T.R | Title | User | Personal Name | Date | Lines |
---|
803.1 | TREK EXPERIENCE... | LILAC::MARCINKUS | | Mon Aug 01 1988 12:57 | 10 |
| JOHN,
I CAN'T COMMENT ON THE SIRRUS, BUT I RODE A TREK 1500 FOR OVER 1,000
MILES AND IT'S A GREAT BIKE. I REALIZE THE COMPONENTS ARE DIFFERENT
BUT THE FRAMES ARE BASICALLY THE SAME. IT'S A SUPER COMFORTABLE,
QUICK, AND FAST BIKE THAT WORKS WELL FOR ALL TYPES OF RIDING. IF
YOU DECIDE ON THE TREK YOU WILL BE VERY HAPPY WITH THE FRAME FOR A LONG
TIME TO COME. I HOPE MY COMMENTS HELP.
JOHN
|
803.2 | Specialized. | NAC::CAMPBELL | | Mon Aug 01 1988 13:10 | 5 |
|
The bikes are equally priced, but the shimano 105 stuff is better
then the light action!! Go for the specialized....
Stew
|
803.3 | Trek | FDCV30::SAIZ | | Mon Aug 01 1988 20:00 | 15 |
| I'd recommend the Trek; I have a 510 which is 5 years old and a
850 which is only 2 years old. I have used both to commute to work
as well as for fun. The 510 is just plain fun to ride and very
responsive. It's not a racer but a road/semi-touring bike so the
ride is quite comfortable on long rides but not the fastest bike
around (probably more the rider than the bike). The 850 is an off
the road bike which more like the truck version of the 510. Its
very stable but heavier so it takes more work to get there.
Thus far I don't have any major complaints about the Treks other
than the dealer. If I had to I certainly would by another one just
be more choosy about where.
Maria
|
803.4 | $$$$$$ | STAR::MCCARTHY | | Mon Aug 01 1988 20:47 | 6 |
|
Spend a few extra $$$ and get the Trek 1200, its got the 105 group.
you'll be glad you did. trust me!!
Joe ( ISUZU )
|
803.5 | Don't trust aluminum... | UMBIKE::KLASMAN | | Mon Aug 01 1988 21:12 | 24 |
| I certainly agree with the last comment; go for the 105 group. I wouldn't
settle for less. However, the comment on the Trek 1000 frame being the same
as the Trek 1500, I'll have to disagree. The geometry's the same, but the
1500 has a different, and better grade of aluminum tubing. The 1500 frame is
the same as the old 2000...
My SO has a Sirrus (I ride it occasionally) and I can't imagine a better $500
bike. The frame is outstanding...it climbs like a rocket and really
accelerates, too. I haven't ridden the Trek's, but I was seriously
considering the 1500, but I heard too much criticism about their quality
control (most New England bike shops have stopped carrying TREK). I was also
concerned about an aluminum frame's ability to survive even a minor crash.
They can't be aligned very easily (if at all...depends on who you talk to
around here). I bent my Fuji frame just laying it down on its side without
hitting anything, and it bent enough that a 35 mph descent was
life-threatening. Previously, I'd hit 45 mph and it was rock solid. I got it
aligned and it is again very stable. I don't think you could do that with an
aluminum bike. It might not bend so easily either, but I don't trust them,
tho I'd love to try one.
I do have a few friends with TREK alum's that like and/or love them. I would
recommend the Sirrus, anyway.
Kevin
|
803.6 | ?one vote for Sirrus | NEXUS::MONROE | | Mon Aug 01 1988 21:13 | 11 |
|
Isn't the 1000 made with aluminum ?
If it is you made want to lean towards the Sirrus,because if the
aluminum frame gets damaged you would have to buy another (i.e.
the aluminum is not as repairable as is steel) and the 105 group
is better then the light action. The Trek is a nice bike but if
all things are equal I would go for the Sirrus.
Good hunting
Tom M
|
803.7 | Read Note 795 for a good time! | DELNI::GRACE | Amazin' Grace | Mon Aug 01 1988 21:37 | 6 |
| I don't want to confuse the issue, but have you considered the Trek
560. If you are considering it, or interested in someone's experience
(mine) that just went through a similar narrowing-down process
as you did, read note 795.
Russ
|
803.8 | I can't decide, get both. | PSG::BUCHANAN | Bat | Tue Aug 02 1988 01:19 | 15 |
| Specialized has an excellent reputation and it deserves it. I've owned
two Specialized bikes, an '84 version of the Allez and a Stumpjumper. The
value and workmanship were both first rate. The Serrus may only cost $500
but it's a racing bike! It's angles are steep and the ride is hard. If
you want to jam it sounds like a great bike.
