[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

1878.0. "Questions on Bike Helmets" by SMURF::DEANE () Tue Mar 12 1991 14:41

I'm in the market for a couple of bike helmets for myself
and my 3 year old toddler. I recently visitied out pediatrician
and obtained a form for a discount on Troxel helmets. (about $20
with shipping). Comsumer reports rates the Bell helmets higher
than the Troxel helmets.

Q1: Does anyone have an opinion on which helmet to buy?
Q2: Does anyone know of any other manufacturing discount for bike
    helmets like the Troxel offer?
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1878.1FAVAX::CRITZJohn Ellis to ride RAAM '91Tue Mar 12 1991 14:5712
    	I did a DIR/TITLE=HELMET and got the following notes:
    
    	22, 199, 216, 229, 486, 495, 616, 739, 836, 900
    	1576, 1711, 1805.
    
    	A good helmet is ANSI and SNELL Z90.4 approved. If
    	it doesn't have the SNELL sticker, I wouldn't buy it.
    
    	Scott
    
    	PS: Kudos to you for wanting to protect yourself and your
    	    little kiddo.
1878.2Bell Quest gets my vote.CSCMA::NOETHMike Noeth DTN 237-7014Tue Mar 12 1991 16:056
    I'm a loyal consumer reports advocate so I went shopping armed with
    their data.  I narrowed things down to between the Bell Quest ($60
    retail) and the Giro Hammerhead ($80 retail).  The place I went
    to had the Hammerheads on sale for $60 but I preferred the Quest
    anyway. It's very comfortable (comes with adjustable padding). 
    If you know your size, you can get it mail  order for about $40-45.
1878.3Safety and ComfortCTHQ3::FREREEllas Danzan SolasTue Mar 12 1991 21:0810
    The best bet is not to listen to others preference ;-)
    
    Seriously, go to a reputable bike shop and have the helmets properly
    fitted.  Make sure that they pass ANSI and Snell standards (they
    probably will but check anyways).  It is improtant that the helmets
    fits right for safety and comfort reason (who wants to wear an
    uncomfortable anything?).  Another factor is your pocket book but then
    the small difference in $ can be viewed as good insurance investment.
    
    Eric
1878.4...and buy from a reputable shop.CTHQ3::FREREEllas Danzan SolasTue Mar 12 1991 21:105
    P.S.  Don't go through the trouble of having them fitted by a reputable
    shop and walk away because you can buy it from a discount/mail order
    place.  That, I consider, is unethical.
    
    Eric
1878.5All Foam or not...OFFHK::MURRAYTom, Telecom AD and Architecture, MKO2-1/D9Wed Mar 13 1991 19:5112
One of the bike mags had something to say, that foam helmets with a thin shell
 are safer at some impact angles than only-foam helmets.  There have also
 been concerns that foam can break up on impact, thus a variety of reinforcing
 systems can be found in different designs.

Always buy Snell approved helmets.

Fitting has not been problemantical for me.  Mail ordering works OK.  If you 
 have to send it back, they might even cover return shipping if you complain. 
 Worked for me when I sent a bike rack back to Performance.

Regards, Tom
1878.6OXNARD::KLEEKen LeeTue Mar 26 1991 15:0926
    Well, I went helmet shopping last weekend.  I choose the microshell
    style over the lycra covering style because of the better ventilation
    (lots of hot, slow uphills around here).
    
    I found that proper fitting was very important, at least for me.  The
    sizes given are very approximate.  The helmet must fit you for width,
    lenght, and height, but sizes are measured for circumferance only.  I
    suppose that works if you have "normal" shaped heads, but I guess I
    don't.  Note that the height of a helmet is important.  The Giro and
    ProTec helmets are pretty shallow, while the Specialized and Bell
    helmets are much deeper.  A good rule of thumb is that the helmet
    should come down to near your eyebrows for maximum protection, a half
    inch to an inch higher if you want to trade off protection for better
    peripheral vision.
    
    Also, there is a new Snell helmet test for 1991.  It is slightly
    stricter than the 1990 test.  Helmets passing the new test will have a
    blue Snell sticker, instead of the old green one.
    
    Finally, some of the helmet manufacturers are advertising weights as
    low as 5 or 6 ounces for their helmets.  These are somewhat bogus. 
    Some manufacturers offer helmets in very small sizes and uses those for
    the advertised weights.  The larger sizes of all the brands (microshell
    and lycra covering) all weight around 8 ounces.
    
    Ken