit my frame
		- I don't know if this really *is* a cost effective solution
		- I don't know if a brand new bike can offer me something that
		  I simply can't get through this approach
	4) This is the option that, emotionally, is most appealing.
	   On the plus side:
		- I can try before I buy
		- I know that all the parts will work together
		- My invested $'s aren't as wasted, if I were to sell, as in #3
		- I get a shiny new bike!
	   On the minuse side:
		- I know that I'd spend at least $700-$1000 per bike
		  (I like expensive/hi-tech "parts"...though I'm not hung-up
		   on expensive/hi-tech frames, the two seem to only go together
		   when buying a new bike.)
		- I'm not sure that these bikes won't start gathering dust next
		  year, just like my old bikes did for most of their lifes.

Sooo, since I obviously have mixed emotions on this topic, I'd really appreciate
any opinions on this topic...especially from folks who have faced a similar
decision and went with options #3 or #4.

Thanks,
John

T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2410.1new bike, but selectivelySHALOT::ELLISJohn Lee Ellis - assembly requiredThu Sep 10 1992 14:0221
    
    A lot of the people here are bike enthusiasts (read: obsessives)
    so replies (such as mine) will be tainted in that regard.
    
    Yes, #3 or #4 sounds best.  I think you'll find it more trouble and
    expense than it's worth to go for #3.  Things may not fit quite right,
    and components bought separately can be more expensive than a new
    "bundled" bike.  Also, another plus with #4 is you have a "beater bike"
    or back-up bike in reserve!  (That is, your old bike.)
    
    You can get quite a good bike for $700 - though it may seem expensive
    to you.  Or $600.  The Bridgestone RB-2 is an example of a well-designed
    steel frame with carefully chosen, mixed components (value for money,
    not the blanket use of one gruppo from one manufacturer, e.g., "all
    Shimano 105").  But there are other choices out there, too.
    
    Other people may be able to comment on the quality of the Raleigh
    Grand Prix frame.  As everyone will say, the frame is the most important
    component - go for quality there, if you have to skimp anywhere.
    
    -john
2410.2Broaden Your Options?ODIXIE::RRODRIGUEZWhere's that Tour d' France thang?Thu Sep 10 1992 14:1120
2410.3Go ride a few....SALEM::SHAWThu Sep 10 1992 14:1326
    
    John, 
    
     It might just be that your enthusism (sp?) level is not as high 
     due to the condition of the bikes. In my opinion, getting hi-tec
     components for an old (20 year old) frame that was nothing special
     to begin with, is not a good investment. At a recreational level
     going to index shifting could probably make a difference on your
     bike, and good wheels.  
     One nice approach IMO is to find a good bike shop with a variety of 
     bikes, road (sport, touring) hybrid, and ATBs. Try them, most stores
     will allow you to take the bike out to ride. See which one best 
     suits your needs, eg, your wife will probably be happier/more 
     comfortable on a hybrid, you might prefer ... etc...
     Once you decide which type suits you best, then you can compare
     between you current bike and the new feel. 
     For recreational riders, there are many good deals especially this
     time of year, which is slower for bike shops and you can find very
     good deals for last years models.  I don't think you need to 
     spent $700.00, unless you plan on doing some serious off road or
     racing or touring...On a recreational level, for last years models
     you could find new bikes from $250.00 to $450.00 which would be 
     just dandy. Compare to spending money on wheels and components on 
     your old bike, which would cost about the same. 
    
     Shaw
2410.4NOVA::FISHERRdb/VMS DinosaurThu Sep 10 1992 16:528
    Go for 4, it's probably cheaper in the long run.
    