However I sold the Allez and now own an aluminium bike for one reason, comfort.
The Allez was a great bike but after a long day on some rough road could
take it's toll. I am aware of the danger of damaging the frame and it's
just a risk I agreed to take.
I would also suggest not going below the 105 group. It seems that every bike
maker has their own version of a 105 bike and they all cost about the same,
Specialized, Miyata, Centurian, Trek, Schwinn, etc.... Ride them and see if
you can feel any difference. If not get the one that looks the coolest!
|
803.9 | Wouldn't part with my Specialized | IMBACQ::ELLISON | Dave Ellison | Thu Aug 04 1988 15:17 | 10 |
| I too own a Specialized Stumpjumper- I'ts a great allround bike.
My other two fujis now collect dust! I have had the oppertunity to
ride most of Specialized's factory demos while out at their Ca.
warehouse. The bikes just get nicer and nicer as the price increases!
If it counts for anything, this is a US company (although most of
their product is built offshore to their US specs). Specialized
is also an exclusive DEC customer. They have come up thru the ranks
with RSTS, and are now running on a medium sized VAXCluster!
Dave
|
803.10 | Even more confused! | WLDWST::BARTLETT | First among equals! | Fri Aug 05 1988 09:36 | 33 |
| Thanks everyone for your replies on this note -
I do appreciate it. It seems as though we have a good number
of Specialized fans as well as Trek fans out there. I must
say however that I am still in a dilemma over which bike to
buy. Perhaps I should put it this way:
I really want a bike that will perform well in a variety
of situations - ie; some touring (1-3 day variety), commuting,
fitness rides, and eventually maybe even a Triathlon (a guy
can dream...can't he?). Now I realize that this bike does
not really exist, but there are a few bikes out there that do
perform well in most of these areas.
Basically, I have narrowed my choices down from 2
bikes to 3 bikes!!! Once again I would appreciate any advice
or info on any of these bikes - preferably from someone who
owns one. Anybody who has looked for a bike like I mentioned
above and has had any success please feel free to reply also.
Here are the bikes I'm considering:
Trek 1000 Components - Shimano Light Action.
--------- Price - $499.00
Specialized Sirrus Components - Shimano 105
------------------ Price - $499.00
Bridgestone RB1 Components - Shimano 105
--------------- Price - $550.00
Thanks in advance,
John Bartlett
|
803.11 | Bridgestone | USMRW2::DRIVETTS | | Fri Aug 05 1988 15:21 | 5 |
| Free Motion Cyclery in Hubbardston, MA (508) 928-4852 sells
Bridgestones and sells the RB1 for $475 tax included. He also sells
Falcon. There is one model with Shimano 105 and Reynolds 531 frame
for $450 tax included.
|
803.12 | OTHER ALTERNATIVES | AKOV11::FULLER | | Fri Aug 05 1988 16:35 | 17 |
| O'neil's in Worcester has three bikes with 105 components that may
be worth a look at. Prices are list, and refer my name to them
and you can receive 10% off plus good sales help.
o Giant 475.00
o Cilo 575.00 (Swiss company, real nice frames)
o Cannondale 640.00
They will also take good care of you if you need any changes, ie
freewheel, saddle, etc.
Ask for Mike or Jim.
ps. If you are going for the Specialized, you may as well buy the
GIANT if your price shopping, same bike, cheaper money
steve
|
803.13 | Long distance Shopping | WLDWST::ELZINGRE | Marty HPS Systems Cupertino, CA | Mon Aug 08 1988 16:20 | 7 |
| I'm sure all of the stores mentioned in the previous replies
are great places to shop, however, the WiLDWeST cluster (where
John is at) resides in Cupertino CA. ;^)
Mail order?
Marty
|
803.14 | You can find them here | PSG::BUCHANAN | Bat | Mon Aug 08 1988 21:07 | 13 |
| There are many top quality shops in the area that sell either or both Trek
and Specialized. Shops that I know that are first rate include:
Bicycle Outfitter in Los Altos
Wheelsmiths in Palo Alto
Shaw's in Santa Clara
Velomeister in Los Gatos
Spectrum in Cupertino
Each of these shops sells at least one of the brands and the Outfitter and
the Wheelsmiths sells both I believe.
