[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

1701.0. "Fisher vs Trek vs Bikeology - Need Advice" by GLDOA::AUGHINBAUGH () Tue Aug 14 1990 22:03

    I am shopping for a new mountain bike. My old ride is a middle of the
    road CyclePro that I have used for the past three years. 
    
    Fisher Mountain Bikes HK-II currently is at the top of my short list.
    Followed by a Trek 990 and the lowend offering from Bikeology. 
    
    The Fisher rides (to me) much better than the Trek. The big question
    with Fisher is the headset design. Is Evolution really here to stay.
    I'm not much of a mechanic and there is only one shop in Indianapolis
    that sells/services Fisher because of the special headset tools, or so
    I am told. Any experienced Fisher owners out there who could comment on
    their durability.
    
    I now own three other Treks, but have never had one of their mountain
    bikes. I would be interested in comments from Trek owners.
    
    Bikeology sure looks like a lot of bike for the money, but I have never
    had much luck ordering via a catalog. I'm concerned whenever I read
    "all major components carefully checked at the factory - simple
    assembly required". Any owners of Bikeology bikes out there? Was it
    simple? Is the bike as good as it sounds?
    
    If all of this or parts of it are covered in other topics, directions
    would be appreciated. Thanks in advance for any and all help.
    
    
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
1701.1Bikeology experienceHPSRAD::SMITHMichael J. Smith, MRO 2-3Wed Aug 15 1990 12:3117
I have a Bikeology ATB, an Access Team.  I got it about a year ago.  When I
made the order they were out of stock and said it would be 10 days before
they could fill the order.  I had the bike within 10 days.  They were easy to
deal with.

The bike came in a big box via UPS.  The assembly consisted of cleaning the
wheels (remove any oil from braking surfaces) and putting them on.  Pedals and
handlebars (stem, handles, cables, etc all assembled) needed to be installed.
Brakes needed to be adjusted.  Drive train was all set up, I did not have to
adjust the shifting.  I'm sure there were a few other odds and ends.  There
were instructions included.  If you have done minor work on a bike and have 
some idea of what the systems are all about you should have no real problem
and there is always this notes file.  I was off in the woods within an hour.

The quality is excellent.  I would do it again but I don't think I will be able
to wear the other one out.  Be sure you know your size and see if you can find
a similar bike to test ride before you order.
1701.2I like my TrekSVCRUS::CRANEWed Aug 15 1990 13:0010
    
      I have a Trek 930 Mountain bike and have absolutly no complaints
    about it.  As a matter of fact I love it !  It cam with Matrix wheels
    and tires that have proven to be bullet proof in even the toughest
    rockiest downhills.  The frame is stable and solid.(even though
    I have to admit the Fat Chance I rode the other weekend was better)
    I don't hesitate to reccomend this bike to anyone.
    
    John C.
    
1701.3No Problems With Fisher 2 years PlusPOWDML::ACOUTUREFri Aug 31 1990 19:5135
    
    
    I have been riding a Fisher Montari SC for 2 years and have had no
    problems. The headset at least on the SC isn't very different from any
    other I have seen. The bottom bracket uses casset bearings, but they
    are not that unusual. You need a tool which removes the retaining clip
    and the whole assembly drops out as a unit. You don't have the
    adjustment hastles like you do with cup and cones..
    
    The SC was equipped the Shimano Deore SC group, a Shark tooth, and Matrix
    wheels. I haven't altered it save for a Blackburn mountain rack and H2O
    cages and a Shark fin to complement the tooth.
    
    I have ridden the bike through h*&& and high water with no problems. I
    do pay a lot of attention to maintenance however. 
    
    In general if you ride in the dirt, rocks, stumps, water bars etc. you
    can spend a bit of time cleaning and adjusting. Although I haven't had the
    problem, I have replaced a few deraileurs on other peoples bikes
    (giggle Treks). I like to poke fun at them and claim that I have a
    better bike, but that damage seems to be luck of the draw.
    
    I have also rented the Trek 850 to try it. The 850 at least, handles
    well, but I don't like the shift levers slung below the handlebars. I
    have also ridden an old Trek 400 elance (sport bike) for 3 year with no
    problems. It was built before Trek moved the 400 down market and it was
    also equiped with Shimano Deore componentry. With the exception of the 
    brakes it has also been an excellent bike. I upgraded them. The only thing
    I question about the Trek ATB's is the lugged frame's ability to take a 
    real beating. My Fisher is a welded chrome molly and is heavy , but it 
    takes a real beating. I jump logs, waterbars, boulders etc. and the bike 
    still looks like new. Good luck...
    
    
                        Arthur Couture