[Search for users] [Overall Top Noters] [List of all Conferences] [Download this site]

Conference noted::bicycle

Title: Bicycling
Notice:Bicycling for Fun
Moderator:JAMIN::WASSER
Created:Mon Apr 14 1986
Last Modified:Fri Jun 06 1997
Last Successful Update:Fri Jun 06 1997
Number of topics:3214
Total number of notes:31946

377.0. "I've got the itch!!!!" by NAC::CAMPBELL () Mon Jul 06 1987 15:03

My current bike is a 1976 Raleigh Competition, and I've recently gotten
the urge to upgrade. The competition has a 531 frame, and Huret derailures.
Actually just the frame tubes, and the fork is 531. It suits my needs for now 
but as I do more riding I keep thinking that maybe I could do better.  I want 
to buy a bike that will keep me happy for quite a while.  I use the bike for 
racing mainly in Triathlons, and I like a real stiff frame since I tend to 
stand on the hills. 

My question really is, will I be able to buy a bike that I will "really"
notice a difference. Not just the "its new" syndrome. Every new bike feels
great but that wears off!

I recently went to Goodales in Nashua and found that just about the most you
can spend there is ~$600, and then you get shimano components on it. I'd like
to spend in the $800 range and I'd like to see something better then shimano
on it.  I also went to Category one Cycle goods, and Paul suggested a custom
job for about $1500. That might be a bit much for me. Is it worth it?????

Should I build one from scratch????

Stew
T.RTitleUserPersonal
Name
DateLines
377.1Funny BikesKIRK::JOHNSONMatt JohnsonMon Jul 06 1987 20:1826
    You're a serious triathlete, so I think it might be worthwhile for you
    to buy a bike DESIGNED for time trials, and keep your old bike for
    training.  Time trials bikes usually have 26" front wheels, upturned
    handlebars, aerodynamic rims, and shallow angles.  They go fast in a
    straight line, which is what you want to do in a triathalon. 
    
    It used to be that such bikes were ridiculously expensive, custom
    affairs.  Recently, however, companies have started selling them as
    part of their standard lineups.  Shogun and Nashbar, for example, both
    offer low-cost TT bikes.  Smaller companies undoubtedly sell some
    pricier (~$800) models.  (I've seen seen a gorgeous Canadian TT bike
    (its name starts with M, but the rest escapes me) that might fit the
    bill.) 

    TTs don't put much stress on a frame, or on most of the components
    (especially brakes!), so you can get away with much less than you would
    on a criterium or road bike.  It's only important to make the rolling
    parts as fast as possible, and to promote a streamlined riding
    position. 

    These aren't a whole lot of fun to ride in other types of events,
    so you have to decide if tri and TT competition is what you really
    want to do best.  If so, you can't do better.  If not, you can barely
    do worse.
    
    MATT
377.2bucks for bikesDEBIT::FISHERP-B-P qualifiedTue Jul 07 1987 11:0515
    I've seen general statements that TT bikes -- upturned handle bars
    and the twitchy steering that comes on those bikes -- are not good
    for triathletes because they require upper body effort at a time
    when the shoulders and arms are recovering.  The usual "triathlete
    bike" has a more relaxed steering, maybe a 39.5" to 40" wheelbase.
    
    Look at the tri-a models that are available and ask why they're
    different.
    
    What's wrong with Shimano?
    
    And do keep the Raleigh, it's worth more as a spare than you'll
    get for it.
    
    ed
377.3Shimano is fine....NAC::CAMPBELLTue Jul 07 1987 13:0113
    
    Re .2
    
    I didn't mean to say that there was anything wrong with shimano.
    I think Dura-Ace is real good stuff. But on a $700 bike I'd like
    to see something a little better then shimano 600 or 105.  My feeling
    is that the headset, BB and other "machined" parts should be Campy
    or some similar quality.
    
    I plan to keep the Raleigh. It's a great bike!
    
    Stew
    
377.4that's about rightDEBIT::FISHERP-B-P qualifiedTue Jul 07 1987 15:0112
    the price niche for Shimano 600 seems to be a $700-800 bike while
    Dura-Ace is around $1200-1400.  Campy Super Record is usually found
    on a bike selling for $1400-1600; C- Record, around 1800-2200.
    
    Campy stuff on a $700 bike would be a Campy Victory or Triomphe
    which I don't think is as good as Shimano 600.  My quick and dirty
    method for testing components is to turn the pedals and see how
    smooth they are.  If they pass, I look at other things, if they
    don't, I move on.  The bearing on 600 are pretty good, on Victory
    it feels like rocks.
    
    ed
377.5SHR001::DEHAHNWed Jul 08 1987 12:5517
    
    I think you might be asking a lot for $800. A SR group alone is
    at least $450, a decent frame about the same. No rims, spokes, saddle,
    bars/stem etc etc etc.
    
