[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

2375.0. "Mountainbike spindle/bottom bracket question." by TOOPHE::FIKE () Thu Aug 06 1992 12:24

	I have a question - about spindles/bottom brackets and couldn't
find this discussed in a search of the present notes.

	On a mountain bike; should the spindle that goes through the 
bottom bracket be centered? or offset?

	On my bike I noticed that with the crank extended horizontally 
parallel to the chainstays, that there is about 1/8" clearance on the
left side and when I rotate the chainside crank back to the horizontal
position parallel to the chainstay it shows over 1/2" clearance. 
	If I can center it I would have equal clearance on both sides which 
would probably prevent my left heel from hitting the chainstay (which I have
done occasionally in rough trail riding). I realize I would have to 
re-align the front derailler because the position of the chainrings would be
closer to the frame.
	Can the spindle be adjusted side-to-side??

	Another quick question- I am going to have to get into the BB anyway
because I noticed a small amount of "play" in the movement of the cranks
(side to side) and a small amount of rusty looking water seeping out where
the spindle comes through on the chainring side (I do ride through some
puddles and hose the mud off later). I am assuming by seeing the water that
my bike doesn't have sealed cartridge bearings and am thinking of replacing
whatevers in there with them. A shimano Deore sealed cartridge bearing cost
about $30. Is this a good way to go or should I just tear the old bearings
out and clean and repack them with waterproof grease (White lithium? regular
car bearing grease? other? any suggestions?). By the way, I've only got about
300 woods-trail miles on the bike so far.
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
2375.1a startSHALOT::ELLISJohn Lee Ellis - assembly requiredThu Aug 06 1992 13:1119
	On a mountain bike; should the spindle that goes through the 
bottom bracket be centered? or offset?

>	On my bike I noticed that with the crank extended horizontally 
>parallel to the chainstays, that there is about 1/8" clearance on the
>left side and when I rotate the chainside crank back to the horizontal
>position parallel to the chainstay it shows over 1/2" clearance. 
    
    Interesting.
    
>	Can the spindle be adjusted side-to-side??
    
    Typically not.  The spindle's races must be oriented with respect to the
    BB cups.
    
    Further commentary from MTB-equipment experts?
    
    -john
2375.2Chain line?DEBUG::SCHULDTAs Incorrect as they come...Thu Aug 06 1992 13:592
    I would have thought that the spindle would be adjusted for the best
    chain line...
2375.3maybe like this?SUSHI::KMACDONALDThu Aug 06 1992 15:1313
>    I would have thought that the spindle would be adjusted for the best
>    chain line...

at least on road bikes, the following applies: One arm of the spindle is 
typically longer (race to end of spindle, sometimes QUITE subtle). The 
long side is the chainwheel side. In the 'classic' configuration of BB, 
one side of the BB assembly was a 'fixed' cup. This meant that your 
spindle always ended up at the same distance out. If it didn't give the 
right chainline, tough (have seen spacers used to get the spindle out 
further occasionally). Many of the more recent BB's have adjustable cups 
on both sides, and by adjusting one in and the other out, you can affect 
chainline, crankarm->frame clearance, etc. Was that the question? :-)
                                      ken
2375.4Elevated chainstays?NQOPS::CLELANDNothin' special, it's just meThu Aug 06 1992 16:1125
    	What brand name is the ATB?
    
    	Is it a factory configuration?
    	If so, are you saying the manufacturer doesn't know what they're
    	doing? What line/level of components are on the bike? What is the
    	crankarm length? 175 mm?
    
    	Crank arm clearance is generally irrelevant with triple chainring
    	configurations. The critical clearance point(s) are the three
    	chainrings. It is difficult to build a frame that handles fat
    	tires, and allows for optimal alignment of the chainrings with
    	the rear cogset, be it a standard freewheel or a cassette freehub.
    	Elevated chainstays solve that particular problem, but that's
    	another story altogether.
    
    	With regard to crankarm clearance: as of late, the measurement to
    	check is the Q-factor, or overall distance between the left and
    	right crankarm. The larger the Q-factor, the more spread apart
    	your feet are. It is inherent that triple-chainring cranksets have
    	greater Q-factors than double-chainring, simply because of the
    	extra chainring.
    