Mike, also in Cupertino
|
803.15 | Are you happy with your choice? | DNEAST::MILLEY_ROBB | Is that brew ready yet?? | Mon Jul 17 1989 17:10 | 14 |
|
re. .0
Which bike did you get?? What do you think about it after a year?
The reason I ask, is because I was looking at the specialized as
well as the Bianchi Brava (GPX group). They are close in price,
but the Brava seemed to have a more comfortable ride.
any suggestions?
Thanks,
Robb_who_has_pounded_the_h*ll_out_of_his_mountain_bike_and_wants_to_
go_spin_on_the_road.
|
803.16 | Trek 1200 | OLDTMR::BROWN | | Fri Aug 25 1989 14:53 | 6 |
| Ok, another "Is this a good deal?" note stuck on the end here...
How about an ('88) Trek 1200 for $500 ($525 w/ tax)? Shimano 105,
but the six instead of the seven speed cluster. The wheels were
a proprietary Trek name: "Matrix". Anybody own a 1200 out there and
wish to comment? Thanks! _Kratz
|
803.17 | Attack of the killer FUJI | EGYPT::CRITZ | Greg Lemond wins 2nd Tour de France | Fri Aug 25 1989 16:02 | 10 |
| Kratz,
No! No! Keep that old beater Fuji you've got! What's
going to happen to it? Are we going to read someday
that this cyclist was terrorized by his old, defunct
Fuji?
I say, keep the Fuji.
8-)> Scott <(-8
|
803.18 | Ahem.. L. Kratz Brown? | IOENG::BERUBE | | Fri Aug 25 1989 17:25 | 12 |
| Hey Kratz... take any tumbles lately?
HA HA
I just added this conference in today. Thought I might run into you
(sorry 'bout that folks) here.
Norm PCSG '86-'88
|
803.19 | | OLDTMR::BROWN | | Fri Aug 25 1989 18:02 | 8 |
| Norm!!
(Why do I feel like having a beer now?) Actually I haven't taken a
tumble since that Littleton dog. I figure if I buy a light, fast,
highly uncontrollable bike it'll enhance my chances. Seriously, the
Fuji Heavy Industry's (well named company...) tank has about had it.
Scott, don't you own a Trek? _Kratz
|
803.20 | Abuse from someone you don't even know | RICKS::SPEAR | MYCROFTXXX | Fri Aug 25 1989 18:47 | 8 |
| Kratz, stick with 2002's, they are less complicated :-)
Matrix is not a "house brand" rim, it is a well known and little respected
name. It is the only product that seems to receive universal abuse from
everyone who has used them. In other words, the Trek-o-la better be cheap
because the rims will need replacement pronto.
cbs
|
803.21 | | EGYPT::CRITZ | Greg Lemond wins 2nd Tour de France | Fri Aug 25 1989 19:12 | 10 |
| Kratz,
Yessir, I have a TREK, although I can't really give you
its pedigree. I bought it used, and know little about it,
except it fits (more or less).
I'm kinda looking to get a NEW set of wheels, myself, and
will be looking at TREK first.
Scott
|
803.22 | Treks are fine | HUB::FORBESM | Life's A Mtn. Not A Beach | Fri Aug 25 1989 19:18 | 5 |
| I have a Trek 1400 (quite similar to the 1200 but with an aluminum
fork) and have had no problems with it at all. The Matrix rims
are fine so far.
Mark
|
803.23 | durable | NOVA::FISHER | Twice a BMB Finisher | Mon Aug 28 1989 11:58 | 7 |
| I think Matrix rims are great. Nancy Raposa did RAAM last year
on Matrix's I did BMB on a pair and after I wrecked the Serotta
and the spokes had the wheel rebuilt. The unlaced rim was still
good so it was used for the rebuild. These are Matrix ISO
clinchers.
ed
|
803.24 | bought it. | OLDTMR::BROWN | | Tue Aug 29 1989 13:05 | 4 |
| Too good of a deal to pass up, I guess. 4 minutes faster round-the-
resevoir than my previous P.R. on its first trip; seemed all downhill.
I'll probably get a second set of wheels anyhow and call the defaults
the "beaters".
|
803.25 | Satisfied Trek Customer! | VIDEO::RJOHNSON | | Wed Aug 30 1989 20:45 | 6 |
| I bought a new TREK 1000 for my wife and a 1200 for myself about
5 weeks ago. We have put almost 500 miles on them and couldn't be
happier. This probably isn't enough time to make any judgement
statements about rims, components or frame reliability, but, they
are sure a pleasure to ride. For what it's worth, they have my
endorsement. So does Chelmsford Cyclery, where we bought them.
|