    Do you really want a super special purpose TT bike, or do you want
    a triathalon bike (two different animals)? Something to think about.
    
    The Canadian bike was probably a Macaroni......ooops I mean
    
    Marinoni
    
    Just kidding....great bikes, Canada's premier framebuilder. You
    can get a full custom frame from him for $450.
    
    CdH
    
377.6Still Looking!!NAC::CAMPBELLWed Jul 08 1987 13:2119
    
    I guess the general consensus is that I'm asking alot for $800.
    That may be true. I guess I'll have to look around a little more.
    
    RE .5 
    I'm not looking for a super special purpose TT bike. I'm more looking
    for a "triathlon" bike. I just hate to use that term (triathlon)
    because I think it was created by marketing. The way I see it, a
    triathlon bike is just a softer racing bike, or a road bike.  Without
    putting a name on it, the bike I want has a stiff frame, tight angles,
    and quality components.  What's a guess at how much I need to spend??
    
    What about just buying a frame (say Columbus SL...) from Nashbar
    and building it up myself???  Are there other places to get reasonably
    priced quality frames???
    
    Thanks for the help!!!!
    Stew
    
377.7same bike?TALLIS::EBARTHThu Jul 09 1987 16:447
    The "M" bike from Canada and the custom bike Paul at Cat. 1 suggested
    may be the same thing. Marinnoni (sp?) is the custom builder Paul
    recommends and is Canadian.
    
    Ed
    
377.8SUSHI::KMACDONALDMacarooned on a Dessert IslandThu Jul 09 1987 18:549
Aaah, the famous Canadian "M" bike note - there (used to be?) a Canadian
framebuilder from Winnipeg named Ozzie Mellon. Several folks I knew either
got bikes from him, or had frame repairs done. Suffice it to say, they were
the worst bikes I've ever seen. On one bike the BB shell was VISIBLY out
of alignment (not 90 deg. to the plane of the frame ... oops ...). I don't
know about the "M" bike mentioned in the previous notes (sounds nice) but
don't assume that anything Canadian starting with an M is any good! After
all, they gave us Molson too!
                                             ken
377.9FORGET THE QUALITY...FEEL THE FIT !DUB01::OSULLIVANFri Jul 10 1987 12:1611
    STEW,
    
    I think that it's best not to get too hung up on the grade of
    component. Obviously you don't want junk , but I would imagine
    that you would find it difficult to "feel" the difference between
    campy and shimano 600. What you will feel the difference between
    is a frame that fits   and one that does not. If your pocket allows
    , spend the extra on the frame, a custom job if necessary, to make
    sure it fits your size and purpose.
    
                                       JOHN
377.10Do You Need Steep Angles?CADSYS::CRABBCharlie SEG/CAD HLO2-2/G13 225-5739Mon Jul 20 1987 18:0826
>    triathlon bike is just a softer racing bike, or a road bike.  Without

>    putting a name on it, the bike I want has a stiff frame, tight angles,
                                                 ^^^^^^^^^^^  ^^^^^^^^^^^^

	Oh, so you want to do crits?  Note, there's nothing wrong with the
	idea of a "triathlon" bike...  You seem real sure that you want
	those tight angles.  Yeah, a triathlon bike is just a "softer"
	racing bike or a road bike.  But you seem to have a good/bad
	evaluation here ("soft", tight angles).  Say, not all "good" bikes
	come with 74 degree seat tube angles.  Sounds like you want a real
	squirrely bike.
	Now, stiffness is something else.  If you really have a problem,
	and I know people who do, then you might want a custom frame made
	of straight gauge tubing.  But, do you really have a problem?
	You don't seem to have mentioned the usual problems with having
	a whippy frame.
	Get a bike that's _comfortable_.  You're going to be competing on
	it.

>    and quality components.  What's a guess at how much I need to spend??
                                                ^^^^^^^^      
         
	How much you got?    

377.11I fell in love!NAC::CAMPBELLMon Aug 10 1987 20:4914
    
    There I was on vacation, when I happened into this bike shop in
    Brattleboro.  After about an hour of talking to the guy he steered
    me to a bike he had in the back room.  It was a hot pink Bianci
    Trofeo.  I couldn't help myself so I bought it after a 45 minute
    test ride!  It's more or less what I was looking for!  Campy SR
    front and rear changers. The BB and Headset is Gipienne, and the
    brakeset is Modole Equipe!  It rides like a dream!!!  The final
    price we agreed on was $680!!!
    
    Now what do I do with the Raleigh competion????  A winter bike????
    
    Thanks for the advice!!
    Stew