    	If you buy a replacement bottom bracket, verify the application
    	thoroughly: with regard to overall axle width, chainstay clearance,
    	and compatibility with your existing transmission.
2375.5PIPPER::GOODThu Aug 06 1992 16:4615
    
    	I just installed a Suntour greaseguard BB (see Cannondale note).
    You force grease in thru a hole in the spindle and spindle bolt.
    The Shimano is a good BB (note .0). The chainringside is usually a
    little longer and BB's are not usually adjustable and the chainring
    side is the fixed side and the Q factor is dependent mostly on the
    cranks used. Take the BB apart (requires tools or ingenuity) check
    the races and ball bearings for damage, grease it and put it back
    together. Pound on the crank when installing it then crank down the
    bolt.
    	Most BB's supplied with most bikes including "top of the line"
    models are not very high quality and replacement will always be an
    upgrade. Check the next DX or even XT grupppo you look at on a bike
    and see what I mean. It probably won't have a DX or XT BB.
    	Regards
2375.6what it is/what I meantTOOPHE::FIKEThu Aug 06 1992 16:4918
      <<< Note 2375.4 by NQOPS::CLELAND "Nothin' special, it's just me" >>>
                           -< Elevated chainstays? >-

>    	What brand name is the ATB?
    
>    	Is it a factory configuration?
>    	If so, are you saying the manufacturer doesn't know what they're
>    	doing? What line/level of components are on the bike? What is the
>    	crankarm length? 175 mm?
    

	It's a Raleigh Crest- factory configured-unmodifed. It has Shimano
	400LX/200GS mix of components. I don't recall saying that the 
	manufacturer doesn't know what they're doing; I did say that the 
	crankarm-to-chainstay clearances were different on each side of the
	bike (which may be fine-or not; that's what I was trying to find out). 
	In the bike books I have seen so far, I haven't seen this mentioned
	one way or the other. 
2375.7Greasegard sounds goodTOOPHE::FIKEThu Aug 06 1992 17:0419
                       <<< Note 2375.5 by PIPPER::GOOD >>>

    
>    	I just installed a Suntour greaseguard BB (see Cannondale note).
>    You force grease in thru a hole in the spindle and spindle bolt.


	Thanks!! This sounds like a good setup because you can re-grease
	periodically without tearing the BB apart. I think I'd go with this
	when the time comes. A bike mechanic I spoke with earlier (after I
	entered the basenote) also mentioned the Suntour greasegard due
	to the additional fact that squeezing new grease in forces the old
	grease and grit out. I ride in a lot of dirt, sand, mud and water
	so this sounds like it was made for where I ride. He also mentioned
	that there are adjustments to center the spindle and he tries to
	get it balanced. He's going to take a look at it tommorrow and let
	me know for sure if it's right/wrong/adjustable or what. Thanks again!

			Regards- mike
2375.8Just as general information on BB spindles...NCBOOT::PEREZTrust, but ALWAYS verify!Fri Aug 07 1992 15:129
    You can also buy just the BB spindle for about $4.00 in different
    lengths.  For example, if you have a bike with a double chainring and
    are installing a triple you may need to move the chainring set out
    further to get clearance for the inner ring.  The local shops here in
    Mpls carry spindles where the length from bearing race to the end of
    the taper on the chainring side changes in 4-5 mm increments.  I
    recently converted a bike to a triple, and replaced the original
    spindle with one approximately 5 mm longer to get the right clearance
    and chain line.
2375.9Got the Shimano Sealed BBDNEAST::FIKE_MIKEMon Aug 10 1992 17:4514
    
    Well, I removed the cranks and opened up the bottom bracket and just as
    I suspected, nasty, swampy water came out. The bearings didn't look too
    bad though, but I figured that as long as I had it open, might as well
    check out an upgrade. The mechanic showed me the Suntour grease guard
    and the Shimano sealed unit. The Suntour was $46 and the Shimano was
    $17. I know I hit a lot of puddles and mud, and they both looked like
    they would solve the problem , but I went with the Shimano sealed unit
    because it's completely sealed (so I can clean the bike with the high
    pressure hose once in a while), and it's nonadjustable and expected to
    last about 5 years; but even if I only get 2 years, it's only $17 to
    replace and was pretty quick to install (if you have a splined BB
    tool). I also replaced the stock stem with a longer (135mm) stem- much
    more comfortable to ride now. Thanks again for all the advice!