    If you're not too fussy, the best prices should be available
    in October -- end of season sales and still before Christmas.
    
    as for .1's "obsessives".  WHO? ME?  Nah.
    
    ed
2410.5How about used?CIMNET::MJOHNSONMatt JohnsonThu Sep 10 1992 16:535
    Also check out any used bikes for sale.  There are many in this
    conference, and many in the Want Advertiser and other places.  A lot of
    people either find that they don't ride, or get totally fanatical and
    trade up -- leaving plenty of nice, fairly new bikes for sale at good
    prices.
2410.6PIPPER::GOODThu Sep 10 1992 17:1711
    
    	I too have a Grand Prix that is sitting somewhere in the past
    residences. I overhauled it 8 or so years ago and it is rideable
    today. New cost $170 cost to fix up (9 years ago) $85. I did the work
    and scrounged for deals. It now has a 600 rear derailer and a 6 speed
    cassette and kevlar tires and brakes and grips and seat. If you have
    the shop do the work and you replace the inferior cranks the cost will
    exceed the worth of the bike.(poor economics)
    	The Grand Prix frame is too soft too.
    
    	Roger
2410.7go for the new bikesNAC::GULICKThose dirty rings !!Thu Sep 10 1992 17:1810
Hi John,

I have seen your machines up close & personal and I do believe that they should
be retired. I think you'll be very pleasantly surprised at the advances made
since you bought your last set of bikes.

The "end of season" sales should start to happen very soon...

good luck,
-tom
2410.8You already put in the miles, you should enjoy them!TLE::TLE::BODGEAndy BodgeFri Sep 11 1992 15:5116
    > My wife and I both have ~20 year old Raleigh "Grand Prix" 10-speed
    > bicycles that definitely need work.  We've been riding more during
    > the last couple of years (to/from work 1-2 times/week, 25 miles
    > round-trip...also geared up for and completed the MS150), but still
    > can't be classified as "enthusiasts"...we do this more for exercise
    > than for fun.
    
    I think you've earned some new hardware!  Whether or not you do it for
    fun, you'll enjoy it a lot more if you don't have to deal with the
    problems inherent with old machinery - to say nothing of the joys of
    light wheels, indexed shifting, etc.  Since you don't seem to be hung
    up on high performance or equipment mystique, you'll find good,
    dependable, enjoyable bicycles for $500 or less - bicycles that'll last
    another 20 years.
    
    Andy (who waited only 14 years, not 20)
2410.9NWACES::HICKERNELLFri Sep 11 1992 17:274
    Just go to a big bike shop and test ride a few.  That will answer your
    question, believe me.
    
    Dave
2410.10Test Ride Rule #1DECWET::GREGORYQuick what is 93**7?Fri Sep 11 1992 18:405
    Never test ride a bike that you aren't prepared to buy.  A new bike
    will always make your old bike seem like a dog.  And it isn't fun to
    ride the old one anymore.
    
    Peter
2410.11RUTILE::LETCHERNo Way, Know How, No CompromiseWed Sep 16 1992 10:408
    I upgraded to new bikes last year and would definitely recommend option
    #4. New bikes are relatively cheap compared to the components, and the
    new features (indexed shifting, especially) are wonderful. It needn't
    cost you the earth, as others here have said.
    
    Piers
    
    Peter: the answer is 60170087060757.
2410.12try note #2CTHQ::LANGLOISCT/TSMon Sep 21 1992 16:315
    Also, check out note #2 in this conference which is the FOR SALE note.
    You might be able to find a nice bike(s) of recent vintage in good shape
    for reasonable dollars.
    
    						Thom...
2410.13The final decision...RANGER::GORCZYCAPATHWORKS/NetWare Product ManagerFri May 14 1993 17:5610
Well....er...we took the plunge (I knew I would).

2 shiny new Trek 2200's now grace my garage next to my 20-yr-old Raleigh's,
172,000-mi, '82 RX7, and 176,00-mi Jeep.

Now I REALLY need a nice little commuting car...maybe a Lexus SC400??

Thanks for the advice, but the STI's finally did me in.
John

2410.14Congrats!!BIGBAD::GULICKThose dirty rings !!Fri May 14 1993 18:146
except now I won't be able to hear you & Ann coming up behind me at the MS150
(it was no trouble with your Raleighs)

STI will be a must on my next bike.

-tom